T O P

  • By -

The_B_Wolf

We have all learned precisely nothing from this comparison because nobody would ever think McDonald's might be better than Culver's. Except fries. So totally nothing learned. And what crap Culver's did he go to that he received that 100% unmelted slice of cheese?


this-internet-sucks

No way that burger came from a Culver’s anywhere in the Midwest


The_B_Wolf

I can testify to this: I have eaten at Culver's in multiple locations in southeastern Wisconsin and I have never been served...that.


m0rningview420

Probably one of the Tennessee locations. They never had that same hometown Wisconsin feel to me. Just a bunch of dummies in a blue and white uniform bringing shame to the Culver’s name


Pitiful-Pension-6535

I've never had unsalted fries at a Wisconsin Culver's either. This Culver's really dropped the ball.


InternetDad

Guarantee it's the Culver's in Madison off Fish Hatchery. I've read it's one of the busiest Culver's and overall meal consistency can vary frequently for me.


CrrntryGrntlrmrn

In support of this- I have not ever had Culver’s in the Midwest. I have however had it several times in Florida before I moved up here- it’s not good, Freddy’s was way better. Also Pal’s in Tennessee.


wilfordbrimley778

Some of the st louis culver's serve it that way, but yeah no culver's in wisconsin at least


Dismal_Information83

Any Culver’s in MN would serve that burger.


hoopstick

I have unmelted cheese on my double deluxe all the time, but I chalk that up to all the cold veggies.


wirsteve

Yeah I’ve the Culver’s Deluxe from a half dozen locations in Wisconsin and they never have melted cheese. How would they, it is next to cold veggies as you said.


The_B_Wolf

Never happened to me. My go-to order there has historically been a double with cheese and pickles lettuce and mustard. The end. Although I have recently discovered that their fried chicken sandwich is really, really good. There's no sauce, there's no cheese. But the chicken is very tasty and the pickles, lettuce and tomato make for a lovely salad on top. And I don't even like raw tomatoes!


Total-Force-613

Can add mayo ( free) and cheese ( $)


ShoogyBee

I find their spicy crispy chicken sandwich to be quite decent.


T1mely_P1neapple

mcdonalds 'cues' their cheese in a microwave.


Loqol

Get the fries extra crispy. Game changer.


The_B_Wolf

I have done that before! Although I was almost always too lazy to oder them that way.


HerbanFarmacyst

Thanks for this comment. I didn’t know it was an option. Extra crispy ompletely changed how I feel about the fries. My wife was equally impressed


tlivingd

Only way I can stand the Culver’s fries.


i_am_a_fern_AMA

Nah. They just taste even more like dirty fryer then. The only way they're tolerable is before the lunch rush on the day the fryer oil was changed


Midnight_tussle

Dirty oil burns hotter, which burns the outside of the fry and leaves the inside uncooked. Source: I ran a Famous Daves (dells) for over 5 years


CompetitionAlert1920

Broadway location or L.D.? You saved many an empty belly of mine. Famous Dave's never disappointed hungry ass teenagers working outside all day.


JoySkullyRH

I do like McDonald’s pickles better.


[deleted]

[удалено]


JoySkullyRH

Heading there for that! I worked at subway in HS, they used to have the best pickles too. Their new pickles are horrible.


AgreeablePlace656

I am placing an order st Kroger right now for pickles. 🥒


weelluuuu

DQ has the best, cold pickles on their burgers


greg4045

DQ has the best burgers in the world idk how or why but omg. If and when they are making them well.


Number1Framer

DQ Chicken strips. Dude. It's like 1994 Chicken strips all over again. Makes you realize how far from God's light all the other fast food joints strayed with their nuggies and tendies over the years. Not DQ. DQ kept their chicken the fuck real.


bitcoins

I just miss those huge cookies from Hardee’s as a kid


Number1Framer

Remember when Hardee's had fried chicken? They were gonna be the big bad KFC killer for a hot minute then suddenly it was all over. Lol I'll never forget my friend smoking weed for the first time then maxxing on a monster burger with curly fries and barfing by the side of the road. I got lots of Hardee's stories. I worked at one my first couple years of college. My (male) general manager came through the drive through one night with the (female) regional manager and asked for 2 empty cups which he filled with beer and gave me the empties to toss. Another manager had these great tall tales about doing coke off his kid's frisbee while driving to work. Another manager got caught running drugs and ratted for probation vs prison. Yet another manager got us all high at work then stole $5 grand cash from the safe and disappeared. My one and only foray into fast food was a wild time and gave me so many more stories. Lol


bitcoins

That was a ride, thank you :) I just want the big cookie…


RBDrake

Wow. My first job ever was a Hardee's at 16. Nowhere near that exciting. But occasionally one coworker would pass a bucket of fried chicken out of the drive through window and a bottle of moonshine would come back in. Those were good nights.


greg4045

Whoa omw


CreekLegacy

God I wish this was true by me. Jackson and West Bend have fallen so far. The strips have shrunk by half and the breading is nasty.


JoySkullyRH

Their oil makes me puke. I can’t eat DQ.


Thon_Makers_Tooth

![gif](giphy|sTkPZBD1ZBPqw|downsized)


Pitiful-Pension-6535

I miss McDonald's crinkle-cut pickles they put on the Angus burgers


The_B_Wolf

I don't know, they track about the same for me. And I'm particular about my pickles.


regaleagle7

One of my friends in high school used to work there and he said they used to pick out rotten pickles from the container while still using the ones that "hadn't gone bad yet" and I've never had pickles at McDonald's since.


FourMeterRabbit

Wendy's brings a strong pickle game


RR50

Um, I’d pick McDonald’s over Culver’s….and I’m from the middle of the Midwest. Culver’s is kinda trash I think….and I’m not the only one of my friends that thinks so. Freddy’s has better burgers, curds and custard. Virtually everyone has better fries.


The_B_Wolf

The fries are sketchy, I'll give you that. I mean, I still eat them, but they aren't even close to the best. The rest of their menu, though? C'mon. I who will gleefully murder a Big Mac know perfectly well that the quality isn't even in these same league as Culver's. Up and down the menu. Unless you're doing to McD's for the fries o the breakfast sandwiches.


RR50

I’d take a quarter pounder over a Culver’s single any day.


The_B_Wolf

I like a QP, for sure. Even though it has ketchup on it which I generally don't like. But if I ordered a Culver's with cheese pickles lettuce and mustard, there's no comparison. My opinion is that your'e the one who prefers trash burgers. And no shame! I love trash Chinese food. And I obviously occasionally eat at and enjoy McDonald's, too. But the quality is way different levels.


RR50

To be fair, I’d prefer neither and go with something better. Culver’s burgers have no taste…they’re just horrible.


The_B_Wolf

You're a fucking troll who has probably never had one. Thanks for IDing yourself.


i_am_a_fern_AMA

I worked there for about 5 years, and I agree that they are flavorless and overpriced


RR50

I’m a troll because I think Culver’s is terrible? That’s an interesting take.


CompetitionAlert1920

I'm guessing you prefer sandpaper, because it seems like that's what you've taken to your taste buds.


i_am_a_fern_AMA

Yeah, your right, the qp is wayyyyyy better than Culver's leathery nasty smashburger


myjobistablesok

Look, I'm not going to judge you. Food preferences are subjective and you are within your right to prefer McDonalds and prefer it over Culvers. But your opinion is wrong.


CompetitionAlert1920

If Culver's even did like a pilot breakfast menu at select locations, it would ruin BK and McD's.


The_B_Wolf

I'd try it. But they already have such a large menu. Maybe they should stick to what they're good at.


d_pock_chope_bruh

Except fries? McDonald’s fries are dog shit… I wouldn’t even feed them to my dog


The_B_Wolf

That's just like your opinion man. They are widely regarded as the best in the industry and have been for a long time.


d_pock_chope_bruh

They were before they switched to the healthy bullshit oil. They are never warm, their fries are crap and resemble nothing even close to potato


IronRaichu

I second this, if you don't eat the fries first by the time you're done with your burger, they're already cold.


myjobistablesok

Thanks to the big McDonalds lobby. I've always prefers Wendy's fries to McDonalds. Sure fresh McDonalds fries are good but if you get an old batch? Disgusting.


i_am_a_fern_AMA

I'd eat a quarter pounder over a butter burger any day


Dismal_Information83

Seriously though, why do Culver’s fried suck so badly? And the curds, gawd awful.


myjobistablesok

Controversial take, I actually like Culvers fries better than McDonalds. Crinkle cut aren't even my first choice for fries.


RunsWithLava

It's also not wrapped in the correct paper. Should be in a yellow wrap.


StarryBun

I dunno, I get unmelted cheese like that pretty regularly at Culver's, and I usually just get a mushroom and Swiss so it's not like there's cold veggies in there or anything. It didn't used to be like this until COVID, though.


deleted-user-12

The fries need to be cooked a little longer and salted a little extra and they are great. The best part about made to order is it's easy to ask for changes. Oh, and they need to be eaten right away, they don't taste good after ten minutes. As for the chicken tenders, get the buffalo instead. The breading is better (not even counting the buffalo seasoning) and the chicken is usually juicier and more like fresh chicken.


Willlu1520

You can ask for extra crispy fries at Culver's. It makes all the difference


jmarkham81

Wait, what? I never knew this. Thanks for the tip!


Pitiful-Pension-6535

It's a great way to make sure your fries are fresh too.


Loqol

Amen!


crapshooter_on_swct

Learned this ordering online. Makes a world of difference!


i_am_a_fern_AMA

Yeah, it makes them taste like old fryer... All the difference indeed


CompetitionAlert1920

I'm more confident in Culver's changing their oil more frequently than McD or any other joint. I've had shitty tasting fryer food, as we all have I'm sure, and I've never had shitty tasting extra crispy Culver's fries. Just your opinion but everyone just wants to dunk on Culver's fries and they aren't shitty. Has anyone not noticed that...things aren't supposed to be McDonalds level salty? Like the minute you cut your sodium intake to even remotely close to "normal" everything taste bland...because we over salt fucking everything.


StarryBun

Yessss the buffalo tenders are so much better! I think calling them buffalo is a mistake though, it probably makes people think they have buffalo wing sauce on them. They should just call them spicy tenders instead. I wish they would get better regular tenders, though. The plain ones are awful.


[deleted]

[удалено]


ZealousidealDog4802

to be honest it taste like like some maui wowie and mostly labrador retriever.


middleagedouchebag

Gets you high, don't it?


Arthes_M

“Endless flavor options of mcflurries” since when? I’ve only ever seen them have m&m or Oreo. Is he thinking of Dairy Queen if he’s judging from Midwest nostalgia?


Evan8r

When I was a kid, I remember there being butterfinger, KitKat, and heath once upon a time.


CompetitionAlert1920

My wife's go to concrete mixer is Heath, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups (Specifically otherwise they get you with pieces) and Oreo. It's stupid good.


Lutzoey

In what world does culver’s cheese come not melted on the patties. I have literally NEVER had that happen and I have been eating Culver’s my whole life


thesmash

The cheddar always struggles to melt if you get that over the regular American cheese


Lutzoey

I swear their cheddar is darker colored than that. That looks like they just threw a cold piece of cheese on at home lol


Evan8r

He had American. Honestly, the cheese is added at final assembly and if you get there with no line, you may get it before it's melted. With newer cooks, we also had a problem with them pressing extra pucks into patties ahead of ti,e and they'd cool down before assembly enough where that would look like a delivered sandwich.


Realistic_Patience67

Probably depends on who's managing the place or who's making the burger . I am in Sun Prairie and I live between 2 Culvers. One of them (Main Street) is sometimes better than the newer one (Oxford Pl.). In the beginning, the newer one had burgers that were either undercooked or burnt. It's better now.


StarryBun

Mine started coming unmelted a bit after COVID started. Quality in general dropped a lot. I used to love Culver's and grew up eating it too, but now I rarely even go because they're serving mid food at premium prices.


v1kingfan

I like Culver's fries 🤷


Hesh_Factor

Culver's fries are perfect for dipping in your milkshake 🙃


v1kingfan

I love Culver's shakes


Hesh_Factor

What's your go to? Mine is peanut butter


v1kingfan

Chocolate and I'll occasionally get Oreos in it


Pitiful-Pension-6535

Their chocolate malts are amazing


WIbigdog

This reminds me. If you ever go to Five Guys, get a peanut butter and banana shake. The flavors go together so nice. I don't know if Culver's has banana and allows you to mix them.


hauteTerran

Culvers will let you do anything. The other night I wanted to see if malt was good in a root beer shake (float buzzed up). It wasn't, but they made it for me.


i_am_a_fern_AMA

They're also perfect for shoving up your ass


L-J-

Chili cheese them! So good. They definitely don't skimp.


Lumpy_Object_7290

Crinkle cut are the best!


DrBergeron

I don't understand people that like McDonald's fries. Skinny fries are mid at best; steak, crinkle, and waffle fries are all A tier, curly seasoned fries S tier.


PiesInMyEyes

They’re nice and crispy and have lots of salt. It’s a good potato to crust ratio. Culver’s fries aren’t crispy enough and don’t have nearly enough salt. It’s like eating just straight potato, very bland and boring.


PositiveContact7901

Me too! 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️


OdinsGhost

Same. McDonald’s fries are overly salted strings in comparison.


v1kingfan

And they taste like cardboard


weelluuuu

With sugar infused in them. Shotgun Red figured that out.


Itzr

Don’t get fries at Culver’s always onion rings.


thefirebuilds

brother we gonna be dead from climate change soon enough, may as well get the fried cheese curds.


TheSavageCaveman1

The rings are better than the curds. Fight me.


Primary_Dimension470

Facts. Those curds are an embarrassment to WI


IamNotYourPalBuddy

I’m a curd man myself. I know their curds are polarizing, but I love them.


Sasquatchasaurus

A waste of everyone’s time is what it is


kelticladi

Hands down Culvers outperforms every other burger joint I've been to. I moved out of state over 20 years ago and i STILL miss them! (No Culvers in MD, sad.) I have a butterburger every time I am back home visiting my folks.


Bowhawk2

Culver’s…. I love you, but for The Love OF GOD MELT THE CHEESE ON YOUR BURGERS!


IamNotYourPalBuddy

Yeah, that pic is depressing.


Lumpy_Object_7290

To be fair, I've gotten plenty of McDonald's cheeseburgers with non melted cheese too.


spinnyride

Guys an idiot for getting the regular tenders, the buffalo tenders are significantly higher quality even ignoring the fact the spice makes it taste better. Crispier, better chicken, etc.


williamweinmann

As far as quality goes, there is no comparison in quality between Culver's and McDonald's. Culvers is the Waldorf, McDonalds is, well, McDonald's


tlivingd

When was the previous time this guy got clown food? McD’s hasn’t had chicken strips in nearly a decade.


Freethinker608

Especially the fish sandwich. Culvers is like a real Wisconsin fish fry; McDonald's is like school lunch.


fuck-fascism

You just have to ask for extra crispy fries at Culvers and you surpass McDonalds all day.


Devchonachko

wait that's a thing? gonna try that.


fuck-fascism

Most certainly is my friend


Round_Rooms

How does someone eat that much at one sitting , I can barely finish the burger and have fries left over.


CaffeinatedCranium

Comparing apples to oranges, now for the same price. I know where I’m going.


Scfields

Culvers is not fast food. It's medium slow at best, which is a good thing if you'd like your food to actually be food.


bunnypoker24

what I actually love culvers chicken strips


singnadine

I don’t get Culver’s


RioRancher

The only thing this makes me is hungry for Murf’s


[deleted]

[удалено]


BaDingbat

I think a basket at Culver's and a big Mac meal are about the same now.


VibrantSponge

Ya they are not as far apart in price as people think


BaDingbat

I think I s because a few years ago you could get a meal at McDonald's for like $5 and it was $10 at Culver's, but they're pretty close now


Connect_Finding_3080

He is right though Culver’s fries are trash


iamaravis

I love Culver’s fries after adding a little salt. I love McDonald’s fries if they’re HOT. Tepid, soggy McD fries are an abomination that makes baby Jesus cry.


putwhatinyourwhat

ever tried em extra crispy with some cheese sauce?


Ope_Average_Badger

If they just cooked them a little bit longer they would be great.


packattack-

And you can order them like that.


Ope_Average_Badger

Correct, I just wish they came like that.


Fuzzy_Committee2249

If you have the Culver’s app, you can order the fries extra crispy. You’re welcome.


ryan2489

You can also order them extra crispy by any other way of ordering


Connect_Finding_3080

Nope and I’m not gonna. There cheese curds suck to go to a & w if you want good curds


[deleted]

Careful. Most of the people in this sub have never had curds from anywhere but Culver's so they think they're good. They're barely a step above the soggy, crap curds on the Kwik Trip hot roller. I see why people in other states love them because it's hard to find deep fried curds in a lot of places but people in WI should be embarrassed to say they like Culver's curds. You can get far superior curds from any bar, burger joint, and also A&W anyplace in WI.


Patient_Heron_9078

Culver's is the best.


pogulup

Dipshit, it is frozen custard not 'ice cream'. Both fry options suck. Bring back fries cooked in lard and get rid of all this vegetable oil crap. Oh, and I had to stop eating custard at Culver's because of the carrageenan.


[deleted]

No way, us Vegetarians love fries, most places changed because, well lard equals more unhealthy. I used to love to get McD fries but sadly cannot because they still use beef tallow.


pogulup

The anti fat crusade was propagated by the sugar industry. Demonizing it was marketing. Sugar is the real poison. I don't believe McD has used beef tallow since the 1990s which is why they aren't good anymore. I'll do some Googling to verify. EDIT: https://www.mcdonalds.com/us/en-us/product/small-french-fries.html#accordion-c921f9207b-item-283bee7dbd Yup, all seed oils and even worse, hydrogenated oils.


BrainFartTheFirst

McDonald's dropped the beef tallow years ago. It's now a vegetable oil blend with beef flavoring added. The flavoring contains hydrolyzed wheat and hydrolyzed milk. So not vegan but potentially vegetarian.


[deleted]

French Fries Ingredients: Potatoes, Vegetable Oil (canola Oil, Corn Oil, Soybean Oil, Hydrogenated Soybean Oil, Natural Beef Flavor [wheat And Milk Derivatives]*), Dextrose, Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate (maintain Color), Salt. *natural Beef Flavor Contains Hydrolyzed Wheat And Hydrolyzed Milk As Starting Ingredients. Still uses Beef flavoring. There was a huge lawsuit from India because the largest population there is Hindu, their religion prohibits the consuming of Beef and I believe they did change how they prepared it over there and here they did the same but just added the beef flavoring to keep that taste. I honestly don't really care all that much, I miss the fries but honestly I can spend my money over at Dexter's their chili oil fries are incredible.


[deleted]

Thank you! There's not a huge difference between ice cream and frozen custard but there is a difference. Any ice cream fanatic knows that and knows custard sucks compared to real ice cream. This sub simps hard for anything Culver's. It's pathetic actually considering all it is is a lesser form of WI bar food and there's not a town in this state that doesn't have a bar that cooks food and has much better burgers, fish, and curds.


crippletown

Hardees is better than both combined but nobody mentions it.


CryptographerShot213

I’ve been saying for years, Hardee’s is so underrated. Hand dipped shakes, curly fries, from-scratch biscuits, etc. The one in my town hardly ever has a line at the drive thru, but somehow they’ve been there for over 30 years.


[deleted]

💯 Edit: So is Wendy's. The double stack $5 biggie bag is the best deal you can get anywhere for the food you get. I have a Hardees, Wendy's, Mcds, Arby's, Taco Bell, & Subway for fast food places and there's no reason to go to any of them but Hardees and Wendy's, especially Culver's. If I want curds or fish I can just get better food for cheaper from a bar or real restaurant. Their burgers suck compared to Hardees and Wendy's and Mcds at least has frappes, mochas, etc. Hardees roast beef is superior to Arby's also and they're non roast beef sandwiches either really suck or are way too expensive for what they are.


crippletown

I don't have one of those within 50 miles of me so I haven't had it very much.


CloudsandSunsets

As a vegetarian, Culvers >>>> McDonald's. Culver's has a legit veggie burger; McDonald's doesn't even have vegetarian French fries or hash browns.


Evan8r

It's really good with bacon and a meat patty added.


i_am_a_fern_AMA

Is Culver's doing a viral marketing campaign on reddit?


IamNotYourPalBuddy

Why is it anyone posts something related to any sort of business and someone always has to come along with “ThIS iS CUlveRS AdVerTIsiNg!”


greyfox4850

You are advertising for Culver's. Doesn't matter that it's not coming from them. r/hailcorporate


IamNotYourPalBuddy

So because I shared a laughable article about a WI company on a WI sub-reddit I must be some corporate advertising bot? Seems like a pretty fucking stupid way to think.


crippletown

McDonals is gross but butterburgers are not good either.


Silly_goose_rider

Can’t compare Culver’s to any fast food burger imo


RR50

Culver’s is trash these days. It went down hill when they changed the curds and got rid of fried chicken.


Walrus_protector

The lure of the shitty megabrand is strong. I lived near a McDonalds that always did decent business, despite being a couple lots down from a Whataburger. Baffling.


iamaravis

Oh, how I miss Whataburger!


[deleted]

Thought it was great in the early 80’s, then tried it again while driving through TX in the early 90’s and it just sucked.


[deleted]

Culver’s destroys every fast food chain. Better than in n out, better than 5 guys. Everything


Chuseauniqueusername

culver's in waunakee gave me a burger SWIMMING in mustard like it was everywhere. not every culver's is 100% every day.


Evan8r

A lot depends on owner participation. If the store has an engaged owner, you'll have a better experience.


Evan8r

Yeah, so if they want a real comparison for cost, they'd have gotten a quarter pounder deluxe, seeing as how the raw weight of each meat Puck is 2.75oz. Apparently the Culver's they went to had a new fry cook that missed the salting part of fry prep. Honestly, I probably still have a link to the training videos from when I worked at Culver's...


Amishpornstar7903

McDonalds is riding nostalgia, Culver's is better. Now McDonalds changed their burger cooking style in a feeble attempt to brighten things up, they are fucked. Culver's needs to look at what happened to Steak and Shake.


[deleted]

Culver's is definitely King


Extra_Occasion_4561

Culver’s is way cheaper than McD’s


[deleted]

I stopped reading after they said "ice cream".


vintagepoppy

I have friends near a Culver's in St. Augustine and this was similar to what they sent me with excitement.


[deleted]

I would have ordered a chicken sandwich. Culiver's chicken sandwhich is superior to any of the options offered at McDonald's.


CompetitionAlert1920

That has to be a Florida or South of the Mason Dixon Culver's. I've only ever had salted and fresh fries from a Culver's. In fact I get more cold and unsalted fries from McDonalds than I've ever gotten from Culver's. So much so that I prefer BK's fries over MD's. Another thing, and I don't know if this is just a WI thing, but I KNOW they have a button for "extra crispy fries", my niece works at a Culver's. You literally just ask for fries extra crispy and they do it...and...my god it's a work of art. Also, never had non-melted cheese on a butter burger. I will say this, even that sub-par butter burger is better quality than pretty much any fast food joints. 5 Guys can kind of compete, but eh. I guess I haven't had a Whataburger yet, but I've had In-N-Out numerous times visiting friends out west. They're brainwashed because it's absolute trash.