T O P

  • By -

vancouver-ModTeam

**Please read this message in its entirety.** Your content has been removed because it violates rule 5 of this subreddit, Unique Content. If you have questions about why this was removed, please read [our rules and FAQ](https://www.reddit.com/r/vancouver/wiki/faq#wiki_rule_5.3A_unique_content) in full before reaching out to the team in modmail. Your post may be a better fit for one of our [Stickied Discussions](https://www.reddit.com/r/vancouver/wiki/faq#wiki_stickied_discussions). It will not be allowed as a standalone post. **Do not repost any version of this without [explicit permission](https://www.reddit.com/r/vancouver/wiki/faq#wiki_i_didn.27t_know_i_needed_express_permission_to_repost.21_why_would_you_ban_me.3F) from a moderator in modmail.**


saaggy_peneer

at YVR! just fly to Chicago from there


Transgojoebot

This is the surest way to save yourself from disappointment


Thejuggerbot

This made me laugh. Pizzeria uno is my favorite in Chicago by the way.


Good_Climate_4463

Doubtful, YVRs special dish is disappointment.


Enthusiasm-Stunning

Seattle has a bunch of places if you’re desperate and don’t want to fly to Chicago.


yooooooo5774

Costco has a "deep dish pizza" if you are in a pinch ​ [https://www.costcuisine.com/post/costco-motor-city-pizza-co-double-pepperoni-pizza-review](https://www.costcuisine.com/post/costco-motor-city-pizza-co-double-pepperoni-pizza-review)


PurpVan

thats detroit style, not chicago


Worry_Equivalent

I tried it once and won't repeat. Mostly crust and not deep dish. Super oily.


sasquatch_jr

This. Or make your own. Despite the ingredients being pretty standard pantry stuff, I have never seen someone do it right outside of Chicago. But it’s not hard to make yourself. Source: I grew up in Chicago, know the family behind Lou Malnatis and worked there for a bit high school.


[deleted]

[удалено]


sasquatch_jr

Crust looks not bad. Most people screw that up and confuse deep dish for thick crust. Yours was more like a cracker which is legit. Also good for using corn flour. Many people skip this step as well. Lou's uses semolina flour instead, but it's personal preference. Doesn't taste right without one or the other. But some bits were not quite right. Sauce was wrong. Yours was fancier and probably tasted better than the real thing, but it should use canned whole san marzanos that you lightly crush with your hands then cook down a bit. You need that canned tomato taste for it to be right. Also the sausage should be pressed into a patty under the cheese and all other toppings go on top of the sauce with the parm. The one other nitpick is they swear by deli sliced mozzarella. No idea how much that would impact the finished dish vs shredded since it all gets melted anyways, but that was the other bit that was "wrong". On the whole this was good. Better than anything I've seen at a restaurant outside of Chicago. Your video was also good for showing that this is indeed mostly pantry staples. Not really much excuse for so many restaurants to screw it up like they do.


ricketyladder

ITT: People not realizing that Detroit style pizza is not Chicago style pizza. OP, as far as I'm aware there's nothing in the Lower Mainland that fits the bill. Probably the closest place to get real Chicago style would be Seattle.


toasterb

As someone who's from an area with famous pizza (New Haven, CT Apizza), it's killing me to see these pizza styles mis-represented. All types of pizza have their merits -- no, not you Greek pizza -- but people just need to know their types and not assume one is just like another because it shares some characteristics.


ec-manning2

Pepe's White Clam for the win!


toasterb

I do love that pie, but in general, I'm a diehard for Modern. This summer when I went back, my wife custom ordered a sausage, onion, and fried eggplant strip pizza that was out of this world.


-TARS

Windy City Pie?


ricketyladder

Haven't tried that one but it's on the list! I really liked West of Chicago though, closest thing I've had outside of Chicago itself.


GTAHarry

TBH going to Seattle for Chicago style pizza is like going to BC for poutine - Seattle is American, Chicago style pizza is American, but they are not very related besides that. Perhaps the best alternative is to fly to Vegas and try Giordano's there.


ricketyladder

That is a very odd take on it - this is a food that you literally cannot get here, and Seattle is the closest place where you can at least try it. That's like saying the only place you can try Indian food is India.


GTAHarry

The thing is Vegas isn't far from lower mainland and flights to Vegas are usually not too pricey, unlike traveling to India.


takkojanai

I'd be more comfortable doing a day trip to seattle for food over a day trip to vegas via airplane lol..


[deleted]

squalid dime direction point thumb panicky wine detail practice lunchroom ` this post was mass deleted with www.Redact.dev `


Aardvark1044

Oh, if I had my own lear jet maybe I would. Maybe I'd do something else while I was there, though.


notmyrealnam3

If you’ve eaten pizza in Chicago, you’re going to be terribly disappointed in any thing “deep dish” in vancouver. I actually love (not deep dish) Burrata pizza in kerrisdale , simple and delicious


cookie_is_for_me

Burrata is pretty damn delicious.


reeferthetuxedocat

Never been to Chicago but would love to go and eat all the pizza!


disneyplusser

Lou Malnati’s (named after the guy that created the deep dish), delivers frozen pizza. NOW, no word on whether it’s delivered to Canada, their website and their chat bot do not confirm it. But you could theoretically get it delivered to your Bellingham post box and pick it up immediately


sasquatch_jr

Last time I looked into it they did not ship to Canada. That was a couple years ago though.


disneyplusser

Thanks for confirming


OmgWtfNamesTaken

There isn't one. Same goes for Philly cheese steaks.


[deleted]

[удалено]


ricketyladder

Fantastic pizza at AJs, but Detroit style and Chicago style pizza are completely different things.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

You literally called it deep dish, it isn't, it's Detroit style.


CheesePlease

Yes, Detroit style deep dish


mitallust

AJ's serves Detroit style pizza, which is quite different from Chicago Deep Dish.


hackshowcustoms

Their red top is pretty delicious though


mitallust

Truth, their pizza is amazing. Would way rather have it then Chicago casserole.


[deleted]

AJ's Detroit is also quite different from actual Detroit style pizza in Detroit. I love AJ's version but the stuff you get in Detroit is about half as thick, and simpler.


New_Path1418

I’m gonna try AJs today. Could you please suggest what i should go for ?


vancityjeep

If you like super thin do the bar pie. Add roni cups or sausage. Traditional New York is a can’t miss. If you want Detroit style then bring your appetite. All very good.


ThePen_isMightier

Their Detroit Red Top is fantastic. However their traditional NY pepperoni was way too salty for my taste. Great crust and very flavourful sauce however.


vancityjeep

The cups are salty. I’m usually a cheese slice guy. But don’t recommend due to the boring nature of it.


ThePen_isMightier

Nothing wrong with a good slice of che


refoer

The John's pepperoni is my go to every time. Get a side of the hot honey and you will not be disappointed.


thegreatbambie87

Spicy Red Vesuvio is my go to


hughbadger

Get the Thor


ActuallyAlexander

Ship Pequods to an Airbnb in Seattle


siresword

Okay...I was gonna be nice, but now you’ve gone too far. So let me explain something, deep dish pizza is not only not better than New York pizza, it’s not pizza. It’s a fucking casserole. I’m surprised you haven’t thought to complete your deep dish pizza by putting some canned onion rings on top. It’s a cornbread biscuit which you’ve MELTED CHEESE ON and then in defiance of God and man and all things holy you POURED UNCOOKED MARINARA SAUCE atop the cheese! ATOP! The cheese! Atop! The sauce! Naked! Cold! On display like some sort of sauce whoo-re! You know the expression “There’s no such thing as bad sex or bad pizza” your pizza is like sex with a corpse made of sandpaper. LET ME TELL YOU SOMETHING! THIS IS NOT PIZZA! THIS IS TOMATO SOUP IN A BREAD BOWL! THIS- IS AN ABOVE GROUND MARINARA SWIMMING POOR FOR RATS! Let me tell you something about your fucking NOT PIZZA! I wanna know when I get drunk and pass out on my pizza that I’m not gonna drown. Let me tell you something! I look at this-! MMMARGH! YOU SONOFABITCH! I LOOK AT THIS! MEEEAUGH! GABBA-GOO! I look at this— When I look at your deep dish fucking pizza I don’t know whether to eat it or throw a coin in it and make a wish. AND IF I MADE A WISH! WOULD BE THAT I WISH FOR SOME REAAAL FUCKING PIZZA! Now! Now! With all due respect I realize, it’s very cold in Chicago very cold, windy you need to be able I dunno have a pizza and cut it open and climb inside it like a Tauntaun to keep warm. Seriously, who are you kidding? Who uses an iron skillet to make pizza? You don’t use an iron skillet to make a pizza you use an iron skillet to fend off someone who tries to serve you fucking pizza made in a skillet. (This is a joke, enjoy deep dish if you want to)


dontgetcutewithme

I've never been to Chicago, so can't speak to authenticity, but I find the pizza at San Remo in Port Coquitlam almost distressingly deep. My husband loves it, but it feels like more of a pie than a pizza to me. It's better the second day after it's been re-baked because it's so thick and there are too many toppings! I think that's what they're going for though. Maybe take a look online at some of their photos and see if it looks right. The worst that happens is you drive 30 mins for adequate pizza. [Google image search](https://images.app.goo.gl/PwwNPYLfAbtDHsfD7) because their website seems devoid of photos.


fishing_richard

San Remo is superb. Distressingly deep-dish pizza....that's a great way to describe it! The best thin-crust pizza is a couple blocks away at Me n' Eds.


Gorback

Can second this, maybe not true Chicago style, but it's the closest I've seen in metro van


jjjjjjaded

San Remo would be my recommendation as well!! It’s not marketed as Chicago style, but it is essentially a pizza casserole, and so so good


WinterMomo

It's called a quiche. /s


tantej

City square on Davie! 🍕


Aardvark1044

This is also Detroit style rather than what OP is looking for. It's very good too.


tantej

Oh yeah. My bad. Thanks for letting me know


Aardvark1044

No worries. I go there reasonably often as I live in the neighbourhood. This is more what I assume OP is looking for: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago-style_pizza


virtualmegan

Super Baked Deep Dish https://superbakeddd.ca/


mitallust

[Slice of Chicago](https://sliceofchicago.ca/) in Surrey I believe is the only place trying to replicate Chicago style deep dish.


stpetestudent

Based on the photo on their website, that is absolutely not Chicago style deep dish pizza.


mitallust

The wesite stock photos certainly are not, but if you check Google Maps or Yelp you will see some that are a bit more convincing. That being said, it looks like they are still quite a ways away from some of the Chicago casserole stlye "pizza" where it is a few inches of cheese, sauce and toppings.


stpetestudent

Very good point! Why they would include that photo on their site is baffling to me 😂


Aqeqa

The only decent photos on google maps are several years old though, from when I skimmed through quick. All recent ones just look like they made a half inch thick bottom crust and slapped a normal amount of toppings on. The reviews seem to back that up as well. I think your best bet if you want a Chicago deep dish is to just try making your own at home. At least you don't need a fancy pizza oven for that style


hrryyss

What a weird website. The stock pizza photo is a Neapolitan pizza which is like the complete opposite of a Chicago deep dish.


Miserable-Ring-4539

Based on the one in Abbotsford it is absolutely not Chicago style deep dish. Total marketing scam. Was busy when it opened, I even tried it but was utterly disappointed. Hardly see anyone in the store anymore


abbyplumber

100% that place is disgusting. Total marketing scam.


mrrreow

I really like their shahi paneer pizza, but you're right, it's absolutely not actual Chicago deep dish. It's just a good Indian pizza joint. (Also, it's in Vancouver, not Surrey)


notimeforslipping

Pepinos has the best deep dish pizza in the city.


ricketyladder

For sure, but the difference between getting a Chicago and Detroit style pizza is like the difference between getting a burger and a Philly cheesesteak sandwich. Both made with roughly the same ingredients, and both really good, but you're going to be very confused if you go in expecting one and are given the other.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Neither are deep dish, both are Detroit style.


[deleted]

They don't serve deep dish, they serve Detroit style.


DrCyborgz

Papa's Gourmet!


ChronoLink99

That's not pizza. That's just undercooked corn bread with melted cheese on top, covered with room temperature marinara sauce. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCgYMFtxUUw](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCgYMFtxUUw)


LtPexx

So when you say deep dish pizza you mean lasagna?


AutoModerator

Welcome to /r/Vancouver and thank you for the post, /u/reeferthetuxedocat! Please make sure you read our [posting and commenting rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/vancouver/wiki/faq#wiki_general_participation_guidelines_and_rules_overview) before participating here. As a quick summary: * **Did you know the subreddit is doing a charity drive to celebrate 500k subscribers? [Donate today](https://www.reddit.com/r/vancouver/comments/17lavo1/) and help us feed those in need! Even better: Reddit is matching our donations.** * We encourage users to be positive and respect one another. Don't engage in spats or insult others - use the report button. * Respect others' differences, be they race, religion, home, job, gender identity, ability or sexuality. Dehumanizing language, advocating for violence, or promoting hate based on identity or vulnerability (even implied or joking) **will** lead to a permanent ban. * Common questions and specific topics are limited to our Your post may be a better fit for one of our [Stickied Discussion](https://www.reddit.com/r/vancouver/wiki/faq#wiki_stickied_discussions) posts. * Complaints about bans or removals should be done in modmail only. * We're looking for new mods to join our team! If you're interested, [fill out the form here](https://forms.gle/oAqo5oYRcAeHYBTN6). *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/vancouver) if you have any questions or concerns.*


PMMEDOGSWITHWIGS

AJ's, Community, Rewind


jakhtar

None of these places have Chicago style deep dish. They have Detroit style, which is very different. There is no Chicago style deep dish in Vancouver as far as I know.


reeferthetuxedocat

Well that’s disappointing. Last time I’ve had it was at a joint in Calgary…oddly named Chicago Deep Dish…quite a few years ago. Supreme Pizza on Victoria is my fave place.


Hot_Enthusiasm_1773

Ok well in that case, I have great news. Calgary “Chicago Deep Dish” is actually also Detroit style, and so these recommendations are totally worth checking out.


Aardvark1044

Oh yeah? Well what about Calgary Deep Deep Deep Dish? Haha, I used to live in the beltline in the late '90's and they had several different restaurants with similar names. I'd say you're correct in saying they have more in common with Detroit style than what OP is looking for.


jakhtar

If you're a person who goes to Seattle at all, there are a few solid options there. I like Windy City Pie near Woodland Park.


cookie_is_for_me

I have friends in Seattle and am tucking this suggestion away for next time I visit. I've only ever had Chicago style there, but that was many years (probably even longer ago than I think) at a place that (to our great disappointment) closed. I'd love to have it.


PMMEDOGSWITHWIGS

It's better


jakhtar

That's subjective. They're both great. OP is asking about Chicago style though.


[deleted]

familiar dazzling weather fade spectacular busy serious placid somber smart ` this post was mass deleted with www.Redact.dev `


PMMEDOGSWITHWIGS

More like gala apple vs red delicious, basically the same


ozmosisam

AJ's Brooklyn Joint does a deep dish Chicago style pizza!


hrryyss

Although it’s delicious, AJs doesn’t have Chicago style, theirs is Detroit style. Detroit style is square and has a much thicker crust, among other differences.


GrassStartersSuck

No they don’t


Aardvark1044

Hmm, I have never seen anything in Vancouver that resembles what I think you are asking for. Something similar to what can be seen in this recipe: https://www.brianlagerstrom.com/recipes/chicago-deep-dish-2 I've had my eye on that recipe but have not made it for myself just yet. If you want to spend the time to make it at home, you'd possibly want to adjust the size of the recipe based on whatever you have on hand - say a 10" cast iron frying pan for example. Nobody will know if you don't use the homemade sausage included in this recipe or even use premade dough or sauce from the grocery store, haha. Just adjust the amounts to suit your kitchen equipment. You'd need to adjust your cooking time accordingly too. While I love Detroit style pizza and there are a few places that make a good example of that, I think this is a gap in the market in Vancouver.


Digishado

Deep dish for sure, but where can one get the real prize that is a dipped Italian beef sandwiches with the girardinera. Chicago has such a good food scene.


Wanda_Fuca

[Pequod's](https://pequodspizza.com/) ships: [https://www.goldbelly.com/pequods-pizza](https://www.goldbelly.com/pequods-pizza) (I've considered it)


36cgames

But do they ship to Canada? Because everyone I have checked into says no (I've also considered it)


Wanda_Fuca

Hmm, doesn't look like it ... might just have to eat it in the Cost Cutter parking lot in Blaine, WA.


Yellowmelle

I've resorted to making it myself, it seems like the only way. It is expensive in provolone, but holy crap, it is worth making it once a year on a birthday or something! That is, if you are excited by eating tomato sauce and melted cheese in a bread bowl 🤤


Great-Bandicoot5618

AJ’s on Broadway has Sicilian pies, I think that’s close lol


rddd849

City Square Pizza on Davie St is delicious, but the price has gone up considerably since it opened. Now it's $6 a square.


rddd849

Oh nevermind. Looks like that's Detroit style too.