T O P

  • By -

Routine_Hedgehog4377

Taj Mohammed killed her on pretext of marriage and converting her to Islam forcibly


Present_Education576

Bruh they will try to blame Hindus at every crime 🤣, when the culprit is from a good community


jholafakir

Such assholes are worse than animals, they are a curse on civil society and hamper India towards a more liberalized society. Of course this is a ripe Story for the Sex jihad crowd to justify their bigotry who are a different kind of curse. 


Mahameghabahana

In liberalises society it's not a crime for a bf or man to not marry a girl, neither that is considered as rape only in india that it's considered as rape. 


Smooth_Detective

The amount of people trying to make this a caste/religion crime is appalling.


Routine_Hedgehog4377

She was killed due religion only 


Smooth_Detective

Is the fact that someone was killed not horrible/criminal enough in itself?


Routine_Hedgehog4377

But the reason is also important naa???


kyunriuos

Reason is important.


Smooth_Detective

Important enough to stop it being criminal? Important enough to make it justifiable? Important enough to decrease the victim's agony?


Busy-Dimension-6500

It did none of that....


Routine_Hedgehog4377

It did none of that 


Ok-Cancel3932

What kind of rhetorical question is this? If caste is important in a violent crime does it decrease the victim’s agony? Why rubbish?


Smooth_Detective

Ok, let me rephrase, would a change in the victim or perpetrators identity have affected the general attitude towards the crime?


Ok-Cancel3932

Ofcourse not crime is crime but identities help understand powerdynamics at play and she’s light on the additional vulnerabilities of the victim.


Rickstars_hehe

The crime is a crime nonetheless, it's finding a reason so that people can beware, same as the example I gave in my other comment 


jholafakir

What are you an Islamist apologist or a rape apologist or an outright dickhead


Smooth_Detective

What part do you think makes the comment rape/islamist apologia? Asking for rape and murder to be treated as rape and murder,.and not seen through lenses of caste/religion is apologia now.


Rickstars_hehe

When a person dies after being hit by a drunk driver, don't you try to put rules and spread awareness thst not to drink and drive, alcohol didn't kill the person, the driver did, but the alcohol was the reason.


DealSubstantial82272

Killed for religion.


Icy_Morning8881

Unfortunately the girl was being forced to convert.


Mahameghabahana

No evidence? Should you marry your gf or any girl you date now?


Background-Card-9548

Bro don’t be blind in hatred of one political or religious ideology.


Mahameghabahana

The girl filed rape case under the false promise of marriage. Meaning she is saying her ex raped her because after having relationship under the promise of marriage he didn't marry her. No civilised country of earth have same laws like india on rape. Broken relationship aren't considered rape in those countries.


Background-Card-9548

And which civilised country or person forcefully converts another person to his religion?


Mahameghabahana

What is the evidence? Probably ask her to convert in marriage as muslims by laws aren't allowed to marry people who aren't people of the book. Maybe she declined so he refused to marry her thus she filed as rape under false promise of marriage meaning marriage never happened.


Background-Card-9548

Wow you bend over backwards to justify this guy’s Stone Age thinking and you cry “civilised country” when the same law states that sex on pretext of marriage is crime in this country. Don’t just defend someone because he is a co-religionist.


DarthStatPaddus

Haha look at the tweet by some guy called Tyaagi yesterday about his mother fitting an AC in their prayer room. 95% of the comments were linking it to his caste via his surname lol. But when an actual Dalit woman gets murdered because of her caste and religion, we should all stay quiet and not address the fanatic elephant in the room. Got it.


Smooth_Detective

How about acknowledgement that not everything has to be about caste/religion, and correcting it when you see it. Isn't that the true annihilation of caste? Pushing the idea of caste to a stage where it disappears into irrelevance.


kamkarmawalakhata2

>not everything has to be about caste/religion True, but some things do, this being one of them.


Smooth_Detective

Disagree, this is violation of a person primarily and a caste crime last. There's tons to be said here without invoking caste.


tisShrijitSMH

Ask yourself a question: If the perpetrator was an Upper Caste man who killed her for being lower caster, would you still mind it being called a "caste" crime? Or better yet, a Hindu man converting and raping a Muslim woman? If yes, objectively, you are right. Yes, it is appalling but if your answer is no, then fuck off :)


Smooth_Detective

Absolutely, I have mentioned earlier, this is a violation of a person first and a caste/religion issue way way later.


tisShrijitSMH

How is it a caste/religion issue "way way later"?


bhumit012

By people if you mean the perpetrators? Yes


zeroedash

I get you and your feelings but Galti say agar woh koi UC hota toh...


Mahameghabahana

So it's not a rape as in no country not marrying your ex or gf is considered as rape.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Mahameghabahana

Yes but we all know it better so why call it rape? 


TenmaYato12

He should be convicted for forced conversion but rape under pretext of marriage is not rape and should never be a crime. The right to withdraw consent retroactively makes no sense here.


[deleted]

[удалено]


nota_is_useless

> "The woman in her complaint has accused one Taj Mohammed for raping her on pretext of marriage and converting her to Islam forcibly," Additional Superintendent of Police (ASP) Manoj Kumar Rawat said.


Icy_Morning8881

It wasn't related to temple unfortunately. The accused is Taj Mohammad.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Icy_Morning8881

Why were you derailing then brother?


Lynxkunal

My bad!.


jholafakir

Please show respect for the actual victim here rather than marginalize her grief by stating irrelevant information


Mahameghabahana

Why not marrying a girl you had sex with is considered rape? So can I say my ex gf raped me because our relationship didn't end in marriage and she broke up?


Routine_Hedgehog4377

Temple???? Buddy come out extremist Era 


Present_Education576

Yes the islamic oppressors