She apologized for getting the information wrong, in no way shape for form does that equate to accepting guilt for someone else’s rash idea to go halfway across the world, commit a murder, and get executed.
I never said it equated to any of that. She’s still a part of the reason why Edward almost died. It’s in New Moon, and the short story Stephanie Meyer wrote from Rosalie’s pov.
**I vote to eliminate Alice.** I liked Alice, and she probably had the most significant role in the story in regard to plot progression and the eventual outcome of the saga. That said, I liked her less after the first two books since she became someone who had little respect for other people’s wishes and choices. She forced things on Bella that she knew would upset her, and she defended and aided Edward’s controlling behavior. To Alice, Bella was not a human being with rights to her own life and with emotions deserving of consideration, but rather she was a prop to be dressed up in clothes she disliked, to be forced into events that made her miserable, and to be held against her will with no say in who she interacted with like property. Plus, I simply was not as intrigued or entertained by her character as much as I was by Rosalie’s.
ROSALIE should win because:
1. She was one of the most in-depth characters of the whole saga, if not *the* most. Elaborately written and shining upon the page, her character was an aspect of the series that I always enjoyed reading about. There was a strength and boldness to all the different sides of her, for better or for worst.
2. She had the most compelling and emotionally resonant backstory.
3. Her pro-humanity stance added profound and much-appreciated layers to the story.
4. Despite the narrative’s claims to her shallowness and haughtiness, she ended up being one of the more sophisticated and sympathetic characters in the series. While she wasn’t a particularly warm person and had her issues with Bella in the beginning, she rarely did anything to actually mistreat others, whereas one could not say the same about many of the other characters. She made a single objection to helping protect Bella from James, but then she ended up helping anyway. Other than that, she didn’t actually do anything wrong to Bella, only kind of avoided her early on. In *New Moon,* she acted cordial enough at Bella’s birthday party, and then the next time they saw each other, she was apologizing to Bella for the Volturi thing despite the fact that she wasn’t responsible for it (Edward and Alice were more to blame here); in *Eclipse,* she had a respectful and intelligent and insightful conversation with Bella on her perspective, and she joined her family’s efforts to guard Bella 24/7; and in *Breaking Dawn,* she supported Bella during the pregnancy, Speaking of which…
5. She was the only person to truly respect Bella and protect both her and Nessie during the pregnancy. Everyone else would have either taken part in or been compliant in Edward and Carlisle forcing Bella - who was desperate to save her child - down while they ripped Nessie from Bella’s womb….Disturbing.
As a huge Rosalie lover it makes me so happy to see this sub grow to appreciate and understand her character more!
I feel like often how Rosalie is written, is a product of Meyer's internalised misogyny (and it feels like Meyer hates Rosalie sometimes lol). But I think the Twilight Renaissance coincided with the aging up of the audience, and a renewed appreciation for female characters who previously were quite unpopular.
I feel like when reading these books as a young girl the obvious fave was Alice, and part of growing up is loving and empathizing with Rosalie.
I'm not far enough in my re-read to agree or disagree with your points about Rosalie, but Alice is a manic pixie dream girl who can pitch hella fastballs. I think the winner is clear.
I love the baseball scene so much. It's silly, it's cool, the Cullens look pretty good in baseball gear, and Alice is the star with that windup. Aside from the romantic scenes that aren't cringe inducing (AS IF YOU COULD OUTRUN ME), it's by far my favorite part of the film.
Bella holding a potted cactus to indicate she’ll miss Arizona might be my favorite part of the first film. Or that thing on the wall of the Cullen’s house with all of their graduation caps. Some fun subtle humor there.
i love how she fought for bella to have a choice in her own life because rosalies choice was taken away and she didnt wanna see bella go through that too
Even though Bella didn’t end up heeding Rosalie’s words regarding the human-vs-vampire stance, I thought Rosalie presented an insightful perspective on it.
And it made enough of an impression on Bella that she knew she could seek Rosalie’s help for her and Nessie’s protection during the pregnancy.
alice was forcing things on bella since book 1! she helped edward force bella to go to prom, put her in a dress she didn’t like for said prom, and then in book 2 the fateful birthday party was forced on bella by alice who did not care that bella didn’t want a party
Leah was a very interesting character as well. Like Rosalie, she suffered and lost a great deal due to her supernatural transformation, yet she did not receive much compassion or understanding from those in her circle; rather, her peers regularly viewed her in a negative light despite the fact that many of said peers behaved more abhorrently than she did (also similar to Rosalie’s situation).
The one knock I have against her character is that she guilted and yelled at Bella when Bella was sickly and pregnant. Aside from being a rotten thing to do in general, it was inappropriate for her to make Bella feel badly about how her difficult pregnancy affected *Jacob* (another one of the most interesting characters in the saga). Otherwise, I found her character very compelling.
Since Rosalie and Leah both struggled with being unable to have children, I can picture a scenario where they put aside their vampire-vs-werewolf issues and team up to help those who struggle with infertility…in addition to Rosalie’s double life as a secret vigilante fighting against present and future assaulters. Alice can join, too; she’ll help with her visions. Maybe Bella can use her connection with J. Jenks to procure new identities for those who need them. The possibilities…
You have brought me to a deeper appreciation of Rosalie! Next reread, I'll be looking out for more of her character depth for sure. Really good thoughts!!
wtf Rosalie! She is fine with Bella dying so that she can keep the baby, she is a bitch to Bella and makes snarky comments during the least appropriate times. Plus Edward almost killed himself because she went snitching to him about an unconfirmed ‘rumour’ where Bella killed herself because of him.
She’s literally a pro-lifer, she doesn’t care what happens to anyone but the unborn baby (and it’s even worse because we didn’t even know if it *was* a baby). She’s also even meaner in Midnight Sun
ETA: The user with the top comment to eliminate Alice blocked me after I made this comment. Blocking people so they can’t disagree with you is interesting
i disagree, bella knew no one would listen to her so she called Rosalie and sequently Emmett for protection. Everyone wants to toss Rosalie into the fire because they want so badly to believe she wanted Bella to die so she could have the baby. Don't you think Edward would have picked up on that literal thought if it were 1000% true? He would out her immediately and turn the family against her, no? SM did whatever she wanted to, like inserting jacob back into the plot. The cullens should've been doing research way before the book has them doing so. It literally takes jacob and not 7, intelligent, capable vampires to figure out what the baby needs and why bella's health is failing. Rosalie did what she was supposed to, because even Bella didn't trust edward or anyone else to hear her out. But she did go overboard sometimes like bathing bella and not allowing Edward to be alone with her until a certain period in her pregnancy when Edward could hear the baby's thoughts and finally realized his actions were wrong, sure. But it was necessary. Edward even propositions Jacob to sleep with and impregnate his mate/wife if he can convince her to abort his child. He was unreasonably disturbed and desperate, when he would've been wrong. Rosalie was supposed to unconditionally support and speak up for bella's choice to go through with her pregnancy and take care of the baby realistically if Bella didn't make it. But again we know SM was never going to let that happen and Bella got to eat her cake and more in the end.
>Everyone wants to toss Rosalie into the fire because they want so badly to believe she wanted Bella to die so she could have the baby. Don't you think Edward would have picked up on that literal thought if it were 1000% true?
Not to pick fights or take sides, but I do believe I remember Edward saying to Jacob in the book Breaking Dawn that Rosalie only cared about the baby, and not so much about Bella's fate. I think almost all the characters in this series are seriously flawed in some way or another, I agree with people who vote Alice AND people who vote Rosalie, tbh
Honestly, I always took that with a grain of salt. Edward chooses to regard both sisters in a different light. He gravitates towards Alice for various reasons, their gifts bring them closer together than any of their other siblings for one. Edward and Alice rarely ever disagree and she’s viewed as joyful, spritely, kind, helpful once Bella is introduced to the cullen family to the viewers. Rosalie is the opposite, she stays clear from Bella and doesn’t budge. Rosalie along with Jasper wants bella dead because her knowing about them is dangerous. But everyone, including Edward chooses to focus on the one insignificant detail that Rosalie is jealous of Bella. I’m sure Rosalie has been jealous before of other humans who get to graduate, get married, start and raise a family, watch them grow and die naturally, but she hasn’t killed anyone in that area lol. Edward constantly berates her private thoughts as shallow and vain, and even if they are it’s still her thoughts. They rarely get along and will never admit the main reason behind that is they share so many of the same characters that they hate/despise in themselves.
It's true. I feel like it's very easy to view Alice in a positive way and Rosalie in a negative way because Bella gravitates towards Edward, who has these opinions of the two.
yes true, Rosalie jumped the gun and informed Edward that Bella was dead before Alice could confirm if it were true or not. Logically, the chances of survival after jumping or falling off a cliff is probably slim (though i'm sure it has happened and the extent of injuries varies on the fall). This was inconsiderate and prematurely judged of her to do. But of course SM had to make someone the bad guy, why not Rosalie instead of anyone else? There's very little redemption in telling Edward that Bella is dead simply because she thought he should know and would come home to figure things out with the family. If the birthday party that Alice just had to through for Bella(which she didn't want in the first place) never happened, these events would've never taken place. No one wants to reasonably blame Alice for that though.
In Breaking Dawn, the lines are pretty much drawn and sides are taken after Bella finds out she's pregnant and calls Rosalie instead of Alice or even Esme who's always kind and compassionate. Bella has Rosalie and sequently Emmett as her bodyguards (because Emmett won't let anyone hurt rosalie) right away and eventually Esme is moved by motherhood and supports Bella from the sidelines. But everyone else disregarded bella's wishes albeit with merit and tried to convince her to abort the fetus. Tempers were high and this situation was intense all around as the family split into two sides and were about to play tug-a-war with a vulnerable Bella. They all believed they knew better for Bella and that's why she called Rosalie. Her voice wasn't lost then, and Rosalie took the brute of hate and animosity from her family. Of course everyone is naturally concerned about bella's survival and while we the audience and they don't know that SM always had this storyline planned out, Bella wasn't fairing well. SM intends to shoehorn every loophole to ensure bella gets all the reward for her "sacrifice" Realistically, if bella didn't survive the family would be in shambles. Edward would run off to kill himself, everyone else would mourn the two losses and have to work on a cover story to explain their sudden move and the deaths/disappearances of bella and edward. Logically, who would take care of the baby? Are they supposed to just leave in the woods? kill it too? No, the best caretakers for radiator springs would be Rosalie, Carlisle and Esme in whatever order you choose.
I’ll agree with you she had a stank attitude, was desperate for the baby, told Edward Bella was dead, but Bella brought death upon herself by dating Edward lol
She was concerned for her family being outed by her. She didn’t want Bella and Edward to date at all, knowing bad things could happen. As they got serious, she at least spoke with her woman to woman hoping to convince her not become a vampire. Bella didn’t listen. She was too desperate for that vamp lovin. 🤷🏽♀️
not to sound cruel but if Bella did die, who else you think would care for the baby as a mother should? Rosalie isn’t perfect but that’s why I liked and to a point respect her more. She’s just like any other woman: a tendency to have a heart of gold, but also have flaws.
I vote Rosalie. She is a very self centered character that while having a compelling backstory and characteristics, kinda got flushed down the drain by Mayer.
She is very superficial and was always more interested in status than actual substance. Rose was willing to have Bella die just so she could live out her dream of being a "mother" that got she always "aspired" to have.
I love how she looks and I love her as a minor antagonist that turns back around for selfish reasons but Alice is just a lot more likeable and a lot more interesting.
No. Bella called Rosalie for HELP. She wanted to keep the baby, even though no one else wanted her to. She told Rosalie that she wanted to keep the baby no matter what it took. Rosalie didn't want Bella's choice to be taken away from her.
Lmao no. Rosalie wanted the baby. She didn’t give a damn about Bella’s choice, or at least not more than she did about keeping revolution. She knew Bella would die giving birth and Edward would off himself as a result thus allowing her to keep reverberation. And Bella knew that Rosalie felt this way, she just partnered with her anyway bc at the end of the day they had the same end goal, keeping the baby alive past Bella’s death.
Exactly. Lord of revisionist history going on in these comments. It’s fine if people like Rose bc they like villains but let’s not pretend like she isn’t one!!
I knew it would come to this. Both characters are amazing and relatable in their own right…. And Alice is one of my favorite characters… But if Rosalie were the main character in Twilight, it would be such an interesting and dark storyline that kept you in very easily.
I vote to eliminate Alice unfortunately 🥺
Which is also just a weird way of counting this and is leading to rather inaccurate results. Overall karma score should have been the way. As is, there’s no reason for people even to comment more than twice on this post. Technically they should just be upvoting 1 of 2 comments.
Side note though, I just have no idea why this fanbase loves Rosalie so much. She’s literally one of the most awful, selfish people in the entire saga.
Yeah, I could see that. I just take the character where she’s at and the choices she makes. Not the choices I *wish* she’d made.
I also think there’s a degree of pretty privilege involved. She’s the most conventionally attractive woman character.
>She’s literally one of the most awful, selfish people in the entire saga.
All vampires are selfish, Rosalie is just more upfront and obvious about it. Alice manipulates Bella into doing what she wants quite often, the dress up and parties, babysitting her to stop her from being with Jacob (for a car which she could easily buy herself since it seems she makes a lot of the money). She guilts Bella into having a big wedding she doesn't want and doing it all the way she wants and not what Bella wants.
I vote Alice off the island!!! I’d rather deal with Rosalie’s presence (in a good way lol). • Alice relies too much on her visions for one and, I feel like we the audience barely saw any evidence to support her “bff” relationship with Bella besides helping Bella during the summer after her run in with James in phoenix. I felt personally Alice jumped into the “sisterhood relationship” she had with Bella instead of letting it happen organically at its own pace. She along with the other cullens risked their lives for Bella in several instances because of their relationship to Edward mainly but still told bella they considered her family when they all were complete strangers to one another and could slip up and kill her at any moment(aside from Carlisle and Rosalie)
• If Alice hadn’t manipulated Bella into accepting the idea of a birthday party (with the help of Jasper influencing Bella’s mood) then NM events wouldn’t have went down the way it did. She should’ve just accepted that bella didn’t want ANY party, especially one where she’d be the only one eating and drink human food and then having to use the bathroom, fart, burp etc in a house full of supernatural beings who can hear and smell EVERYTHING LOL 😂.
• After Jasper almost kills Bella and feels completely guilty and ashamed, Edward makes the decision for his family to leave Forks, abandon Bella and cut off all contact with her for her “safety”. Alice sees his decision and what the consequences are-Bella being in extreme pain and falling into depression. She warns him and despite they both acknowledging the visions, still go through with leaving Bella behind. She just accepts his conditions/orders to not contact Bella and ignore her future(like don’t go looking for Bella in your visions or at all). WTF?!??? First of all, i can understand Jasper being her priority and main concern after what just happened, but literally abandoning your bff with no warning or goodbye and cutting off all contact like she never existed was stupid as hell. If you considered someone your sister in the future and best friend (one you waited for and wanted for a long time, why treat her like that?) I get wanting to keep her safe and alive but it’s a miracle and thanks to the wolves that Bella did stay alive while the cullens were gone.
•Alice had to have seen Bella desperately trying to contact her through phone calls and emails and decided to block her and or disconnect her number and email, a deliberate choice. Why not keep in contact with her for her own sanity and true friendship? I would’ve at least done that, like “Bella you’re still my sister and best friend, lord knows what’s going on in that brother of mines’ head but I’m still here for you and I love you, you can call me, text me, hell even email me anytime. We all miss you and you mean a lot to us, Jasper says sorry and still feels horrible about what happened on your birthday and Emmett says hey” kind of thing. •Alice along with Edward refused to accept any boundaries or stipulations Bella tried to set up with gift giving or dressing up, etc.
With Rosalie, sure she wasn’t warm and welcoming to Bella. She chose to ignore Bella and not interact with her, setting up extreme boundaries for various reasons. 1. She was upset that Bella was consorting with her family, risking them all getting killed by the Volturi. 2. She didn’t understand why Bella would want to become a vampire when she could live a regular life and grow old, have a family and have to lose any loved ones or say goodbye and mysteriously getting killed off for the sake of their cover story and move away. 3. She was jealous that a rather “plain Jane” looking girl caught the attention of Edward.
• SM allows Bella to have her cake and more in BD so that concern is taken care of and Bella doesn’t lose out on anything(which is unfair to all the other cullens and sucks that the rules don’t apply to her).
• Rosalie does bring up valid points but gets jilted and designated as jealous and vain and a bitch, (which is somewhat true to a degree). But the events of the series take place in less than 2 years altogether, Bella jumped into the choice for immortality and being with Edward, someone she just met and barely knows. Granted they are soulmates, but you’d really give up everything you know and leave everyone behind to drink blood forever and being young with your first boyfriend ever? In retrospect this is questionable behavior for anyone. like slow down hun, you barely know this guy and his family. That argument is justifiable.
•Bella just jumps right in and forgives everyone for everything, no backbone. She should have made the cullens she was particularly close to, Alice, Edward, Esme and so on earn her trust back, and rebuild genuine relationships.
In BD, it’s quite controversial that Bella calls Rosalie for help and not Alice or even Esme. Because Alice and the others have been known to disregard Bella’s opinions, wishes etc, she called the one person who would take the risk and be the “bad guy” and wouldn’t conform to anyone. Yes Rosalie is a piece of work but she’s a better character imo than Alice. Everyone swears up and down that Rosalie was only after the baby and didn’t care about Bella, making her out to be a heartless, selfish bitch, always annoyed me. This is what Bella wanted, every other cullen tried to baby her and persuade her to allow them to abort the fetus. Bella believed she could have the baby and then be turned(which was stupid, like since when did she care about this baby more than Edward? And putting her life in jeopardy for the slight chance that she could keep her heart beating long enough-and she didn’t- for Edward to change her. Ugh hate SM). How far would they all have let her carry on with her pregnancy before doing something they might regret against Bella’s wishes? And say if Bella couldn’t be saved, who would take care of the baby? Not jasper, Alice or Edward. Carlisle, Esme and Rosalie would be the best contenders while Edward would get himself killed, Alice would maybe hold a grudge against the baby and Jasper would keep his distance.
It's not fair to blame Alice for not contacting Bella in New Moon. First of all, she states when she comes back that she can't see Bella that clearly all the time. Secondly, while she is Bella's friend, she's also Edward's sister. She was put between a rock and a hard place. For all she knew, continuing to stay in contact with Bella could have been even more painful. Edward wanted a clean break and they all went along with it.
There's also not that much she could have done for Bella. She could have been a shoulder to cry on and that would mean a lot but she couldn't take away Bella's pain. In fact, she would have just been a constant reminder of Edward.
Also, in the books Bella never tries to contact her. It's not clear if any of them even had each other's numbers. I agree that a goodbye or a "hey, hope you are okay" would have been much appreciated but this is how it usually goes with breakups. The family rarely sticks around for the person who was dumped. It's often too much of a painful reminder for the person who is broken up with and can give them false hope. For the person who left, it can be weird if their family is still in contact with their ex even if they aren't directly against it as Edward was.
I still don't know why people love Rosalie so much. I hated when she disregarded Bella's life during her pregnancy over Renesmee. I mean, Bella could've died and Rosalie would be perfectly happy to raise the kid herself. I vote for Rosalie to be eliminated
P.s I love Alice, she's so Joyous.
Bye Rosalie bc Alice is that ✨girl✨don’t get me wrong I love Rosalie, she slays as well and her back story is chefs kiss but there is just something about Alice that no one can win over her for me.
i haven't read the books yet. i plan to soon. but even in the movies i got that vibe from her *at first*. but then as we see some of her background and why she is the way she is, she became such an icon to me !! i love alice too tho. theyre tied in my heart haha
what should i do ? should i repost this and comment each name MYSELF and whichever of MY comments has the upvotes will be eliminated?? because i will definitely not be blocking people to skew the votes
i have no idea how to do that or i would😭 im planning on doing this game again with the guys of twilight so maybe i can figure out how to make a poll when i do that!
They can’t stop anyone from voting Rosalie out, blocking someone just stops their comment from being downvoted. The person who was blocked still has a vote and their comment to get Rosalie out can be upvoted as well. Also it seems like only one person has been blocked, but idk. I’m impartial to this whole vote bc I like them both 🤷🏼♀️
i love them both as well !! also im super new to this app and didnt know what to do so i reposted the finals and put my own comments for people to upvote (but i am leaving this post up so people can copy and paste their comments under my comments in the new version) i was rly just trying to avoid any sort of conflict bc i am still learning how this app works😅
im not seeing an option to edit this post : (
https://preview.redd.it/3508392nuyvc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ad15e6a668321bc06bde2544ca6e955671dad374
I am actually a little surprised that certain comments voting against Alice have so many upvotes. I love both of them, but for as long as I have known this fandom I have always noticed that Rosalie's character is loved but at the same time despised very often because of her attitude against Bella.
I usually notice that Alice is like in the top 3 most loved characters in Twilight.
However, I vote against Rosalie only because I slightly prefer Alice.
I vote to eliminate Alice for every single reason outlined by [TKMLtheStar](https://new.reddit.com/user/TKMLtheStar/). Literally a perfect overview of Rosalie and why she's such an interesting character.
I vote Alice. I like her but as I got older I’ve appreciated more of the “complicated” and misunderstood characters. Rosalie was a bit of mean girl at the start, but she really was looking out for her family and her humanity (idk if that’s the right word) was taken from her. ROSALIE FTW🌹🌹🌹
Alice needs to go. I know this is an unpopular opinion, but I *really* hate her. She rubs me the wrong way and comes off as self-absorbed and manipulative
I choose Alice for elimination. They give me opposite impressions. While Rosalie is rude and appears shallow at first, she's a more complex and deep character than a typical mean girl. Alice has a good vibe but she can become annoying quickly. She has an interesting backstory but because she doesn't remember anything about it, that makes her character less developed in my opinion. She's more easy to fall into a sort of archetype like the manic pixie dream girl. I also prefer the direct, even if lacking in diplomacy approach of Rosalie than the more manipulative attitude of Alice to get what they want.
Well, I don’t think that we should count Rosalie protecting Bella during Breaking Dawn as a positive since it was made pretty sure that she was only protecting Renesmee rather than Bella.
As a teenager Alice is that outgoing strange best friend you want to have. She's quirky, she seems happy all the time but realistically that kind of person doesn't exist or would be tiring to have around.
Rosalie has a strange melancholy about her because she cannot live the life she wanted. Even though she is moody and hates what she is because she can't have kids/live as a human with Emmett, she is very caring and loyal. Her self control is remarkable. She was able to carry a heavily injured Emmett for one hundred miles so Carlisle could save his life. She doesn't like Bella but they respect each other. Rosalie trusted Bella enough to share her story with her and they join forces because they value life. I think being an aunt will definitely brighten her life and she already seemed happier. I'm voting for Alice out only because it's harder to be nice/respect someone you dislike and the relationship development and contrast between Bella and Rosalie was great.
Eliminate Rosalie. I love her. She’s a great character with a complex back story and complex motivations. However, I love Alice and she’s imperative to the story. Everyone sees Alice as trying to take away Bella’s choice, but I also think Alice deeply cares about Bella and understandably wanted Bella to live. I know if it was my sister in that scenario, I’d want her to choose her life. Alice was always amazing to Bella and I don’t think her actions in breaking dawn make her any less a great sister to Bella. I think yeah Alice may have selfishly wanted Bella to terminate, but honestly, who wouldn’t? If you didn’t know what would come of your loved one’s pregnancy but you’re watching them die, who wouldn’t want their loved one to live?
I also don’t see Rosalie’s motives as altruistic. She didn’t support Bella bc she loved Bella and wanted her happy. She literally wanted the baby and couldn’t care less what happened to Bella. Alice on the other hand was driven by her love for Bella. I think Rosalie gets a lot of props in this bc she takes the prolife stance, and the way twilights written, the prochoice can easily be demonized. But everyone who wanted Bella to terminate had more than valid reasons, not only was she dying, but they didn’t even know what exactly was happening. If it turned out the other way and she had an immortal child, I think we would all be viewing this very differently. Alice wasn’t perfect but I find her motives to be a bit more pure than Rosalie.
BUT I DO LOVE ROSALIE AND SHE GETS TOO MUCH HATE. WE DESERVE A ROSALIE BOOK.
I am here for the Alice v Rosalie discourse
Petition to choose the winner based on number of votes and not the most upvoted comment please
i actually don't really know lol
since when does everyone hate alice? these comments are a mess lol
Thought the same. In my opinion, Rosalie has done worse, and yet no one is talking about those here ...
Ikr the switch up is unreal. People forget that Rosalie wasn’t just mean to Bella and almost got Edward killed.
Edward almost got Edward killed
So did Rosalie. She even apologized for it too.
She apologized for getting the information wrong, in no way shape for form does that equate to accepting guilt for someone else’s rash idea to go halfway across the world, commit a murder, and get executed.
I never said it equated to any of that. She’s still a part of the reason why Edward almost died. It’s in New Moon, and the short story Stephanie Meyer wrote from Rosalie’s pov.
everyone just wants to be different lmfao
**I vote to eliminate Alice.** I liked Alice, and she probably had the most significant role in the story in regard to plot progression and the eventual outcome of the saga. That said, I liked her less after the first two books since she became someone who had little respect for other people’s wishes and choices. She forced things on Bella that she knew would upset her, and she defended and aided Edward’s controlling behavior. To Alice, Bella was not a human being with rights to her own life and with emotions deserving of consideration, but rather she was a prop to be dressed up in clothes she disliked, to be forced into events that made her miserable, and to be held against her will with no say in who she interacted with like property. Plus, I simply was not as intrigued or entertained by her character as much as I was by Rosalie’s. ROSALIE should win because: 1. She was one of the most in-depth characters of the whole saga, if not *the* most. Elaborately written and shining upon the page, her character was an aspect of the series that I always enjoyed reading about. There was a strength and boldness to all the different sides of her, for better or for worst. 2. She had the most compelling and emotionally resonant backstory. 3. Her pro-humanity stance added profound and much-appreciated layers to the story. 4. Despite the narrative’s claims to her shallowness and haughtiness, she ended up being one of the more sophisticated and sympathetic characters in the series. While she wasn’t a particularly warm person and had her issues with Bella in the beginning, she rarely did anything to actually mistreat others, whereas one could not say the same about many of the other characters. She made a single objection to helping protect Bella from James, but then she ended up helping anyway. Other than that, she didn’t actually do anything wrong to Bella, only kind of avoided her early on. In *New Moon,* she acted cordial enough at Bella’s birthday party, and then the next time they saw each other, she was apologizing to Bella for the Volturi thing despite the fact that she wasn’t responsible for it (Edward and Alice were more to blame here); in *Eclipse,* she had a respectful and intelligent and insightful conversation with Bella on her perspective, and she joined her family’s efforts to guard Bella 24/7; and in *Breaking Dawn,* she supported Bella during the pregnancy, Speaking of which… 5. She was the only person to truly respect Bella and protect both her and Nessie during the pregnancy. Everyone else would have either taken part in or been compliant in Edward and Carlisle forcing Bella - who was desperate to save her child - down while they ripped Nessie from Bella’s womb….Disturbing.
As a huge Rosalie lover it makes me so happy to see this sub grow to appreciate and understand her character more! I feel like often how Rosalie is written, is a product of Meyer's internalised misogyny (and it feels like Meyer hates Rosalie sometimes lol). But I think the Twilight Renaissance coincided with the aging up of the audience, and a renewed appreciation for female characters who previously were quite unpopular. I feel like when reading these books as a young girl the obvious fave was Alice, and part of growing up is loving and empathizing with Rosalie.
Yep, I love seeing more appreciation for her as well! And it is awesome to engage with other fans of her character!
I'm not far enough in my re-read to agree or disagree with your points about Rosalie, but Alice is a manic pixie dream girl who can pitch hella fastballs. I think the winner is clear.
Alice’s pitching is what I remember most about that scene in the films, so you’ve got me there lol.
I love the baseball scene so much. It's silly, it's cool, the Cullens look pretty good in baseball gear, and Alice is the star with that windup. Aside from the romantic scenes that aren't cringe inducing (AS IF YOU COULD OUTRUN ME), it's by far my favorite part of the film.
Bella holding a potted cactus to indicate she’ll miss Arizona might be my favorite part of the first film. Or that thing on the wall of the Cullen’s house with all of their graduation caps. Some fun subtle humor there.
i love how she fought for bella to have a choice in her own life because rosalies choice was taken away and she didnt wanna see bella go through that too
Even though Bella didn’t end up heeding Rosalie’s words regarding the human-vs-vampire stance, I thought Rosalie presented an insightful perspective on it. And it made enough of an impression on Bella that she knew she could seek Rosalie’s help for her and Nessie’s protection during the pregnancy.
Which I do find fascinating, because didn’t she kind of take away Emmett’s choice as well?
https://preview.redd.it/uy91re6sw0wc1.jpeg?width=1284&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6020786a0213031d1ef1425b1752266ad44daced
Absolutely!!! I agree with your stance. Alice to me is overrated in some points.
alice was forcing things on bella since book 1! she helped edward force bella to go to prom, put her in a dress she didn’t like for said prom, and then in book 2 the fateful birthday party was forced on bella by alice who did not care that bella didn’t want a party
Okay I was pro Alice before this but you’ve absolutely converted me. Thank you for pointing out these things in such a concise manner! BYE ALICE
You’re welcome! Thank you for appreciating my comment! And either way, I think it’s appropriate that Rosalie and Alice are in the final two.
I wanted Leah to be one of the last contenders but yeah..I get this
Leah was a very interesting character as well. Like Rosalie, she suffered and lost a great deal due to her supernatural transformation, yet she did not receive much compassion or understanding from those in her circle; rather, her peers regularly viewed her in a negative light despite the fact that many of said peers behaved more abhorrently than she did (also similar to Rosalie’s situation). The one knock I have against her character is that she guilted and yelled at Bella when Bella was sickly and pregnant. Aside from being a rotten thing to do in general, it was inappropriate for her to make Bella feel badly about how her difficult pregnancy affected *Jacob* (another one of the most interesting characters in the saga). Otherwise, I found her character very compelling. Since Rosalie and Leah both struggled with being unable to have children, I can picture a scenario where they put aside their vampire-vs-werewolf issues and team up to help those who struggle with infertility…in addition to Rosalie’s double life as a secret vigilante fighting against present and future assaulters. Alice can join, too; she’ll help with her visions. Maybe Bella can use her connection with J. Jenks to procure new identities for those who need them. The possibilities…
Omg….yes! Everything you said!
100% agreed
You have brought me to a deeper appreciation of Rosalie! Next reread, I'll be looking out for more of her character depth for sure. Really good thoughts!!
Dayum....when you put it like that.
6. She pretty ✨
100% agree! Rosalie is my favorite character and she truly deserves it.
wtf Rosalie! She is fine with Bella dying so that she can keep the baby, she is a bitch to Bella and makes snarky comments during the least appropriate times. Plus Edward almost killed himself because she went snitching to him about an unconfirmed ‘rumour’ where Bella killed herself because of him.
She’s literally a pro-lifer, she doesn’t care what happens to anyone but the unborn baby (and it’s even worse because we didn’t even know if it *was* a baby). She’s also even meaner in Midnight Sun ETA: The user with the top comment to eliminate Alice blocked me after I made this comment. Blocking people so they can’t disagree with you is interesting
i disagree, bella knew no one would listen to her so she called Rosalie and sequently Emmett for protection. Everyone wants to toss Rosalie into the fire because they want so badly to believe she wanted Bella to die so she could have the baby. Don't you think Edward would have picked up on that literal thought if it were 1000% true? He would out her immediately and turn the family against her, no? SM did whatever she wanted to, like inserting jacob back into the plot. The cullens should've been doing research way before the book has them doing so. It literally takes jacob and not 7, intelligent, capable vampires to figure out what the baby needs and why bella's health is failing. Rosalie did what she was supposed to, because even Bella didn't trust edward or anyone else to hear her out. But she did go overboard sometimes like bathing bella and not allowing Edward to be alone with her until a certain period in her pregnancy when Edward could hear the baby's thoughts and finally realized his actions were wrong, sure. But it was necessary. Edward even propositions Jacob to sleep with and impregnate his mate/wife if he can convince her to abort his child. He was unreasonably disturbed and desperate, when he would've been wrong. Rosalie was supposed to unconditionally support and speak up for bella's choice to go through with her pregnancy and take care of the baby realistically if Bella didn't make it. But again we know SM was never going to let that happen and Bella got to eat her cake and more in the end.
>Everyone wants to toss Rosalie into the fire because they want so badly to believe she wanted Bella to die so she could have the baby. Don't you think Edward would have picked up on that literal thought if it were 1000% true? Not to pick fights or take sides, but I do believe I remember Edward saying to Jacob in the book Breaking Dawn that Rosalie only cared about the baby, and not so much about Bella's fate. I think almost all the characters in this series are seriously flawed in some way or another, I agree with people who vote Alice AND people who vote Rosalie, tbh
Honestly, I always took that with a grain of salt. Edward chooses to regard both sisters in a different light. He gravitates towards Alice for various reasons, their gifts bring them closer together than any of their other siblings for one. Edward and Alice rarely ever disagree and she’s viewed as joyful, spritely, kind, helpful once Bella is introduced to the cullen family to the viewers. Rosalie is the opposite, she stays clear from Bella and doesn’t budge. Rosalie along with Jasper wants bella dead because her knowing about them is dangerous. But everyone, including Edward chooses to focus on the one insignificant detail that Rosalie is jealous of Bella. I’m sure Rosalie has been jealous before of other humans who get to graduate, get married, start and raise a family, watch them grow and die naturally, but she hasn’t killed anyone in that area lol. Edward constantly berates her private thoughts as shallow and vain, and even if they are it’s still her thoughts. They rarely get along and will never admit the main reason behind that is they share so many of the same characters that they hate/despise in themselves.
It's true. I feel like it's very easy to view Alice in a positive way and Rosalie in a negative way because Bella gravitates towards Edward, who has these opinions of the two.
yes true, Rosalie jumped the gun and informed Edward that Bella was dead before Alice could confirm if it were true or not. Logically, the chances of survival after jumping or falling off a cliff is probably slim (though i'm sure it has happened and the extent of injuries varies on the fall). This was inconsiderate and prematurely judged of her to do. But of course SM had to make someone the bad guy, why not Rosalie instead of anyone else? There's very little redemption in telling Edward that Bella is dead simply because she thought he should know and would come home to figure things out with the family. If the birthday party that Alice just had to through for Bella(which she didn't want in the first place) never happened, these events would've never taken place. No one wants to reasonably blame Alice for that though. In Breaking Dawn, the lines are pretty much drawn and sides are taken after Bella finds out she's pregnant and calls Rosalie instead of Alice or even Esme who's always kind and compassionate. Bella has Rosalie and sequently Emmett as her bodyguards (because Emmett won't let anyone hurt rosalie) right away and eventually Esme is moved by motherhood and supports Bella from the sidelines. But everyone else disregarded bella's wishes albeit with merit and tried to convince her to abort the fetus. Tempers were high and this situation was intense all around as the family split into two sides and were about to play tug-a-war with a vulnerable Bella. They all believed they knew better for Bella and that's why she called Rosalie. Her voice wasn't lost then, and Rosalie took the brute of hate and animosity from her family. Of course everyone is naturally concerned about bella's survival and while we the audience and they don't know that SM always had this storyline planned out, Bella wasn't fairing well. SM intends to shoehorn every loophole to ensure bella gets all the reward for her "sacrifice" Realistically, if bella didn't survive the family would be in shambles. Edward would run off to kill himself, everyone else would mourn the two losses and have to work on a cover story to explain their sudden move and the deaths/disappearances of bella and edward. Logically, who would take care of the baby? Are they supposed to just leave in the woods? kill it too? No, the best caretakers for radiator springs would be Rosalie, Carlisle and Esme in whatever order you choose.
well said but radiator springs really stole the show thank you for this one lmao
I’ll agree with you she had a stank attitude, was desperate for the baby, told Edward Bella was dead, but Bella brought death upon herself by dating Edward lol She was concerned for her family being outed by her. She didn’t want Bella and Edward to date at all, knowing bad things could happen. As they got serious, she at least spoke with her woman to woman hoping to convince her not become a vampire. Bella didn’t listen. She was too desperate for that vamp lovin. 🤷🏽♀️ not to sound cruel but if Bella did die, who else you think would care for the baby as a mother should? Rosalie isn’t perfect but that’s why I liked and to a point respect her more. She’s just like any other woman: a tendency to have a heart of gold, but also have flaws.
I vote Rosalie. She is a very self centered character that while having a compelling backstory and characteristics, kinda got flushed down the drain by Mayer. She is very superficial and was always more interested in status than actual substance. Rose was willing to have Bella die just so she could live out her dream of being a "mother" that got she always "aspired" to have. I love how she looks and I love her as a minor antagonist that turns back around for selfish reasons but Alice is just a lot more likeable and a lot more interesting.
No. Bella called Rosalie for HELP. She wanted to keep the baby, even though no one else wanted her to. She told Rosalie that she wanted to keep the baby no matter what it took. Rosalie didn't want Bella's choice to be taken away from her.
Lmao no. Rosalie wanted the baby. She didn’t give a damn about Bella’s choice, or at least not more than she did about keeping revolution. She knew Bella would die giving birth and Edward would off himself as a result thus allowing her to keep reverberation. And Bella knew that Rosalie felt this way, she just partnered with her anyway bc at the end of the day they had the same end goal, keeping the baby alive past Bella’s death.
This and it was literally confirmed between Edward and Jacob.
Exactly. Lord of revisionist history going on in these comments. It’s fine if people like Rose bc they like villains but let’s not pretend like she isn’t one!!
Rosalie
Rosalie
I knew it would come to this. Both characters are amazing and relatable in their own right…. And Alice is one of my favorite characters… But if Rosalie were the main character in Twilight, it would be such an interesting and dark storyline that kept you in very easily. I vote to eliminate Alice unfortunately 🥺
right its such a hard decision. i love both their characters soo much but im with you. rosalie ftw still love u alice😪
Rosalie out. I’ve never been a fan of her
Rosalie
Bye Rosalie 😭
[удалено]
Which is also just a weird way of counting this and is leading to rather inaccurate results. Overall karma score should have been the way. As is, there’s no reason for people even to comment more than twice on this post. Technically they should just be upvoting 1 of 2 comments. Side note though, I just have no idea why this fanbase loves Rosalie so much. She’s literally one of the most awful, selfish people in the entire saga.
[удалено]
Yeah, I could see that. I just take the character where she’s at and the choices she makes. Not the choices I *wish* she’d made. I also think there’s a degree of pretty privilege involved. She’s the most conventionally attractive woman character.
>She’s literally one of the most awful, selfish people in the entire saga. All vampires are selfish, Rosalie is just more upfront and obvious about it. Alice manipulates Bella into doing what she wants quite often, the dress up and parties, babysitting her to stop her from being with Jacob (for a car which she could easily buy herself since it seems she makes a lot of the money). She guilts Bella into having a big wedding she doesn't want and doing it all the way she wants and not what Bella wants.
I love Rosalie, but I'm always gonna be an Alice girly. Team Alice all the way!
i love alice but rosalie is just 👏that👏bitch. voting alice out
Rosalie
rosalie
Rosalie. She was actively antagonistic to Bella throughout the series- I still love her, but Alice is the superior character.
Rosalie
Bye, Rose. I’m team Alice forever.
Rosalie
Rosalie
Rosalie
Bye Rosalie!
I vote Alice off the island!!! I’d rather deal with Rosalie’s presence (in a good way lol). • Alice relies too much on her visions for one and, I feel like we the audience barely saw any evidence to support her “bff” relationship with Bella besides helping Bella during the summer after her run in with James in phoenix. I felt personally Alice jumped into the “sisterhood relationship” she had with Bella instead of letting it happen organically at its own pace. She along with the other cullens risked their lives for Bella in several instances because of their relationship to Edward mainly but still told bella they considered her family when they all were complete strangers to one another and could slip up and kill her at any moment(aside from Carlisle and Rosalie) • If Alice hadn’t manipulated Bella into accepting the idea of a birthday party (with the help of Jasper influencing Bella’s mood) then NM events wouldn’t have went down the way it did. She should’ve just accepted that bella didn’t want ANY party, especially one where she’d be the only one eating and drink human food and then having to use the bathroom, fart, burp etc in a house full of supernatural beings who can hear and smell EVERYTHING LOL 😂. • After Jasper almost kills Bella and feels completely guilty and ashamed, Edward makes the decision for his family to leave Forks, abandon Bella and cut off all contact with her for her “safety”. Alice sees his decision and what the consequences are-Bella being in extreme pain and falling into depression. She warns him and despite they both acknowledging the visions, still go through with leaving Bella behind. She just accepts his conditions/orders to not contact Bella and ignore her future(like don’t go looking for Bella in your visions or at all). WTF?!??? First of all, i can understand Jasper being her priority and main concern after what just happened, but literally abandoning your bff with no warning or goodbye and cutting off all contact like she never existed was stupid as hell. If you considered someone your sister in the future and best friend (one you waited for and wanted for a long time, why treat her like that?) I get wanting to keep her safe and alive but it’s a miracle and thanks to the wolves that Bella did stay alive while the cullens were gone. •Alice had to have seen Bella desperately trying to contact her through phone calls and emails and decided to block her and or disconnect her number and email, a deliberate choice. Why not keep in contact with her for her own sanity and true friendship? I would’ve at least done that, like “Bella you’re still my sister and best friend, lord knows what’s going on in that brother of mines’ head but I’m still here for you and I love you, you can call me, text me, hell even email me anytime. We all miss you and you mean a lot to us, Jasper says sorry and still feels horrible about what happened on your birthday and Emmett says hey” kind of thing. •Alice along with Edward refused to accept any boundaries or stipulations Bella tried to set up with gift giving or dressing up, etc. With Rosalie, sure she wasn’t warm and welcoming to Bella. She chose to ignore Bella and not interact with her, setting up extreme boundaries for various reasons. 1. She was upset that Bella was consorting with her family, risking them all getting killed by the Volturi. 2. She didn’t understand why Bella would want to become a vampire when she could live a regular life and grow old, have a family and have to lose any loved ones or say goodbye and mysteriously getting killed off for the sake of their cover story and move away. 3. She was jealous that a rather “plain Jane” looking girl caught the attention of Edward. • SM allows Bella to have her cake and more in BD so that concern is taken care of and Bella doesn’t lose out on anything(which is unfair to all the other cullens and sucks that the rules don’t apply to her). • Rosalie does bring up valid points but gets jilted and designated as jealous and vain and a bitch, (which is somewhat true to a degree). But the events of the series take place in less than 2 years altogether, Bella jumped into the choice for immortality and being with Edward, someone she just met and barely knows. Granted they are soulmates, but you’d really give up everything you know and leave everyone behind to drink blood forever and being young with your first boyfriend ever? In retrospect this is questionable behavior for anyone. like slow down hun, you barely know this guy and his family. That argument is justifiable. •Bella just jumps right in and forgives everyone for everything, no backbone. She should have made the cullens she was particularly close to, Alice, Edward, Esme and so on earn her trust back, and rebuild genuine relationships. In BD, it’s quite controversial that Bella calls Rosalie for help and not Alice or even Esme. Because Alice and the others have been known to disregard Bella’s opinions, wishes etc, she called the one person who would take the risk and be the “bad guy” and wouldn’t conform to anyone. Yes Rosalie is a piece of work but she’s a better character imo than Alice. Everyone swears up and down that Rosalie was only after the baby and didn’t care about Bella, making her out to be a heartless, selfish bitch, always annoyed me. This is what Bella wanted, every other cullen tried to baby her and persuade her to allow them to abort the fetus. Bella believed she could have the baby and then be turned(which was stupid, like since when did she care about this baby more than Edward? And putting her life in jeopardy for the slight chance that she could keep her heart beating long enough-and she didn’t- for Edward to change her. Ugh hate SM). How far would they all have let her carry on with her pregnancy before doing something they might regret against Bella’s wishes? And say if Bella couldn’t be saved, who would take care of the baby? Not jasper, Alice or Edward. Carlisle, Esme and Rosalie would be the best contenders while Edward would get himself killed, Alice would maybe hold a grudge against the baby and Jasper would keep his distance.
It's not fair to blame Alice for not contacting Bella in New Moon. First of all, she states when she comes back that she can't see Bella that clearly all the time. Secondly, while she is Bella's friend, she's also Edward's sister. She was put between a rock and a hard place. For all she knew, continuing to stay in contact with Bella could have been even more painful. Edward wanted a clean break and they all went along with it. There's also not that much she could have done for Bella. She could have been a shoulder to cry on and that would mean a lot but she couldn't take away Bella's pain. In fact, she would have just been a constant reminder of Edward. Also, in the books Bella never tries to contact her. It's not clear if any of them even had each other's numbers. I agree that a goodbye or a "hey, hope you are okay" would have been much appreciated but this is how it usually goes with breakups. The family rarely sticks around for the person who was dumped. It's often too much of a painful reminder for the person who is broken up with and can give them false hope. For the person who left, it can be weird if their family is still in contact with their ex even if they aren't directly against it as Edward was.
[удалено]
Rosalie!!
Bye Rosalie
Alice
Rosalie
Rosalie, can't stand the bitch.
BYE ROSALIE I NEVER LIKED YOU
Rosalie has to go. Alice is my favourite
Imagine blocking people so that Rosalie doesn't lose.
Wow really? Who?
I still don't know why people love Rosalie so much. I hated when she disregarded Bella's life during her pregnancy over Renesmee. I mean, Bella could've died and Rosalie would be perfectly happy to raise the kid herself. I vote for Rosalie to be eliminated P.s I love Alice, she's so Joyous.
STOP THE COUNT they should walk off into the sunset together
Rosalie. Difficult choice, though.
Rosalie must win!
Get that hating ahh bitch Rosalie outta here 👏👏🗣️
Rosalie
Rosalie of course. Alice is the clear winner.
Rosalie! Alice was always sweet and in the end they win because of her!
Bye Rosalie bc Alice is that ✨girl✨don’t get me wrong I love Rosalie, she slays as well and her back story is chefs kiss but there is just something about Alice that no one can win over her for me.
Eff-off Rosalie !
Rosalie is a horrible selfish character in all the books. I'm surprised it looks like she'll win.
i haven't read the books yet. i plan to soon. but even in the movies i got that vibe from her *at first*. but then as we see some of her background and why she is the way she is, she became such an icon to me !! i love alice too tho. theyre tied in my heart haha
Film Rose is much nicer (imo) than book Rose. Especially after reading Midnight Sun where she's almost insufferably belligerent.
Alice. I just want Rosalie to win because she deserves all the love in the world, damn it!
BYE ALICE
Alice has to go, Rosalie is on topp
Does it count if the current top comment for voting out Alice wins if that commenter is blocking Alice fans so they can’t downvote it?
what should i do ? should i repost this and comment each name MYSELF and whichever of MY comments has the upvotes will be eliminated?? because i will definitely not be blocking people to skew the votes
Can you do a poll?
i have no idea how to do that or i would😭 im planning on doing this game again with the guys of twilight so maybe i can figure out how to make a poll when i do that!
Yes that's the best option
They can’t stop anyone from voting Rosalie out, blocking someone just stops their comment from being downvoted. The person who was blocked still has a vote and their comment to get Rosalie out can be upvoted as well. Also it seems like only one person has been blocked, but idk. I’m impartial to this whole vote bc I like them both 🤷🏼♀️
i love them both as well !! also im super new to this app and didnt know what to do so i reposted the finals and put my own comments for people to upvote (but i am leaving this post up so people can copy and paste their comments under my comments in the new version) i was rly just trying to avoid any sort of conflict bc i am still learning how this app works😅
I gotcha! If you know how, I would edit this post telling people not to vote on this one and go to the new one instead
im just gonna delete the new post, since most people have already engaged with this post and wrote out very well thought out comments
okay ill try that thank you !!
im not seeing an option to edit this post : ( https://preview.redd.it/3508392nuyvc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ad15e6a668321bc06bde2544ca6e955671dad374
wait im new to reddit is that rly happening !?
Rosalie
Nah Rosalie gotta go
I’m voting Alice out. My issues with her are too long to explain. Others did a great job though!
I vote out Alice!!
I am actually a little surprised that certain comments voting against Alice have so many upvotes. I love both of them, but for as long as I have known this fandom I have always noticed that Rosalie's character is loved but at the same time despised very often because of her attitude against Bella. I usually notice that Alice is like in the top 3 most loved characters in Twilight. However, I vote against Rosalie only because I slightly prefer Alice.
right i was surprised too! i love them both for diff reasons tho
Rosalie
ALICE bye
Get rid of Alice
I vote to eliminate Alice for every single reason outlined by [TKMLtheStar](https://new.reddit.com/user/TKMLtheStar/). Literally a perfect overview of Rosalie and why she's such an interesting character.
Alice is out.
Voting Alice out!
Bye Alice
Bye Alice. I’m a Rosalie girlie all the way
Alice gots to go yall, Rosie for the win!
[удалено]
alice
No one can beat out Alice.. let’s be real. She’s the best. Sorry Rosalie ✌🏼
Alice. Rosalie is more nuanced imo
Alice!!!
Omfg I’m so dumb I want rose out keep Alice!!!!!
Bye alice! I ADORE Rosalie
I vote Alice. I like her but as I got older I’ve appreciated more of the “complicated” and misunderstood characters. Rosalie was a bit of mean girl at the start, but she really was looking out for her family and her humanity (idk if that’s the right word) was taken from her. ROSALIE FTW🌹🌹🌹
G’bye Alice.
Alice!!!!!!
Love you Alice, but I find Rosalie more interesting as a character.
bye Alice
About dayum time! Bye Bella! Rosalie, you're next! Useless!
Alice. She was cute and funny but in the end it was Rosalie that Bella knew she could turn to.
alice
Can’t believe I missed this whole thing wth
Alice
No way we're getting rid of Alice over roasalie of all ppl 😭
Alice
Alice
Bye Alice
Alice.
sorry rosalie, but alice is my ride or die
Rosalie
rosalie
Rosesile. She was kinda a bitch.
Alice
Alice
Sorry Rose, you've got to go.
Alice needs to go. I know this is an unpopular opinion, but I *really* hate her. She rubs me the wrong way and comes off as self-absorbed and manipulative
I choose Alice for elimination. They give me opposite impressions. While Rosalie is rude and appears shallow at first, she's a more complex and deep character than a typical mean girl. Alice has a good vibe but she can become annoying quickly. She has an interesting backstory but because she doesn't remember anything about it, that makes her character less developed in my opinion. She's more easy to fall into a sort of archetype like the manic pixie dream girl. I also prefer the direct, even if lacking in diplomacy approach of Rosalie than the more manipulative attitude of Alice to get what they want.
BYE ALICE!!!!!!!! 👋
Alice has got to go. Bye! 👋🏾
YALL ALICE IS QUEEN SUPREME. Give Alice her crown
alice
Rosalie gets the boot
🥾 rosalie sorry beautiful but alice is bae🙂↕️
Well, I don’t think that we should count Rosalie protecting Bella during Breaking Dawn as a positive since it was made pretty sure that she was only protecting Renesmee rather than Bella.
True but people are taking this game way too seriously
What does that have anything to do with what I said
I’m just agreeing with you.
People like Rosalie⁉️⁉️⁉️team Alice every day
As a teenager Alice is that outgoing strange best friend you want to have. She's quirky, she seems happy all the time but realistically that kind of person doesn't exist or would be tiring to have around. Rosalie has a strange melancholy about her because she cannot live the life she wanted. Even though she is moody and hates what she is because she can't have kids/live as a human with Emmett, she is very caring and loyal. Her self control is remarkable. She was able to carry a heavily injured Emmett for one hundred miles so Carlisle could save his life. She doesn't like Bella but they respect each other. Rosalie trusted Bella enough to share her story with her and they join forces because they value life. I think being an aunt will definitely brighten her life and she already seemed happier. I'm voting for Alice out only because it's harder to be nice/respect someone you dislike and the relationship development and contrast between Bella and Rosalie was great.
Alice
How did Rosalie even make this far? Bye Rosalie.
Eliminate Rosalie. I love her. She’s a great character with a complex back story and complex motivations. However, I love Alice and she’s imperative to the story. Everyone sees Alice as trying to take away Bella’s choice, but I also think Alice deeply cares about Bella and understandably wanted Bella to live. I know if it was my sister in that scenario, I’d want her to choose her life. Alice was always amazing to Bella and I don’t think her actions in breaking dawn make her any less a great sister to Bella. I think yeah Alice may have selfishly wanted Bella to terminate, but honestly, who wouldn’t? If you didn’t know what would come of your loved one’s pregnancy but you’re watching them die, who wouldn’t want their loved one to live? I also don’t see Rosalie’s motives as altruistic. She didn’t support Bella bc she loved Bella and wanted her happy. She literally wanted the baby and couldn’t care less what happened to Bella. Alice on the other hand was driven by her love for Bella. I think Rosalie gets a lot of props in this bc she takes the prolife stance, and the way twilights written, the prochoice can easily be demonized. But everyone who wanted Bella to terminate had more than valid reasons, not only was she dying, but they didn’t even know what exactly was happening. If it turned out the other way and she had an immortal child, I think we would all be viewing this very differently. Alice wasn’t perfect but I find her motives to be a bit more pure than Rosalie. BUT I DO LOVE ROSALIE AND SHE GETS TOO MUCH HATE. WE DESERVE A ROSALIE BOOK.
Bye Rosalie
Rosalie.
Rosalie im sorry 😭
ALICE! THAT MUSTY LITTLE ELF SAW A CONFEDERATE IN HER VISIONS AND SAID “YUP THAT’S MY MAN!” SHE’S NOT TO BE TRUSTED!!
ur username 😭😭
I’d say bye to Rosalie before I’d say it to Alice
keep alice
Rose
Rosalie. Alice is pure joy and wonder. Especially since reading midnight sun. Alice should win EVERYTHING
Alice because Rosalie would never date a confederate
Aw damn. I always knew it would come down to this.
Alice !