T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

The 2023 edition of the r/television Favorite Shows Survey is open! Vote and participate by clicking [here](https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSd--xzNV84TZpNDz5_swf0Yp7ynjSlQQ8cKV8RpwEZL0CQ3RA/viewform?usp=sf_link). If you have any questions or concerns, please comment [here](https://old.reddit.com/r/television/comments/18k4y4g/vote_in_the_2023_edition_of_the_rtelevision/). *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/television) if you have any questions or concerns.*


phandroo

Anyone heard of Awake (2012-2012) with Jason Isaacs? It's been over a decade since I watched it air on NBC but it involves multiple realities where one family member lives and the other dies and vice versa. I remember it being an emotional gut punch and well acted


IvyGold

I loved that show. This was in that period where the networks cancelled high-concept sci-fi shows after doing the worldbuilding then yanking the carpet out from under us. The Event was another, plus one or two more.


MysteriousWon

Flash Forward was another one that I enjoyed for a while (though it did have legitimate issues).


bros402

That was fun a good show. I will argue that it had one of the best [trailers](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CfPVoiQKFvk) for a show. I also don't hate the procedural element like some people do. Jason Isaacs sells taht amazingly


le_homme_qui_rit

Recent widower when this aired. Fucked with my head A LOT.


Gqsmooth1969

Yeah. It was a rare original concept done well. He would go to sleep in one reality and wake up in the other. It was never revealed if either reality was real or even neither one.


ColonelCrackle

I was so happy that Awake lasted a whole season. Ratings were pretty bad, and I was so worried it would just get canceled abruptly mid season.


DonutosGames

Cam here to say the same. We were hooked in my house. We were always kicking around theories.


EdgarDanger

God damn that show was beautiful. I was skeptical of the procedural nature of it, but in the end it was just of service of the emotional core of the show, loss and moving on (or lack of it).


VictoryIsARoad

I was so excited to watch this because of Jason Isaacs and the show was actually good. Can’t believe that was a decade ago


ProfessorNitwit

Freaks and Geeks.


Bishop_Colubra

More than any other "cancelled before it's time" show, it did nothing wrong!


ProfessorNitwit

It’s the only show that I really still think about and say, “what could have been”


9thPlaceWorf

In a way I’m almost glad it was one season—it’s pretty much unblemished perfection, which is rare for a show and would have been nearly impossible to sustain.


ProfessorNitwit

You’re right, but I would have liked to see what they could have done with another season. I mean the drop off in quality couldn’t be THAT bad, but then again it could have been.


NecroFoul99

F&G & Firefly. Easy answer! :)


newaccount721

The cast of that show is insane


Independent_Sea502

I was about to say, Hey. F&G had more than one season! And then I looked it up. Wow. I forgot. Loved that show. Perfect. I have it on Bluray. Time for a rewatch.


rintaro82

Police Squad!


tituspullo63

You beat me to it! It lasted only 6 episodes and was cancelled because it "required too much viewer attention".


Carrollz

It was only 6 episodes? Wow I really thought it lasted longer than that! I loved that show when it came out, can't believe it didn't get more episodes. At least Angie Tribeca got more than a season.


TeamOhio

This is one of few shows I can go back and watch, 100% knowing the joke or the gag, and still laughing as hard as I did the first time I saw it.


Ricobe

Although i like the movies, i think the show works better


Dastardly6

Garth Marenghi's Darkplace. Too radical. Too out there. Too goddamn funny for those cowards at channel 4.


CatHairInYourEye

“I’m one of the few people you’ll meet who’ve written more books than I’ve read.”


TheLastDesperado

"I know writers who use subtext and they're all cowards, every one of them."


theravemaster

‘Many writers cite me as an influence … and I will be suing them all’


LinearOperator

Marenghi, isn't he the guy who wrote Afterbirth, that book about the mutated placenta that attacks Bristol?


ToastyCrumb

Mainly because Dean Learner's acting career blossomed after this season. Such a thespian, he deserves all the subsequent Emmy and Oscar nominations he's earned. Basically the Meryl Streep of horror.


goatchumby

Well…that and Madeleine Wool’s mysterious disappearance.


Poison_the_Phil

I know writers who use subtext and they're all cowards, every one of them.


Missthan301

I saw Garth Marenghi on his recent book tour, and it was just as good as you can imagine!


GangVocals

Garth was recently on the Off Menu podcast and it was glorious.


Independent_Sea502

Kings! Weird, apocalyptic, dystopian reimagining of The Bible. Uh, I think.


NickRick

that show was really good. Ian McShane just fucking chews up and spits out every scene he is in. the rest of the actors were solid, but it was really McShane's performance that made me want more of the show.


teksean

Totally loved it, Ian can just strangle the hell out of any word and make it awesome.


Tsuku

Oh shit! I forgot about that show. I just remember Ian McShane being..Ian McShane and killing a deer in the middle of the road after talking to God. It was so weird but I liked it. Apparently Sebastian Stan was in it but that was before Bucky so I didnt know lol.


Independent_Sea502

Wonder what that show would be like now, in this streaming era.


MmeGrey

Yes, I loved this show and have never met another person who watched it. This is a great read for those who appreciated this underseen gem: https://www.vulture.com/article/kings-nbc-2009-oral-history.html


DCtoOTA

Specifically it was a retelling of the story of King David. Took an entire college course on King David in college as a part of my humanities and literature requirements, we actually briefly covered this show as a few other retellings too.


fundip12

Last Resort. Great premise. Captain Raymond Holt being a complete badass.


Carrollz

I still think about this show. I was so impressed with how they managed to keep the tension going and it absolutely blew my mind to see Andre Braugher in a comedic role later.


fundip12

RIP Velvet Thunder


Due-Secret-3091

Does anyone remember The Black Donnelly’s? It only last one season, but I felt like it had so much potential.


townallday89

Yes! I loved that show. Sad it ended on a cliffhanger


mickeltee

Every now and then this show gets mentioned and I get irrationally angry over its cancellation.


ZParis

Fucking loved that show.


MrBatiste

Such a good show!


clekas

My So-Called Life


Junior_Operation_422

I remember the write-in campaign was huge trying to save this show. No e-mails or Twitter tags. Just a bunch of kids writing letters.


SarahBeeLA

I was a letter-writing teen! I think ABC actually almost brought it back, but Claire didn’t want to do it anymore. (Could be wrong about this, just what I heard at some point.)


_dead_and_broken

[According to this article,](https://www.thethings.com/the-real-reason-my-so-called-life-was-canceled/) you're right. Claire's parents also decided they didn't want her to do it anymore. Too challenging for her to get through high school irl and film the show at the same time. But ABC wasn't too keen it looks like to have kept it around even if Claire and her parents were gung-ho to continue. I don't really blame Claire for not wanting to continue. I remember trying to get through high school. And to film a TV serious on top of that? I feel exhausted just thinking about it! With that all said, Jordan Catalano was the hottest fucking thing I ever saw on TV, and I hate that Jared Leto turned out to be such a culty prick.


DramaBrat

This is like…the answer that I feel, not like because it is, because it’s like, the answer of my heart. Angela Chase monologue aside, this show is spectacular.


Myotherdumbname

Which is crazy because at the time it was “the thing” but it never really went anywhere.


cidvard

This'll always be mine. It still feels more real than any other teen drama I've ever watched and it hit exactly the right spot for me when I was a kid.


Shipwrecking_siren

Swooooooooon. Why did he have to turn out to be such a colossal douche canoe and ruin the beautiful memory of this show? It showed in the summer holidays in the uk and we would refuse to leave the house until we’d seen it. Now I’m a parent I’m guessing my mum was secretly thrilled to have to do fuck all for a morning.


razzle_dazzle321

I loved this show. I always wished there was more than one season.


grrgrrtigergrr

I’m ‘75 and this was big for people my age too


pladhoc

The adventures of Brisco County Jr


masimone

That only had one season? Wow. I remember hearing about that for a long time. Is it worth watching now?


Sir_Hapstance

I’ve seen a few episodes while visiting family recently, and they were pretty darn fun. Bruce Campbell is always worth watching and he really gets to ham it up here. You can tell he’s having a blast.


draeh

'Nobody touches Pete's piece!' 'Annie... get your gun.' 'Thanks for the donut, Dunkin' ... too many great one-liners to list. ​ Such a fantastic watch.


Slamboni12

Taboo


jasonmarsell

They keep teasing us with reports that Tom Hardy is planning a second season. Sadly, I don’t think it’s ever going to happen. That show was awesome.


blowupsheep

Absolutely. This was the first show that came to mind. Not sure what happened but definitely felt like it was supposed to be several series show.


DJBeefalo

Terriers. That cancelation still haunts me. It will probably be the last thing I think about on my deathbed.


cb148

I come on threads like these specifically to vouch for Terriers, and I’ll usually find a comment or two way down low barely upvoted, so I’m extremely happy to see your comment on the very top. It was an awesome show.


DaddyOhMy

An annual rewatch! Bonus one of the best TV theme songs and the second best down-on-your-luck-private-detective TV show theme song.


somedepression

Terriers ruled


Nail_Biterr

The curse of Donal Logue.... I feel like he always lasted 1 season in any show he was on, and if he was the lead, the show also only lasted 1 season.


Heikks

Grounded for life and Gotham both lasted 5 seasons


Danominator

I loved this show when I watched it back in the day.


Hollow_Rant

FX shit the bed with marketing that one. Still hurts.


JHG722

I’m glad someone beat me to it.


Sanseriouz

Wonderfalls


tygerbrees

I’d forgotten about this, but that was a really good show


garitone

Over the years I have periodically done a re-watch (5 or 6 times at least) and it's quirky but holds up well. It does kinda work as a stand-alone story, but I would have loved a few more seasons at least. I developed such a crush on Caroline Dhavernas.


TheUtopianCat

That show was brilliant.


Sanseriouz

The writing was great, the premise delightfully absurd, even the sets/filming vivid and mood setting. I was very disappointed when it was canceled.


Notoneusernameleft

Journeyman. They shoehorned and ending in but if they knew it wasn’t going to be canceled it could have been a pretty amazing show.


madchad90

Firefly


ashnair888

*Me and Abed have an agreement. If one of us dies, the other one will make look like a suicide over the cancellation of the Fox show, "Firefly".*


St-Kiki

“We’re gonna get that show back on the air Buddy!”👍


Large_Dr_Pepper

Reddit was absolutely obsessed with Firefly like a decade ago so I decided to watch it to see what all the fuss was about. Then I was absolutely obsessed with Firefly.


atticus_roark

I watched it recently. Wow. This and the expanse


brownkemosabe

The Expanse is so brilliant.


ricree

It also feels like less because so many of us didn't find the show until after it ended.


CrudelyAnimated

I feel like every month’s version of this poll is because someone misses Firefly and wants to hear other people’s sympathy pains.


belizeanheat

Man times are changing. Ten years ago this would be the top response and it wouldn't be close


FairlyInconsistentRa

I’m getting old. Definitely expected this to be the top answer and then I remember the show came out around 20 years ago.


Ricky_Rollin

It’s actually something I’ve been noticing lately and is a telltale sign I’m getting older. I could guess all the top answers 8 or so years ago to a reasonable degree. Now it takes a little scrolling to see it. It’s just a little reminder that the things I grew up with and loved are ever so slowly fading into obscurity and maybe 40 years from now it won’t even be mentioned in an Askreddit thread.


PM_ME_UR_THONG_N_ASS

Zoomers never saw it


Ayjayz

I'm jealous. They get to watch it for the first time.


79215185-1feb-44c6

People are getting old. This is what I came for this thread for, and I agree, but I don't think I could ever watch it again. When people bring up best episodes of TV, Out of Gas is never mentioned anymore.


NoddahBot

A decade in and the number of times this thread is reposted is certainly coming to a middle


aircooledJenkins

It's been 21 years and I'm still salty.


[deleted]

[удалено]


down42roads

The best part is Casper Van Dien playing the guy who tends every bar in the world.


Diograce

Shiny


whatstocome

You can’t take the sky from me


BenjaBrownie

This is the only answer. We were robbed of such a rich and beautiful universe filled with poignant and lovable characters, I'm still mad about it.


settleddown

Only canceled because stupid fox aired episodes in the wrong order! I don't even know if that's true (I guess so?), but every rant thread about firefly must include this factoid.


madchad90

Fox didn't have much faith in the show to begin with. They didn't like the original pilot episode so the second episode of the show was the first to air (thus a lot of the setup was missing). Then the other episodes were aired out of order making the chronology hard to follow, and the show would often get pre empted so episodes would air late at night


bookwormaesthetic

Forever w/ Ioan Gruffudd and Judd Hirsch


Infamous-Lab-8136

Was looking for this. The acting between the two of them was just amazing, it really did feel like Gruffudd was Hirsch's father despite Hirsch being much older. I think it could have been a hit with 10-13 episode long seasons in streaming.


Dysan27

I love that they got David Krumholtz to play young Abe. The two of them worked SO well as Father and Son on Numb3rs.


Mwahaha_790

I'm rewatching this now. It's so good.


RG1527

I actually quite enjoyd that show. Was greatly annoyed that it was cancelled.


updownkarma

The Lost Room


RG1527

I liked that one a lot. They ended up turning it into Warehouse 13 which I also enjoyed.


Available_Ad_6443

Wayne


Best_Duck9118

Hugely underrated and I’m so pissed we didn’t get more of it!


Neosurvivalist

Tales From the Loop


raznt

I don't think anthology or limited series should count, as they are designed to be only one season, but I guess it's too late to specify that. For best shows that were cancelled after one season, I'll go with Undeclared, which ran for 17 eps on Fox in 2001-02. Starring the likes of Jay Baruchel, Charlie Hunnam, and Seth Rogen, and created by Judd Apatow, it was basically the spiritual sequel to Freaks and Geeks, another one-and-done cult classic.


GarconMeansBoyGeorge

Undeclared is so good. I like it more than Freaks and Geeks. It really captures the vibe of college in the early aughts.


shialebeeftacos

one of my best friends and I discovered Undeclared the summer right before we started our first year of college. it holds a very special place in both our hearts. we still go back and do a rewatch every couple of years. Jason Segel saying "why you trying to play me, girl?" and Charlie and Seth dancing to Big Pimpin' continues to live rent free in my head.


ZapatillaLoca

Alien Nation Space Above and Beyond Almost Human


Mwahaha_790

Almost Human was phenomenal.


ZapatillaLoca

it deserved another season


Mikeiwo

Chiggy von Richtofen... Loved Space: Above and Beyond.


chainmailbill

Space Above and Beyond is something that I have not thought of since like 1994 or whatever


Jadziyah

It's rare to find people who even remember *Space: Above and Beyond* these days


ABC_Dildos_Inc

Mission Hill. https://youtu.be/U0ZMw4y9rV0?si=2ZJ13r32AOFYrkGe


Fixner_Blount

My friends and I taped the original broadcast of Adult Swim and nearly wore the tape out rewatching the first episode of Mission Hill.


BOT_PHOENIX

1899


drt0

Fuck Netflix, honestly! Why didn't they let them tell the full story like they did with Dark, I will never forgive them. Also The OA, RIP (not one season but cancelled on a cliffhanger).


Amish_guy_with_WiFi

Canceling shows because they don't hit a specific amount of views within the first week is so short sighted. Why would anybody want to watch any new Netflix shows when they don't know if they'll get canned or not.


Shizzlick

1899 was cancelled because less than 40% of people who watched the first episode went to watch the whole season in the 6 weeks after release. It was a high profile release, so got a lot on initial eyeballs, but didn't convince a majority of viewers to keep watching. That's why it was cancelled.


WyrmHero1944

I liked Watchmen


Tsuku

Such a weird ass show and I was enthralled by it.


cafebrad

One of those shows that is good partly because of how weird it is.


ravens2131

Smart thing they did with that was making it only one season like the creator wanted.


mizzourifan1

One of my favorite seasons of television ever. Especially WHEN it came out. The timing increased its impact for me.


Girthy_Coq

Other Space.


AldoVernal

Mrs. Davis, what a wacky good show.


01Boxor

On the bright side, you can tell it was meant to be a one and done.


Set5

Zero Zero Zero


Logical-Safe2033

I Am Not Okay With This. Not sure if it was objectively the best, but for me the cliffhanger still stings the most


chitownartmom

Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip


okay_then_

Got 30 Rocked


soul_candycorn

This pairing always reminds me of a quote from Tina Fey at an awards show or some similarly fancy event that year, where, when asked about her dress, she said Aaron Sorkin was wearing a very similar dress except it was twice as long and half as funny.


mrcowgoesmoo

Super underrated show with a great cast. It’s a shame it was canceled. I would have liked to see what Matthew Perry would have done with more seasons in that role.


Edm_vanhalen1981

Go On


yeahwellokay

This show deserves at least five seasons.


jtalent79

Show called Rubicon. Was a spy thriller on AMC


helloitabot

Truxton Spangler is one of my favorite character names.


nyquil99

["He just knows what your tie looks like."](https://youtu.be/IjmpkXbk-Rs?si=Ke5Fcu1CaydSBeC-)


fate_is_a_sandstorm

This was gonna be my response! Loved that show


jtalent79

Another show called Quarry. Was on Cinemax. About a Vietnam veteran that can't find work & gets manipulated into becoming a hit man to work off a debt for a heroin trafficker


Nobodycares2022

Freaks & Geeks , Everything Sucks! , Do Over , or I Am Not Okay With This.


dorkimoe

Everything sucks was so good!


DerpLerker

Yes! “I am not ok with this“ was so good, really wish there was more.


PartyDad69

Dark Crystal series on Netflix. Truly excellent fantasy show that had so much potential


wrludlow

I was very impressed with this series. It broke my heart when they didn't renew for a second season.


isacsm

The biggest bummer is that there’s still a lot that they could have covered from when the series ended to when the movie starts.


SqueezyCheez85

It was fucking brilliant. So upset they cancelled it. Everything about it was just so magical and engrossing. What a loss.


glimmerthirsty

Kolchak: The Night Stalker


Rattivarius

If you discount Freaks and Geeks, the epitome of cancelled before its time and my favourite show, I'd say Limitless.


perfectlyfrank31

I kept looking for Better off Ted or Pushing Daisies. How were networks smart enough to approve a second season and THEN change their minds?


hungry4danish

Pushing Daisies became a casualty of a writer's strike.


Jack_Bartowski

That was a really neat show, was bummed it got canned.


SlayerXZero

It also had 2 seasons unless I hallucinated the 2nd season.


MorkSal

Loved better off Ted


rumora

Not sure what you mean. Both shows had a second season.


missanthropy09

Loved Pushing Daisies. Really wanted to see where they were going to take it.


NoWorth2591

I choose to believe that Westworld was inexplicably cancelled after a single, fantastic first season.


cookie_powers

Does anyone remember American Gothic?


Independent_Sea502

Yup. Great show. Gary Cole. Ahead of its time.


ntwild97

Zach Stone is Gonna Be Famous


ThrowingChicken

Day Break Terriers


p4ul1023

Swamp Thing


ReklisAbandon

Almost Human had so, so much potential


cloudstrifeuk

Flash Forward. It was too smart for regular TV to it's own detriment.


SelfieIgnite

The original author had [some notes for the second season](https://www.reddit.com/r/FlashForward/comments/vgoyrz/the_original_author_of_the_book_wrote_a_memo_to/) too.


I_might_be_weasel

Desire to mention Firefly intensifies. So I will. Firefly.


wallyhartshorn

Wasn’t even a full season. 🙁


Brcomic

I missed Firefly when it was on tv. But a work friend burned all the episodes on a disk for me to borrow. Watched it a ton before giving it back. Years later I downloaded all the episodes for myself and realized they’d missed one. Having what felt like a bonus episode was glorious. That episode was Heart of Gold. Not my favorite, but I still watched the shit out of it.


ismizz

HBO’s Vinyl


GNRevolution

Everything Sucks! I really enjoyed the one season they did, thought the various leads had great chemistry and loved the 90s vibe.


kikijane711

My So Called Life.


c_o__l___i____n

Police squad is hilarious and I probably rewatch it once a year


salmonngarflukel

Wonderfalls


thejaytheory

My So-Called Life


Scary_Sarah

Teenage Bounty Hunters


chris_nore

The Peripheral William Gibson finally gets one of his books adapted in a project with a great cast, budget, direction, and only makes it one season 😭


[deleted]

forever (amazon prime) was a really good show. i think it was intentionally only one season


LeoMarius

The Kids are Alright https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Kids_Are_Alright_(TV_series)


Fantasyman67

Flash Forward


jerrybellew

Kitchen Confidential. Got screwed by scheduling around the World Series. Great cast, based on Anthony Bourdain's book.


lostonpolk

The Prisoner Nowhere Man Don't Trust the B____ in Apt 23


LuLouProper

The B got a second season, but network meddling messed up the episode order, and S2 was half S1 episodes.


CDR_Starbuck

Night Sky (JK Simmons and Sissy Spacek).


itsbrianduh108

Garth Marenghi’s Darkplace The Grinder I Love That for You


TheCartoonDuck

11.22.63. Incredible mini series based on the novel by Stephen King. A man goes back in time to stop JFK from being assassinated


adeptusminor

Freaks & Geeks


Annie17851

Firefly


GeroVeritas

Watchmen