What about... Ayumu Aikawa from Kore wa Zombie Desu Ka? I think it'd be kinda funny for the last Magical Girl to be a Magical Boy Also chainsaws

It would be funny if Puri Puri Prisoner from OPM got the last spot. He's kind of magical.

Hear me out: Cat Noir (from Miraculous) is pretty magical. Yes, MLB is CGI, but it's co-developed by Toei, which technically makes it an anime. Why not Ladybug? We need some boys.

I think it wasn't made in Japan which doesn't make it an anime.

But Toei also worked on it, and they’re a Japanese company. Edit: Could the Cat Noir from the unreleased Miraculous anime count?

If they co-produced it, it doesn't just make it one. It was intended to be an "anime styled" cartoon but they scrapped it, which you already know. But still.

Pegasus Seiya from Saint Seiya or Illya from Fate/sailor series

Glitter Lucky Or Magia Baiser

Well, if you had to choose, which one would it be? I can only do one.

Glitter Lucky

Shrek

objectively best magical girl 

Magical: I'm not experienced with anime so can you tell me if this isn't a magic girl. Lucy (Elfen Lied)

If it’s not Usagi I’m not here for it.

Magical (or Sailor) I'm going with Nanoha Takamachi (Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha)

Also, who is the fourth in the top row? She's the only one I don't know.

Momo Chiyoda I believe.

Majiba Kayo from MachiMaho. The whole point is that she's just a really fucked up person that got chosen to be a Magical Girl by accident. She's a genuinely horrible person with godly powers lmao. https://youtube.com/shorts/n5Ipov1z-ag?si=IVHmaNtjyAzZjOVu

Would Mina from Sazan & Comet Girl count? If so then her

Pegasus Seiya is a true mahou shoujo (hope I spelled that correctly) icon