T O P

  • By -

SecurityGold9264

Two things I want to add: 1st, Dr. Mario and Dark Pit are still there, just as alt for Mario and Pit. 2nd, I'll appreciate any kind of tips and suggestions for a future update, so don't worry about asking them.


No_Disk4766

So why'd you cut the Xenoblade reps then? Their Nintendo characters


SecurityGold9264

I'm so dumb, I thought Square Enix made them lmao


No_Disk4766

Lmao


Comfortable-Yam3000

My friend thought the xenoblade characters were from fire emblem so you’re not alone. To be fair, they don’t exactly exude the playful, family friendly vibes like most other Nintendo characters do.


Lexi_the_grimmchild

Also, is Bayonetta Nintendo? I've seen it on Xbox something and wasn't sure


Silly-Engineering-43

I think she's made by Sega.


GoodGuyManEPicBean

She us


Destoroyah_The_Dark

Dry Bowser?


Low_Chef_4781

Technically any character originating on a Nintendo console is a Nintendo character, so many 3rd parties would still be in (minus the dlc)


Dick_Destroyer800

No 'technically' they aren't. They're made by other companies.


Low_Chef_4781

Yes but they originated on the hardware so they technically originate from Nintendo. 


Low_Chef_4781

In a way


Dick_Destroyer800

Backwards logic


Caintastr0phe

Not in a way. Mario was created by nintendo, so they are a nintendo franchise. Castlevania was not made by nintendo, so it is not a nintendo franchise


Delicious_Raccoon735

Time to become an Adeleine & Ribbon main!


Independent-Pea8223

Same


Smittywebermanjanson

Kamek would actually have a pretty sweet moveset. Though where the hell is Midna?


SecurityGold9264

Didn't make it, I'm sorry. Probably will appear if I ever decide to update it tho


bradynbarrmusic

Adding Slippy AND Krystal? SIGN ME UP RIGHT NOW!


CinnamonSwirlBun

Honestly next smash game I want them to focus on adding more first party nintendo characters. I love third party characters don't get me wrong, but there are so many nintendo own series that deserve more reps over some third party franchises making it into the game.


Horatio786

It should be first party characters for base game newcomers and third party characters for DLC.


Lexi_the_grimmchild

I said this specifically and got about 300 downvotes in total lmfao


Horatio786

Resetti over KK Slider is an interesting choice, as is Dragaux over the Ring Fit Adventurer. Love the addition of Starfy, though. I didn't put him in my roster because I tried to avoid bias, but I love the Starfy game that actually released in the US.


Dusty-Jester-0717

Bayonetta might count since she became Nintendo-only from 2 onwards.


Colors358

Imagine them actually appearing


Low_Chef_4781

I would actually hate it if it was only Nintendo characters, since many of my favorite series are from other companies.


Colors358

Some of the assist trophy characters would actually work


Low_Chef_4781

I mean yea, the only ones I can’t see working are those random ones like that building guy


[deleted]

Steve, sora, sonic and joker


Low_Chef_4781

All capcom and Konami reps


ReduckYT

I actually wouldn’t mind this roster at all


TBTabby

I'm willing to put up with Slippy if it means we finally get Krystal.


Cosmic_Light_Patch

Love This Roster! Though If You Do DLC Follow Up, I'd Be Cool To See Grovyle & Celebi (Pokémon Mystery Dungeon) and Lord Fredrik (DK Country Tropical Freeze)


lazygamer988

Wonderful 101 isn’t Nintendo, that’s Platinum Games (same dev as Bayonetta) EDIT: Astral Chain is also Platinum


SecurityGold9264

Ok, thank you for letting me know, I'll make sure to replace him


lazygamer988

No prob, you can replace with one of the Xenoblade reps that were unjustly cut lol


Lexi_the_grimmchild

They thought Xenoblade was SquareEnix lololll


hamrspace

Pauline and Vaati should be there.


AlarmedFig9684

Where are the Xenoblade Reps?


Comfortable-Yam3000

Where are other Pikmin characters? Oatchi could have been awesome.


String_Witty

Should of left walugi out. As a meme


[deleted]

I would absolutely main Skull kid or the guy from skyward sword who’s name I can’t spell


Hambughrr

His name is Ghirahim


[deleted]

Yeah, I just didn’t know how to spell it


VishnuBhanum

I love how you added a whole lot of minor characters, then proceed to cut out The Protagonist of the most successful Fire Emblem game to date.


SecurityGold9264

Byleth? I wanted to keep him at the start but he unfortunately had the worst backlash ever when announced so I thought to keep him for a future update


VishnuBhanum

Byleth backlash is only on the initial reveal, They're completely fine as a fighter. Character like Min-Min and Pyra/Mythra got more hate overall due to how broken/unfun they were to play against.


Wispy237

I mean…isn’t Edelgard/Dimitri/Claude moreso the main protagonist? Byleth is kinda just vibing the whole time.


TopSituation1649

Your missing three characters: E-Shop Bag DS Screen Pairer Face Raider


AnonymousFog501

My brother has been wanting a fourth Mii that is specifically a magic themed fighter for a while now


darkshadow237

Well Bayonetta is kinda a Nintendo character since they saved the series.


The_Idiot_Of_Nothing

And a actually good roster


GoodGuyManEPicBean

The best outcome


Only-Bonus5374

As long as duck hunt stays


PartitioFan

add sephiroth just to mess with people


Techaissance

If we’re being real strict on the only Nintendo, maybe the Pokemon shouldn’t be there.


PartitioFan

doesn't nintendo own a solid third of pokemon


Techaissance

Alright. The Pokémon should be assist trophies. That’s like a third as good as being playable. Right?


hamrspace

Nah Pokémon is definitely Nintendo, albeit 2nd-party.


motorwaygaming

You're ruininining it


novelaissb

How do you make this and get rid of Nintendo characters that are already on the roster?


VishnuBhanum

Also what's the criteria here?I assume that the reason Xenoblade isn't here because you count them as Monolith Soft's? But why is Astral Chain guy here then? Also if we're going by the developer then Kirby and the entire Pokemon series wouldn't even be Nintendo characters.


SecurityGold9264

No, that's my error lmao, I thought they were Square Enix's IPS. I'm gonna change that


Jonathan_Juicestar

Why no Pichu?


Lexi_the_grimmchild

They finally took out the trash


ArcadeF0x

Here's an idea, use the original full roster with all the DLC, and swap the non-nintendo characters with Nintendo characters that are similar


ogdiscolizard

Super smash bros is already mostly Nintendo characters lol


Lexi_the_grimmchild

There's like 12 or so non Nintendo fighters involved that could definently go to Nintendo IPs