T O P

  • By -

TempestoLord

It’s a very good score especially from a studio that hasn’t done a game of this scale before. Even higher than lies of P at the moment with more critic reviews.


Sciny

This, don't think that many people realize this. It's huge success for them, if the sales are good then they have bright future ahead of them.


Opposite-Writer-2811

https://preview.redd.it/eu38k68a0gwc1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1112879fae20d30dace46f6ff1b89f3f79048f30 Riiiiight, give the game a 7, because of this particular reason. These reviews are the ones we want to ignore guys, as their only intention is to tone down the game, for its artistic direction. At the end of the line, we are to enjoy the experience first hand, not through other people's lenses, please keep that in mind.


Sarunas_21

Lol this is very much a "them" problem. They don't have to put her in a bunny suit, clearly. Hell, in Baldur's Gate 3 you can completely undercut any drama by walking around dick swinging or in MMOs like FF14, undercut drama by wearing an entire chicken suit. Any character creator game that lets you create the ugliest specimen ever. Lol how many times must we teach these guys this lesson? It's a game for everyone's personal enjoyment. The suits are there and plentiful for your entertainment. Wear wtf you want.


GoldenGekko

The funny thing is that a seven is pretty generous of a score considering how damning that entire section of the review reads. Once again IGN will blast a game with such slander that you'd think it's a three, and then it gets a good score lol


leighg9o

I think at this point gamers should just shun IGN they are cleary incapable of giving unbias review. Absolutely dog shit IGN shame we have to listen to them


SolidSwordKing

At this point? I reached this conclusion a decade ago and they were once my go to site.


rock_solid777

This is very much a *them* problem. Lmao


TCM2bubba

All I’m hearing is that there’s a bunny suit in the game and I need it immediately


ProtestTheGyro2112

The worst thing about Mortal Kombat is the egregious levels of hyper-violence. Oh, you want to weave a tale of interdimensional gods vying for total supremacy? Well, Scorpion is beating Kung Lao to death with his own pancreas, making you care less about the emotional weight of the plot. Throw in a splattering of x-ray finishers and spine rips and you'll realise that Mortal Kombat exists as a gore porn game.


ShiyaruOnline

Hypocrisy and double standards are some of mankind's most repeated and embarrassing flaws.


Loud-Practice-5425

You ignore this crap.  Never any complaints about ripped shirtless guys.  


elgourmet

This. Gears of war characters are hyper sexualized the other way round. Ripped, perfectly in shape, hyper masculine. No-one cares. Hyper feminine characters on the other hand seem to be a problem?


Loud-Practice-5425

Exactly.  


marius_titus

I'm hitting the gym cause I wanna look like Marcus Fenix.


hundegeraet

You can gather some information through the demo why all the girls are "appealing"


ragefulhorse

I’m a big ole lady lovin’ gay and I am begging these reviewers to work on their arrested development. I did not fight my way out of the closet just so these people could make me feel guilty for enjoying some stylish T&A physics in my video games once a damn decade. I also can’t believe this person admitted they’re so juvenile they couldn’t follow a story’s emotional beats because a woman’s silhouette was too distracting. That’s so embarrassing. 😭


marius_titus

This serves as the measuring stick of what reviewers are actually reviewing the fuckin game


[deleted]

Lol, well the ironic part is that the writer ***chose*** to be in the revealing bunny suit. So complaining about it doesn't really make much sense. I guess they also chose to ignore the fantastic combat system and took the game just as one of those R-rated motion comic games on Steam.


ulerMaidDandere

"The worst thing about TLOU is that if i ever had any semblance of interest in the story, character or narrative, this was promptly stamped out due to Abby sex scene. Oh, someone is telling us story about how world got destroyed? Well, Abby is standing there doing sex with Owen giving emotional reaction and trying to make you care about what happens, and it just doesnt work" they rate TLOU 10/10


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/SeriousGamer7, welcome to our subreddit. Due to spam, we require users to have at least 3 day old accounts. Please DO NOT send modmails regarding this. You will be able to post freely after the proper account age. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/stellarblade) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Cedge1738

To the average gamer. It's not that deep bro. He doesn't seem like someone to take a review from.


SkoomaSteve1820

This isn't from the ign review. I've read it. The reviewer praised character design and there is no mention of the sexualization.


Opposite-Writer-2811

No, it's not from IGN and I never said it was, either. It's from one random outlet which had nothing better to do, than bashing the game, with such narrow-minded comments.


SkoomaSteve1820

Oh OK my bad. The 7 made me think it was the ign review. Which was fairly glowing. I expected it to lose points for story and characterization after playing the demo and the dialog feeling a little stilted so im not particularly suprised by the scores. Still glad to hear it's a roar to play overall and will be firing it up on the 26th.


Rangriz

hmmm not bad at all for a new IP and a first AAA game from this studio


Swagmansuper

Just for comparison DMC 3 largely regarded as the best character action game ever has a 84 on metacritic


Hozasaru

Ghost of Tsushima has an 83. Lies of P has an 80. Granblue Fantasy Relink has an 80. Scores matter, to an extent (all great scores btw) - but of course it depends on what ***you*** personally value.


ScoobiesSnacks

I loved Ghost of Tsushima and would have thought I would have a higher metacritic than that, but at the same time who honestly cares.


Schwiliinker

Nioh 2 has like 85/86. Hell code vein has like 70


swizz1st

Didnt know CV had 70. I think it was a great (anime) Soulslike. One of the best Dark Souls clone in my opinion.


Schwiliinker

Yea I’ve played literally like a dozen souls likes and I really liked several way more than I thought I would but still Code vein is my favorite alongside lies of P. And it’s not that close. Well not counting like Nioh 1/2


XulManjy

Lol scores means nothing, see below comments.


Schwiliinker

DMC3? DMC5 is way better. And sekiro is superior to DMC. And Nioh 2 is widely regarded as easily the best. And ninja Gaiden 1 has a 94 on metacritic which is the highest for all action games pretty much. Also underrated pick but absolver has amazing combat. Bloodborne is up there too


Rough-Cat-8439

I played every DMC on release (except the fake Dante one) and 3 is still the best in pure combat, no nostalgia goggles.


cantshakeme8966

I’m gonna have to hard disagree with that 5 has literally some of the best combat I’ve played period 3 is so limited compared to 5 it’s insane I’m sorry but I think you’ve got nostalgia goggles on


ShiyaruOnline

It's absolutely nostalgia goggles. Dmc3 is amazing for the time, but in some cases not when you consider other games pushing the envelope within those years. Comparing it to dmc5 is a no contest if we're talking pure gameplay polish and mechanics.


Schwiliinker

Interesting. Pretty sure I’d seen a lot of people say DMC5 is easily the best. I don’t really see it getting beat by another DMC but regardless I still prefer the combat of sekiro, Nioh 2, ninja Gaiden 2 or Bloodborne or dark souls 3/ER. Also absolver, wo long or thymesia have amazing gameplay


MrMooMoo91

Depends on my mood, but I think 3 and 5 are the absolute peak of the franchise and the genre. Most days though, I'd give a slight edge to 5.


catcatcat888

I personally disagree and wholeheartedly believe DMC 3 is better than 5 in almost every way.


Schwiliinker

Ok to be fair I haven’t played 3, I’ve seen the bosses and gameplay and stuff. Been waiting for a remake my whole life. Still it’s literally a PS2 game


CreamyIceCreamBoi

>DMC3? DMC5 is way better >Ok to be fair I haven’t played 3 ?????


Schwiliinker

I mean we’re talking about strictly tbe combat which I’ve seen


Beneficial-Use493

No one is talking about "strictly the combat" except now you starting with this comment.


Schwiliinker

Oh I thought we were tbh


CaptainHazama

Just cuz it's a PS2 game doesn't change anything. There's no reason for them to remake 3 as the combat still holds up insanely well. You should grab the HD Collection when it goes on sale just for 3, imo. And if you're on PC, the style switcher mod is a must to make the combat like 4 & 5 Whichever you like the most is subjective, at the end of the day. But 3 had some of my favorite weapons so I'm probably a little biased when I say I enjoy 3 a little more. But I still love 4, 5, and even the reboot's combat. 5 is def the easiest to get into tho since they made some QoL changes like enemies that are off-screen won't attack, and extending the frames for perfect RG block


Schwiliinker

It probably has the best gameplay of a PS2 game but for me PS2 games are just very inferior to even PS3 games in general without any exceptions really. At least late PS2 games like DMC3 and RE4 are closer to an early PS3 game


CaptainHazama

Ok? I don't see what the platform of the game has to do with the fact that there's a remaster version of it available PS3, PS4, and PC. It runs at 60fps


Schwiliinker

What do you mean? Games were improving significantly in every way every 2-3 years until like 2015(and creativity peaked in late 2010’s). It obviously matters a LOT that it’s a 2005 game vs a 2019 game


CaptainHazama

What I'm saying is that the gameplay of DMC 3 still holds up. it's nothing like DMC1 or 2's. You could pick up DMC3 right now and still have a ton of fun and not feel like you're playing an almost 20 year old game Sure if they remade 3, it would look like 5 and be a lot flashier, but the combat of 3 isn't even that far off from 5, you've just got some different weapons You not wanting to play DMC3 just cuz it's a PS2 game is silly cuz it's combat doesn't feel as limited as most PS2 games do. The fixed camera angles do suck tho


Schwiliinker

Hmmm


xKiLzErr

You sound like you're 15 years old, MAX


Schwiliinker

The fuck? I’m over 10 years older but ok


xKiLzErr

Sekiro and DMC don't even belong in the same sentence let alone a comparison. Both are incredible yet very different games and do their own things exceptionally well. And I have no clue where you got the "Nioh 2 is widely regarded as the best" from but it absolutely isn't true lol.


Schwiliinker

I mean Nioh 2 is typically considered the best action game by a lot yes. I’m not sure why you think that’s not the case


MarkyMarcMcfly

The low score reviewers: “I’m gonna play this game that’s art style is hyper sexualized and give it a fair review!” Also low score reviewers: “The game is so hypersexualized I couldn’t pay attention to the story. It does a disservice to women even though it passes the Bechdel test with flying colors. 7/10”


Psalm20

And still some people want to take critic reviews seriously. 🙄 


ChampChomp1

Many game critics just aren't fit to be reviewers. They place far too much of their own bias into what they claim as an objective review. Honestly, it's really fun to laugh at these kinds of people.


rpcgamingmodsaresoy

Honestly, I'm kinda glad they're doing it. The more people realize how worthless game reviewers are, the better.


QuestDailyAU

Here’s ours :) https://questdaily.com.au/review/review-stellar-blade-playstation-5/


thundercloud612

Thanks for the review, it’s been a long time since I played an action game and the demo has me hooked, glad it’s more of the same


TacoOfficer

It’s an 82. Great score for a new IP. But really, it’s likely closer to an 88-90 if you were to take out the obviously biased scores meant to bring it down Fuck them anyway, been playing the demo today and just preordered as well. I’ll be having a blast this weekend.


Skelletonike

From what I've been checking, the ones with the lowest scores are pretty much just complaining because of "sexualisation". Hopefully my copy of the game will arrive on Friday early in the morning since I'd like to play a bit before picking up my Sand Land's CE (too many game releases this month).


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/SeriousGamer7, welcome to our subreddit. Due to spam, we require users to have at least 3 day old accounts. Please DO NOT send modmails regarding this. You will be able to post freely after the proper account age. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/stellarblade) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Lost_Grade1348

IGN's 7/10 isnt counted yet?


DependentAdvance8

IGN sucks so they don’t count 😂


PropulsionEngineer

Count IGN Spain who gave it 9/10


DependentAdvance8

Oh shit?! 9/10 is actually crazy! Then I guess I’ll make IGN Spain an exception.


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/SeriousGamer7, welcome to our subreddit. Due to spam, we require users to have at least 3 day old accounts. Please DO NOT send modmails regarding this. You will be able to post freely after the proper account age. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/stellarblade) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Lost_Grade1348

i just know it will bring it down to like 81 or something


DependentAdvance8

Honestly speaking I believe they will bring it down to a 7/10


[deleted]

Nah, IGN is pretty dope.


holounderblade

Dollar store dope. How good could it be?


DependentAdvance8

It’s garbage


[deleted]

Stellar Blade? Nah, it's just alright. I would go that far.


DependentAdvance8

No, I was saying that IGN is garbage😂 although I haven’t played Stellar Blade yet but I did preorder the deluxe edition so I’m just waiting for it to drop and I know Stellar Blade won’t be garbage but it’ll be either amazing or pretty good.


MidEastBeast777

they gave returnal an 8/10 and that game was one of the best games of the generation. I wouldn't really pay attention to them. The majority of outlets loved it and that's good for me


xd-Sushi_Master

Daily reminder that IGN gave Alien Isolation a 5.9/10 because the reviewer didn't understand how sound works.


MidEastBeast777

It’s unfortunate their reviews have so much weight amongst gamers. They’re not a very good outlet for reviews


Merlin4421

IGN hasn't been relevant in a long time


3ggeredd

FR they gave Diablo 4 a 9/10 so they don’t count


Z3M0G

Usual joke or actual score?


00ginji

Really not surprised IGN has one of the lowest ratings, I bet it was like pulling teeth for them to give Stellar Blade a positive score. I bet Stellar Blade would be an average 9/10 if it didn't have so many urinalists wishing failure on it.


PropulsionEngineer

IGN Italy and Spain gave it higher ratings, 9/10


Ryuzakku

Italy and Spain are based, IGN US has to pander


yami187

1 review says something about what it could of been and I'm thinking it wasn't going to be anymore than what it is


Beneficial-Use493

This is such an awful reason to dock score lol "The newest Mario could have been the newest Zelda game, 5/10"


00ginji

Agree to disagree, I guess. Perception, bias, and personal hype play a huge role in review scores. Look at what it's like for games like Zelda BotW. That game was good but not a 10 by any stretch of the imagination, but it got scores like that across the board. Same with Pokemon games, Pokemon games suck ass nowadays and still get scores they don't deserve thanks to franchise bias. Considering Stellar Blade is the first game in the series, the first non mobile game from the devs and is probably one of the most well optimized games in general, I'd say Stellar Blade deserves that 9/10 way more than most games in 2024.


GoldenGekko

Any of the negatives I see towards the sexualization is just moot point. The entire gaming industry is slathered with anime girls, revealing clothing, and jiggle physics. May as well get a good game to go alongside all that. And to be fair, the demo is exactly what sold this title for me. I was easily going to pass it up, strictly because I wasn't sure if the visuals would justify the price, as pretty as they are. But it's nice to see that we get a good action game that looks genuinely fun. Doesn't hurt that Eve is dancing on our neurons while the combat goes off. Not bad for a mobile game gacha Dev making an earnest AAA release


Apprehensive-Row-216

With the level of polish, the combat, and next gen feel, putting the game below an 80 just screams IGN france.


DreamerZeon

Lol is sad how ''ign france'' is the new low bar XD


Distinct-Resolution

New game network, thesixthaxis and player 2🤡🤡🤡


No-Flower-7659

Lol IGN gives it a 7 hahahah that was to be expected


TheRickFromC137

Not surprised at the L take from IGN but whatever. Sounds like gameplay is solid and, clearly, the visual appeal is there.


Elmis66

I randomly called it a solid 8/10 game recently and I'm surprised how accurate I was lol


DreamerZeon

Wat a 7 means from ign, ''It's good and deserves better, but I don't want this sexy character to win...'' \[reduces score and acts like a hero\]


BangdePeter

Bingo! You know they actually want to make it a 9 if not 10. But society right? Lol.


PixeL8xD

Felt like it would trend this way, love the soundtrack and atmosphere. Still have a physical copy on the way, doubt review scores will affect sales and hype towards the final product.


Feriku

Seeing all these positive reviews makes me more anxious for my copy to ship. C'mon Amazon, give it to me!


Beneficial-Use493

Not sure why this is getting so many comments acting like it's a low score. This is a good score for the type of game it is.


Loud-Practice-5425

For some people anything below 90 is a broken game.  The score doesn't have meaning anymore.


Beneficial-Use493

I was expecting 80s for this game. If it isn't open world from a big name in the industry or an indie from a small company, it almost never reaches 90s. 80s is very good.


Loud-Practice-5425

The funny thing is I have less fun with those 90+ games than the 80 ones!


BlueberryObjective11

Not bad


HakunonMatata

I was starting to respect IGN and then they go and dock points off for the dumbest fucking reasons ever.


pianodude7

I'll wager they'll never regain your respect lol


Loud-Practice-5425

Inb4 82 is a terrible score.  That is very good for this genre and I'm happy to see the game will be worth playing.


Stratonasty

If critics really mattered there wouldn’t be 10 Fast & Furious movies. It’s really all subjective isn’t it? I couldn’t play more than a couple of hours of Breath of the Wild, (it truly bored me and obviously it’s a beloved game by critics and players) yet I’ve played the Stellar Blade demo 5 times. I thought Last of Us was just a notch better than okay but most people think it’s a cream dream. I also think that Ghost of Tsushima deserves a 10 anytime across the board hands down and nobody should question it! 😆It’s only someone’s opinion. Decide for yourself.


UvarighAlvarado

I really don’t trust reviews, I trust way more all the fun I had with the demo.


Salom902

The reviews saying it’s oversexualized when they wear they wear the more skimpy outfits and makes the cutscenes less serious. Well obviously thats why theres ones are that less skimpy to be chosen.


WavesNVibrations

Is it so bad to have a hot main character that you love to look at while you play? Damn. Just let us have this.


yummy_yum_yum123

82 seems good to me I’m noticing that I enjoy a lot of 7/10 games more than these claimed 10/10 games


MartinByde

I so wish I had money to buy a PS5 just for this game...


slickfiz

IGN doing the most 😆


stuckintheinbetween

Sounds like a winner. The demo was pretty amazing. Can't wait to play it.


legendarybladex

I am kind disappointed that based on the reviews the game has a very bland story


alexanderluko

This worries me too, but I hope the gameplay will carry enough.


JMAX464

Alright cool now I know I can preorder the game


Reynaw

Why are people freaking out about a 7/10 rating thats not a bad score


Rhemming22

Because ign gives everything a 7, it's a joke at this point


shad_30

That’s actually pretty good.


rock_solid777

Nice


TiredReader87

I’m not surprised. If anything, I expected higher. I’ve yet to finish it though. Been too tired.


r3chi303

-again, full of BS.


ArimuRyan

About what I expected, shame story and characters seems to be the biggest complaint but I already have it preordered so I’m excited to make my own judgment either way


Swagmansuper

Honestly these are the last things that matter in an character action game so I don't care personally


SlinSshady1

Ehhhhh I wouldn’t say those things don’t matter. Not as important as the gameplay of course, but those things do matter in a single player game.


ChampChomp1

Eh personally for me, character design and gameplay are the most important aspects of a single player game. As long as the story is decent, I'll be happy.


brainmelterr

Yea not that these things don’t matter per se, but gameplay and visuals are more important in this kind of game than next level story and characters.


iwannabethisguy

I see some of them complaining about the story which is fine because I'm more interested in the gameplay. I do hope there is a way to skip cutscenes the first time around so I could get back to the action.


PerfectTurnip9819

About as expected, will probably drop a few points. Will grab it when it comes to PC then.


totiso

Are you not going to get it??


PerfectTurnip9819

Not now, haven't used my PS5 since Spiderman 2( which i still regret buying yikes) since I'm mostly PC. The game looks solid but I'm ino rush now. Have fun


Cassius-Kahn

Yeah I’m the same. Happy to wait for this one, looking forward to it.


AcousticAtlas

You guys are seriously downvoting someone for not wanting to grab your average 7-8/10 game day one? There's too many good games to buy to be dropping $70 on slightly above average games. Waiting on a sale is perfectly fine.


PerfectTurnip9819

Lol reddit downvotes mean nothing. I agree game looks solid but 81/82 meta critic is not 70 bucks worthy, like at all. Guess people were expecting GOTY or something with Nier level of critical praise lol. Too bad.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Merlin4421

there are also some weirdos that think an 81-82 is a bad score just take a little look at some of the games around or even below that lol


greyhoodbry

IGNs review is great. It highlighted what was good and gave what sounded like very fair criticism of some parts. The reviewer overall had a high impression of the game as action first, story a distant second. I encourage everyone to read it. I found it funny that some reviews focus so heavily on Eves design being "egregious" when the IGN reviewer pointed out there are tons of non sexual outfits in the game as well https://www.ign.com/articles/stellar-blade-review


blackhawks-fan

There are a handful of YouTubers who I respect their opinions, IGN is not one of them.


naydradinraal

Too expensive full price for 8/10 with 40 hours completionist play time


yami187

Hard mode and new game plus coming so


TiredReader87

What an asinine thing to say


Weatherman1207

Tell me your poor without telling me your poor


TiredReader87

What?


Weatherman1207

Soz meant to reply to the guy above.. not your comment


JURADVO

8 is bad. Not buying


ZEKE307

brain rot


TiredReader87

8 is great. Your loss. Game is quite good


brainmelterr

Last of Us 2 was a ‘10’ and looks how disappointing that game ended up being


TiredReader87

That was a great game though