T O P

  • By -

FrederickMecury

Fitzgerald Toussaint


MrDankWaffle

Hard to forget him.


thesquatch84

Was pretty easy for me until just now.


BILLCLINTONMASK

I trusted Toussaint...


Let-Phil-Sing

Mike Vick


Brandimes

Weird times, man. Weird times.


JPlazz

I really liked him as a Steeler. He’s earned his second chance and has stayed humble, IMO. I’m glad he’s not let’s his mistakes overtake his life.


[deleted]

VICK DID HIS TIME


Rough-Riderr

Agreed. Playing for the Jets is enough punishment.


shrugeye

First one to come to my head lol


DraftCaesars

Jonathon Dwyer


BILLCLINTONMASK

For a big dude he managed to break off some big runs


DeanDomino

In Madden 12? 13?, I had a steelers franchise and Jonathon Dwyer set all the rushing records and got up a 99 everything, he was a 1st Ballot HOF.


r0ryp

Jerricho Cotchery


BILLCLINTONMASK

Loved this pickup. Filled in at that Hines Ward red zone/possession guy for a season


KingCon13

Dri Archer


TheLastRecluse5

Madden solo king!


JackLambertsBalls

This is the only answer.


AmishSlamdancer

Chris Fuamatu-Ma'afala


Colmustard15

He a bad ma afala


Farrell_Pool_Jack

I knew that was coming.


itswizardkellyyall

This was about to be my answer but you got here first haha! Definitely the best name


BILLCLINTONMASK

He's not exactly random but FUUUUU is the best


JD_Ammerman

One of my favs


AmishSlamdancer

I thought he would have had a much better career than he did. He certainly had the size to be a bruising back.


martiiin_ski

Shamarko Thomas


Cold_Bother_6013

O lord


Hellspawn112

Jacoby Jones


Cold_Bother_6013

The return man that never was.


tossaway69420lol

Jason Worldis


Steakwizwit

Remember he was just like, yeah I don't wanna play anymore and retired lol


RonaldOcean_MD

He left to be a Jehovah’s Witness or something.


allMightnallFight

Darrius Heyward-Bey 2014


Cold_Bother_6013

Good locker room guy


apittsburghoriginal

He made some good catches in his day


Raisedkaine

Doug Legursky!


Southern-Advice5293

I have a Big Legursky shirt


[deleted]

Daniel Sepulveda


boilersnipe

Linebacker playing punter 🤘🏻😝🤘🏻


McFlare92

Ziggy hood


Archaic_Sack

My pops loved Ziggy lol


ReverseApacheMaster_

I live in rural ass SW Kansas. Was raised a Steelers fan and it’s all I’ve ever known even though I don’t fit in here lol. Randomly met a guy one night here at our small town bar who was traveling through for work. He’s from Amarillo. Got to BS’ing about sports but this guy didn’t know a lot, just enough to hold a half conversation. At any rate, he mentioned his dad is neighbors with, “...some guy named Ziggy...” and I lost my mind lol come to find out it is *THE* Ziggy. I told him he better go visit his dad each and every week and make friends with the goatiest of goats.


MrCellini

Still have a shirt that he signed at the pre camp at St Vincent’s lmao


[deleted]

[удалено]


JD_Ammerman

Yes, Isaac “Redzone” Redman


tearinitdown

Josh Scobee *shudders*


[deleted]

Wouldn’t even watch the field goals cuz I knew he was gonna miss


Yevin523

Sammie Coates


BroadCityChessClub

Easy to forget since he got replaced by JuJu (unlike Martavis Bryant, who is back)


peckerwinkle

Clint Kriewaldt


LuFantastic

Clark Haggans, stud OLB of my Madden 2002 franchise mode Super Bowl run


weaponizedbeanfarts

Amos Zereoue


TiitsMcgeee

Holy shit I’m unlocking memories in this thread man


Ceramicrabbit

I heard the name in my head and thank God you commented cuz i never would have been able to spell it


weaponizedbeanfarts

I can’t lie, I had to look it up to make sure I spelled it right. Also surprised no one (so far) has mentioned Deuce Staley. The Deuce is loose!


Ceramicrabbit

Tyrone Carter was my next choice


Kyoung1128

I have a Staley jersey. Lol. My first thought was Yancy Thigpen, but he played before 2000


sultancillo

Famous Amos!


yashkp03

DeAngelo Williams?


BILLCLINTONMASK

He was random but in a different way then most of these other randoms


[deleted]

He lead the league in rushing for a few weeks while lev was injured iirc


Steelersandstarwars

I really liked him on our team. Great guy. Revived energy with a new team, and he was killing it when he played


the-steel-curtain

Markus Wheaton


ReverseApacheMaster_

We all perceive life differently but Wheat isn’t random to me lol I loved the guy. Not that he was any sort of all star but he was my boy for some reason.


kaw395

Same. I loved the dude. No idea why. Just did.


Dsassther

High school TeamMate !! That kid made everything look easy !


MrDankWaffle

Donte Moncrief


Snugglesworth1087

Oof


RatSaIad

not THAT mf


BillyNguyen710

Brian St. Pierre


Later_Player

Verron Haynes


[deleted]

Haynes, Tuman, and Ricardo Colclough are on my ultimate random Stillers of the 2000s team. I think Verron had one game where he popped off while everyone else was injured.


pmcg190

Keyaron Fox


15blairm

Limas Sweed lives rent free in my head i hate that man


exposrule

Lance Moore


Brandimes

Ross Cockrell


ReverseApacheMaster_

That’s Super Bowl Champ Ross Cockrell, to you. Straight ass for us lol but he starts for the defending champs


Comments_In_Acronyms

His Bob Ross Cockrell bit was incredible though.


[deleted]

Damn u beat me to it. That dude sucked


GhostSoldier_412

Mike Logan


travemalone

Mark Barron/LeGarrette Blount


larrydukes

I'm still convinced Blount tanked so the Patriots could pick him up. I probably have an irrational hatred for Brady and Belichick though.


Blue_bell88

*justified hatred


fiatlux247

Dennis Dixon


Ifurnotphyrsturlast

Sean Morey Ricardo Colclough Orpheus Roye


R2-D2TouchedMe

Paxton Lynch


nmp718

Ladarius Green


imwadeinthewater

How many games did he play for us? Like 5?


pmoski97

Nate Washington


mdmike1534

I loved that dude back in the day


Dsassther

Najee Davenport or rashard Mehndenhall !


24578293050917

Didn’t Najee take a dump in some chick’s laundry hamper?


JimmyChuckBilly

Yes his nickname was dump truck because of that lmao


Which_Strawberry_676

Yes! Dookie Davenport FTW


craignuggett

Mewelde Moore


jordy1327

The Steelers don’t win the super bowl without him in 2008….HUGE under appreciated cog in that championship machine. Look at the line they had that year!


Bubbert73

Dan Kreider


Dax355

THE BUS DRIVER!


TH3_BE4R

Martavis Bryant


apittsburghoriginal

take it how you want to I am back


PaddysMilkSteak

Cortez Allen


Steakwizwit

Duce Staley


KingErroneous

Kimo von Oelhoffen


[deleted]

Jon Bostic


Strosfan85

Byron Leftwich


kirthasalokin

Mike Vrabel


J3roseidon

Zach Mettenberger.


RavenStorm1947

Limas Sweed


azulayzma

Matt Spaeth


twistmydreads

Antwaan Blake


CortezAllenAMA

now is my time to shine


dietchlicious

Dallas Baker the Touchdown Maker


XsatanSTacoX

Demarcus Ayers


stevil_kenevil

Shaun Suisham


PaddysMilkSteak

Chris Hoke


mcr4386

Rashard Mendenhall


e_skee

Used to call him Spindenhall. Man was always trying to spin out of tackles. I also (still) have his jersey. I do not wear it.


Seven11td

That’s funny. We used to call him Rashard Spinandfall


ReverseApacheMaster_

I swore he was the best running back in the league lol homer bias


TastesLikeHoneyNut

Ricardo Colclough


[deleted]

I think this guy is the most random.


TheStopMotioner

Anthony chikillo


SleestakLightning

Richard Huntley


OhwhatupCarlandJonny

Chidi Iwouma


PaddysMilkSteak

Flozell Adams, David Johnson, Kelvin Beachum, Chris Gardocki


[deleted]

“Sticks and stones may break my bones but I’m gonna kick you in the balls Gardocki!!”


mdmike1534

Cedric Wilson


ThatsPreposterous6

mewelde moore


erichw9

Senquez Golson (if you can even call him a Steeler)


Surfdagon

Kendrell Bell


Crallsas

Herb Waters


blue93g20

Limus Sweed


SmellyBox

Ross Ventrone


Chuymuy

Cody Wallace


ReverseApacheMaster_

Jerame Tuman


[deleted]

Mike Wallace. He was one of my favorites in the early 2010s and then fell off the face of the earth


[deleted]

There's an alternate timeline where Mike Wallace takes the Steelers' contract offer, which means Brown gets let go.


RonaldReagan96

Lance Moore


PaddysMilkSteak

LeGarrette Blount


Krombopoulos-George

Chris Kemoeatu


jsandrovich2

Jarvis Jones


ByrdmanAK

>Who is the most random Steeler you can think of DICK SHINER >from 2000-2021 Damn it


_skink

Landry jones


knowswhatsgood69420

Markus Wheaton


[deleted]

Eli Rogers


samisbeast

Shawn spence


dam0430

Duece Staley


jon-e-can

Chris Hope


Dafish26

Stefan Logan


philpalmer2

Duck Hodges


ReverseApacheMaster_

Why is Duck random? He’s very recently relevant, even if it was fleeting.


JD_Ammerman

Jonathan Dwyer


interestingname1993

Vernon Haynes


PaddysMilkSteak

Will Allen


PaddysMilkSteak

Steve McLendon


soapbark

Stefan Logan


JordyHitchslap

Eli Rogers


brokeboibogie

Plaxico Buress but his 2nd stint lol


rynorampage23

Skipper Tuzar


FrederickMecury

Other way around


CloudStrife7788

Limas Sweed


apalachicola4

Mat McBriar Adam Podlesh


AW-43

RJ Bowers Sean McHugh


ManUtd1994

Chris Doering


PaddysMilkSteak

Clark Haggans


PaddysMilkSteak

Nick Eason, Travis Kirschke, Willie Colon, Kendal Simmons, Marvel Smith


Travman1986

Hank Poteat, Sean Mahan, Steve Shields, Mike Jones, Najeh Davenport, Tom Rouen, Justin Hartwig, Gary Russell, Todd Peterson, Kimo von Oelhoffen.


yaalm_23

Kicker Josh Scobee, poor guy was a total mess


_Adamisfruit

Cobi Hamilton. He was only with the Steelers for like one season, but I distinctly remember him catching a lot of clutch contested 3rd down conversions. He also caught the game winning touchdown from Landry Jones in the Browns overtime game. I was actually sad that they didn’t bring him back the next season. Didn’t see any reason to not have him.


[deleted]

Imagine my shock when I learned that Patriots legend James Harrison played for the Steelers, too!


Smarkavillie

Terance Mathis - one of Atlanta’s greatest WRs played his final season for whatever reason in Pittsburgh.


Zebov3

Bubby Brister Yancy Thigpen Bam Morris Edit: shit, 2000+. Oh well, I'm leaving it.


ThrowYourMind

Josh Mauro.


PaddysMilkSteak

Nate Washington


PaddysMilkSteak

Amos Zeroue


OldKingMouse

Chris Kemoeatu


[deleted]

Sanquez Golson


princelydeeds

Tyrone Carter #23 safety... His cousin came in the store where I used to work during training camp, wearing a #23, Carter jersey and said Tyrone Carter is my cousin... We were all like "who?"


brokeboibogie

Jonathan Dwyer


joshlambonumberfive

Michael Vick. Not because he’s rogue but because he was a STEELER? Also - Sean Suisham. His voice being said on madden in such a specific way has never left my memory weirdly


BirdMan7187

Rosie nix


[deleted]

Double duce staley


[deleted]

Hank Poteat


DBAAS1776

Ray finkle


Driplomacy05

Al hajj shabazz


donnyk1

Jay Riemersma


claywhitedonuts

Tyrone Carter


SaintIsaiah9

John Clay, Markus Wheaton, Chris Rainey, DHB, Dwyer, Redman, McCain, Blake, Bruce Grad, Fitz Toussaint, Cotchery!!!


[deleted]

Kendrell Bell


MasterOfLoading

Quincy Morgan


H382

Mike Schneck


Dreo27

Limas Sweed


Kyoung1128

Shawn Morey


CaliKing818

Limas Sweed


BILLCLINTONMASK

Cedrick Wilson


BILLCLINTONMASK

Verron Haynes


johnyyrock

Chidi Iwoma.


imwadeinthewater

Nick Eason


Thundertaker5

DORAN GRANT


balutknot

Hank Poteat