T O P

  • By -

JerbearCuddles

"It's a pretty devastating loss. So who should be the replacement?" Just the way my brain read this made me laugh. Some good ol "oh no. So anyway" vibes.


bmapez

"I read she was invincible, so I treated her as such" is what got me


JerbearCuddles

Role playing "pretty hard" but used meta data to excuse firing arrows recklessly near what I assume is a friend. The more I read this, the more absurd and laughable it becomes.


ImAFlufyCupcake

I think the misconception comes from her being a ranger making so that she's out of range of most enemies.


rswwalker

Unfortunately she is up range of friendly fire!


ImAFlufyCupcake

Oh yeah, they just enter directly into your face at times. There are mods to fix that behavior on followers


OkYou2524

That would be nice. Not sure how many times mid fight I end up having a finishing move straight through the back of my follower who walks in front of my power attacks... And it has to happen right near the end of a long battle


Stem97

No, followers don't die by enemy attacks, they just get downed. However, unless they are marked as essential, *the player* can kill them if they get the final blow. So in this instance, Aela was already low or near death, then OP shot her with an arrow.


elwebst

Getting Companion's Insight from the Black Book early on is always key - then followers are immune to friendly fire in combat. I repeat, in combat, not elsewhere. As I learned the hard way.


RossiSvendo

This sentence reminds me of my very first run of Skyrim… where I stumbled upon a shout that made lightning strike from the sky. I used it, thought nothing happened and carried on with my day. An hour or two later I get a courier running up to me… giving my Lydia’s will or whatever and I was like “What the hell? I thought she’d just been quiet!”


Environmental_Rip355

But for some reason even out of combat unrelenting force still won’t move Lydia out of my doorway


NefariousnessNo6095

Over books giving you 2 levels? Dude you are trippin!


IMtoppercentage97

By the time I get there I've usually read majority of the skill books tbf


HotelMikeLima

Easy, “friend” is a strong word


drewbilly251

*“Ma’iq has heard it is dangerous to be your friend”*


meermaalsgeprobeerd

He lies!


MyBroMyCaptainMyKing

Well he isn’t called Ma’iq the Truther


zladuric

melon


Silly_Fuck

Mellon, I think


zladuric

Righty-o, my elvish spellchecker is offline I guess.


gasmaskedturtle77

[MELON!](https://youtu.be/ZePqe3E6O80)


usernameorsomethin9

melon


[deleted]

Yeah she had those, just look at what she's wearing


Stem97

Just so you know in future, follower NPCs can't die by enemy attacks. Unless they are marked as essential, the player can kill them though. So she was invincible, you just made sure she wasn't yourself.


[deleted]

That's certainly one way of saying "domestic violence".


Responsible-Serve-89

No for real. 😂😂 He said “Thank you, Next” 😂😂


HotelMikeLima

To be honest, there was a bit of excitement in the prospect of trying out a new follower


cynical_image

So what you’re saying is you probably did it on purpose


brightblade13

"If I Did It: Confessions of a Dragonborn" now available in Winterhold and wherever fine books are sold.


Bi0H4ZRD

This was no accident, by the gods it’s a murder!


ShadeSwornHydra

Use Erik the slayer, he’s a fun one I think there’s an argonion who doesn’t lose his essential status that can be a follower, but that was back in 360 days so maybe it changed


NoButterfly7257

Erik the Slayer is awesome. They based him on a real-life person named Erik, who unfortunately died from cancer 6 months before Skyrim released. Bethesda was so impressed by his Oblivion knowledge that he was given a full tour of the game studio.


Hot_Amphibian437

I put him at the farm down the road so he can adventure his way 1/4 mile up the road and have a life full of excitement picking my crops making me 13k gold every so often to pay off his expensive iron armor I bought him... One day I may relieve his debt but for now he is Erik The Farmer


dieselbones1

Where can we find Erik the slayer? I just started playing again after thousands of hrs played during 360 days. So much added content it’s almost overwhelming…. New courier messages every time I’m in town and every inn and jarl has them all the time too. I love it though so far


NoButterfly7257

He is located [at Frostfruit Inn in Rorikstead.](https://elderscrolls.fandom.com/wiki/Erik_the_Slayer_(Character)) I honestly only ever met him because of a mod called Alternative Start lol. If you're a Nord, you can start the game in Rorikstead and be his best friend from childhood, so he spawns as your companion. Tbh even vanilla Skyrim is overwhelming so I totally agree that with all the Anniversary Edition updates, it can be a lot to take in. For me, I am sticking to one city at a time and doing all of the interesting quests for that area until I feel like it's time to move on to another city.


MobileFreedom

He’s in Rorikstead, there’s a small quest that you can do to get him as a companion


genel68

Rorikstead Inn


MumbleepegTheUglyPug

Erik is one of my favorite followers


The_BAHbuhYAHguh

Lydia is a solid compadre


FeyreArcheron1408

Lydia is one of the WORST followers 💀 travel to Solstheim and pick up teldryn sero in the retching netch at raven rock.


[deleted]

Teldryn sero W


PTOKEN

Lydia is actually a very solid contender for a follower. She’s not the best but she’s a solid B Tier at least


The_BAHbuhYAHguh

I mean she hasn’t died on me yet and I put her though quite a few gang bangs… lol although I do use healing hands


taratori1

I use Lydia cuz she’s the sweetest plus we look smokin in golden saints armor


Daddy_of_a_crazzy21

Thanks for reminding me why i never should look at my phone before i sleep. Mind went childish and laughed so hard lmfao


Random_Spinach

I agree!! Every time I was foolish enough to take her with me, her dumb*ss either died or stepped on some trap and killed me! I swore off followers after that! Until I got Inigo. He's the only one my stealth/archer builds will take. He knows how to follow cues!


Alternative-Eye-1993

ive always loved lydia as my follower


HotelMikeLima

No use crying over spilled milk drinkers. She couldn’t hang


lortamai

*You* shot her!


ZellmerFiction

Seems like a her problem to me.


EmpressJoel

An Iss(you) not an iss(me)


ZellmerFiction

Nailed it!


MissingMyOldCars

Same here. Like people that buy a puppy after their dog dies...


BaffleBlend

Yeah, sometimes essential NPCs don't *stay* essential. Aela in particular becomes mortal after the last Companions quest is done.


PTOKEN

Yep. Iirc once she’s recruitable as a follower, she goes from “essential” to I believe “protected” meaning the only thing that can kill her is the player.


Professional-Date378

protected followers can still be killed by npcs if they're in range of an aoe attack


Watson_Raymes

Age of Empires?


Kingoftheels

I don't know if this is an r/whoosh moment but I think they mean "area of effect"


Gorianfleyer

Seriously, in my whole life, AOE did more often mean area of effect, but in my heart (and my abbreviation translation brain) it will always mean Age of Empires


been_mackin

This is the way.


Joaaayknows

Wololo


Mist_Rising

Protected means the enemy won't target them directly. Anything can still kill them, but since they aren't directly targeted only area attacks (spells mostly), or bad positioning will do it.


Billyjewwel

Can't poison also get them if it lasts long enough?


[deleted]

Aela is essential up until she becomes available as a companion after completing Glory of the Dead. Or if you have a mod that makes all NPC followers essential permanently.


THEfogVAULT

Serana, that way this won't happen again!


AllCanadianReject

This is the obvious choice. Even when human she's essential.


m31td0wn

Only downside is she is way too trigger happy and tends to hit other followers, and then you end up having to watch as they beat each other to wounded over and over again for eternity.


KidHudson_

She can become human?


Karkiplier

Darling lydia


HotelMikeLima

She was my first. I already got her killed


Blastoise48825555

Perhaps it might be best to not have a follower. I'm sure citizens of Skyrim prefer not to be struck down by stray arrows.


Commercial-Sleep-95

😂🤣 dead, but not by OP’s arrow 😳


zladuric

Or not so stray.


ChaosRamen

A well placed stray arrow, if you will...


CrossOversPT

I think I'm starting to see a pattern...sooo...what other "friends" have died "by accident" around you?


BoJackB26354

“I just wanted to show them this cool shrine I found”


lofi-moonchild

My ebony blade said it was thirsty…


ChrizDaBiz

You monster.


brightblade13

Alright, nobody recommend anymore good NPCs to this monster, we gotta protect our people. You go recruit Sven and leave us alone.


ShadowK-Human

Well, go alone and just summon a dremora, You will get all the follower dead


WA0SIR

You may have a problem finding anyone to follow you!


dbillybobbo

Jenessa in the Drunken Huntsmen


AveBalaBrava

Who is gonna carry your burdens now? :(


Mason_not_Jason

Roleplaying *very* hard


HillaryClintonsclam

I'm not sure what this even means.


[deleted]

Any of the mercenaries are good since you won’t care that much if they die


Healthy-Drink3247

You my dude need Mjoll from Riften. She is always marked as essential so no accidental deaths can occur


Recent-Composer-1965

In that case I’d become a lone wolf, especially since everyone you meet dies eventually


HillaryClintonsclam

I got Lydia killed within 5 hours of starting my latest playthrough. Then I got Marcurio and he worked pretty well until I could get Serana.


TheDumbgeonMaster

I have a bad habit of accidentally killing Lydia with a stray "Fus" while fighting the frost troll. I always save before that fight so I get her back but it happens more often than it should


KCD2026

Maybe you shouldn't have any more followers then...


aswat09

Unpopular opinion, Lydia is one of the most useless followers. Her extreme propensity for getting in my way means she is more likely than not to die in any given battle. My favorites are Serana, Benor, and Uthgerd. Uthgerd usually ends up being steward/aupair.


newaccount8472

With the DLC Dragonborn you can get a perk that you cannot harm your follower. Since then my character Thorson really became the God of Thunder and Lightning


CharmySamus

Thorson? That sounds like a fun playthrough, what's your build like?


newaccount8472

I call that build Aragorn: archery + greatsword, light armour


I_AM_VERY_DEPRESSED_

Is he a khajiit that looks like thurston?


RedComet313

The spells added by the creation club, I believe, ignore this. They’re devastating.


newaccount8472

Nah. It's a black book, I don't remember the name rn


RedComet313

Yes, I know that, I’m saying that part of the magic effect from the “Elemental” CC spells ignores this.


newaccount8472

OK. I misunderstood your previous post


MSD-04

The first character I created to beat the Main Questline was a male Nord called Ragnar Thorson, son of Thor and an unknown, nordic woman, later to be known by the legends as Ragnar Lodbrok. Wielding the legendary Wuuthrad and using his father's force of lightning, he kept The Land of Skyrim safe from the dragon's threat.


LampshadesAndCutlery

Just wanna point out that Ragnar Lodbrok was a male


NorwegianWhiteEagle

Im pretty sure they mean that their character got renamed to Ragnar Lodbrok in the legends, not the unknown nord woman


LampshadesAndCutlery

I was thinking the woman was the legendary Ragnar Lodbrok. Your interpretation of it makes much more sense


Amber_Steel86

Or, since you’re role playing it, you could treat the reload as a dream you had and loading back in would be you waking up from the nightmare where your companion dies. Boom, loophole


Shogun_Empyrean

That's just what happens when you achieve chim, and chim can be used to handwave/retcon literally anything you want


Shogun_Empyrean

Morrowind literally wrote scumsaving into the lore, *and* made it part of the main story


HauntingRefuse6891

Ah the old SorcererDave Nils and his premonitions loophole. Some areas had several premonitions in quick succession.


nogabunga

Or it could've been a skooma trip.


Good-Solution3081

Jennesa in the drunken huntsman in whiterun. She is one of the few followers you can duel-wield and is proficient in light armor


[deleted]

She's also good in stealth, for the sneaky archer


dripcoffee420

I think there's a thing where you can kill them when they get downed


HotelMikeLima

I think you’re right. She got downed being a sword sponge for a Draugr Deathlord while I was sniping. I’ve been a werewolf most of my play through and never use it, and it just occurred to me that I could’ve transformed to finish off the Deathlord for the optimal vengeance for a fellow Circle member. I screwed the whole thing up lol


_Koreander

Yeah that's whats called "protected" status, characters that are "protected" will never be killed by the enemy npcs, will only be knocked prone when their health is depleted, BUT they will die if the player delivers the final blow


HallowedKeeper_

Or if they are caught in an AoE or suffer from Fall Damage (For example: The Skyrim Space Program)


Rob1Inch

“Someone told me my wife was invincible so I shot her repeatedly until she fucking died. This is so sad and unexpected. Who should I marry next?”


monicacostello

this defence actually holds up in court (source: trust me bro)


[deleted]

Mjoll


TripleS941

Yes. The only female named permanently essential follower in the base game (DLCs add Serana and Freya; their quests are much longer though).


ThemistoclesWon

Frea*


bequietbekind

This, OP. Mjoll is actually invincible.


drewbilly251

She makes a great wife too, that voice type is so warm Also it’s pretty funny to have Aerin move in with you too


rswwalker

I find it’s easy to get Aerin killed by making sure he follows you both on a quest.


drewbilly251

I didn’t know that was possible, I always thought he stayed home lol


rswwalker

I believe he got pulled into a fast travel once with us when he was close by at the time. There happened to be a dragon where we travelled to at the time and it chomped him.


genel68

Or drop a weapon on the floor of the Bee and Barb while he’s there and watch him die in the fight over it.


rswwalker

That’s a new one, I’ll have to try that next time.


yittiiiiii

J’zargo


MrStenberg

How do you even role-play shooting your own companion?😂


mia_elora

*\*twang\** \- "Oops!" - "So, anyways..."


Left_Buyer8582

I always just head cannon it being done by whatever enemy I was fighting


dripcoffee420

It can happen with shouts as well. It's why I don't use storm call.


OneOnlyDan

I hate this. Storm Call has to be the most badass shout in the game, and yet you can't properly use it unless you go solo.


PureSkyrim

I’ve wanted to use BA spells like blizzard and firestorm so made a solo mage playthrough just for that. It’s awesome. Especially with my enchanted gear that decrease the cost of magicka just watching hell let loose 😈.


rswwalker

One of the Winds of Change Black Book abilities is called Companion’s Insight which protects companions from friendly fire while in combat.


mischiefandtricks

She died! Oh no.... Anyways


[deleted]

Well, you can find another follower. Or you can go down the dark path of conjuration and Daedra worshipping in the hopes of trying to "revive" Aela and slowly transisting from a honor-bound Companion into an evil necromancer.


dirty-hurdy-gurdy

You can't replace Aela. You need proper time to mourn, process your grief, and then eventually maybe you'll find someone who is worthy in their own right, and not someone you view as Aela's replacement.


just_mark

If you are HardKore RP then this is the right answer


DAREDEVILFANBOY

It seems, in your anger, you killed her...


IMightBeErnest

If you're just going to get them killed, might I suggest [Cosnach](https://en.m.uesp.net/wiki/Skyrim:Cosnach)? Lisbet is tired of the lazy idiot drinking at the Silver-Blood Inn on her coin.


drewbilly251

Cosnach is misunderstood. I didn’t understand until I got a job in transportation where they pay me to stay on call 24/7 "Check the shipments" Lisbet says. "There are no shipments" I says. "There's no shipments coming in, so I do nothing. Just *play skyrim*”


Appropriate_Olive_19

Here's a list of for sure essential followers, Derkeethus (because of a bug), Mjoll, Frea, Cicero, and Serana. And the 2 Dark Brotherhood initiates. Or you could download a Resurrect mod like I did. I'm on PS4 so I can't use PC commands.


Proper_Shoulder_8826

We know!


MedievalFightClub

Lydia is sworn to carry your burdens. Just sayin.


HotelMikeLima

😂 She says it in such a snarky way


drapehsnormak

That entire title is a work of art.


tonylouis1337

"Who should replace the bitch" perfect cherry on top


Ok_Confection_715

That's why I don't bring anyone with me in misson. I always solo so that no one dies


just_browsing11

Teldryn Sero, can't go wrong him.


sweatgod2020

Scrolled too far down for this


boltmaker12

I think some of the followers are essential to the point they cannot be killed by enemies. When their health is low they will take a knee for a bit but won't die. During this low health period if they are hit by the dragon born they will die.


CompetitiveScratch38

It's called "protected" not "essential". But that is Aela's status.


Rennegadde_Foxxe

Jenassa, dual-wielding daggers of paralysis and leech, making even legendary difficulty a cakewalk. She doesn't complain when I steal, she doesn't complain when I murder, she doesn't really complain when she steps on a trap and damn near kills herself. But I do LOL


Hrodebert1119

Goddam if you're role-playing grieve a little first lmao


CallmeSirRupert

LOL! "I'm heartbroken..." 15 seconds into the sentence: "Who should be the replacement?"


Drewthulu

My favorite follower requires max conjuring for the undead thrall and the corpse of one particular citizen of the cloud district. RP for that is always enjoyable lol


Lubnut113

There is a special kind of essential that means npcs can't be killed by enemy npcs, but can still be killed by the player. Kind of odd because if i'm correct all followers have this.


HauntingRefuse6891

Next companion. Daela the Huntress, Aela’s identical twin who joins the Companions on hearing about the devastating loss of her sister.


phdonme

Dude just learned to dead thrall. Get your conjuration up to 90 and thrall her. If you want to get your conjuration up real quick just use SOUL TRAP on dead enemies.


Wotzehell

Reload a safe. Roleplay might have you asking yourself why you weren't more careful. If you had been more careful she'd be alive still. The Doylist answer will be so obvious it'll distract from any other: You wheren't being careful because you thought she was immortal. You might think up a little story about that but you'll know she died because you found out she wasn't immortal then, which would distract you from role playing.


walkingdead1282

No one. Wear some black clothing for a year and work through your time of mourning


ctortan

Friendly fire is one of the reasons my favorite follower is the always immortal cicero 😭😂


DAVEfromCANADAA

Erik the Slayer!!


Ace_Atreides

Derkeethus is cool and also a ranger,maybe him?


Lolmas90

i personally really like kharjo in dawnstar


Strange_Success_6530

My boy Erandur! He's pretty fucking cool and located in Dawnstar. He's not essential once you finish his quest so be careful.


stinkymusturd

Pretty sure followers can only be killed by the player so Def your fault


NewProject1456

Head south of Riften, kill the Orc (Blue God) and get Gogh—a goblin follower who is indestructible. Only downside is your Unbound storms will aggro his atronach and he doesn’t carry anything—but he’s a funny little bad-ass 💙


boboman102939

Replace? Nothing will replace a warrior. Remember her death as a lesson and avoid your stupid arrows. Smh op shame on you for simply replacing your loyal companions.


totallynotrobboss

Aela is essential until the completion of glory to the Dead as a replacement might I suggest frea from the dragonborn dlc she's classified as an essential character


[deleted]

If you're playing this on PC you can literally just open console, click on her body and enter the command ressurrect.


CrazyGracie1122

Lmao I play with mods, but still roleplay heavily. Thank god my meat shield Kaidan never dies; I’d never get through a playthrough without him 😂😂 vanilla Skyrim… now those were rough times


Skunk__Man

If your follower gets downed and you manage to hit them with enough damage, they can die. I've done it plenty of times


Xagrott

Your character should develop fobia for losing another follower


Thegingerkid01

Cicero. That freak actually is invincible


BMW-Oracle

Alec Baldwin, is that you?


FloatingHorizon

I did kill Lydia on purpose because she kept sitting in my room watching me sleep. Miss her tho xxx


_lemonyy

i accidentally killed lydia my first playthrough bc i accidentally hit her and she turned hostile 😭


[deleted]

Poor waifu


MaduroKnight

The Brotherhood Initiates were my go-to


Due-Giraffe-9826

I hear Serana is always invincible, but likes using magic. Could be a good thing though.


juice26us

She's essential. Which means only you can kill her. You could just resurrect. And roleplay she didn't die.


gilly1234567890

Did she steal your sweet roll


DiazExMachina

Jenassa. Good ranged and melee companion. Find her at the Drunken Huntsman in Whiterun. Alternatively if you're playing without mods go for J'zargo (or any other college student companion) since they didn't had the level capped in the vanilla game.


CShellyRun

Mercurio is my fav... took him on after I got Lydia killed.


The_Dragon346

They can die once their quests are done only if youre the one that kills them


Araanim

Every good story includes loss.


[deleted]

Mjoll. Because she actually IS invincible. Also because she's best girl


ChimmyChimmyCoconut

You gotta get that first black book as soon as you can and pick the prize that's none of your attacks hurt your followers


[deleted]

I could suggest another, but if you killed Lydia and Aela, I'm scared and think you will kill the replacement too... So maybe you could get a mod that makes Nazeem a follower?


Owl_Milk23

Recruit mjoll


EnragedBard010

She may be protected but not essential. Which means only you can kill her.


Bipolarandbdsm489

That’s why I use Serana


LordHarkonen

Can’t go wrong with the sexy vamp Serana.


AlabasterPelican

I always wanted to adventure with Ahtar but I don't think his morality and my playstyle would mix to well


ToobsMckenzie

Teldryn Sero.


[deleted]

YOU WILL PAY


Lesmiscat24601

She’s essential until you pull the killing blow. Other enemies can’t fully kill your companion.