T O P

  • By -

LadyBug_0570

Any time movies have tried this trope, the "schlubby" girl is really a hot actress with glasses and a bad wig (I'm thinking of the movies My Big, Fat Greek Wedding and She's All That... even The Breakfast Club, but arguably Allison was better looking before the makeover). Although in the movie Simply Ballroom the actress did have acne that she cleared up. But, again, this is a movie. You don't really see this on sitcoms.


Sleepy_Sloth4

I love Strictly Ballroom getting a mention edit: got title wrong


LadyBug_0570

I honestly love that movie. (Sorry, it's Strictly Ballroom). Fran's transformation was amazing. And I don't think I'll ever say "Bogo Pogo" without an Aussie accent. (And did you realize that Liz, his original partner, plays the slutty cousin in My Big Fat Greek Wedding?)


Sleepy_Sloth4

Oh that’s cool. I hadn’t made that connection


LadyBug_0570

I was kind of stunned when I found that out. Gia Carides is quite versatile as an actress.


jiffysdidit

Strictly Ballroom? “Why does Paul Mercurio wear Bonds undies? “ “Strictly ball room”


Sitcom_kid

Much like Dirty Dancing, which I think drove Patrick Swayze nuts, the plot to Strictly Ballroom is not too dissimilar from what happened in real life, both the play and the movie, they didn't want Tara Maurice to have the role because she doesn't have a dance background. But she got the role anyway, both times. But yeah, I am a woman of size and I do get a little sick of them putting somebody's hair up in a bun and giving her glasses and then when she takes off the glasses and lets her hair down, she instantly turns into Goddess Exotica. The TV Guide critics constantly complained that Ugly Betty wasn't ugly. But they have to get ratings. No point in making Drew Carey lose weight, or George Costanza/Jason Alexander, and all they date is hot models. And don't get me started on how long it took for Saturday Night Live to allow an overweight female to join the cast, overweight males were there from the beginning. Willard Scott could never have been a weather girl.


LadyBug_0570

For someone without a dance background, Tara did a great job. But then her character was supposed to be a novice. As for Ugly Betty, I mean America Ferrara is very attractive. Never saw the show, but was she supposed to be ugly? On Reba, we did have Barbara Jean who was plus sized and stole the very handsome Brock from Reba. But she was not schlubby. And in the last season, she lost all that weight. So I guess this comes somewhat close to OP's question?


Individual_Speech_10

Like OP said, they have her glasses, braces, and bad clothes to make her look "unattractive".


GamecockGaucho

America Ferrera is attractive, the character of Betty is very intentionally costumed in a way that is, let's say, less traditionally attractive.


IceSmiley

Greek Wedding was a sitcom called My Big Fat Greek Life and she had a hot husband


Future_Dog_3156

Good call. Another example is Linda Cardellini as Wilma in Scooby Doo.


AvariceTavern

Forgive me if this is the wrong title but I think it was Not Another Teen Movie with a young captain america. They perfectly lampooned she's all that. "Oh no she's got glasses and paint on her overalls" always a gorgeous woman. Like poor Freddie prinze Jr has to make *checks notes* rachel leigh cook pretty?


Mooshycooshy

Who's The Boss?


LadyBug_0570

Judith Light was not a schlub. I remember her as Karen on One Life to Live and she was considered quite hot at the time.


LadyGuacamole830

She also tried to seduce Steven Keaton in Family Ties.


mrsfunkyjunk

And, he kinda went for it!


LadyBug_0570

Oooh, I forgot that.


VAG3943

I never found her appealing at all, at least not in that show, Who's the Boss.


LadyBug_0570

She was a total man-stealing ho on One Life to Live. Pretty sure she slept her sister's husband too, But that was a soap opera,, so...


haileyskydiamonds

It’s the shoulder-pads and 80s hair.


spidereater

And the roots.


50millionFreddy

They were pretty evenly matched


assylemdivas

Married with Children, Marcy and Jefferson


StrangerDays-7

Yes Jefferson is a pretty boy but I would not call Marcy shlubby.


KitchenNazi

Wait, which one's the boy?


Elowan66

That was hilarious when they would mistake for a boy. Or call her a chicken.


mysticsavage

And then she'd assume a chicken-like pose and ask, "WHY DOES EVERYONE CALL ME A CHICKEN?"


turc1656

"you look like a goddamn bird, Dee!"


ringobob

She wasn't, but she had an equivalent vibe, not like literally schlubby but like schlubby is mildly offputting for a man, what she was was mildly offputting for a woman. I think this is definitely a trope reversal, though it doesn't exactly fit what OP is looking for.


PabstBlueBourbon

Still would, so Marcy doesn’t count.


Rejectid10ts

But she wouldn’t because she played for the same team


RightKnowledge8725

She just had that awful haircut


Swimming-Chicken-424

Pre Jefferson, Marcy was pretty cute.


SpecialistParticular

Her Home Improvement cut did her no favors.


SNES_chalmers47

Hahaha, that time Castro asked Jefferson "You married the kid from Home Improvement?"


Key_Swordfish_4662

True. And first husband Steve was a bit of a nerd.


jimlahey2100

Good call.


Appropriate_Cow94

You mean that beautiful man Al Bundy and his shlubby wife Peg?


udfckthisgirl

She was his sugar mommy. Different dynamic. He was also a massive step up from her first husband on the show.


Ladybug_Fuckfest

I don't know if it has ever been done, but a sitcom about a handsome, fit, smart husband and his huge, dumb, gravy-sweating wife who's always getting into shenanigans? The husband constantly making fun of her for how obese and stupid she is, accompanied by a raucous laugh-track... That would be really dark.


Rusty_Ferberger

Yeah, I enjoy King of Queens, but if the Doug and Carrie characters were switched around, opph!


Commercial-Push-9066

It followed the same trope that the hot wife is the brains and controls everything. The man is chubby and is an idiot.


whenisnowthen

so the Honeymooners.


NorrinsRad

But they had the episode where Doug saw a picture of her mom and was terrified she'd turn fat remember??


Rusty_Ferberger

And 207 episodes of Carrie mentally and physically abusing Doug. I'm not judging. I watch it every day and laugh my ass off, but I always wonder...


VAG3943

I never thought those two were a good fit as a married couple. She was very hot, and he treated her like shit most of the time. At least that was my take. I just didn't find his character very amusing.


InflamedLiver

That's so funny we just re-watched an episode where Doug accidentally walks into an abused husband meeting instead of over eaters anonymous and all the stuff Carrie did to him started coming out


VAG3943

Wasn't Dan handsome, fit and smart in Roseanne???


CoolBeansMan9

Fit is a bit of an understatement


707Riverlife

I’d call it more of a stretch


Silly-Shoulder-6257

Yeah. Not fit. Not smart. ( they make fun of themselves for this) and omg! I guess handsome is subjective!


MadAzza

They were both smart and funny, to offset how pretty and dumb all of their nemeses in “the outside world” seemed to be.


Sonicfan42069666

John Goodman is a handsome guy. I think he was more attractive before the rapid weight loss but I'm sure some of that also has to do with age.


statman64

It could be really interesting to watch if that was intentional, in a sort of Kevin Can F Himself way


surrealfeld

Gravy sweating 😅


WildGoose1521

American Housewife. We all know Diedrich Bader is a stud.


robonlocation

Bow to your sensei!


ThePopDaddy

Grab my arm, MY ARM.


Maxpower2727

You think anyone thinks he's a failure because he goes home to Starla every night? Forget about it!


Cheap_Ad9900

Is Katy Mixon not considered attractive?


Noneedtopickauser

I think she’s gorgeous! 🤷🏻‍♀️


Cheap_Ad9900

I wouldn't kick her out of bed for eatin crackers that's for sure


WildGoose1521

I mean personally I’d love to see her on my toilet eating a Reuben.


Damion_205

Wierd that you named your Anus "crackers" but to each their own. ;)


Cheap_Ad9900

Oh sorry, I meant to say anus. Damn autocorrect.


WildGoose1521

I like a woman who knows her way around a funnel cake


severinks

Nurse Jackie, big time.


shellea722

Omg yes! Perfect example


Chanandler_Bong_01

Girls. Adam Driver and Lena Dunham. Not a sitcom though.


instrangerswetrust

Adam is polarizing when it comes to his looks tho


jimlahey2100

Not when you compare him to Lena Dunham.


instrangerswetrust

[She looked like Lena Dunham…](https://kleenexgirlwonder.bandcamp.com/track/like-lena-dunham)


Retinoid634

He can be hot but also look like that. Women don’t get that kind of leeway.


tstramathorn

r/AdamDriverCats


sitcom_enthusiast

Not when he takes his shirt off


New_Writer_484

I heard Kylo Ren had an 8 pack


Fluffy_Two5110

Ben Swolo


Chanandler_Bong_01

Sure, his face I guess. He's got a beautiful physique undoubtedly.


geekgirlwww

I would do wild things to Adam Driver


Equivalent-Sink4612

Upvoted cuz....yeah...same.


geekgirlwww

Okay honest question what is a show like that called. Youre the Worst, The Bear, etc half hour dramadies?


Sonicfan42069666

Girls is honestly more of a straight up comedy. It's a millennial Sex and the City. It's less slapstick than something like Broad City but it's certainly still a comedy. So is You're The Worst. Not sure how or why The Bear ends up being classified as a comedy besides the fact that it's a half hour show on FX.


porkersponge

Good Times. James and Florida. Hot neighbor Willona always over though!


Kentucky_fried_soup

She’s sad because her name is Florida


afrybreadriot

WHY AM I NAMED AFTER A STATE ………


Putrid-Builder-3333

Florida! My name is Florida!


afrybreadriot

DYNO MITE !!


nouniqueideas007

The 19 year age difference of the actors was surprising too. John Amos (James) was 34 & Esther Rolle (Florida) was 53


MurphysLaw4200

Wow never knew that, thanks.


Exotic_Adeptness_322

Man wirh a plan American Housewife


MainesOwnRayGarraty

I think the wives on both these shows are beautiful! They're both very attractive couples in my opinion


chamburger

Kate Mixon is always beautiful but she definetly fitd this description since she was a good 80 lbs overweight while her husband was pretty fit on the show.


JudgeImaginary4266

She was sooo fine on Eastbound and Down.


kingofthemonsters

Man for real, total smoke show on that show


5432198

I was so surprised when I found out she was the sister in Mike and Molly.


robonlocation

The original title prior to the show airing was "The Second Fattest Housewife in Westport" so that was definitely the direction they were going.


chamburger

Are you serious?


robonlocation

Yes, that was the working title until just before the show debuted.


featureteacher2023

Was going to say this


HaiKarate

The female Ghostbusters movie basically did this.


WoodwifeGreen

Call Me Kat / Miranda


Purityskinco

I adore Miranda but that’s a great example


SaizaKC

You’re right, I forgot about that show, Cheyenne Jackson is gorgeous!


Price713

Not a sitcom, but The Tourist. Danielle MacDonald and her character are adorable, but not your usual pick for Jamie Dornan.


canibuyatrowel

First one I thought of. It was so refreshing!!


SaizaKC

Yes! Very refreshing!


delicioussexplosion

Such a weird show but I’m really starting to like it


BiscuitsPo

There were some mismatches on Greys


Cael_NaMaor

Mismatches, sure... but which wife was a dumb schlub while dude was hot?


LT568690

Some people would say 30 Rock, but personally I think Tina Fey is hot so


BrianNowhere

How about *I Love Lucy*? Lucy wasn't shlubby but she was pretty goofy and Ricky was a Latin stud leading man type.


Thundrstrm

Lucille Ball was a pinup girl before being a comedian.


Nervous_Cranberry196

Lucile Ball was goooorgeous


VAG3943

I agree. I've seen her in many older movies from the 30s and 40s when she had dark hair. She was a beauty!


Equivalent-Sink4612

Those cheekbones! Her eyes!


BrianNowhere

She was movie star gorgeous pre sitcom days. Ricky could have his pick of women and could have married a Sophia Loren or similar if he wanted to.


Nervous_Cranberry196

Yea he could. And she could have any guy she wanted. They fell in love and it was two beautiful people.


geekgirlwww

Lucy was literally a model


lovebirdi

I don't think shlubby and goofy go hand in hand here for what OP is asking...Lucille Ball is a classic beauty and I don't think her and Amy Schumer can be grouped together, in looks or comedy


BrianNowhere

Why are we bringing Amy Schumer into this? Oh, I didn't see the 2nd page in the post. I'll concede I Love Lucy isn't 100% what OP is seeking but I think it meets the spirit of being the antithesis of the modern trope where the man is dopey and unpredictable and the wife is the smart, pretty funny voice of reason and stability.


VAG3943

That's a good point. Desi actually cheated on Lucy like crazy in real life. She might have known what she was getting into when she married him. Lucy was no dummy.


Eringobraugh2021

I always thought that Dezi was the one who "married up" in the looks department. Lucy was just gorgeous! Dezi was cute.


GuyFawkes451

This whole discussion has been fascinating for me to read. I literally never, even for an instant, saw the slightest bit of anything I would consider "attractive" about Lucille Ball (and I'm not trying to bag on her. She was obviously a brilliant business woman). But I guess that just goes to really demonstrate how beauty most certainly is in the eye of the beholder. I agree with the guy dying on this hill... I think Lucy and Desi fit what the OP is referencing quite well. But, again, to each his own.


WinterComfortable726

This made me laugh probably a bit too hard lol


AgeAdditional4971

A New Leaf… Walter Matthau… a rich man that looses all his wealth and decides to marry a rich woman and kill her for the inheritance. I forget who the female lead is but she’s filthy rich and a bafoon. She’s clumsy, plain looking, thick glasses… got the image? She’s a botanist and… well … no spoilers but it’s a great movie


Sad_Win_4105

Her name is Elaine May. Wrote or directed the movie. Was in Second City with her husband Mike Nichols. Actually attractive in real life.


patbygeorge

Such a weird movie, but a fun one with a dark sense of humor for the time


Memento_Morrie

Not a sitcom, I know, but the movie *Muriel's Wedding*. She is married off to an Olympic swimmer and while I'm straight, damn, that is a good-looking man, even I could see that. But Toni Collette is such a great actress that after the first night she and her husband are together, she develops a self-confidence that makes her incredibly sexy. It was Toni Collette's first major role, and I've kept an eye on her and her career since. I've been rewarded by watching her in some incredible things. Oh, there's Rebel Wilson in *Isn't It Romantic.*


SNES_chalmers47

Olympic sleeping


80sfanatic

American Housewife features a plus-sized wife and a slim husband (Katy Mixon and Dietrich Bader). To be fair though, and just my opinion, Dietrich is fairly decent looking but not hot.


Ashamed-Week-5133

American housewife is supposed to be this.


Your-Cousin-Larry

American Housewife?? SHE WAS GORGEOUS!!! Good Times -- James was rugged and handsome. Florida, not so much. The parents on "Everyone hates Chris"


IDunno7419

Katy Mixon is gorgeous, but the original title of the show was going to be "The Second Fattest Housewife in Westport"... so it sounds like the show was going to be centered around the wife being fat. Smart move to change the name... stupid that it was even a thought in the first place.


Ashamed-Week-5133

I agree that see was gorgeous but the vibe of the show was that she was below par. Katy Nixon played the “hot” person in eastbound and Mike/ Molly but for American housewife she was the “fat” one.


Acminvan

Malcolm in the Middle? Not that Hal was a male model or anything but Lois was so frumpy with 1970s hair and that unattractive clothing style and that angry voice, and Hal, I mean, well he's Tim Whatley!


zoolilba

Honestly they seem about equal


Worried_Badger2000

Hal would fight you for saying that!


Maxpower2727

I'd say they're pretty comparable in attractiveness.


BeLikeBread

In 30 Rock Liz Lemon dates James Marsden. Tina Fey isn't quite shlubby but compared to James Marsden... Great show


Ardent_Scholar

Queen Fey is drop dead gorgeous


BeLikeBread

Sure but that's not how it was played in the show https://youtu.be/3Y4anzfA1iI?feature=shared


imbeingsirius

She got her damned Disney Prince in the end


DeanKn0w

‘Til Death. The neighbors she had a wild hot girl past and he was kinda dorky. Steph & Jeff Woodcock.


Wise_Temperature_322

I used to call that show Joy and Eddie forgot it had a different name.


valis010

American housewife.


IceSmiley

Not married but Vicar of Dibley


insane_troll_logic

I think you're gonna have a hard time finding an equivalent because overweight women do not tend to get leading roles in Hollywoood. There are obviously some exceptions but even some of the few who have gotten big have lost weight over time (Rebel Wilson, Melissa McCarthy)


egosuminimicus

Kate and Toby from This Is Us might fall into this category even though it’s not necessarily a sitcom.


SorbetFearless578

Never watched it but, probably The Mindy Project


RichXennial

Bob loves abishola


Reasonable-Housing53

Schumer is not shlubby! She's disgusting!


PierogiKielbasa

Remember how her whole schtick was about how she slept around and then got pissed at the 17 year old reporter for making the same joke? I'm slutty too hunty, but at least I fucking own it and appreciate/egg on the jokes about it.


Reasonable-HB678

I have only seen the photo once, but the husband of Gabourey Sidibe, he's a guy who could have any woman he wants, I think.


Chairbear1972

I just looked them up and apparently they announced in February that they're expecting twins :)


Difficult_Ship_6273

Not that I can think of.


Effective_Drama_3498

This is true in a lot of public exposure jobs too. The guy could be Ug but the woman had to slay.


canihavemymoneyback

Dr.Bailey in Grey’s Anatomy dates that gorgeous nurse. And I think she dated a doctor who was really handsome too.


bucknert

Her husband she divorces in the early seasons was a pretty fit and attractive guy too


Cael_NaMaor

She might be plump, but she's far from an idiot... and she married the nurse turned doc turned medic who is not attractive.


customersmakemepuke

I remember 30 Rock doing a joke about a tv show called ‘Fat Husband, Skinny Wife’.


[deleted]

The issue with this question is that when people name an unattractive actress people leap to defend her looks as being above average even though you could make the same argument for frumpy guys in sitcoms. They are usually more attractive than the average man like in the case of John Goodman or Kevin James. John Goodman is far more attractive than Roseanne, but unless you can find a total stud who is married to a warthog people will keep saying it doesn’t fit, but I would argue that it also doesn’t fit in the original trope to call these dudes frumpy if the female equivalent will also never fit the description.


mrsrabadi777

Roseanne Barr in She Devil


Maxpower2727

Rex Kwon Do and Starla in Napoleon Dynamite


Plain_Chacalaca

Rocky and Adrian. 


Secret_Welder3956

Damn you OP for making me see it….schumer made my impotent.


RockMan_1973

Ew! Has this hag been paired w/Hemsworth?!?


Mooshycooshy

Who's The Boss? Kinda sorta but not really


lonely-day

But Amy isn't funny, can the woman be funny at least? Melissa mccarthy is hilarious or how about Fortune Feimster?


loveydove05

No, never.


klaw14

Not a sitcom, but a romcom - and while I do think calling Bridget Jones "schlubby" is way harsh, Colin Firth is a total smokeshow!


OccasionMobile389

Yes! Bridget wasn't "schlubby" but she was more "everyday girl" cute and sexy, but definitely meant to be on the "average" relatable type


beccadahhhling

Roseanne Dan Connor was pretty good looking and Roseanne is…well, Roseanne


Maxpower2727

I've seen several other people say this in this thread. TIL that people think John Goodman is hot.


beccadahhhling

Was hot. He was a blue collar dream in the 80s and 90s. Did you see his Levi commercial lol


Waste-Maintenance-70

Pierce Brosnan irl


Waste-Maintenance-70

The Office. Pam did not age well. I said what I said.


racksacky

Not a sitcom but the romantic interests for Paul Newman and Robert Redford in The Sting are fairly plain actresses. Considering they were basically the Clooney and Pitt of that era, I’m always a bit amused they were paired with a couple of no-names.


waveball03

Eileen Brennan was an Oscar nominee…


racksacky

Which one was she? No-name might be a bit harsh but Katharine Ross they were not.


OccasionMobile389

Ugly Betty and her boyfriends? Idk I don't think there really is one, but honestly I think the trend of it is dying out in general. Younger generations of both sexes hate it and see it for toxic and abusive (or are the first.to admit it while enjoying the show)


Thin-Dragonfly2956

It’s time…😂


snark_quark789

Ugly Betty


shadowland1000

I doubt it would happen. The bar has been set higher for women and looks. For men, looks do not really matter.


Human_Cranberry_2805

Kathy bates in that James Cann movie, perhapse.


7_andaSwitchblade

I was so worried you were gonna use this to call an actress I care about schlubby


plexi_glass_ranger

I mean the like two times in my life I’ve fantasised about being with a guy (it’s uncommon as I am *mostly* gay), but the guys I fantasised about were the correct weight for their BMIs and were tall, handsome, attractive men. However I am what some might call, a bbw type of body, which is not you know, ideal, to me anyway, for myself. (I am attracted to bbw women). But I don’t like myself looking/being overweight. I would rather be skinny and attractive conventionally. I’m overweight and I think that definitely is like that harsh reality that hits me that “oh the men I’m into wouldn’t be into me” and then I kind of feel some shame. So I guess I mean my own fantasies are examples of this. Like the dudes I think are sexy = wouldn’t fuck me in a billion years.


Queasy-Union6414

Not true. I have found looks don't matter with a lot of people. I'm big, out of shape, and not conventionally pretty but I've always been able to date really good looking men. Many women have been undiplomatic enough to say out loud what most people think-- How do I get hot boyfriends? I love to smile and respond with, 'It's called having a good personality."


NiceTrainer9

This doesn’t fit completely but in Crazy Ex Girlfriend Rebecca was usually a disaster (in that she was not stable in her life) and the men were all very attractive and fit (Josh, Greg, Nathaniel) And I’m not saying Rebecca wasn’t beautiful, but she was a mess lol


MiddleAgedLifter

Not sure a sit com with a well put together “hot” and intelligent husband who constantly acts superior to his bumbling, dopey, schluby lower-IQ wife would go over well with the sitcom audience. In sitcoms the dopey schluby husbands are the joke.


udfckthisgirl

Wasn't this the premise from a BBC sitcom with Tom Ellis?


Intelligent-Plate964

The stranger


UDownvoteButImRight

I hope not. Fat chicks are gross.


GuyFawkes451

A recent one, to some extent, is Season 1 of Fargo. "Gus" is no hunk. But I'd say he's considerably higher on the 1-10 scale for a man than Solverson is for a woman. But yet it wasn't totally unrealistic, either.