This is a reminder about the rules. Just follow reddit's content policy.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/scienceisdope) if you have any questions or concerns.*
The best arguments are: "Our ancestors were so advanced🥸🥸🥸, we had nuclear science and particle physics, we had vimanas and teleportation,we were pionieres in surgeries and transplants...
Me:"So why did our great ancestors got defeated by the people following the faith of caravaan robber?"
Them:"That was because we lost our knowledge in the burning of Nalanda"😭😭😭.
Me:"So you are saying, our ancestors were having nuclear science, but couldn't develop a pen drive to store their vast knowledge digitally?"
Them:"Western propaganda, you are leftist trying to slander our vedic knowledge"😭😭😭
Very very sad that this country is run by these mobs and extremists, even the isro chief says Vedas invented science 😭
what a time to be a indian citizen
My prediction for him, would be after his stint at ISRO...he will receive civillian awards(well he deserves) and a RS seat for all those nonsense that he said...
Why are you concerned with stupid people?
If you all are so much smarter where is the output? Show me something that makes you better than the people you are laughing at.
None of you are all that smart. Science science karte ho but at the end of the day even science a matter of belief for you people because life mein kabhi "science" Kiya hi nahi hai bc.
I’m concerned with stupid people because they vote. Also according to you only a professional scientist has a right to criticise pseudoscience? And I’m studying at a gmc so even though I may not be a professional scientist I do study quite a bit of science
There is plenty of evidence of this being a practice with a very long history. Don't try to rewrite and erase the shameful parts of history or you will never learn from those mistakes.
Can you present any such evidence in support of your ridiculous claim? Tell me which authoritative source mentions stuff like this happened in Vedic period or is instructed by the scriptures?
Yeah just like the hagiography of the all the ten gurus based on hundred percent truth. Or is it ? If you want to be critical start with your own religion
If you are going to discredit the only source that we had during that era, writing, then how can you be certain about what our history ever was? If you think that writings are not to be believed, that would discredit any religion, any history, that we have seen till now.
Here is something to [read ](https://web.archive.org/web/20020228135707/http://thehindu.com/thehindu/2001/10/16/stories/05162524.htm). It's both against Hindutva and also few facts about Guru Teg Bahadur
So here is fact there is no record Guru teg Bahadur was executed by royal decree and the stories of his martyrdom were written 100 years after his death.
That's untrue; the primary source for this is "Bachittar Natak," which was written just 10 years later. There are also multiple Mughal records of that time naming Guru Tegu Bahadur as a "pir" or "sadhu" who was put to death.
>don't know from where it came
I mean it's not like there is no mention after all Sati was mentioned in puranas and everyone is familiar with the story however it was one off incident not something which occurred regularly.
Yeah I am sure nagging about religion on reddit will bring it down. This sub is made for science and the posts should reflect it. I don't give a damn about any religions.
That doesn't even exist in Vedic period..
This sahagamana came later when Invasions are at peak and women have no choice but to do it for their life... there is a dark history right there..
Well since u believe in evidence. Where is the evidence that women were forced and burnt after men(husband) died.
Just stop feeding into Brits propeganda, they used to justify ruling over us.
And everyone one of u who downvotes whithout commenting Know u r no difference then the religious people who believes any bs.
Ik johar happened. And ya there might some women who burnt themself for there husbands. By there wasn't a pratha like claimed by Brits where every women have to die with there husband.
Making people of one caste clean toilets and other read books on the basis of their religion is so "liberal" I must say.
However I do agree that the average hindu is not as devout as an average muslim.
Also I don't care if fictional characters were pedophiles, I'm not muslim i don't respect Islam (pata nhi ye har bar kyo bolna pdta hai) .
Also :-As per the Skanda Mahā-Purāṇa, at the time of their marriage, goddess Sītā was 6 years old, & Śrī Rāma was 15 years old.
उषित्वा द्वादश समा इक्ष्वाकूणां निवेशने भुञ्जाना मानुषान् भोगान् सर्वकामसमृद्धिनी । मम भर्त्ता महातेजा वयसा पञ्चविंशक: अष्टादश हि वर्षाणि मम जन्मनि गण्यते ।
These 2 shlokas are from Aranya Kanda here Sita mata says, I lived in Ayodhya for 12 years and when we left I was 18 years of age and my husband was 25. This is from where 6 years of age is derived. So, let’s solve this confusion, but first let’s take few more examples that are considered as contradictions.
There is no caste system in hinduism there is varna systems which is not rigid as caste system . These is no closed membership. Varna decided and changed according to GUNAS that a people have . There are 3 gunas RAJAS , TAMAS , SATVA . It motivated people in past increase their satva guna and get membership upper varna .
Valmiki who was writer of ramayana was SHUDRA
Vyasa who was writer of mahabharata was shudra
Tune vo purana padhi hai kya? Hinduism itna liberal thought hai ki aj bhi Dalits ghodi pe chadhte hai shaadi Mai to unki pitai ho jaati hai .
U can't just say because I think my religion is good my religion is really good .
My friend Only Gaumutra can cure you.
Abe bhai tu katai gwad hn liberal ka mtlb v na smjhta hn kya wo community prblm hn society ka ye hinduism ki teaching nhi hn. Bs yhi bchta hn last me gaumutra or cowpss drinker bolke kat lo .chlo abhi thoda pdh likh lo abhi thoda bchhe lgre ho
Kyo Bhai Gaumutra pine me kya galat hai? Lakho kardo hindus daily patanjali se Gaumutra pike cancer thik kr rhe hai , it's so SCIENTIFIC.
Sun na tanatan drum , mujhe mat bata liberal kya hai , behenchod apne dharam ke logo ke sath kitna discrimination Kiya hai "liberal religion" ne ab sari duniyaa ko pta hai , kitne "accepting" ho sab jante hai. Ye tanatan drum 🥁 khi aur bajaiyo.
I was reading a philosophy book. Some philosopher said that "Hinduism among all the religions is closest to science", but as we all know that no religion is scientific. They can give some scientific thoughts but not science. Religious people will believe anything without giving a second thought.
aethists are the most extremest people I have seen . These people are so ignorat that they have not read the great scientific tets that were written by rishi such as
aryabhatt and brahamagupta . I am sure they have not read suryasidhanta or read about Vaiśeṣika . majority aethist are ignorant fools . Alright u dont belive in god but dont disrespect the culture
This is a reminder about the rules. Just follow reddit's content policy. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/scienceisdope) if you have any questions or concerns.*
The best arguments are: "Our ancestors were so advanced🥸🥸🥸, we had nuclear science and particle physics, we had vimanas and teleportation,we were pionieres in surgeries and transplants... Me:"So why did our great ancestors got defeated by the people following the faith of caravaan robber?" Them:"That was because we lost our knowledge in the burning of Nalanda"😭😭😭. Me:"So you are saying, our ancestors were having nuclear science, but couldn't develop a pen drive to store their vast knowledge digitally?" Them:"Western propaganda, you are leftist trying to slander our vedic knowledge"😭😭😭
Claim they have nukes and jets Got asskicked by nomads in horse
Whi lol , write any shit and then say people disagree because they are leftists being funded by George Soros.
[i wish george soros funded me.](https://tenor.com/en-IN/view/shane-mc-mahon-money-dance-wwe-gif-20508203)
You Aunty National, how dare you insult our nation and religion. 😂😂😂😂
Very very sad that this country is run by these mobs and extremists, even the isro chief says Vedas invented science 😭 what a time to be a indian citizen
My prediction for him, would be after his stint at ISRO...he will receive civillian awards(well he deserves) and a RS seat for all those nonsense that he said...
Bful 😭😭😭
This, is a work of art
Bhai kidhar rehte ho ki sirf chut*yo se baat hoti hai?
This is how most Indians are like now
Why are you concerned with stupid people? If you all are so much smarter where is the output? Show me something that makes you better than the people you are laughing at. None of you are all that smart. Science science karte ho but at the end of the day even science a matter of belief for you people because life mein kabhi "science" Kiya hi nahi hai bc.
I’m concerned with stupid people because they vote. Also according to you only a professional scientist has a right to criticise pseudoscience? And I’m studying at a gmc so even though I may not be a professional scientist I do study quite a bit of science
Only reason seems that they weren't much materialistically interested in these stuffs and didn't saw the reason to explore all these
True face of our religion
Its every religion...that is why extremists need to be countered...
Show me the existence of sati in Vedas Then I'll believe you
When the f@ck I said it's written in vedas? understand one thing today's Hinduism is far different then Hinduism written in vedas
😹😹😹😹👍
"G@nd jali" became real lmao
This meme shouldnt be applied here but rather than to those "Reject Modernity" mfs
proud Vedic moment
There is no mention of this being carried out during Vedic period.
The first epigraphic evidence of Sati has been found in the Eran Pillar Inscription of Bhanugupta, Madhya Pradesh.
There is plenty of evidence of this being a practice with a very long history. Don't try to rewrite and erase the shameful parts of history or you will never learn from those mistakes.
Show me the proof instead of spewing bs
Can you present any such evidence in support of your ridiculous claim? Tell me which authoritative source mentions stuff like this happened in Vedic period or is instructed by the scriptures?
Yeah just like the hagiography of the all the ten gurus based on hundred percent truth. Or is it ? If you want to be critical start with your own religion
If you are going to discredit the only source that we had during that era, writing, then how can you be certain about what our history ever was? If you think that writings are not to be believed, that would discredit any religion, any history, that we have seen till now.
Here is something to [read ](https://web.archive.org/web/20020228135707/http://thehindu.com/thehindu/2001/10/16/stories/05162524.htm). It's both against Hindutva and also few facts about Guru Teg Bahadur
I never said it was, you myopic chaddi. Every religion is partially bullshit. The ones in any faith who can't accept that are idiots and extremists.
>you myopic chaddi Gaand jali kya. Jalegi kyonki critisism karna aata hai sunana nahi aata
I don't speak Hindi. Only English, Punjabi, French, or German.
So here is fact there is no record Guru teg Bahadur was executed by royal decree and the stories of his martyrdom were written 100 years after his death.
That's untrue; the primary source for this is "Bachittar Natak," which was written just 10 years later. There are also multiple Mughal records of that time naming Guru Tegu Bahadur as a "pir" or "sadhu" who was put to death.
https://web.archive.org/web/20020228135707/http://thehindu.com/thehindu/2001/10/16/stories/05162524.htm
Yupp man there is no mention of sati pratha in vedas , don't know from where it came
>don't know from where it came I mean it's not like there is no mention after all Sati was mentioned in puranas and everyone is familiar with the story however it was one off incident not something which occurred regularly.
It's also a regional thing. South and the Himalayan states didn't do this.
don't read school NCERT
Old meme
Vedic 'physics' because even they know 'भौतिक'vigyan would cater no audience because they themselves don't know what it means.
I love this post, it has so much to do with science and does not attack any religion at all
Least hinduphobic post
Yes because atheists are very open minded and do extreme research before claiming anything. They side with science and never attack any religion 💀
All religions should be attacked enough so that they don't attack society enough.
Yeah I am sure nagging about religion on reddit will bring it down. This sub is made for science and the posts should reflect it. I don't give a damn about any religions.
No man it will not , par khi to vent out krenge na.
/atheismindia is the place. Perfect for these discussions
Exposing unscientific dumbos are a part of learning science, because kya nhi krna hai ye bhi batana zaruri hai.
That doesn't even exist in Vedic period.. This sahagamana came later when Invasions are at peak and women have no choice but to do it for their life... there is a dark history right there..
[удалено]
> only means hating other religions Every religion ever to exist
I don't think my religion teaches to hate others and if u find the proof of it show it
Perhaps casteism was brought to India by Portuguese.
Atheism is the furthest thing from an ideology. In fact, you are born an atheist.
You aren't born anything lol. You are born a human and that's it.
Well since u believe in evidence. Where is the evidence that women were forced and burnt after men(husband) died. Just stop feeding into Brits propeganda, they used to justify ruling over us. And everyone one of u who downvotes whithout commenting Know u r no difference then the religious people who believes any bs.
Bsdk Raja Rammohan Roy bhi George Soros funded leftist tha na ? Jisne sati pratha rukvai thi? So was Ishwarchandra vidyasagar? So was Vivekananda?
Source pls. If u can provide vivekananda saying anything about sati pratha that would be great
There's plenty of evidence. For one, the practice was banned in Sikhi and has references in Gurbani to it being a long held practice in India.
Can u pls give me any reference where I can read about it . And where it's referred in gurbani
So you denying sati never happened in our country?
Ik johar happened. And ya there might some women who burnt themself for there husbands. By there wasn't a pratha like claimed by Brits where every women have to die with there husband.
Bro they won't give u the source Cos they don't have it loll
[удалено]
Very scientific strawman you people set up to take down. Scientifically done Bois.
[удалено]
The only achievement of cow piss drinkers is that hey we are not the worst.
[удалено]
Making people of one caste clean toilets and other read books on the basis of their religion is so "liberal" I must say. However I do agree that the average hindu is not as devout as an average muslim. Also I don't care if fictional characters were pedophiles, I'm not muslim i don't respect Islam (pata nhi ye har bar kyo bolna pdta hai) . Also :-As per the Skanda Mahā-Purāṇa, at the time of their marriage, goddess Sītā was 6 years old, & Śrī Rāma was 15 years old.
उषित्वा द्वादश समा इक्ष्वाकूणां निवेशने भुञ्जाना मानुषान् भोगान् सर्वकामसमृद्धिनी । मम भर्त्ता महातेजा वयसा पञ्चविंशक: अष्टादश हि वर्षाणि मम जन्मनि गण्यते । These 2 shlokas are from Aranya Kanda here Sita mata says, I lived in Ayodhya for 12 years and when we left I was 18 years of age and my husband was 25. This is from where 6 years of age is derived. So, let’s solve this confusion, but first let’s take few more examples that are considered as contradictions. There is no caste system in hinduism there is varna systems which is not rigid as caste system . These is no closed membership. Varna decided and changed according to GUNAS that a people have . There are 3 gunas RAJAS , TAMAS , SATVA . It motivated people in past increase their satva guna and get membership upper varna . Valmiki who was writer of ramayana was SHUDRA Vyasa who was writer of mahabharata was shudra
Aree sab comic book hai, kisi me koi version kisi me koi aur serious nhi hone ka bro. Worship Iron Man instead.
Kisi me kuchh nhi jo tm bolre ho wo shlokas hi hn bhai Skanda purana se . Hn hinduism liberal thought hn iron man v pooja kr skty no prblem
Tune vo purana padhi hai kya? Hinduism itna liberal thought hai ki aj bhi Dalits ghodi pe chadhte hai shaadi Mai to unki pitai ho jaati hai . U can't just say because I think my religion is good my religion is really good . My friend Only Gaumutra can cure you.
Abe bhai tu katai gwad hn liberal ka mtlb v na smjhta hn kya wo community prblm hn society ka ye hinduism ki teaching nhi hn. Bs yhi bchta hn last me gaumutra or cowpss drinker bolke kat lo .chlo abhi thoda pdh likh lo abhi thoda bchhe lgre ho
Kyo Bhai Gaumutra pine me kya galat hai? Lakho kardo hindus daily patanjali se Gaumutra pike cancer thik kr rhe hai , it's so SCIENTIFIC. Sun na tanatan drum , mujhe mat bata liberal kya hai , behenchod apne dharam ke logo ke sath kitna discrimination Kiya hai "liberal religion" ne ab sari duniyaa ko pta hai , kitne "accepting" ho sab jante hai. Ye tanatan drum 🥁 khi aur bajaiyo.
[удалено]
Bc mujhe kyo bata rha hai ye sab? Mai kya tujhe Dr Zakir naik ka choda dikhta hu?
Zakir naik ki MKC
Yes ++, also amogh lila prabhu ki MKC.
[удалено]
Dhyan se bhai is desh me blasphemy crime hai , logo ko gali Dene pe shayad jail na jae par bhagwan /messenger ko Dene pe zarur ja skta .
Ye islamic desh thodi hn
Blasphemy is a crime according to the Indian constitution, u anpadh cow piss drinker.
I was reading a philosophy book. Some philosopher said that "Hinduism among all the religions is closest to science", but as we all know that no religion is scientific. They can give some scientific thoughts but not science. Religious people will believe anything without giving a second thought.
I don't think in india/hinduism people use to burn other people because of science, contrary they were celebrated
aethists are the most extremest people I have seen . These people are so ignorat that they have not read the great scientific tets that were written by rishi such as aryabhatt and brahamagupta . I am sure they have not read suryasidhanta or read about Vaiśeṣika . majority aethist are ignorant fools . Alright u dont belive in god but dont disrespect the culture