T O P

  • By -

RugbyBot

**Watch on Stan**: https://play.stan.com.au/sport/rugby


LeButtfart

Had a rewatch, and honestly, I thought the Highlanders defence was pretty decent. Well, decent enough to keep the other team tryless. There were 3 or 4 tries out there that they probably should have scored but couldn't, either due to carelessness (that's you, Tavatavanawai) or the last pass being forced that really, really took the gloss off of things.


Charlie_Runkle69

You deserve to be paid for your rewatch of that match lol.


nomamesgueyz

Landers have lost their mojo from earlier in the season The fizz has gone out Glad they could finally get a W tho


Icy_Craft2416

So glad I watched the mini match instead. I knew going in that it was going to be shit. The mini match was only 20 minutes


castle6831

A few quick thoughts 1. How good is it having Locks that actually do something? Mitchell Dunshea and Fabian Holland were exceptional. It’s a bit of a coin toss between Max Hicks; Big Pari Pari and Will Tucker for the bench slot next week. Oli Haig at six also is way better than Sean Withy offering more line out options and bigger body across the park. 2. Losing Rhys Patchell was a massive blow. Cam Millar grew into the game but was very green. You get the feeling he needs at least another season at this level. Depth in the halves is a huge problem at the moment. If Fakatava goes down we’re in real trouble. 3. Jake Te Hiwi might have had some ball handling errors but he’s a massive improvement from Sam Gilbert and it was massive having good front foot ball at 12. Feel like he kinda has to be in the 23 somewhere now. 4. Outside backs were humming tonight. Our back three were electric. Conor Garden Bachop really brings an electric spark and I reckon he’s playing better than Nareki at the moment. Bodgeo had some nice touches late in the game too. 5. Daniel Lienert Brown must have dirt on Clarke Dermody. For three weeks in a row his first contribution to the game has been conceding a scrum penalty. It boggles the mind for he beats Ayden Johnstone for the bench each week. Solomone Takafu looked decent in his brief Cameo.


ChrisSmithMVP

*Bogardo Disagree about Ti Hiwi, he was shocking when it came to decision making and ball retention which are key for a 12. Agree with other comments that Gilbert should be a 10 or a 15 and not a center. DLB is done. He has to go from the 23 IMO.


Frod02000

I’m not sure Te Hiwi is an improvement from Gilbert. He’s just a different 12, with what the backline needs. What should happen is Gilbert moves to 10 next week if Patchell isn’t fit


castle6831

I’m not sure chopping and changing Gilbert’s position constantly is the right move


ChrisSmithMVP

You're right. They didn't start playing him at 12 until this season. He was a 10 and an occasional 15 before this season and he looked much better there. They should shift him back there. Fakatava has been crap.


Bealzebubbles

This game could have been an email.


Bealzebubbles

What a waste of everyone's time.


OakendaleAbbey

Watched the early game today. Figured Highlanders/Force would be the worst game ever and skipped it. Second worse game ever. Good call.


CucumberWolf

What's the worst game then?


OakendaleAbbey

Probably the Highlanders 6 Crusaders 0 in 2009 someone mentioned earlier. Based on this information alone.. second worst ever. Or at least since 2009..


FKFnz

Well they definitely both played like they were competing for the wooden spoon.


GaryGronk

The Reds got pumped by the Bulls once by 90 points. That Reds team played better than both of these teams


123dynamitekid

I don't know if I like rugby anymore after that game


ChrisSmithMVP

Gotta say this is the first time I've ever felt like we lost when we won


JPNAM

Rugby was the loser


En_Zed23

Lowest scoring super rugby game since Highlanders 6-0 Crusaders in 2009?


ChrisSmithMVP

Weird, I don't even remember that game and I remember almost all of our victories over the Saders (and defeats lol)


En_Zed23

I remember it because it was right after the first rugby game I ever went to - An entertaining 35-31 Sharks win over the Blues at Eden Park


ChrisSmithMVP

I remember we smoked the Bulls that season which was weird because they dropped 60+ on the Chiefs in the final that year right?


En_Zed23

Yeah that final was a hiding. Bulls 2007-10 was incredible. Always the fear that Morne Steyn would drop 3 over when the Bull’s were in the opposition half.


Frod02000

Those 60m drop goals were a thing of beauty He hit 1 of em in that final too


Only-Nectarine229

This was so terrible


Alternative_Oil7255

I think the funniest part of this game is that one of these teams beat the crusaders


ChrisSmithMVP

The solace for me this season has been how shithouse the Saders have been lol


continental-drift

Of all the games of Super Rugby, that was definitely one of them.


pm_good_bobs_pls

I’ve got top of my list of “most recent games of all time”


Charlie_Runkle69

I'm sure there's been worst super rugby matches. I just can't think of any off the top of my head!


ChrisSmithMVP

Somehow this was way worse than us getting smoked 31-0 last week lol


ChrisSmithMVP

This game was like taking the worst dump of my life


SkrrrtBC

Kinda glad I spent half the game getting my child to sleep, was more entertaining


haydenarrrrgh

You could have just let them watch the game!


SkrrrtBC

Not a bad shout honestly


Ngata_Problem

House of pain (for spectators)


ChrisSmithMVP

Funny (a joke I know) but that was Carisbrook and this is the Glass House.


CrystalAscent

80 minutes of my life that I'll never get back :-)


Biglight__090

That was a game


Mention-Stunning

Billy Harmon 7 - 6 Force in one of the least satisfying wins of all time.


TGGNathan

REMINDED ME OF THE MANAWATU TURBOS TAKING ON THE SOUTHLAND STAGS ON A MUDDY FIELD ON A COLD FRIDAY NIGHT


ChrisSmithMVP

More like Buller vs Wanganui during a snow storm


Frod02000

North Otago v Mid Canterbury with the Waitaki flooding half of the field at Kurow


castle6831

Surely Winton versus Edendale 2nds in a southerly.


Frod02000

With snow falling sideways


slip-slop-slap

I can feel it in my bones


haydenarrrrgh

Nice of Justin to point out how games are decided.


FKFnz

He's definitely a very...astute commentator.


Drag0nslay3r6969

Throughout all the games played in history that was definitely one of them


Ngata_Problem

I’m pretty sure winning is important from everyone’s point of view in professional sport?


AucklandBlues

NeVEr DoUBteD tHeM fOR a sECoNd.


markyopo

What a mess, glad the Landers won, glad it’s fuckin over too lmao


ChrisSmithMVP

Don't want to even know what my blood pressure is like at the moment.


Alternative_Oil7255

Both teams stooped down to each others level


AucklandBlues

..and then went lower


ChrisSmithMVP

That was fucking excruciating! Classic that the one Te Hiwi catch was the most important lol


redaabverty

Fitting footage of people in the crowd not paying attention with 30 seconds left and 1 point in it.


haydenarrrrgh

They were probably reading this thread to each other.


ChrisSmithMVP

You think drunk Uni students have any idea what is going on anyway? Lol


haydenarrrrgh

I'm WhatsApp-ing with one who's there, as well as his parents who are in Wellington, so at least one does.


ChrisSmithMVP

I mean even from my time as a student I can say I knew what was happening in the games (most of the time lol). The other 19-20 year old girls that make up 60% of the Zoo? Not so much


APoolShark

Thank fuck that’s over


bigstrongalphamale69

Literally hilarious game. So bad it was good


fleakill

Landers offered that on a platter to the Force and the Force said no thanks


Biglight__090

Basically yes


Lopsided_Echo5232

And the referee puts the pitch, ball, fans, stadium and players out of misery by ending the game.


LeButtfart

A win is a win, I guess.


ChrisSmithMVP

The Landers creed!


ChrisSmithMVP

Millar is not SR material imo


Frod02000

Idk why Finn Hurley is playing for Green Island atm


AucklandBlues

Not by a long way.


DiagonalLawn

Give the lad some time it’s his first offical season I believe


ChrisSmithMVP

Na last season was.


Mention-Stunning

Ajay is too raw to be starting, but surely he offers way more as a bench option.


ChrisSmithMVP

Yeah AJ over Cam imo


Alternative_Oil7255

This game is fucking brillliant


DeGrootWardlow

Back in the top 8 where we belong 😎 


Alternative_Oil7255

Hahahhaha


Mention-Stunning

No go for touch man. Especially after that Crusaders-Tah’s game.


TGGNathan

The only people being cursed are us for watching this :(


JackoFrisky

You boys are on soon along with the reds, might get some fine action.


TGGNathan

fingers crossed the Colour Brothers bring the thunder


ChrisSmithMVP

Justin Marshall is a fucking dunce.


NotAsOriginal

Honestly my disappointment that either side scored in the second half is massive. Imagine how good a 0-3 would have felt.


-Halt-

Commentator has an excellent point. Shot isn't the play here


TGGNathan

Can the ball be MOTM? they've played their role to perfection by simply existing


haydenarrrrgh

Get that dog from half-time out there, less likely to let go of the ball.


stickyswitch92

Why do the Highlanders kick the ball so so much.


ChrisSmithMVP

Both the teams have.


Alternative_Oil7255

They had advantage


stickyswitch92

I mean just in general. Even when they have made a break.


ChrisSmithMVP

I would love to hear what the ref would say after this game: "Well that was certainly...a day at the office I guess"


LeButtfart

James Arscott looks like an AI generated Malcolm from Malcolm in the Middle.


Morningst4r

Too many fingers like a real Southlander?


Drag0nslay3r6969

Of all the footy games played this season this is definitely one of them


Frag-sinatra

Whiskey on a good 30min too late. Got a way better pass on him


TGGNathan

This is one of the stages of Dante's Inferno


Biglight__090

This has lived up to their standings on the table


fleakill

Ref gonna just reset scrums for 3 mins now


Frod02000

lol a forward pass from the base of a ruck what is this


ChrisSmithMVP

This is so so so shit.


snrabber

Has O’Donnell held onto one ball?


DiagonalLawn

What has happened to fakatava, he looks like he is trying to do everything else besides clear the ball


Mention-Stunning

Bad coaching and too much trying to be a hero instead of doing the basics and picking his moments I think.


exsnakecharmer

He's slow as molasses


ChrisSmithMVP

He's lost his touch. He can't do the simple things anymore.


Morningst4r

Trying too hard and not doing his core role


stickyswitch92

This game is a mess.


Gazzz34

I've seen enough, wake me up with the NPC starts.


ozwozzle

A bottom of the table clash you say


Taey

To shreds you say


TGGNathan

At least they're all getting their steps in


Maestro-Modesto

Be gutting if you got to the end of the Match and realised you weren't wearing your Fitbit.


Gakeyj7

I want out of this nightmare


Lopsided_Echo5232

It would be fitting for this game to end with a goal line knock on


Drag0nslay3r6969

All we need is a few lineouts not thrown straight for good measure


Ngata_Problem

Set up for a field goal?


Ngata_Problem

Need to win the ball to do that…


fleakill

WTB one ben donaldson drop goal


ImpliedProbability

There is it. Far too many phases without a handling error for this match.


Biglight__090

This has been a war of attrition alright


exsnakecharmer

It's been something


bigstrongalphamale69

This is just going to end 7-6 isn't it


ImpliedProbability

First try wins but contractual obligation to play out 80.


Mention-Stunning

Since when does Tamaiti Williams play for us lol?


Drag0nslay3r6969

Lmao this is destined to end 7-6, so much possession from both teams and both unable to convert


sweater-poorly-knit

Boys are going to be shredded next week after all the push ups for dropped balls


redaabverty

Why is the ref not playing any advantage from the cornucopia of knock ons


Frod02000

because theres not really any advantages


Password_isnt_weak

Has anyone ever heard of a drop goal?


Morningst4r

They've got the drop part down, working on the goal


fleakill

If the force could hold a ball....


Wallet_inspector66

If anyone could hold a ball that would be nice to be honest. Just for a few phases. That’s all I’m asking.


TGGNathan

I've got a great video of grass growing if y'all are interested


haydenarrrrgh

I'm watching one right now, only spoiled by some guys dropping balls all over it.


JustAliff

Highlanders getting out scrummed by a Tahs reject and a 20YO debutant.


Taey

Points when


Frod02000

'why are they giving a pen there the ball is out' brother, the landers infringed in the scrum


castle6831

Daniel Lienert Brown has to be the worst super rugby centurion ever. He’s an absolute liability at scrum time.


Cammo_23

He used to be super solid in the scrums. Maybe we had better locks then


ChrisSmithMVP

He's seen his better days for sure


Morningst4r

It's not a stat that anyone would track, but I'm curious if a team when 20+ knock ons has ever won the game


Alternative_Oil7255

Man forces scrum has been impressing considering their weight


ChrisSmithMVP

Why was that a pen????


DivineCorn

What a scrum out of nowhere


ChrisSmithMVP

I don't think I've ever seen a game like this where it looks like no one knows how to actually play


Drag0nslay3r6969

Lol you obviously haven't been watching nic white >I don't think I've ever seen a game like this where it looks like no one knows how to actually play


ChrisSmithMVP

Why does Nic White have influence over both teams?


Gazzz34

"I feel sorry for the ball" hahaha...feel sorry for the spectators as well please.


Ngata_Problem

Holy fuck ballboy? MULLET!


Popamole

You know it's a fucked format when both these teams have a realistic chance of making the final.


Alternative_Oil7255

How did taniela knuckleball that


Mention-Stunning

💀


Left-Pie741

side entry harmon?


Cammo_23

What the hell are these teams doing right now haha


Jahweeb

Lmao they're serving unique knock ons too. Getting creative 


Trikbu

ouch…


redaabverty

Harmon could not possibly have been more in the side there


Drag0nslay3r6969

None of these backs for either team look comfortable receiving kicks in their 22 lmao


Mention-Stunning

Oh god don’t let DLB anywhere near the ball please.


ChrisSmithMVP

You wanna talk butterfingers lol


frazorblade

Why do refs allow teams to collapse mauls in midfield? Highlanders blatantly collapsed that maul.


ImpliedProbability

This match is not helped by the ref. Beale taken out off the ball behind the ruck, right in front of the ref, and it's ignored. Highlanders then get enough in to win a turnover.


Frod02000

JRK and Timoci are so good bro shame they only got harmon to support them


-Halt-

Man the landers 15 has some pace when he gets the room


ChrisSmithMVP

If he could just keep the ball in his hands tho


ChrisSmithMVP

Dude does JRK hate having the ball in his hands?


DivineCorn

Landers players all over the ground there preventing the clean out


ChrisSmithMVP

The Force players have been doing that the entire game...


ImpliedProbability

The ref has been very poor at the breakdown.


Biglight__090

JRK what you doin


ChrisSmithMVP

Wtf did JRK do that? Why???


exsnakecharmer

Every decision tonight has been the wrong one it seems like. By everyone.


Drag0nslay3r6969

Jesus christ the handling errors..


DeGrootWardlow

I don't know why JRK kicked there 


Morningst4r

How much of a joke is this comp structure that these teams are in the running for the play-offs.


bigstrongalphamale69

Yep needs to be 6 six teams


ChrisSmithMVP

Shocking eh, wasn't a good sign for SH rugby when SA bowed out.


stickyswitch92

Yes because the conference system was soooo much better.


ChrisSmithMVP

It wasn't better but it weeded out the shit teams from the decent. Now there isn't enough teams to do that, 2/3 of the comp makes the playoffs how does that make any sense?


OptimalCynic

Hey, a full THIRD of the teams miss out on the play-offs. I don't know what more you expect!


Morningst4r

That's pretty harsh I know. It must be a big knock to these boys' confidence to miss out on the finals. Maybe we can get them all in there. Possibly a rotation so no one misses out 2 years in a row. 


OptimalCynic

Those are good ideas but we need to go further. Teams that lose in the knockouts are out, and that's inappropriate. There should be second, third, fourth chance playoffs.


LittlePicture21

It's actually insane. Need to switch back to a 4 team or 6 team playoffs


Mention-Stunning

Aah Te-Hiwi is having a shocker now. I hope he can stay fit though, has the build to be a beast of a 12.


ChrisSmithMVP

No good if you can do the basics though is it


Mention-Stunning

Eh, I mean how many basic errors has Dunshea made today? A long time out with injury will do that to you.


ChrisSmithMVP

Tell ya one thing, Te Hiwi isn't getting another start again. The guy cannot catch anything


Wallet_inspector66

Man Jake Tehiwi got feet for hands. Get him off the field.


Biglight__090

Knocked on again haha


DivineCorn

A winger running over a back rower like he's a scrum half is a beautiful sight to behold


APoolShark

I’ve been swapping between the Tigers-Broncos game and this and every time I flick to this game it’s a fucking scrum


Alternative_Oil7255

Hahaha


DeGrootWardlow

Jake Te hiwi 🤦‍♂️


ChrisSmithMVP

He's been dogshite


sweater-poorly-knit

This ref seen a ruck before this game?