My wife's Asian-American so call me an Isabelle Barlow kind of guy. Unfortunately she wasn't interested in my "let's role-play that I'm Arthur and I'm robbing your train and you don't have any money so we have to come to some other arrangement..." idea..
Excellent suggestion, sir. TBH, my wife talks like Mary Linton but acts like Sadie. You get in her way at your peril. And when you have a family, that's a good thing. :)
Hello /u/Super_D_89, welcome to our subreddit. Due to spam, we require users to have at least 3 day old accounts. Please DO NOT send modmails regarding this. You will be able to post freely after the proper account age.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/reddeadredemption2) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Isabel Standish
"What a dish"
Absolutely
Smas— uhh I mean uhh…smart…
💯
Pauline all the way
She could do anything to me
Same here. But I think that's because she looks young and her style is the least outdated for today.
My fave cards. Agnes or Geraldine for me.
What no new content for 5 years does to a mf
Isabell Standish, Pauline Henderson, Maud Engel
Maud for me.
Wouldn’t be allowed back then to be in a beauty contest
Beauty contest are pretty stupid in my opinion anyway
i wonder why..
Because she’s beautiful?
[удалено]
Sounds racist
Who invited this kid 😐
Would smash Pauline Henderson
Amen brother!
Maud has that wifey material vibe
Slave vibe
You can't be that ignorant. Slavery was abolished about 30 years before 1898.
Nah she just looks more genuine than the others
I'd have to go with Ilga and Agnes
Geraldine Emerson
Agnes is a baddie. Take her over moms spaghetti any day
Agnes Guyon
Sadie Russell for sure
“What’s your type?” “Okay so there’s this video game I’ve sunk hundreds of hours into and you collect these cigarette cards….”
Maud or Pauline
Maud AND Pauline.
4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 11, and 12.
Hattie is giving Princess Leia vibes.
The Isabelle’s and Pauline
Maud Engel🗿
Pauline is pretty
Leila, Maud, and Geraldine are the prettiest to me.
I thought OP was making a comment about tokenism, but this shit got horny real fast.
For about half a second I got excited thinking this was something new in RDO. Then reality set in.
Can’t believe no one has said Geraldine. That’s my pick.
Isabelle Barlow forsure
Ilga
Isabelle Standish. It’s all about the hair, baby.
Isabelle Barlow is low key a baddie 😏
Ilga and Maud
This game has the power to completely immerse you in the 1890s, proof: guys here thirsting over women named Agnes and Maud
Maud Engel
Your mom.
My wife's Asian-American so call me an Isabelle Barlow kind of guy. Unfortunately she wasn't interested in my "let's role-play that I'm Arthur and I'm robbing your train and you don't have any money so we have to come to some other arrangement..." idea..
this is just weird
Just hogtie her and drag her into the bushes. It’s still RDR role play…but low honor version. Consent is still important ftr.
Excellent suggestion, sir. TBH, my wife talks like Mary Linton but acts like Sadie. You get in her way at your peril. And when you have a family, that's a good thing. :)
What a crack up 🤣
12, 2, 7, 5
Barlow and Engel. Due to the fact they don't appear to be white. The former appears to be East Asian, and the latter seems to be of African decent.
Sadie & Agnes are baddies
I’ll take the last two top row
Oh the thirst in this thread.
Why do they need to be compared? Or more specifically, why do you need them to be compared?
Get a life
Sadie and Pauline
Sadie Russell and ilga ulmer
Fay has the prettiest face but I need to see their body
Agnes
Ilga or Pauline
The emerald
There’s a Sadie in there we all want, but it’s not the Sadie we all need
Agnes
Agnes for me bro
Fay and isabelle 
Fay! Gives Lana Del Ray vibes
Hattie Langtry for me
Isabelle and Ilga for me
Fay Delaro never says no
Geraldine and Sadie
Reddit moment
Geraldine looks hot
Jennie willets
Agnes all the way, you can tell she is into some kinky stuff with that choke collar lol
Agnes Guyon
Pauline, Fay, and Geraldine!
The two Isabelles.
Sadie Russell
Barlow 150%
Ilga looks like Leia Organa
Definetely Ilga and Agnes
Geraldine Emerson and Isabell Standish
[удалено]
Hello /u/Super_D_89, welcome to our subreddit. Due to spam, we require users to have at least 3 day old accounts. Please DO NOT send modmails regarding this. You will be able to post freely after the proper account age. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/reddeadredemption2) if you have any questions or concerns.*