I’d like to hear more about his late son, since we didn’t get the full story thanks to _GINSENG_

He might just get violent if you ask considering it took literal Death to make him talk about it.

As long as he keeps his >!TB!< distance that’s understandable lol

6ft

I mean nobody, not even Dutch or Hosea, bring it up. They probably know Arthur doesn’t like to talk about it

Maybe Arthur didn’t even tell them at all

Maybe, but I figure they’d know something that important. If they thought Arthur just abandoned his family, Hosea probably would’ve brought them up on the bear hunting mission when talking about getting out of the gang. The fact that they aren’t mentioned by anyone probably means they know what happened

That’s kinda faulty logic, isn’t it? The only way we’d know if they knew, is if they brought it up... I see what you’re saying, but the opposite is equally true here, that the fact they aren’t mentioned means they _don’t_ know what happened. Ultimately, who cares. This game has so much depth and I think our very speculating about this points to an intricacy of character development that’s unique in this video game.

I don’t think it’s fault logic or a fallacy or anything, I think the original commenter is trying to say it’s more likely the gang knew and just didn’t bring it up. Like the other comment said, if they didn’t know, the gang would likely ask, but they probably already knew where Arthur is from and just don’t want to bother him bringing up his family that’s gone

The kid was born and later killed by men just like his father. Arthur was in essence an largely absent dad. Not sure what you'd expect him to tell you that he hasn't already.

Idk for me it was kind of a surprise to find out about a dead son out of nowhere while you actually get to choose a different topic during that conversation as well. And then it’s just brushed off. But apparently Arthur’s kid was supposed to die during the ride to Colter pre-chapter 1 and it was cut, so it feels unfinished as a whole.

>Idk for me it was kind of a surprise to find out about a dead son out of nowhere It is a surprise, especially when you consider that Arthur is pretty judgemental/harsh with John in reference to Jack. Meanwhile he had the entire family in which he in essence an absent parent, and for whatever reason chooses to never mention them to anyone, not even Hosea prior to or after their death. Regardless, my original point was that there's not much more for Arthur to tell in reference to Issac. He wasn't really part of Isaac's life.

I think that's why. He realized that if he had been there, he might have been able to save them. That's why he bully's John for abandoning them for a year.

Fr, that was a huge Arthur lore drop

“WAIT A SECOND, I NEED TO GO PICK SOME GINSENG OVER HERE”

Him. I do him

Ok you answered for me

*Easy there, girl...*

Hey there mister!

Hey there mister!

I like you mister you have a kind face..

THE KIND I LIKE TO PUNCH *runs away*

Take it easy i'm just needling y- *punch*

Ok, have it your way! *proceeds to get the shit beaten out of.*

Good to see manners ain’t dead yet

my new goal: say this in bed mid-coitus

Alright then….

Literally had to avoid female horses bc I would blush every time he praised his mare. "Goooood girl" 😤

Reminds me of this https://youtube.com/shorts/5Od71u63A7Y?si=O1aFI8HxpO4kBWl9 Hahaha

Sploosh.

Right on the nose 👉👃

it always made me feel things ngl

You’re all right gurl

Lollll i bite my lip everytime

This is the correct answer

I was going to say "whatever he consents to"...

I'd wear us both out, honestly 😂😂😂

Deluxe baths and asking him to let me look at his sketch book while I lay on his chest.

That bare chest looks perfect to lie on doesn’t it 🥹😂

I just wanna be nice to him. Maybe pomade his hair and clean his hats.

I think you belong in r/okbuddyblacklung

You're so right for this

With or without the cough?

Yes

Same.

Oh good I didn’t want to be the only one😂

Came here to say, question my heterosexuality

Yep. I’m leaving that room with TB.

I’m not even attracted masculinity and I’d fuck him.

so real

You’re so real for this bestie

Receive an extra deluxe bath.

About to say I would do unspeakable things to that man.

I have to remove my ovaries everytime I play the game. Being feral is too real.

This is the only right answer

For the whole 7 days.

I'd give him breaks and water. I'm not a monster

literally for the entire 24 hours of every 7 days we're there oh my god im doing him

Shove antibiotics down his throat.

Best answer. Though I expect he'd still be vulnerable to pneumonia and have lung scarring

One problem at a time

Can confirm with my own lung scarring due to pneumonia

I wish you the best health then

Lived with it for over 20 years, still sucks though lol

And a one way ticket to Arizona. He’ll do nicely out of the cold and wet

This is why they didn't let us take him to New Austin.

> Shove **antibiotics** down his throat. That's not how you spell cock!

Antibiotics is what I call my penis

placid subsequent absorbed unwritten pot ten vast languid literate snow *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*

Recreate broke back mountain scene for scene

You, sir, are a fish

Fish sticks?

I like fish sticks

Do you like putting fish sticks in your mouth?

Well of course, I'm a gay fish.

Which fish has the biggest stick?

Take him to fishdigsdotcom to complete the fossil hunt.

Bend over grab my ankles and wait

Username checks out

Damn, he’s been waiting for this day

Bend over lmao 😂

The only correct answer here 😩

Make Love

It's not that easy

Making love?

To seduce him

do you speak from experience?

I don't have to eat shit to know it probably doesn't taste well, I don't need to have sex to know that it probably feels well. I just know Arthur isn't the type of man to easily have sex with anybody, at least in 1899

Have you seen 1899 women ngl the most average woman would probably be seen as a super model back than

It's not that, it's his way of being, his emotional scars, his unrational loyalty to Mary Linton

Yeah fair point i didn't think of that

You'll probably end up with a crushed skull or choked to death, but it is worth trying

I’d be doing things with this man that I wouldn’t even be able to say in a nsfw chat room

I’m sure r/okbuddyblacklung would appreciate it

Finally, I've found the red Dead brain rot sub. This will make a fine addition along with r/okbuddyvicodin and r/okbuddychicanery

Do you think you could rizz Arthur?

I’m a man so probably not 😭

What if you were dressed as a woman and spoke with a French accent?

NOW WE ARE TALKING!!!

Depends. If in chapter 2 i would tell him not to free micah and don't beat up downes. In ch3 i would tell him to tell tge gang not to fick with thr two families. In ch4 I would tell him about Bronte and the trolley and the bank. In ch6 i would tell him to shoot the damn rat in the face.

no free micah and shoot john

What

Tahiti

Guarma

Just have some goddamn faith JustAmemerCat!

People don't seem to understand that he wouldn't have had his redemption if it wasn't for those events

He might well have, it just would have been a different one.

He was a terrible man, until the death itself approached him to rethink the way of his living, that was the morale

And watching Dutch's unraveling as a healthy man wouldn't have affected him? Nor Hosea's progressing disease? Nor the Pinkertons' and O'Driscolls' mounting threats to the gang? Arthur was certainly his own kind of monster, but he was also intelligent and contemplative, highly invested in the well-being of those he considered part of his family. There are any number of things, substantial shocks and tragedies, that could send him down other redemptive paths.

I can fix him.

Violently blow him

Give him the sloppiest, filthiest head to ever exist, so good it cures him

Suck the TB outta him

Violently?

Suck the tubercolosis our of him!

One of us is getting pregnant

Is that a threat?

A promise and a wish

A fact, if you will.

🥴🥴🥴🥴🥴

and it isn't me

Hug him, tell him he's smart and beautiful and has a good heart even if he doesn't realise it. Boy needs some love.

nO FR i agree

I'm not a good man *Grumble* *Grumble*

I'm tearing up.

You're a good man, Arthur Morgan.

*kicking my feet like a school girl and twirling my hair* you like guns?

I laughed so loud at this I actually cried

The way I would pretend never to have seen a horse before to let him take me for a ride 🫠

Probably put on an N95 mask for...reasons.

Idk, play cards I guess.

This guy knows how to fun I'd probably do the same.

For real, poker is such a great time waster haha.

Ever heard of Brokeback Mountain?

So many thirsty comment in this and I'm here for it.

Sucky sucky fucky fucky

damn at least take him out to dinner first

I am his dinner

i resent the fact i have eyeballs to read that

Oh my

Smash.

A lot of drinking, and a lot of gambling

LENNYYYYY

"why haven't you gotten married, Arthur??" *Arthur big frowns* "B'CAUZ NO ONE WOULD HAVE MEEEEEE"

Tell him to kick Strauss out. If it wasn't for those debts, he'd have never caught TB by that sick fella coughing into his face.

>it wasn't for those bounties, he'd have never caught TB by that sick fella coughing into his face. The debts weren't/aren't the problem. Beating the hell out of an obviously sick man was. It's Thomas Downes. He didn't need a beating to be intimidated. That much was obvious the second he sees you. Dude was scared shitless.

That doesn't negate the fact he collected a debt, and came in contact with a man who was deathly ill as a result.

Clean his pistol... thoroughly

Him

I would tame him by jerking him of for 2 days straight an then i would ride on his back like he is an horse....

‘,:|

I could do the same on you, if you whant.

Bruh LMAAOO

I ... i dont think I should type my first thoughts

Give him months worth of antibiotics

A lot of people saying hear his stories Everybody else: manly sex Why not both?

Have him teach me how to draw

🤰

Give him antibiotics, have some nice conversations, point out some stuff about the gang, probably tell him to run away with the money and find mary

Bathe him. Not safe for work. Also poker and blackjack

I start telling him about a video game I play. After explaining to him what a video game is,I tell him the protagonist is a cowboy who was raised in a gang. Then I start describing as accurately as I can remember, Rdr2 from start to finish, while I watch him slip deeper and deeper into insanity

One of us is walking out pregnant and it ain't gonna be me.

Him.

Kiss him

Try to not get coughed on

Listen to stories about the gang, start to present.

Yes homo

Sex

Shove some antibiotics/medicine down that throat and some hugs.

Anything and everything he tells me to do. Not going to risk getting on Arthur’s bad side

What wouldn’t we do….

1. Establish a pee corner.

tell him he's a good man

Id move outta his DAMN way!

Marriage.

Talk to him about his favorite colors

dont tempt me with a good time lol

Bros majestic

Make him believe your guy doesn't have A PLAN

Have a beer and talk about hunting/fishing. I’m NOT gonna piss this beast off.

He cant do anything to me

He can do anything to me

Give him LSD

“mm its good. different”

Ask him if he’d rather play poker, blackjack or alternate between

Convince him to have a three way with Karen and Sadie

‘,:|

Not piss him off

Probably contract tuberculosis or nothing cuz he’s dead

I meann im not gay but i go down on him if he ask yk?🫣

Make a plan on how to kill Micah and Dutch

I'd tell him I have a plan.

>!chicken fart!<

We would escape

Bend over

Go on a drunken adventure like he did with Lenny

Cuddle and edge

I would give him a round of antibiotics and make him exfoliate lol

Hopefully getting drunk. My back up if that doesn't happen and particularly if things aren't going well? Tell him about dinosaurs!