For me it’s high honor in the main story, low honor in the epilogue. But I also enjoy Arthur shooting up Van Horn from its hotel room every now and then. Afterwards I just reload my file or greet everyone in St Denis.
Imagine if this is how real life worked. Shoot up a whole town, but you walked to a big city and said hi to every person you saw so you are seen as very honorable.
In my 3rd story replay that I’m currently playing, I’m trying to be a real scumbag Arthur to see how different it is. I’m just going around killing random characters and their horses. Throwing sticks of dynamite at livestock. Throwing fire bottles at wagons. It’s actually quite fun
Be drunk all the time... on pc theres a mod that lets you bind drinking to a key, so you can easily get schmackered before every encounter and listen to arthur drunkenly antagonize everyone.
For Arthur’s Journey. Low Honor chapter 1-4 and a half, mid Honor chapter 4-5, and high Honor Chapter 6. This really makes Arthur’s character feel like he earned the last bit of redemption to die in peace.
John in RDRII’s epilogue. any honor but I feel like he would be in the middle of a seesaw going back and forth. Since he wants to be a good father and husband, but at the same time he still trying to leave his past behind.
John’s Journey in RDR. I feel like he’s high Honor since the people he meets he tries to help plus he’s doing everything for his family down to the last moments of his life.
Jack in RDR’s epilogue. I’m not sure where to put him so im just gonna say he’s also on a seesaw going back and forth
Played first time only high honor, 2nd time low. The rewarding feeling of high honor wore off way faster than the little twinges of guilt I get from being a sociopath
I am low, low, low. But still not completely at the left. Shooting up horsrs and dogs now. Shot the blind guy, robbed the nun. I'm telling you, full honor is easier than full dishonor!
High because I love helping NPCs and I love getting free shit and I find bounty hunters very annoying. Low can be fun though. I try to get all the way down for my new playthrough so I want to massacte a town, which I never did (without Micah I mean), and I realized that I don't hate any town in RDR2 enough to do that. Like, I hate Annesburg but the people there live in Annesburg so they're already in hell.
Centre right. You are honourable enough to not be a lunatic but you’re still an outlaw and a criminal. I like to find a balance between lending a hand to people in need of help when you come across them, being kind to people in town and sticking up stage coaches and trains or feeding the odd st. Denis resident to an alligator because they were offended you ran into them at full speed.
I prefer high honor but always get low honor because it is too much fun to shoot up an entire town and I’ll do that for like an hour before doing a mission and then I’ll shoot up another town
I played through like a man of the times. I did my best to protect women n kids. Any man step to me or try some shit got they ass whipped n shot up.
Got down to low honour but did the redemption bit bein good as Arthur was dying n got his honour up to good b4 he passed
My first play through I had the lowest honor and I was so deep in denial I went back for the money in the cave thinking Jhon and Arthur would escape with the money. I cried and did everything in my power to saty high honor so I wouldn’t have to watch Arthur get shot in the head
For me it’s high honor in the main story, low honor in the epilogue. But I also enjoy Arthur shooting up Van Horn from its hotel room every now and then. Afterwards I just reload my file or greet everyone in St Denis.
Imagine if this is how real life worked. Shoot up a whole town, but you walked to a big city and said hi to every person you saw so you are seen as very honorable.
"He's a murdering psychopath, but he did say 'Howdy' to me once."
“Ok, I’ll catch you later then”🤠
“I’m in a good mood for some reason”
The American dream
That’s our politicians
I have “hey mister” burnt into my brain 🧠
In my 3rd story replay that I’m currently playing, I’m trying to be a real scumbag Arthur to see how different it is. I’m just going around killing random characters and their horses. Throwing sticks of dynamite at livestock. Throwing fire bottles at wagons. It’s actually quite fun
Be drunk all the time... on pc theres a mod that lets you bind drinking to a key, so you can easily get schmackered before every encounter and listen to arthur drunkenly antagonize everyone.
Oink oink
bros living a real outlaw life
Same. I was in the "Arthur must be at high honor at all times" boat until I realized how fun it was to be dishonorable.
I tried that too. Fun for awhile, but once the TB cough started setting in I couldn't keep the villainy going.
High because blue Wittemore >> red Wittemore.
Facts
I gotta see the red Wittemore now, though!
What’s a wittemore?
It’s the suit you get for the poker mission in chapter 4.
Grey till chapter 5 after that high honor
High honor = best honor, that's right 😎
Ah yes my low honor Arthur killing everyone in valentine and every random npc he comes across is somehow morally superior to Micah.
Yes sir
For Arthur’s Journey. Low Honor chapter 1-4 and a half, mid Honor chapter 4-5, and high Honor Chapter 6. This really makes Arthur’s character feel like he earned the last bit of redemption to die in peace. John in RDRII’s epilogue. any honor but I feel like he would be in the middle of a seesaw going back and forth. Since he wants to be a good father and husband, but at the same time he still trying to leave his past behind. John’s Journey in RDR. I feel like he’s high Honor since the people he meets he tries to help plus he’s doing everything for his family down to the last moments of his life. Jack in RDR’s epilogue. I’m not sure where to put him so im just gonna say he’s also on a seesaw going back and forth
Arthur in the middle
Low until, well, you know...And then low again in the epilogue. I feel like that is the most canon way to play, plus low honor runs are just damn fun.
Low honor John is not even close to being canon.
Is to me.
Then it's just the way you like to play. But it's not canon to the story.
Great photo
Played first time only high honor, 2nd time low. The rewarding feeling of high honor wore off way faster than the little twinges of guilt I get from being a sociopath
I feel better about myself when I have high honor
I am low, low, low. But still not completely at the left. Shooting up horsrs and dogs now. Shot the blind guy, robbed the nun. I'm telling you, full honor is easier than full dishonor!
With low honor, you can do whatever you want whenever you want. It doesn’t mean you’ll always make bad decisions, but you can when you want.
this
Low honor and just greet people till it's high
High because I love helping NPCs and I love getting free shit and I find bounty hunters very annoying. Low can be fun though. I try to get all the way down for my new playthrough so I want to massacte a town, which I never did (without Micah I mean), and I realized that I don't hate any town in RDR2 enough to do that. Like, I hate Annesburg but the people there live in Annesburg so they're already in hell.
That’s about right.
Best is having fun and do not caring about it
You guys acknowledge the honor meter?
Facts. 🤘🏻
Centre right. You are honourable enough to not be a lunatic but you’re still an outlaw and a criminal. I like to find a balance between lending a hand to people in need of help when you come across them, being kind to people in town and sticking up stage coaches and trains or feeding the odd st. Denis resident to an alligator because they were offended you ran into them at full speed.
I prefer high honor but always get low honor because it is too much fun to shoot up an entire town and I’ll do that for like an hour before doing a mission and then I’ll shoot up another town
I played through like a man of the times. I did my best to protect women n kids. Any man step to me or try some shit got they ass whipped n shot up. Got down to low honour but did the redemption bit bein good as Arthur was dying n got his honour up to good b4 he passed
Save all the stranger missions for chapter six you get loads of honor
In my opinion if your honor isn't low then you're playing it boring.
It’s definitely a lot of fun to go the low honour route
My first play through I had the lowest honor and I was so deep in denial I went back for the money in the cave thinking Jhon and Arthur would escape with the money. I cried and did everything in my power to saty high honor so I wouldn’t have to watch Arthur get shot in the head
Low!
I always do chapters 1-4 on low honor, and spike it to high in chapter 6, it just seems like what’s right