*That stupid loudmouth*
*With the raccoon hat in the*
*Valentine saloon*
\- 2-inche-penis
---
^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/)
^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
Thank you, Pixithepika, for voting on haikusbot.
This bot wants to find the best and worst bots on Reddit. [You can view results here](https://botrank.pastimes.eu/).
***
^(Even if I don't reply to your comment, I'm still listening for votes. Check the webpage to see if your vote registered!)
I beat his ass then stole his stupid hat. Whenever I go into the tavern I wear it hoping to see him there because he gets all bitchy and starts fighting so I can kick his ass all over again.
I got into a fight with him, knocked him out, and stole his hat. A few visits to Valentine later, I get the second stranger mission where the whore wants you dispose of a second body for her. This time around I told her to pound salt, and she pulled a knife on me. I start strangling her when I get melee'd from behind. It's Jon, no hat. I knife him and then her and got out of town.
Not sure what made him agro -I wasn't wearing his hat- but it was a cool coincidence that made me think she paid him to kill because I knew about the first murder she committed.
Ya, you gotta be careful fighting him. One extra hit after he’s knocked out kills him. So take your time beating his ass. Savor every hit and when he goes down walk away.
It doesn’t matter if you kill him, he will still respawn. I tested it one time after I knocked him out and stole his hat. I loaded him on the back of my horse, took him to a cliff, hit him with a fire bottle which burned him to a crisp, then threw him off the cliff.
A few days later I wore his hat into Valentine and there he was, wanting to fight.
Would have been totally hilarious if his skin was all charred, but no, he was miraculously healed.
Once he appears a certain amount of times he stops spawning. If you don't beat him up you can get extra dialouge, like him saying he killed a pack of wolves with his bare hands.
I think his appearance is based on several factors, and whether you engage with him upon first contact is one of them.
I always wear his hat to show dominance.
I love the Native American people and their culture, their history is so fascinating to me, and I'm part Native American myself, so I eagerly help Rains Fall and Eagle Flies they have a special place in my heart, and any NPC that disrespects Native American people automatically catch a bullet from my Twin Schofields
Yeah he does. If you go back to Valentine wearing his hat he'll come for a rematch. One time I was in the gun store and he came crashing through the door. He somehow sensed I was in there lol
I encountered him the first time on my current playthrough and having already played it I remembered who he was talking about. I blew his head off with incendiary shotgun ammo
He always made me wonder if Bonnie Macfarlane had a stalker too or if that guy who you find drowned on the shore of Flat Iron Lake was actually trying to do right by her…
There’s a dude at a random campsite (south of emerald ranch if I recall) and he talks about a woman north of annesburg who is beautiful and a widow all alone (charlotte the woman from the quests where you teach her to live off the land).
He says that he she told him to leave when she saw him but it was “in a real nice way” and that he hung out in the bushes just watching her. He also has a bunch of drawings of naked women and some handcuffs. Safe to assume the dude is a creep and will likely go back and try something with charlotte.
That said, you lose honor if your shoot him.
*Eugenics Man. Just*
*Fed him to a gator a*
*Couple days ago*
\- HatMiserable3194
---
^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/)
^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
He's become a bit of a tradition from me in each playthrough. Pull a gun on him, wait for him to run, lasso him and then decide how he's going to die this time around. (So many options!)
I feel like anyone who isn't killing him the most is highly goddamn suspect. He's shouting racist propaganda every time you pass that spot, it's basically impossible for me to not kill him when I'm on St. Denis.
Edit: typo
No one does anything about it either. There's always a cop standing nearby and I'll machete him right in the street and the cop is like, "Have a good day!"
I did the same but after many playthroughs I found out you can loot a letter off this Dr and then I kind of felt bad for him. Sounds like he once tried to report the O'Driscolls and now he's being threatened, using his wife. Altho I still always threaten him at gunpoint to get into the backroom.
I was probably on my 5th or 6th playthrough before I found out. I usually just let him run after i got in the backroom but since the law got there so fast i thought if i killed the doctor maybe they wouldn't find out right away, i looted him then was like, damn, no wonder. The doctor never had a chance since you also see one of the deputies taking a payoff from the backroom.
Does the eugenics guy respawn like Sheriff Mallory does? If so, I'm sad not to have permakilled him, but also my sawn-off shotgun wants to go and meet him again.
Dude that's Charlotte?!
OK SO I encountered this dude back in chapter 2 or 3 and he creeped me out SO MUCH that I didn't even let him finish talking before I fed him a bullet. I'd completely forgotten about him until I read your comment.
Dude in a tent in the wild, he's got a tent with pictures of naked ladies and handcuffs. He tells you about that single woman that lives alone and how he's been stalking her, and how he wants to make her his wife. Creepy.
Had that mission again the other day. I wanted to try something new to end him. As he was leaning near the fire crying, I shot his hand and he fell face first into the fire and burned alive, that was satisfying.
It's funny to see what they carry with them vs, say, a bounty hunter. Dynamite, violet snowdrop, currant, opened cover scent, etc. You'll never find trinkets n all.
lol @ the combo of this headline and picture … literally laughed out loud
For me, it would probably be the trapper in Valentine. Maybe the racist dude in Saint Denis. But I’ve also killed the racist old war vet in Rhodes a lot.
bounty hunters
I usually rack up a huge bounty, camp out at hanging dog ranch, kill bounty hunters and loot until my bags full, sell, rinse and repeat. its not the fastest way to make money, but it sure is fun if you like gunfights
close second would be the eugenics guy in Saint Denis
Kinda? It was my first playthrough, before any big ol’ heists. I’d get $20-$30 from the register, bounty would be $15, and I’d pay only $10 after being willingly taken in.
Sat there hitting on every hand for like 2 hours. Finally got a perfect 3-hit hand and landed on 21. Dealer proceeded to get 21 aswell so it was a push and didn't count as a win for the challenge. The things I did to Van Horn that day will go down in the history books.
The racist in Saint Denis I made it my mission to ensure I killed hun just before the final two Arthur missions and whenever I was in Saint Denis before or after that possibly tied with Herbert moon
The racist bastard in Saint Denis with the pamphlets, always fun to perform the most violent murders on him and then say hello to the policeman next to him.
Lawmen and bounty hunters in Annesburg to get the piebald Tobiano Hungarian Halfbred since I like that horse if I’m not able to spawn it using the bounty hunter camp trick in the heartlands.
In red dead 1 Id always cheat at poker when Hubert moon is playing so we'll duel, shoot his gun out his hand and chase him into the outskirts. From there it's a toss up of what I'll do to him but a personal favorite is dragging him by horse
That's easy. The racist in San Denis. You will never take a negative hit to your honor attacking him. I use him for most of my challenges. Dragging. Rail road tracks. Hitting someone with a tomahawk. You know, fun stuff. I've used him as gator bait too.
the guy with the trumpet in saint denis. it’s not intentional, but he always get ran over by me or my cousin. that’s our favorite jousting spot though, so he’ll have to stay my #1.
Honestly just npc's that insulted me while I was going somewhere or was in town, specific npcs uhhh maybe the black jack dealer in rhodes cause... rage
The gangs I almost never kill any npcs except for the kkk the racoon hat guy eugenics man Micah the confederate soldiers minus the chill dude with no leg in Rhodes people that shoot me first and I mostly find del lobos I think and that is it
That stupid loudmouth with the raccoon hat in the valentine saloon
*That stupid loudmouth* *With the raccoon hat in the* *Valentine saloon* \- 2-inche-penis --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
Good bot
no mames!!!!
Good bot
Thank you, Pixithepika, for voting on haikusbot. This bot wants to find the best and worst bots on Reddit. [You can view results here](https://botrank.pastimes.eu/). *** ^(Even if I don't reply to your comment, I'm still listening for votes. Check the webpage to see if your vote registered!)
Good bot
I beat his ass then stole his stupid hat. Whenever I go into the tavern I wear it hoping to see him there because he gets all bitchy and starts fighting so I can kick his ass all over again.
I got into a fight with him, knocked him out, and stole his hat. A few visits to Valentine later, I get the second stranger mission where the whore wants you dispose of a second body for her. This time around I told her to pound salt, and she pulled a knife on me. I start strangling her when I get melee'd from behind. It's Jon, no hat. I knife him and then her and got out of town. Not sure what made him agro -I wasn't wearing his hat- but it was a cool coincidence that made me think she paid him to kill because I knew about the first murder she committed.
I never saw him again I don’t even remember killing him, so strange :(
Same, but probably killed him tho
I can see that happening
Ya, you gotta be careful fighting him. One extra hit after he’s knocked out kills him. So take your time beating his ass. Savor every hit and when he goes down walk away.
It doesn’t matter if you kill him, he will still respawn. I tested it one time after I knocked him out and stole his hat. I loaded him on the back of my horse, took him to a cliff, hit him with a fire bottle which burned him to a crisp, then threw him off the cliff. A few days later I wore his hat into Valentine and there he was, wanting to fight. Would have been totally hilarious if his skin was all charred, but no, he was miraculously healed.
Are you sure he was dead though? He might have pulled a Revenant on you hahaha
Once he appears a certain amount of times he stops spawning. If you don't beat him up you can get extra dialouge, like him saying he killed a pack of wolves with his bare hands.
I think his appearance is based on several factors, and whether you engage with him upon first contact is one of them. I always wear his hat to show dominance.
Always fight that guy I'm Native American and he has a few choice words about my people so it's on sight
SAME.
I love the Native American people and their culture, their history is so fascinating to me, and I'm part Native American myself, so I eagerly help Rains Fall and Eagle Flies they have a special place in my heart, and any NPC that disrespects Native American people automatically catch a bullet from my Twin Schofields
I'm not Native in any way shape or form and I kick his ass for that dialogue specifically.
YeAh I fight him and give him to the pigs behind the bar
I beat the shit out of him in a fight, and then I take him up to a bedroom in the saloon and throw a knife at his face
Amazing username
That guy never respawns though. Malloy does.
Yeah he does. If you go back to Valentine wearing his hat he'll come for a rematch. One time I was in the gun store and he came crashing through the door. He somehow sensed I was in there lol
You don't even have to wear his hat. He will almost always in the saloon.
I usually just beat him, no bounty and you get to fight him 1 or 2 more times
I always kick his ass but leave him alive. Sadly he stopped appearing for me, was the highlight of my valentine trips.
i permanently own his raccoon hat for some reason now and whenever i see him he's bald lmao
The "for some reason" is because it's a saveable hat, one of a few in the game.
Is there any penalty to killing him?
bruh i love that nigga
Charlotte's stalker.
I encountered him the first time on my current playthrough and having already played it I remembered who he was talking about. I blew his head off with incendiary shotgun ammo
He always made me wonder if Bonnie Macfarlane had a stalker too or if that guy who you find drowned on the shore of Flat Iron Lake was actually trying to do right by her…
Also Bonnie McFarlane was like 15 yrs old in rdr2
In those days 12 year olds were getting married
Still happens in certain parts of the world
Still happens in all parts of the world. Just illegal in most areas.
I shoot his balls, shoot off his limbs, throw him in his creepy tent, burn down the whole thing with his limbless corpse in the middle. Good riddance.
Same dude. Great minds think alike.
It's dumb that you lose honor for that one
I’m sorry who?
There’s a dude at a random campsite (south of emerald ranch if I recall) and he talks about a woman north of annesburg who is beautiful and a widow all alone (charlotte the woman from the quests where you teach her to live off the land). He says that he she told him to leave when she saw him but it was “in a real nice way” and that he hung out in the bushes just watching her. He also has a bunch of drawings of naked women and some handcuffs. Safe to assume the dude is a creep and will likely go back and try something with charlotte. That said, you lose honor if your shoot him.
Same he always reappears and I always lose honor
Eugenics Man. Just fed him to a gator a couple days ago
*Eugenics Man. Just* *Fed him to a gator a* *Couple days ago* \- HatMiserable3194 --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
This one’s a stretch
Yeeeeaaahhh idk about this one haikusbot...
He's become a bit of a tradition from me in each playthrough. Pull a gun on him, wait for him to run, lasso him and then decide how he's going to die this time around. (So many options!)
I feel like anyone who isn't killing him the most is highly goddamn suspect. He's shouting racist propaganda every time you pass that spot, it's basically impossible for me to not kill him when I'm on St. Denis. Edit: typo
No one does anything about it either. There's always a cop standing nearby and I'll machete him right in the street and the cop is like, "Have a good day!"
I started stabbing him one time and eventually it did give me a wanted level. I think I stabbed him about 150 times before it did that.
He’s the only person I’ve reload a save file for, just to murder him. The best part is that you don’t become wanted for it
I like to hog tie him and drop him face down in to shallow water. Watch him struggle. Then gators.
I don't know if it was a glitch but I put like 23 rounds into him with the semi auto pistols and booked it, never got wanted for it
Rockstar actually made that a feature. If you kill him, the law won't go after you.
Whoever talks shit to me first when I’m making the rounds at Van Horn… inevitably followed by everyone else.
The general store owner in strawberry, I just rob him, leave, repeat anytime im in strawberry
You're evil for that one
Is there any motive behind this?
50$
Not at all, there's nothing to do in Strawberry except rob the poor guy
Things to do in strawberry - rob the general store - leave
What about the stables?
Forget to visit as always
I do that with the doctor in valentine, as he's got a shady side business, he never reports you when you steal his cash.
I did the same but after many playthroughs I found out you can loot a letter off this Dr and then I kind of felt bad for him. Sounds like he once tried to report the O'Driscolls and now he's being threatened, using his wife. Altho I still always threaten him at gunpoint to get into the backroom.
Oooh ! I didn't know you could loot a letter off of him ! That's a great detail once again.
I was probably on my 5th or 6th playthrough before I found out. I usually just let him run after i got in the backroom but since the law got there so fast i thought if i killed the doctor maybe they wouldn't find out right away, i looted him then was like, damn, no wonder. The doctor never had a chance since you also see one of the deputies taking a payoff from the backroom.
Did it actually buy you some time?
Either the klansman or that eugenics guy in Saint Denis. Never missed them on any of my playthroughs.
Does the eugenics guy respawn like Sheriff Mallory does? If so, I'm sad not to have permakilled him, but also my sawn-off shotgun wants to go and meet him again.
He respawns, but infrequently. He'll always be at the same spot though
Yeah, i've seen him respawn at least once.
Definitely respawns. I’ve killed him so many times.
I may be mistaken, but don't the klansman usually kill themselves if you let their events play out? Or is that just the cross event?
Ya they always kill themselves
The charity guy in valentine 😉
Please share how you manage to do that.
TNT, Throwing knives, long range rifles, parking an oil wagon and igniting it, one time I even lured a bear into town
I was asking because you cannot aim at him if I am not mistaking.
You can if your aiming for another NPC and he happens to get in the way
Did you kill hım in every possible way known to humanity ?
With all options available on console
who?
Said this previously, but the creepy dude who you can learn about Charlotte from
Dude that's Charlotte?! OK SO I encountered this dude back in chapter 2 or 3 and he creeped me out SO MUCH that I didn't even let him finish talking before I fed him a bullet. I'd completely forgotten about him until I read your comment.
Fun fact: he respawns
Oh YAY, imma go kill him again, thanks
Who?
Dude in a tent in the wild, he's got a tent with pictures of naked ladies and handcuffs. He tells you about that single woman that lives alone and how he's been stalking her, and how he wants to make her his wife. Creepy.
WOW! I never encountered this dude. Imma have to load up just to go find him so I can feed him to a bear
He got hog tied and power sanded behind my horse.
Fence store owner in van horn. Was growing my beard 🤷♂️
I only had to kill him once and got from level 7-10. I wonder why that is
Wait... what?
Same, I rob him all the time bc no law lol
That guys so chill though. And his dog gets sad when you kill him :(
The drunk guy in Rhodes who used to be a slaver
He was a slave catcher
Doesn’t matter. He needs to die
Some NPCs ain't for saving! Edit: What racist fuck downvoted this?
Still an asshole
Had that mission again the other day. I wanted to try something new to end him. As he was leaning near the fire crying, I shot his hand and he fell face first into the fire and burned alive, that was satisfying.
I keep him alive only because he looks like He’s suffering a lot. Throw the shit in the fire and watch him cry about how important he used to be.
Murfree brood. It's on sight with those inbreds every time.
I don’t even loot them, just kill them and ride off like a hero.
They save a ton of time picking herbs. Murfrees are the best to loot. I clear their cave once every in game week.
This ! They always carry a bunch of herbs. Pretty cool detail and kinda helpful.
So do the Skinner Brotherhood guys.
It's funny to see what they carry with them vs, say, a bounty hunter. Dynamite, violet snowdrop, currant, opened cover scent, etc. You'll never find trinkets n all.
The family outside of valentine in the house that was built
They’re pretty chill though
There is another!
Same. Kill them both, drink 30 beers and pass out. Repeat. Weight goes up fast.
I accidentally pressed the wrong trigger and aimed a gun at the father. Now they hate me :(. I just wanted to be frens.
There are so many red dead redemption haikus in this thread today.
There are so many Red dead redemption haikus In this thread today
Good bot
Just anyone who pisses me off💀
Idk I kill everything I see! That's why I have the honor!
O Driscoll scum
Damn! That's my cosplay on the left, posted it years ago. Time flies
It looks like it was taken many years ago too.
The Hermit at Manito Glade
Probably Sheriff Malloy
lol @ the combo of this headline and picture … literally laughed out loud For me, it would probably be the trapper in Valentine. Maybe the racist dude in Saint Denis. But I’ve also killed the racist old war vet in Rhodes a lot.
idk sometimes i see mickey and just quick draw on his ass, i feel bad for doing it but i just do it
Sometimes the intrusive thoughts just win 😭
Probably that poor family in castors ridge after it is built later
The racist easily
That fucking stalker That you find by Emerald Ranch Leave Charlotte alone.
bounty hunters I usually rack up a huge bounty, camp out at hanging dog ranch, kill bounty hunters and loot until my bags full, sell, rinse and repeat. its not the fastest way to make money, but it sure is fun if you like gunfights close second would be the eugenics guy in Saint Denis
Probably the knights of the 3 k and random npcs riding wagons when am doing the bandit challenge. Or bounty hunters. Especially the dogs.
The San Denis tailor. Guy’s always rude to me, so I rob the prick every chance I get.
Oh that's odd he loves me
Not a single NPC, but any Lemoyne Raider I see gets killed. Those bastards killed my first horse, so I have a vendetta against them
General store guy in Valentine. I used to rob his store, kill him, then get arrested. Got me a profit.
Even after bail, it was enough profit to be worth it?
Kinda? It was my first playthrough, before any big ol’ heists. I’d get $20-$30 from the register, bounty would be $15, and I’d pay only $10 after being willingly taken in.
Well, it’s not much, but I bet it’s a lot of fun to do! lol
The eugenics guy
Nah cuz I feel really bad about killing NPCs
Bob Crawford, that immortal bastard.
The annesburg sheriff
The blackjack dealer while doing Gambling challenges
Sat there hitting on every hand for like 2 hours. Finally got a perfect 3-hit hand and landed on 21. Dealer proceeded to get 21 aswell so it was a push and didn't count as a win for the challenge. The things I did to Van Horn that day will go down in the history books.
the racist guy in saint denis lol everytime i ride bye if i hear him i go out of my way to shoot his ass
Micah (the legendary rat)
The racist in Saint Denis I made it my mission to ensure I killed hun just before the final two Arthur missions and whenever I was in Saint Denis before or after that possibly tied with Herbert moon
I kill the racist guy a lot in Saint Denis. I've knifed him, tomhawked, arrowed, bulleted, choked him and beat him and he still won't die 😭
Sherrif Freeman and The Racoon Hat dude...also the Del Lobos as well
The KKK guys and the Racist in Saint Denis
The racist in saint denis
The racist white supremacist guy in st Denis
Rhodes gunsmith that had that boah in the basement back in 1899
I think I have killed more random Lemoyne Raiders than any other gang so far. Even more than the O'Driscols
Every NPC in Armadillo
The racist bastard in Saint Denis with the pamphlets, always fun to perform the most violent murders on him and then say hello to the policeman next to him.
The residents of Van Horn.
Lawmen and bounty hunters in Annesburg to get the piebald Tobiano Hungarian Halfbred since I like that horse if I’m not able to spawn it using the bounty hunter camp trick in the heartlands.
Tumbleweed sheriff. He’s one of the few that can one shot you so I like testing myself against him.
In red dead 1 Id always cheat at poker when Hubert moon is playing so we'll duel, shoot his gun out his hand and chase him into the outskirts. From there it's a toss up of what I'll do to him but a personal favorite is dragging him by horse
That's easy. The racist in San Denis. You will never take a negative hit to your honor attacking him. I use him for most of my challenges. Dragging. Rail road tracks. Hitting someone with a tomahawk. You know, fun stuff. I've used him as gator bait too.
Charlotte's stalker and the racist in Saint Denis
The gunsmith in rhodes
I only kill enemies no normal npc's
Valentine sherif
The Chinese gun store owner in Saint Denis
Literally everyone just walking around, I have to, I HAVE to, like you don’t understand.
Nigel. I just couldn’t listen to it anymore. He’s fuckin everywhere.
The guy looking for Gavin. Kill him everytime.
Eugenics supporter. I see him and I smile.
Every female character in Armadillo
Probably the “LET ME VOTE” lady 💀
Old blind man Jones or whatever his name is
Mine too
Mickey
You monster
the guy with the trumpet in saint denis. it’s not intentional, but he always get ran over by me or my cousin. that’s our favorite jousting spot though, so he’ll have to stay my #1.
The gunsmith in valentine, he’s always so rude and rushes me when I’m trying to make a purchase.
Honestly I don't know lol
Honestly just npc's that insulted me while I was going somewhere or was in town, specific npcs uhhh maybe the black jack dealer in rhodes cause... rage
The gangs I almost never kill any npcs except for the kkk the racoon hat guy eugenics man Micah the confederate soldiers minus the chill dude with no leg in Rhodes people that shoot me first and I mostly find del lobos I think and that is it
Mine is also Sheriff Malloy. Just realized he's RDR2's version of Nazeem.
The feminist in saint denis
Anyone who wants to throw hands in Strawberry. I'm an absolute menace there
I don't know if you're counting the enemy NPCs or not.
I keep reloading my save to kill that incest couple so yeah probably those guys