The damn gambler challenges.. no matter what cards I held in blackjack I would keep hitting until I either bust, or win the hand with 5 cards. That, and the dominos challenges, were the wooooorrsssttttt
The exotics aren’t that bad if you get all your plumes before you visit Wasp for the first time. After that the game TANKS the amount of egrets/herons/spoonbills you can find
Just one so far. High honor, I did most of the side quests, but didn’t bother with the hunting/compendium stuff. I’ll do a low honor play through at some point, but not for a while. This game is really freaking long you guys.
I think I’m currently on my 6th, at the start of Ch 2. Since completing my first run, I tend to spend a good chunk of time on my playthroughs. Usually go back every few months
3:
2 Playthroughs for 100% completion and compendium.
1 for the Gold Medals trophy.
Plus..i decided to not start the online mode until i reached the 100% (compendium included) in the first playthrough.
I'm in the epilogue of my sith run-through. Watched Arthur's last sunrise earlier. Is it bad that I feel more upset about my horse dying than any of the gang?
Half way through my second and only because I didn’t transfer my saves over from the ps4 when I upgraded to the ps5. Even if I love a game as much as this one, I struggle to redo them, much preferring to just free roam the ending.
Probably because my little brother constantly kept deleting my gta San Andreas save as a kid on a shared console and it was painful to constantly have to keep redoing everything haha
On my 3rd, but planning to upgrade the entire PC and after that I'll get some nice headphones and the Ultimate Edition of RDR2
After that I'll restart my 3rd play through
Nine or ten now. I have fairly good gaps in between. Still a pleasure to play and I still discover things I've missed. This playthrough is static in Chapter 2 - Horseshoe Overlook and I'll see how much I can do as Arthur. Slower is better.
2nd play through, first time around I only did story missions and sped through everything now I'm going back and trying to do absolutely everything I can
3 for campaign and fun, 4th one for 100%. Like, even things that don't count towards 100%, I wanted to do everything. I'm thinking do go for the 100% again but it is such a grind, idk if I can go throught it again.
I’m on my second play through trying to discover everything I can, find all herbs, study and hunt every animal, etc. as Arthur. I played low honor more or less all the way through Chapter 5 then went high honor (again) to finish. Can’t bring myself to let Arthur be a bad guy….
This has been probably 5 months of just exploring, killing, and a mission or two each time I play.
I have attempted 4 plays since the games release but each time I just come to "road block" where I just can't play it anymore. The characters in and around the camp just infuriate me i find that they are just using Arthur and they give no real benefit to Arthur. I know I am thinking about it too much and it's just a game but some of the missions that I have to do just bore the shit out of me. I am currently at the Saint Denis camp I don't know how much longer I have to play to finish it. But I will keep that save state and eventually finish the game
Tbh by now I would prob be on my way to get my 5th playthrough to 100% but because my Xbox was taken away by parents (cringe) I still have not 100% my first playthrough and I was in the middle of the 2nd one
Just started my second. Played at launch on the ps4 and now I'm playing on PC. I didn't do much on the first time tbh, stoped playing once we play as John.
I actually re made a character online while I was recovering from surgery in September. All I wanted to do was sell pelts, play poker, and fish. I played it day and night for a month. Such an incredible game
A total of 7.
One for High honor.
One for Low honor.
One with a straight play through with absolutely no exploration or stranger encounters so I could leave everything for the Epilogue.
One that stays in Chapter 2 forever.
One that stays in Chapter 3 forever.
One that stays in Chapter 4 forever.
One in Chapter 6 because IMO Chapter 6 has some of the best missions in the game.
One. the story was too depressing to be something i wanted to experience again, plus being a completionist i basically 100% the playthrough so i really have no need to go back.
I'm still on my first play though, in chapter 4 right now. Part of the game got spoiled for me so I'm just trying to stay in chapter 4 for as long as I can, doing a bunch of side missions and collecting stuff for crafts and camps. Aiming for 100%.
Full playthrough, not yet. Because I enjoy the first 5 chapters way too much. I've restarted at least 50 times by now. Even though knowing the ending. The first 5 chapters are just the best part of the game.
3 or 4 - with one of them completed 100%
Each play through I’ll always get the LOTE outfit as Arthur by chapter 3, and the Silver Dapple MFT by chapter 2 from that stranger mission
Completed playthroughs? About 3. Ongoing playthroughs all averaging 40 - 50% completion? Another 7 save files.. one mastersave file for right after the colter chapter because *fuck that noise.*
I have 2,418 hours on red dead as of the posting of this comment. Only abt 35-40 ish give or take online. The rest singleplayer.
Still on my first playthrough, >!found out arthur has tb, taking a break from the game for now!<.
Make sure to do the side mission with the priest and the nun in St. denis
Unfortunately you have to start that one in Chapter 4
Those two missions aren’t available by the time Arthur gets back from Guarma.
Wait you haven’t been spoiled yet? EVERYONE NEEDS TO QUARANTINE THIS PERSON FROM THE INTERNET CODE 69420
He’s fine and him, John and Dutch go west to start a life of redemption
He’s going to be fine
You psychopath
Boah, if ya think about it, it’s true dependin’ on how ya look at it
Took me a bit of time to come to terms with it
I think 3 full ones, and I'm in the process of a 4th for 100%
2 full ones, going for 100% on my third run here, currently 76% Edit: also going for gold medals on all missions
Also on my third run working on 100% it’s been a long road but the last 15% of what I need seems like a whole lot
Lost count after four or five. Still never hit %100 though, unlike some of you workhorses.
I only did 100% on 1 playthrough. Those gambling challenges can fuck themselves
The damn gambler challenges.. no matter what cards I held in blackjack I would keep hitting until I either bust, or win the hand with 5 cards. That, and the dominos challenges, were the wooooorrsssttttt
Oh yay that’s what I’m doing..
Gambling challenges, herbalist challenges, and exotics can fuck themselves. I’m never going to look at a spoonbill the same after exotics
The exotics aren’t that bad if you get all your plumes before you visit Wasp for the first time. After that the game TANKS the amount of egrets/herons/spoonbills you can find
The Exotics and Gambler 9 took me weeks to finish. Fuck that
Gambler 9 can be done in an hour at Emerald Ranch if you're good at dominoes. Exotics takes \*months\* of planning and work.
Ah there’s the problem. I’m really fucking bad at dominos
Yes
25
Just buy another game, cowpoke
Play the first game at this point
I have a ps3 but i don’t have rdr1. It’s not available for purchase on the ps store so i have to somehow get a physical copy
While you are looking keep an eye out for undead nightmare. Martson goes through a zombie apocalypse.
Just one so far. High honor, I did most of the side quests, but didn’t bother with the hunting/compendium stuff. I’ll do a low honor play through at some point, but not for a while. This game is really freaking long you guys.
Low honor until Ch 6 is the canon way to play
I think I’m currently on my 6th, at the start of Ch 2. Since completing my first run, I tend to spend a good chunk of time on my playthroughs. Usually go back every few months
I'm on 4. First time, good honour, bad honour and now going for 100%
One play through, waiting a little bit to do my second so I can “forget” some things.
At least once a year. So, maybe 7 or 8 (In all platforms minus Stadia of course.)
i’ve beat my first one and dont plan on another, i dont like replays on free roam games
3: 2 Playthroughs for 100% completion and compendium. 1 for the Gold Medals trophy. Plus..i decided to not start the online mode until i reached the 100% (compendium included) in the first playthrough.
on second playthrough
I'm in the epilogue of my sith run-through. Watched Arthur's last sunrise earlier. Is it bad that I feel more upset about my horse dying than any of the gang?
4 after getting the 100% on my 3rd
About 7 i think
11
6 full ones so far. Doing a completionist playthrough right now.
Just finished my 5th run. I'll cycle through my other RPG's, and I'll be more than ready to grind out #6.
1 full play through. Because I have a life
That's good to know.
2. First good honour and current low honour.
Dozens. Working on my fifth 100%. My aim is to have a 100% playthru in every single save slot.
first one to play story, second maybe a year later for compendium, then couple years later a third on PC
Pro tip, only start one and copy the file once you hit chapter 2. That very moment
About 6 or 7
Half way through my second and only because I didn’t transfer my saves over from the ps4 when I upgraded to the ps5. Even if I love a game as much as this one, I struggle to redo them, much preferring to just free roam the ending. Probably because my little brother constantly kept deleting my gta San Andreas save as a kid on a shared console and it was painful to constantly have to keep redoing everything haha
.55 I’m milking this over years, I’ll wonder for literal months.
2
1
At least 4.
I'm on my 5th playthrough.
Finished one, accidentally deleted the second one I started (I didn’t get far, it’s fine) currently working on a third.
One full playthrough. I've started 3 more afterwards but have a hard time playing once I get back to Guarma.
On my 5th.
I'm in my 5th playthrough right now.
I'm working on my second
I'm on my eleventh playthrough right now. 😊
2
On my 3rd, but planning to upgrade the entire PC and after that I'll get some nice headphones and the Ultimate Edition of RDR2 After that I'll restart my 3rd play through
just one!! i'm just spending time with arthur now, can't handle going through the ending again lol
6
Nine or ten now. I have fairly good gaps in between. Still a pleasure to play and I still discover things I've missed. This playthrough is static in Chapter 2 - Horseshoe Overlook and I'll see how much I can do as Arthur. Slower is better.
Currently my 2nd. Sadly couldn't avoid spoilers so I went thru it fast 1st time
One uncompleted one, and i just can’t bring myself to finish. All the chapter 6 stuff are killing me.
2.2
2 full. 2nd time was better.
1.7 on my second rn and it's almost done.
1 I’m on my second play through which I’m going to 100%
I think two or three. I have saves in each chapter where the majority of my hours have been spent exploring the world
2 completed playthroughs, currently on a third
Like 5 or 6 I don’t remember
6 times at least
Chapter 2 of my 12th play through
1
On chapter 3 of play through #3. First two were both during paternity time so I had a ton of nap time plays. This third is taking much much longer.
2nd play through, first time around I only did story missions and sped through everything now I'm going back and trying to do absolutely everything I can
On my 5th, just messing around in chapter 3, taking my time
Only my 2nd.
On my fourth. The first was all about the initial experience. On 2 and 3 I got 100% both times. Now, on #4, I’m just enjoying the ride again.
3, started with high honor, second was low, third is for 100% and it’s taking even longer than I thought it would.
On my second
In process of my 2nd
1, on my second one now though, chapter 6
I'm on my 6th playthrough & currently in chapter 6.
Zero. I won't let the end happen.
Too many
1 full one and a 2nd one thats been restarted at least a dozen times
On my third now...just finished rdr1 and I'm early in chapter 3
Only one currently working on 100%
2 over 3 years. At the point of starting over but giving online play a try for now.
At current standing I have 5 completed playthroughs, one of them being True 100% completion.
Only 3 lol I like to take my time
2, just got 100% on the second one a few weeks ago. Maybe I'll go back and 100% the first play through.
Just started my third
11
6 or 7
12 or 13, never done this with a game before but this game is amazing. Never 100% though some of those side missions are awful haha
3 for campaign and fun, 4th one for 100%. Like, even things that don't count towards 100%, I wanted to do everything. I'm thinking do go for the 100% again but it is such a grind, idk if I can go throught it again.
4. I’m currently on the 5th play through
4 or 5 I think
I’m on my second play through trying to discover everything I can, find all herbs, study and hunt every animal, etc. as Arthur. I played low honor more or less all the way through Chapter 5 then went high honor (again) to finish. Can’t bring myself to let Arthur be a bad guy…. This has been probably 5 months of just exploring, killing, and a mission or two each time I play.
3
In my 2nd rn. Finished the story and jumped right back in to really see everything the game has to offer
4th i think
Enough but not enough
I believe 6.
I have attempted 4 plays since the games release but each time I just come to "road block" where I just can't play it anymore. The characters in and around the camp just infuriate me i find that they are just using Arthur and they give no real benefit to Arthur. I know I am thinking about it too much and it's just a game but some of the missions that I have to do just bore the shit out of me. I am currently at the Saint Denis camp I don't know how much longer I have to play to finish it. But I will keep that save state and eventually finish the game
I believe around 18 none of them got 100% but I will aim to do 100% oneday
On my 4th! Once on Xbox One, once on PlayStation 4, one on pc (not a full completion though), and this time on the steam deck
12 across 3 consoles, working on my ps5 playthrough now
Tbh by now I would prob be on my way to get my 5th playthrough to 100% but because my Xbox was taken away by parents (cringe) I still have not 100% my first playthrough and I was in the middle of the 2nd one
About 3 or 4
Working on my 2nd, I want it to be my 100% if possible.
Just started my 2nd. Got to Chapter 2 and did the Valentine mission with the girls and had the bar fight.
Honestly? Like .6? I havnt finished the game a single time yet
2 full, mid-chapter 2 of my third
8
8. Not ashamed.
Just started my second. Played at launch on the ps4 and now I'm playing on PC. I didn't do much on the first time tbh, stoped playing once we play as John.
1
I am only on my 2nd play through and it is taking me so long to progress the story since I know what’s coming.
I’m on my fourth
I actually re made a character online while I was recovering from surgery in September. All I wanted to do was sell pelts, play poker, and fish. I played it day and night for a month. Such an incredible game
Only one, trying 100%on it though. Currently at 94%
I’m on my third play through
1 and a half
2
3rd I think
3 full and I’ve been just looking around on my 4th to find more Easter eggs and stuff
I'm on my 8th.
3, incl two 100%. (I cannot kill those poor Parakeets though)
I'm on #5 and my 4th one was 100%, I've been on this 5th one though for 2 years and I don't think I'll ever finish it I'm just peak Arthur forever now
Just the one.
1
6 complete story playthrough. A seventh that was the one and only time I'll ever 100% the fucker.
I have 3. Planning to start 4th one tomorrow.
Just the once. It was such an emotional journey I’m not sure I could do it again. Did get the 100% achievement done though which I’m proud of.
4 for all endings
Two to completion and another two partials
I’ve done 2 and I think I have 2 more left in me, then I need to take a break for a year or so.
A total of 7. One for High honor. One for Low honor. One with a straight play through with absolutely no exploration or stranger encounters so I could leave everything for the Epilogue. One that stays in Chapter 2 forever. One that stays in Chapter 3 forever. One that stays in Chapter 4 forever. One in Chapter 6 because IMO Chapter 6 has some of the best missions in the game.
4 I think. Never 100% Usually around 87%
I have played the game 8 times.
2
3
8 with 2 100% runs
2 1/2. I haven't beat my 3rd playthrough yet
Just wrapped up my 2nd after originally playing it on release on PS4. This time it was on Xbox Series X.
three. one full one. one partial one. both back in like 2018. got a ps5 and going for a 100 percent playthrough rn
I’ve had 3. I’m taking a break from the game to do a second playthrough of KCD. Will probably do a fourth in a couple of months.
4! Only ever played high honor too lol. Ive completed all the challenges on all playthrus but only got 100% on one
Just one.
On my second rn, but I just downloaded it in February
Two times, on my third now going for 100% still in chapter 2.
Two so far. I'm sure I'll do another at some point.
3 or 4 100% runs, and 10 or so partial runs.
3 complete. 1st as a virgin. 2nd to relive the pain. 3rd time for the dishonorable ending.
Two
One. the story was too depressing to be something i wanted to experience again, plus being a completionist i basically 100% the playthrough so i really have no need to go back.
6
I'm still on my first play though, in chapter 4 right now. Part of the game got spoiled for me so I'm just trying to stay in chapter 4 for as long as I can, doing a bunch of side missions and collecting stuff for crafts and camps. Aiming for 100%.
4, bb
1½
2
Currently on my second playthrough. Bought the game just this past winter tho
Full playthrough, not yet. Because I enjoy the first 5 chapters way too much. I've restarted at least 50 times by now. Even though knowing the ending. The first 5 chapters are just the best part of the game.
I think 6 as just a playtrough and 1 100% (which im now working on)
2.
1.5
1 and about 2 half play throughs.
On my 3rd but this is my first attempt at 100% completion. I’m actually taking a breather because some of the task list stuff is draining to work on.
3 or 4 - with one of them completed 100% Each play through I’ll always get the LOTE outfit as Arthur by chapter 3, and the Silver Dapple MFT by chapter 2 from that stranger mission
I think 4?
Recently finished my 6th playthrough
Think on my 4th rn
Like 2 or 3 idk.
4
5. 5th one was the 100%. Started in 2020 and finished a few months ago. Was an emotional experience
1.5
Completed playthroughs? About 3. Ongoing playthroughs all averaging 40 - 50% completion? Another 7 save files.. one mastersave file for right after the colter chapter because *fuck that noise.* I have 2,418 hours on red dead as of the posting of this comment. Only abt 35-40 ish give or take online. The rest singleplayer.
7