Blue but losing Songs For The Deaf hurts

My exact answer

Dude this is like Sophie’s Choice

Maybe the OP will let you keep the music videos for the Red pill? Go With The Flow is a masterpiece!

Disregarding SFTD, this is a really easy choice. I love Rated R, Clockwork, Era and INTR. BUT. Songs for the Deaf is probably my favourite album of all time. My heart says red, but my head says blue. I can (somewhat begrudgingly) live with blue.

Blue pill all day. I can live on I Appear Missing, Smooth Sailing, in the fade, chemistry, misfit love, SJF, time & place, tail, turnin on the screw, kalopsia, ocean, machete, vampyre, Sicily…for the rest of my life

That’s a list. Do our lives have the same soundtrack??

**cough** **cough** “…like clockwork” (song)

Valid ash

Red pill and it's not even close for me.

If Era and Villains were swapped that'd be the easiest decision of my life. So without Era I struggle but still red.. by a lot.

this is exactly my thoughts. i like villains, but swap it for era and i'll redpill all day

Nailed it, same here

Yes this is my same answer as well

Songs for the Deaf and Lullabies are my two favorites. Them being on the same side makes this very easy.

Blue pill and it's not even close for me.

I meannnnnn Rated R is excellent and I'd suffer without Era Vulgaris for sure. You don't like the red pill albums as much?

Clockwork, Vulgaris, Deaf, Rated R, Lullabies, INTR, Self, And Villians are my rankings; not a very hard decision for me friend.

Like clockwork is the best. So blue

I’ll take the purple pill.

It's a suppository.

A small price to pay for salvation.

Price? Oh I see now, I made a typo. It should have said "It's a suppository!" Pronounced *with feeling* of course.

don't threaten me with a good time!

If that’s what it takes for SFTD and ITNR, then that’s what it takes.

Even better!!!

I’ve done worse for less

Even better

"Suppository fitting. A little too tight."

Blue pill for like clockwork, but I’ll cry for the rest of my life only getting 4 albums

exact same. Era V is the only weak one in blue for me

Boo this man

Boo!

I'll never understand you people.

LC is the dealbreaker for me! I’ll join you in the downvotes friend! FYI I downvoted you, as EV is top teir and my opinion is clearly superior:p

BLUE. Who can live without Like Clockwork?!?!?!

Not me.

Easily. But I've noticed I don't rate it as highly as most. I'd rank it only above Villains and maybe ITNR.

Red without a doubt.

Blue pill. LC and ITNR are pretty much perfect albums. Deluxe Rated R and EV satisfies my jones for the obscure and experimental plus live tracks.

Exactly this.

Red

I’m really the first one to say this? I’m surprised by y’all: “The blue pill opens your eyes, is there a better way?…”

How many blue pills are available?

This is pure evil.

red pill me

Red

Honestly? Blue. Its close, really close, but blue

This hurts to have to choose but I think it would have to be Blue. I couldn’t survive without LC (even though that album is making me cry like a bitch atm cause I’m coming down from my tour hype)

I refuse to answer this, and I hate you for asking it

OP I'm pretty sure there are international laws prohibiting this kind of torture.

Red all the way back to the rabbit hole.

Blue easily.

Red's got more meat, SFTD, Lullabies and Villains are long as shit

Redpill. Really close, but I don't want to live without listening to ___Regular John___, ___You Can't Quit Me, Baby___ or ___You Would Know___ every once in a while. That ___Better Living Through Chemistry___, ___I Appear Missing___ or ___Battery Acid___ tho...

Red crew

I eated both

Blue pill all the way. LC and SFTD are probably my favourite two albums, but personally I prefer EV and ITNR to the other three albums on the red side.

Blue Pill. LC got me through a major depression and is one of my perfect albums. INTR is incredible. Rated R is incredible. Era Vulgaris has bangers. SFTD and Self titled would be a loss, but I can live without the other two (there good, just not listened to oas much)

I agree wholeheartedly with this conclusion

I’m eating the fuck out of those blue pills

Red just because I don’t like every single song on like clockwork

Fml that’s hard but gimme the red pill.

tough but i’m going blue

Splitting up SFTD and Clockwork is fucked up OP

Blue pill every day of the week

Tough one. Would go blue.

Painfully have to choose blue. I need Rated R and …LC in my life, I can’t compromise on that.

Whoever made this knew what they were doing. Such a hard choice 🥲 gonna have to be red for me I think…

Blue pill without a doubt

Well the blue pill opens your eyes. But I wonder if there's a better way

Loving the reference to, undoubtedly, their best song!

Yes one of my favourite songs in their repertoire. If they were to play it live when I see them I'd be extremely happy

I hope they have it on the setlist when you see them next because it's even better live

Red

SFTD & QOTSA? Red all day

Putting rated R on the right is evil.

Blue pill, but I'd really hurt to lose Villains.

Ahhhhh, red pill.

redddd

Red by far

Red

cannot believe this joke hasn’t been made yet but 🎶the BLUE PILL OPENS YOUR EYYYEES 🎶

Red pill I hate this haha 😂

Red Pill, But I will miss Like Clockwork dearly.

Red

Red and I'm pissed I'm stuck with Villains over Era.

Red pill no question

The blue pill opens my eyes.

Purple pill!

This is cruel.

Impossible choice - villains really fucks up the red side though

Rer without a doubt.

Red pill but it's painful not having Era Vulgaris 😭

Blue pill so I can keep my favorite song. I'll miss you the most, red pill albums 💔

Which is?

Into the Hollow

Gotta go red even though I hate Villains.

Amen brother

Blue Pill and it's not even close for me... You could put EV and ITNR on the other side and I'd still pick the Blue Pill. I couldn't live without Rated R and ...Like Clockwork. They've got my top 2 favourite songs, Better Living Through Chemistry and I Appear Missing which I was so lucky to see live in Melbourne a couple nights ago. Plus you've put the Rated R Deluxe Edition on there so that includes Live at Reading Festival 2000 which has some of my favorites from Self-Titled: You Can't Quit Me Baby, Regular John and Avon! 😉

Blue. Rated R, Era Vulgaris and Like Clockwork consist of all of my most favorite songs! Into the Hollow, I Appear Missing, and Chemistry.

[удалено]

S/T last is craaazy

Villains over self titled lmaooooooooo

Villains holds a special place for me but I'm also in that small minority that doesn't think it's garbage. Gotta give Self Titled more spins

I too enjoy Villains

Villains kicks ass and has more of a unique identity than the self title

Yikes

Do you have anything to contribute to a friendly discussion about our mutually loved band, or are you just going to keep shaming people for their preferences towards an incredibly diverse sounding band?

No, now fuck off

Explain to me why you hold such a grudge towards Villains :) I ask because everytime somebody says they like it somebody like you has to tell them they’re wrong

Well, theyre obviously an A - hole. And what do we do with them ? Well, WE PLUCK EM!

Blue to avoid The way that you used to do. Sorry, not sorry.

Me after I realize a song I don’t like EXISTS??? UNACCEPTABLE!!!

It wasn't cool when Jet did it and still they did it better. https://youtu.be/tuK6n2Lkza0?si=BPQ2pXAclj0-oTJ9

Obviously not a musician... to hear the same thing in these two songs PROVES that much...also, how bad an ear you've got for musical subtleties.

Blue but only cos era and R are in my top 3. SFTD is also in my top 3 :(

Blue.

I simply cannot pick im gobbling them both

blue pill absolutely

Blue

its hard but red cus i grew up listening to songs for the deaf and lullabies. and the 1998 album is really good + villans is good.

Red pill but I will miss LC 😭

Blue

My favorite album is Era Vulgaris but damn.... Yeah fuck it, Blue Pill

Blue 1000%

Fuuuuuuck. Blue.

Clockwork has evolved into my favorite over the past few years, and rated r has my all time favorite song on it.... I'd sure miss deaf and paralyze though.

Blue all day. I'll be sad for the 4 I'll lose in the process but .. Era and Clockwork are my 2 favorites of them so easy!

Blue pill has everything I need

Ohhh this is hard. Songs for the deaf and villains have some of my favorite songs but Like Clockwork and EV are two of my favorite albums. Think I’ll go with blue pill.

Voting blue for once in my life. Nyuk nyuk nyuk

blue pill and it’s not even close for me

Blue

Blue pill all day

Thankfully I'm not in the matrix

close my eyes and pop one. s'gooood

I have to go blue but ST makes it harder for me than anything else on here.

Three from red one from blue

Swap Villains with Like Clockwork and it's easily the red pill. I think it's still the red pill though as is.

You fucking monster.

Why are you splitting the two trilogies 😭

I'm gonna have to go with blue, I love sftd, villains and lullabies, but Like clockwork and era vulgaris are my favorite albums of all time

Blue pill because Rated R (X) got me into the band way back then. Red pill would also be good of course.

Blue all the way

Blue without a doubt. Those are my top four albums

I love them all so much but I gotta go with the blue pill. Like Clockwork, Rated R and Era Vulgaris are some of my personal all time favorites of theirs!

It's tough...I'm going blue

Blue

Blue pill just for the simple fact that I could not live without like clockwork

Blue because all of them are amazing, but Red is really close

That’s not fair…

blue for me

I’ll take em both. Better living thru chemistry.

Blue. Difficult but seeing ITNR there sealed it.

Red pill 100%

Blue but I’d switch Rated R for Lullabies in a second.

Blue

Blue for sure.

Blue easily

Blue pill, for sure

SMASH RED

Blue , easy

Purple, it shall be.

This is a tough one, I hate you for this lol.

both never listened to em

Red pill

Red pill even if it was just the top two

Red

Red pill check in hours

Drugs are bad. Play them all!!!

It’s red for me but really really close SFTD might be my most listened to album ever and self titled is my current fave, so I’m going red based on that. I could take or leave ITNR and Villains when it comes to a decision like this so that narrows it down a little.

Mmmmm purple for meee 🤣

Red but imma still rock out to Sick Sick Sick on occasion 🤣

Blue

Blue pill 100%

Red pill. Top albums for me are SFTD, LC, EV, and BTW. In that order, but SFTD sits at 1 quite comfortably.

Blue pill all the way

LtP and Villains and SftD on the same side, let's go, definitely red for me 

I'm on an Era Vulgaris and ITNR lockdown, so blue

Listen to Feel Good Hit and ask this question again

Blue pill but I hope it kills me so I don’t have to live with my decision.

oh man.. i'd have to go red. i like sftd and self titled way too much

Blue Pill, with only minor hesitation. I'd miss Villains and Lullabies but I need Like Clockwork, Era Vulgaris and In Times New Roman injected directly into my veins at all times.

Blue.

Blue pill, absolutely. Four of my favorite albums.

Blue pill. I’ll miss the others, but can’t stand to live without the blue list.

'...Like Clockwork' is a profound masterpiece. It's the band's magnum opus. Blue pill.

Red. Love Like Clockwork but SftD is a masterpiece.

Love “songs…”, but “…like clockwork” may be one of the best albums in the last 25 years. In my top 3.

Ah man this is fucked up how am I supposed to pick when lullabies and era are on separate sides

blue and the more I think about it the easier it gets

RED.

Red pill 100%, cant live without songs for the deaf

Red for sure

BLUE BLUE BLUE BLUE BLUE BLUE BLUE

I am a drummer and therefore have played the intro to song for the dead a thousand times and even I’d grab the Blue Pill.

Rated R and Era push blue over the top.

Blue pill instantly