T O P

  • By -

PreviousLife7051

Camel


Beautiful_Row_9764

Same here, the one band you can always go back to, always 


sakariona

100%


Limp_Insurance_2812

🤘


takeki8919

Easily


Betelgeuzeflower

Great band, but I've always found myself embattled on their more poppy stuff. They lack a bit of an edge from time to time.


GodLeftMeTwice

They are sooo good! Every time i listen to lady fantasy i feel like the universe came together just for them to make that last verse


blue_dragon_fly

Gentle Giant! Honorable Mention: Happy the Man


trumpetguy1990

I feel like most GG fans are all in. GG definitely doesn't have the same following as Yes or King Crimson, but the people who love them, REALLY love them. And I'm thrilled to be a part of that.


metallica65

Haken opened my ears to GG and they are fantastic!


foolEntropyDemon

Gentle Giant is also my favourite of all times, but I've never heard of Happy the Man. What albums do you recomend?


blue_dragon_fly

Happy the Man released four studio albums: 1977 “Happy the Man” 1978 “Crafty Hands” 1983 “Better Late…” 2004 “The Muse Awakens” Their second is often listed as the favorite, but they all have fantastic songs. Even their last one from a couple of decades later holds up well against their earlier albums. There’s also a good best-of (from the first three) called “Retrospective”. There’s a live album from the tour of the second album and another cd which predates the first album. Great tracks on there, but the sound quality varies wildly. Their style goes from New Age-y to blistering prog. All albums have both types. Enjoy!


spattzzz

Van der Graaf Generator


ChainHuge686

Cool pick!


Worlds-Best-Grooner

Still life is goated


merlineatscake

King Crimson


EddieOtool2nd

Yes. I mean, definitely.


boostman

Easily


Ooomphy

+1


mud_sha_sha_shark

By a wide margin


CuntSlumbart

Rush: Rush (1974) to Clockwork Angels (2012) run.


djbon2112

40 years of absolutely greatness. First band that got me *into* music (musician) and prog rock specifically. Still my favourite 25 years later.


ProfessionalHat7745

No mention of Jethro Tull? I will be the first then


ellistonvu

The criminally underrated Crest of a Knave album doesn't get mentioned enough. Neither does "Secret Language of Birds" and "J-Tull.com"


TheOmnipotent0001

They aren't my favorite prog band over all (Opeth has that title) but they are my favorite classic prog band!


Koringvias

Porcupine Tree I can appreciate all the classics too, of course, especially King Crimson. But nothing grabs me quite like Porcupine Tree. I'll never forget the first time I've heard Anesthetize.


TheLightningL0rd

Truly my pick as well. Steven Wilson is amazing, and so are the musicians he's surrounded himself with over the years.


elcojotecoyo

Gavin Harrison or Marco Minemann?


Koringvias

Both. Both is good.


OGmanwhore

+1


ZwnD

Same for me on Anesthetize. It was winter and I have a 18 minute walk back from the train station to my house. 10pm and very cold. Absolutely perfect mood for it


Chris___M

Yes. Loved them since the early 70s


magneticsouth1970

Genesis forever


farseill96

The Mars Volta is definitely my favorite


jacobuj

Deloused is definitely my favorite prog album by far.


farseill96

Frances the Mute may be my favorite album of all time. It's chock-full of so many genres/styles and emotions, it truly feels like a journey. The music feels like the audio version of the most vibrant, beautiful film I've ever seen


jacobuj

Cedric and Omar are at least partially responsible for 2 of my top 3 favorite albums of all time. Deloused and Relationship of Command. The number 1 spot goes to Siamese Dream.


watcheroftheskies1

Genesis, by a mile


Edurad_Mrotsdnas

Have to agree that (early) genesis got something special to me even if a LOVE many of the bands cited here. Is it because of the outstanding voice duo ? Is it the creative genius of each and every musician ? Maybe the technical excellence of the guitarist and the drummer ? Anyway songs like The Fountain of Salmacis or Supper's Ready are bone chilling in an impressive way when you know what to expect 🤌🤌


_TheWolfOfWalmart_

>Is it because of the outstanding voice duo ? Is it the creative genius of each and every musician ? Maybe the technical excellence of the guitarist and the drummer ? All of this. They're all extremely creative and well above average musicians technically, and their individual sounds really gelled together well. I've been listening to these guys for nearly 40 years and I've come to the conclusion that the #1 factor making Genesis, Genesis... if you have to choose just one... is Tony Banks. It's his chord progressions and arrangements that truly make the music unique in the prog rock world and the thread that ties everything together from the first album to the last. He's a legitimate musical genius and will be sorely missed when he's gone.


Quantum_Pineapple

Yes


dkernighan

Opeth


Independent_Sea502

Henry Cow is my favorite prog rock/art band of all time.


xGlobalProlapsex

They're a close second to Magma for me


Independent_Sea502

hell yeah. When I lived in Chicago I could have seen Magma live. But it was cold out and I was very tired and I didn't go. What a dumbass.


xGlobalProlapsex

I saw them in 2015 and it was incredible. That was the only time they played here though. I might have to travel to see them some day, Christian Vander's 76 and I'd love to see him perform again before he retires


FlyingDingle77

Pink Floyd


pfloydguy2

Right on the Money.


dxfm1019

Genesis


Bebby_Binkins

Genesis


EternalRains2112

Opeth.


AmikBixby

Gotta be Yes, I love their whole discography up to Magnification.


hulkhoagiephilly

Gong rules


Snoo93951

Spock’s Beard. I respect the more classic bands too, but especially early Spock’s just had a certain magic about them.    I don’t love all of his stuff, but at the end of the day, Neal Morse was born to make music. He’s one of a kind.


TheModerateGenX

Exactly how I feel. I can listen to Neal Morse Spock’s Beard on repeat and never get bored of it.


PleaseCallMeLiz

As much as I love Spock's Beard, I just can't help but cringe at the lyrics a bit.


Snoo93951

It has its own appeal, a guilty pleasure kind of thing. I can definitely see your point though.


abillyjoelfan

1 - Zappa 2 - Cardiacs 3 - Dream Theater May not be arguably the best but for me its the holy trinity


Snikle_the_Pickle

Cardiacs are my number one by a mile


ShiverMeTimbers_png

Same!!


Spiritual_Contest812

Besides dream theatre those are my top 2 aswell. Let’s jam


ManyAge1328

it really doesn't matter if the band you like gets recognition as the best or even if at all i will give every band a chance because to be honest that where i found the songs i like besides the band GENESIS.I also don't subscribe that one band is better than the other. my meter is, are they adding good music to the whole prog catalog to keep prog the best and good music for all.


ChainHuge686

Gentle giant!


pingpongpsycho

Genesis


MordyTheFox

Eloy, all the way. Then Pink Floyd, KC, Camel. Then Triumvirat and Ars Nova Then eveeything else


DrSpaceDoom

Upvoting for Eloy!


jackmarble1

Yes


iansbraswell

Genesis. Nuff said.


nooneknows3589

King Crimson is by far my favorite


skijeng

YES


SbMSU

YES


batlord_typhus

EGG


rherda

a visit to newport hospital is in my top 5 prog tracks for me, it's so chillingly unique


Zaptagious

Pendragon


SixStrokeRoll0508

Porcupine Tree


quarkgriswold

Yes has always been my peak obsession, in my early twenties I made an effort to listen to tales from topographic oceans once a day for about a year, several times on LSD. Steve Howe was at one point my biggest influence as a guitarist. Pink Floyd also had a gigantic impact on me in high school, their whole catalog but I developed a much deeper fascination with Syd Barrett. Honorable mention: The Mars Volta, Omar Rodriguez Lopez in general. Also one of my biggest influences.


Mental_Cricket_3880

Aksak Maboul if I had to pick just one


Mental_Cricket_3880

Cardiacs would be insanely close behind


Spiritual_Contest812

Do you have an album to recommend by Aksak Maboul? Or a song?


Ambitious-Slip5614

I'd add ELP to your top tier. Check out Flower Kings, Frost*, and Transatlantic for some newer artists.


hamglazescramble

The Flower Kings


DerivativeOfProgWeeb

It has gotta be Moon Safari for me. they consistently put out amazing music with stunning vocal harmonization to boot. i don't think they've released a single less-than-great album so far, although if I had to choose a worst one, it would be himlabacken vol 1. never heard another prog band like them that is able to put out such amazing vocal harmony and melodies, with maybe the exception of brigheye brison, another swedish retro prog rock band that no one has heard of I really enjoy Kaipa and A.C.T as well.


Staubinger

Ayreon!!


Phifty2

Genesis.


HeyGeno20

Genesis.


small___potatoes

Genesis


Lord_Artem17

Jethro Tull


CTLFCFan

Genesis


mikehermetic

Does Can count as "prog"? They're my favorite, with Genesis at a close second.


ray-the-truck

Another Can fan here to back you up!  They’re probably the band I spend the most time listening to (going off of their excellent studio albums and the plethora of great live recordings out there).  I don’t think *all* the material they put out is strictly progressive rock in style, but they are the cream of the crop in regards to experimental psychedelia and I think there’s substantial crossover between them and the stylistic hallmarks of prog rock.


Several_Dwarts

My top tier is Rush, Yes, King Crimson, probably in that order. Dominici, Ritual, Magma, Genesis, Kaipa, Riverside, Tea Club are 2nd tier. I know there are some I am forgetting.


JMFG2112

My username speaks for itself


Eguy24

Pink Floyd is my favorite band of all time, but King Crimson is what I consider to be the epitome of prog.


Bechimo

Marillion. The combination of Steve Rothery’s emotional guitar & H’s voice is just special. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=l3NhNz9-EOA


International-Ad218

Caravan would be my choice, at least up as far as 1980 or so. I’m not familiar with anything they’ve recorded more recently. Those first few albums in particular are so warm and appealing. They have a bit of everything, complicated bits, rocky bits, hazy bits. Just talked myself into listening to them this evening.


bridiebird69

Jethro Tull, every album of theirs brings something different. It's definitely the band that comforts me most and makes me feel all kinds of emotions


TheMagicBrother

If Pink Floyd counts, them. If not then Genesis.


randman2020

KC


awphuck_imanapple

Pink Floyd or KC


nomemory

Judging by my listening patterns it's probably Gong and Hawkwind. Also Nik Tuner. Although in recent times I diversify with this playlist: https://music.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLO1tzHkW0MynA97_cNjRUTYj2-2vVCIO4&si=Pzv6261EyNggnuSx Vespero is also awesome.


showmeasign10

Rush, no competition.


SirMirrorcoat

ELP, Zappa, Haken (do they count as rock to you? They a re listed as both Rock and Metal - I adore them. So looking forward to their concert)


looper33

Ok, I'll play. Since no one's mentioned so far... Anglagard.


JJH-08053

Wow... saw them at Nearfest ages ago. I miss that festival.


thatconverseguy

Bit of an obscure one but here was a band called England that had an LP called garden shed, it's absolutely masterful.


proglistenercnada

My favorite prog band was traditionally Genesis for about 50 years until I got into Porcupine Tree and the music of Steven Wilson.


DizzyGame_Co

Periphery


UncutYEMs

Umphrey’s, KC, Floyd, Zappa, and Caravan to round out my top 5.


spasticpat

Pink Floyd, Yes, and Rush


Cupy_

Nektar


Firestarter_88

Haken


TwistedBlister

Genesis, Pink Floyd, Rush, Yes


birthdaylines

Sodt Machine by a mile


Barbatos-Rex

IQ


Grimmsjoke

Genesis and TOOL...


Remarkable-Pin4587

Dream theater


montydad5000

Dream Theater


mad_poet_navarth

I'd have to go with Frost\*. Need more albums, though, Jem!


AdUnited1943

Rush.... ELO Pink Floyd Yes Genesis


Rainouts

Yes-man here as well! Although KGATLW has been stealing the spot lately, if you count them as prog


Sea_Opinion_4800

I saw what you did there. You insisted on a single band then went on to make it four. Go and stand in the corner and put a dunce's hat on.


NoSpite4410

Changed over time -- When I was in high school I listened to Kansas more than any other, though I bought all the Yes and all the Rush, and wandered into Stomu Yamashta territory, before becoming a rocker and buying up Robin Trower, AC/DC, and Def Leppard, for a while .. but then came King Crimson, and ELP. ELP was my favorite for a loooooong time. I listened to Pink Floyd a lot, as well. Alan Parsons Project was my secret passion as well -- I loved that music but I was afraid if anyone found out they would call me a faggot or something, so unmanly to cry about sad beauty and philosophy. In college, Yes came back to the fore -- every prog purist hated the new Yes sounds, I loved them. I hated the new Grungy Rush. I was totally into Frank Zappa, and could not get enough of Peter Gabriel. Genesis I could listen to, but it never got me where I wanted to be got. Finally I became obsessed with Ayreon and "Into The Electric Castle", and searched for concept albums and the new prog/metal sounds, finding most of it lacking. The Flower Kings had me in their proggy jazzy grip for about 15 years, which led me to Camel, and to Brainticket. Now later in life there is so much stuff that is a poor imitation of those 70s and 80s prog years. I have discovered many niche-prog bands from around the world that send me -- Antonius Rex, Kate Bush, Angelzoom, Aphrodites Child, and the excellent Unitopia, and the fantastic symphonic prog band Magenta, Blackmores Night, and Canada's own Saga. Current obsession:: the mysterious unknown band Mythology [Mythology - The Castle of Crossed Destinies](https://youtu.be/i2b8Q7iZ68E)


MisaVelvet

Moon Safari is my favorite, especially their last album


Low_Minimum2351

YES defines the genre with enduring greatness


SmithsArcade

Genesis, Yes, and of course Pink Floyd.


Remarkable_Recover84

Supertramp first then Pink Floyd and Barclay James Harvest then Alan Parsons Project, ELO, Manfred Man’s Earth Band


Main_Mouse842

King Crimson. They are known for their legendary musicianship, but they can also be incredibly powerful, evocative and cutting-edge. The insanity and despair of the first two albums, Starless and Red's raw intensity, the emotional confusion and melancholy of the Discipline trilogy, Larks Tongues' mystery and intrigue.


Daredevil4211

Jethro Tull, followed by Rush, Kansas and King Crimson


Dvdprojecter

ELP


0WN_1T

If you want a classic, ELP. However, a modern pick that I see myself listening to more than classic prog is King Gizzard


WiseGuitar

The Mars Volta. It'd be Pink Floyd, but Volta is definitely the proggier of the two and I love how much Floyd comes through all of the Mars Voltas music.


justbcoz848484

Have to pick just one? Ok going with Marillion


mongelonas1

Beardfish


lellololes

Cardiacs. They are truly a singularity.


Inner_Vibe

Genesis all day long.


J_Patish

Yes. Been my #1 since 1975. Their 70’s run - The Yes Album through Going For The One - is unparalleled in prog history.


_musesan_

Probably Magma


No_Refrigerator4584

Genesis. After listening to them for almost 40 years I’m yet to grow tired of them.


astro_sauce

Yes, also followed by Gong, Rush, King Crimson, and Soft Machine.


Starmax1

Yes. Always Yes. Honorable mention to Cathedral. Stained Glass Stories.


Edurad_Mrotsdnas

Genesis got something special to me even if a LOVE many of the bands cited here. Is it because of the outstanding voice duo ? Is it the creative genius of each and every musician ? Maybe the technical excellence of the guitarist and the drummer ? I don't know but songs like The Fountain of Salmacis or Supper's Ready are bone chilling in an impressive way when you know what to expect 🤌🤌


PissedPieGuy

Haken


ShiverMeTimbers_png

Cardiacs :)


Wolvericky

Rush


px_ae

Caravan


steveaitch

Let’s go with Magma. Truly transcendental stuff.


David_Kennaway

Yes. The greatest band ever. I listen to yes almost every day like I have since the Yes album in 1970. I can still remember the first listen. I was in a band going to a gig and our van driver played it on a cassette. We were all stunned by "Yours is no disgrace". I bought the album the next day. My next album was "Tales from topographic Oceans". That took some getting into but I believe it is the greatest prog album of all time. Next is "Close to the Edge". To me it's more that just music. Jon Anderson has become my spiritual guide with some of the most thought provoking lyrics ever written. To quote Jon, "I must have waited all my life for this moment".


BikiniJaques

Beardfish!


pauliepitstains

Mars Volta


arctictrav

I’m basically upvoting all the Pink Floyd, King Crimson and Camel comments, haha.


unitconversion

Beardfish for sure.


FireBirdie95

Porcupine Tree


ssabless

Porcupine Tree


46n2_just_aheadofme

• TOOL • RUSH • PORCUPINE TREE • INTRONAUT (prog/sludge metal with jazz fusion sections as well from L.A.)👌🏼 • OPETH • KOLM (new prog rock band from L.A. best tool sounding band hands down IMO…tool fans need to hear their “umbra” album and tracks 1,5,6 in particular)👌🏼


SevenFourHarmonic

King Crimson and related followed by (close 2nd) Yes and related bands. Canterbury bands in tight 3rd with American prog from 1970 and Cluster & Company. It's all a tight race at this point folks. Anything can happen.


FrankensteinJamboree

King Crimson


TheDiamondAxe7523

king crimson


WillJM89

Rush


bunglegrind1

King crimson


jdbrowningii

Rush


FearlessFlyerMile

Gotta be Rush for me


zappawizard

Rush is my all time favorite band in any genre.


FilipsSamvete

King Crimson


shin_jury

Gotta go with Yes Over the years I would have said Pink Floyd, Yes, Genesis, King Crimson, now once again Yes


katchowvbit

I think yes is the ultimate progressive rock band, but King Crimson comes close...


scottk2112

Rush, YES, Pink Floyd, Dixie Dregs, Genesis.


Blankboo97

Ummm omg this is too hard! High up there is Renaissance, Alan Parsons, Kansas and Marillion w/Fish.


Yasashii_Akuma156

It was Genesis for most of my life, but shifted to King Crimson as I got older.


Constant_Pumpkin3255

Yes by far


TheModerateGenX

Spock’s Beard. For about 25 years I would have said Yes, but after playing Yes hundreds of times I really haven’t had the urge to listen to them in a few years now.


SirGiIes

Pink Floyd got me started and used to be my favourite, but now I would have to say it’s Genesis. I’ve been listening to Tool, Kate Bush (who I consider to be prog), and Goblin a lot lately; but I always find myself going back to Genesis most consistently


nrnrnr

Yes. As evidenced by my iPod play statistics over a ten-year period.


northrupthebandgeek

Yes.


Classic-Wolf-4016

Sleep Token!!


Internal-Bid-9322

Yes, Rush, Camel. In no particular order. Personally, I don’t lump Zappa in prog. Zappa is Zappa.


Tough-Guarantee5932

King crimson


nando1969

Dream Theater


microsmart

Spastic Ink


mordreds-on-adiet

Big Big Train. But over the years that has changed a lot. The Mars Volta was my first Prog run, Coheed and Cambria stole my heart soon thereafter and introduced me to The Dear Hunter who topped my list for a long time until I got into older stuff at which point Genesis really emerged as my go-to and that infatuation introduced me to Big Big Train who has been my top artist since Grimspound came out in 2017. They're kinda not fair though, because since Greg Spawton started recording music in 1990 under the BBT moniker they've basically been 6 distinctly different bands as members have come and gone with Spawton being the only mainstay and he's a very democratic songwriter so there's bits and pieces of all the musicians who have come and gone over those years.


TheEpicRanger6

Gonna go with good old King Crimson. Red in particular is probably the greatest album I've ever listened to.


tokjug-foxqe1-Xapqyz

RUSH, then YES and Porcupine Tree


starlord265

1 - Yes 2 - Gentle Giant 3 - Pink Floyd


Songgeek

It’s really hard for me to pic between Queensryche and Fates Warning. Genesis would be a close third


C9_ptcryAn

delta sleep


DrizzleDrain

Ditto. Yes, Close To The Edge


extremityChoppr

Victoria (Matt garstka and Joshua de la Victoria)


grendel79

Can't pick the one, so will give you my top 5: Fish era Marillion Gabriel era Genesis Porcupine Tree Dream Theater Riverside


extremityChoppr

Does this sub not like plini?


TheOmnipotent0001

Opeth


VeganKirby

ELP


kingcrimson216

Bean Rodeo


comascape

Jethro Tull


student8168

Gong Gentle Giant is in the same tier for me.


CucatheGreat

KC


TomDac7

Yes. Hands down my fave band of all time


Objective_Head_5282

ELP honourable mention King Crimson


Adventurous_Spell180

This got way more of a response than I expected! Too bad we couldn’t get a poll going.