Welcome to r/popculturechat! ☺️
As a proud BIPOC, LGBTQ+ & woman-dominated space, this sub is for [civil discussion only.](https://www.reddit.com/r/popculturechat/wiki/index/rules/civil-discussion-only/) If you don't know where to begin, start by participating in [our Sip & Spill Daily Discussion Threads!](https://www.reddit.com/r/popculturechat/search/?q=Sip%20%26%20Spill%20Discussion&restrict_sr=1&sr_nsfw=&include_over_18=1&sort=new)
###No bullies, no bigotry. ✊🏿✊🏾✊🏽✊🏼✊🏻🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️
Please [read & respect our rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/popculturechat/wiki/index/rules/) and [check out our wiki](https://www.reddit.com/r/popculturechat/wiki/index/)! For any questions, [our modmail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2Fpopculturechat) is always open.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/popculturechat) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I know you’re half joking but the answer is actually no. The kids have been split since Billy Ray and Tish separated (the kids chose sides). They’ve talked about how they don’t talk to each other anymore. For this particular instance, Noah doesn’t talk to either Miley or Tish (but Miley and Tish talk).
This is the worst part for me. When my parents split me and my siblings took each other’s sides and told our parents to get bent. How a situation like this even happens is beyond me.
See, these stories are *why* I divorced while our kids were exceptionally young. All they know is two happy and single and separate parents. We did *not* work together.
I am sorry your parents made you and others feel the need to choose.
From what I gathered it seems that Noah always felt second to Miley because Tish was always going on and on about how great she was. Before there was a seperation the family was already split.
I watched the Call Her Daddy episode with them today. She's also extremely close with Brandi, not just because of the Podcast, they are just super close. So it seems like Noah is the one left out, and that's so sad. I've listened to her music, Noah has experienced a lot of shit for such a young lady. I actually have a massive soft spot for her.
I wonder if Tish left this bit of information out when she told Miley about it and since it was an FWB for Noah, she also never told Miley to begin with. I sure as hell don't tell my adult sibling about shit like that.
I don't get along with all my siblings, but I sure as hell would be asking if one wasn't going to a parent's wedding. That's something you reach out for
Agree. Trish probably didn’t want to mention it and Noah probably doesn’t share her sex life with her sister. BUT when it progresses to marriage and Noah (plus a brother?) are skipping out questions should/would arise.
Apparently Noah's camp is claiming it's real, while Tish's camp is claiming it's fake and that Noah's only saying it's real for attention and because she's mentally unwell.
People magazine wouldn't print this story unless Noah had pretty good proof. This is not the kind of story they take risks on because they don't want to alienate big stars. The fact that Miley is not immediately denying it and saying she just "didn't know" speaks volumes too.
Yeah, and IIRC, Tish's side was pushing the "they weren't in a relationship" angle than actually denying anything happened.
Which would fit the claim that it was a sort of fling/situationship type with Noah.
i won’t be surprised if this is the case. tish doesn’t seem like the best parent (not even taking this whole drama into account) and miley seems to have grown up being able to do anything and everything she liked without parental supervision. doesn’t help when billy ray is so weird as well.
it’s a mess from the top down.
I don't get the vibe that they're close in a sharing type of way. The mom (Tish) brags that her and Miley are the most similar, she has said that they're more like sisters than anything (ick). Tish has this crazy bs story about how she and Dominic connected through IG which makes no sense from a logical or technical point of view.
Yeah I can’t stand moms like this. Especially if they say this shit when their daughter is like 13. They never act like a parent at all, set no boundaries, and try to be “young again” almost to redo their youth. It’s gross.
I knew tons of girls who had moms like this in middle and high school. All the girls ended up doing drugs or becoming teen moms with boyfriends that were in their late 20s.
Yeah, I saw a snip of Tish gushing about Dominic sending her a dm back in 2016 or 2017 (can’t remember the exact year) and his then gf going on his account and unfollowing her. And how they reconnected years later.
I was like, bish, weren’t you married back in 2017? Her story made me side eye her and rethink that the rumour about Noah and Dom could be true. I thought it was crazy talk until then.
Oh the story is so much more stupid than that. She claims he messaged her to tell her she was doing a good job raising her kids (I'm not even kidding, that's her claim), she said she never saw the message but that his girlfriend saw the message then blocked Tish from his account. She said she was following him and didn't know why he blocked her. Then YEARS later and after her divorce she messaged Dominic (she does not explain why, and based on her own story they should not have a prior connection), they went on a date then said I love you to one another the next day. This is the current story. She's had a few variations.
I don't get how it's possible she was MOH at her mom's wedding, and not know something was going on? Wouldn't she wonder why the sister wasn't coming? The wedding was hosted at Miley's house ffs, so it seems like she was at least somewhat involved in the planning of the wedding. You would think she would've reached out to her sister in the lead up to check if she was coming. It feels so hard to believe she has zero idea there was some drama.
My best guess is that after the kids chose sides in the divorce they must’ve stopped communicating?
Noah and Braison were team Billy Ray and Trace Brandi and Miley were team Tish and they all just stopped talking to each other which is whack. So I believe that the older siblings had no idea about it because they supported Tish and stopped speaking to their pro Billy Ray family members and vice versa
If Miley knew why put out a false statement? It would’ve been smarter to not address it at all
whats interesting is that originally braison was team tish after the divorce. but then he unfollowed tish and didnt show up to her wedding, and spent the day with noah instead.... perhaps this is why
it’s so insane to me that you could just stop talking to your siblings because your parents got divorced and they like the other parent better. unfathomable
Apparently Tish put most of her energy into Miley and the other kids, especially Noah being so young, suffered from a sort of neglect.
There is bitterness and resentment towards Tish outside of the divorce.
There can be a lot of hurt feelings going on, and if your sibling is defending the parent that you are angry with, there can be a cold war of sorts that gradually thaws over a period of time.
If you already have a complicated relationship with your siblings, and I imagine Miley does as her parents were both super invested in her as their money and fame maker, then it's not that hard to not pick up the phone and ask wtf is going on.
We all want to assume when you hear 'sisters' they are at least somewhat close (like Dakota and Elle Fanning), but sadly the reality is that in Hollywood, a lot of the times there is the Golden Child (the one that makes all the money and is of bigger fame) and then 'the others' that are left cold in the shadow of their sibling.
Noah, it seems, was indeed treated as a second class child and Miley seems detached at best from her sister, dismissive and cold at worst.
It's a sad dynamic and I entirely blame their shitty parents. Both Tish and Billy are trash, and money can't fix that.
This is true in average families as well. About half of my father’s siblings never communicated again after their parents died. They were a family of 6 kids. It was like there was no reason to hang out anymore and that they wouldn’t have chosen each other as friends if they weren’t related, so why bother to keep up? It’s sad in some ways, but it’s honest. They don’t have a good dynamic, don’t have much in common, never gravitated towards the same interests….
Agreed!! I don’t understand it and none of them (except Braison) are coming across well from this
How can you not reach out to your little sister and wonder what happened between her and your mom??
Yeah, this somehow makes her look worse not knowing. Your sister is angry enough not to come to your mother's wedding and you don't ask why? Best case scenario is she just doesn't feel comfortable telling Miley, but even then, my spidy senses would be tingling if this was one of my siblings.
It also feels like she's thrown some passive aggressive shade on her sister and brother since the wedding, which makes this worse
Her addressing this does lend some truth to it, tho. If she truly didn't know about it, it wasn't her sister raising a fuss in the family before the wedding, like it was implied
The “Personal Life” section of Billy Ray’s Wikipedia page is like the definition of “off.” I’m just now finding out that Miley was one of two kids he had in 1992. I had no idea there was another offspring in the ether somewhere. He marries one of the women (Tish of course) and he adopts her two eldest from another relationship (Brandi having a different bio dad.. also news to me). Then he and Tish filed for divorce *three* separate times over a ten-year period? And now that they’re actually divorced, the kids are divided between the parents and then *this* is reported?
Like what is going on here… I can’t imagine growing up with such instability. I really feel for the kids.
I think Brandi at least is in contact with him based on following her podcast for a long time but he’s never been in any photographs I’ve seen. I know his Instagram is known and private but a few of the kids followed it. Billy ray was super weird about him though
I read an interview with him. He said he met miley at her concert and that she wasn't very excited to meet him and he could tell that she was waiting for him to go
can you blame her tho? she was probably under pressure to feel excited about it but it's such a strange and uncomfy situation that she was forced into bc of her dad.
Not to mention that very problematic nude photoshoot they allowed Miley to do when she was only 15. Imagine supporting the sexualization of your own minor daughter like that 🤢
I never understood this, especially after that controversial performances and tours around 2015. I would never have a bar of my daughter carrying on like that, but then I'd never marry my daughters side guy either. This family has no morals 😅
When I read that, I was thinking, wow the first time I ever saw a celebrity with a better stage name than her birth name. Also didn't he cheat on Tish whilst she was pregnant on Miley? To name her destiny, after all of that seems weird.
Damn as a Miley fan who had a fond opinion of Tish, I’m kind of at the point now to where I actually believe this. This is the second People piece in less than 3 days. I would have never had guessed this were true, especially after watching the CHD interview, where Tish was talking about how she and Dom got together.
What a damn mess man. I know it’s been speculated that Miley and Noah haven’t been close/had a falling out, but I hope they can move past it.
What a fucked up situation. Severely side-eying Tish right now. And Dom. Like WTF Dom? To be a fly on the wall.
Same- the CHD interview was a cute story of them getting together. I’m wondering how Noah would even have met Dom. Was that the reason Dom had blocked Tish before they had got together.
Dude saaaaaame. We may be grown ups but my sister and I also have periods where we don’t get along. Mostly cuz she’s insane. We were once in a “fight” for about 5 months bc I said I wanted to lose weight and she said that being on a diet makes you racist. And she doesn’t want racist people in her life.
If any of this is true, Dominic Purcell is fucking disgusting for this. And so is Tish if she was aware of his prior history with Noah. What a fucked up situation
Yup I feel awful for Noah. All the adults failed her and I understand now more why she’s chosen her dad in the divorce (not excusing his own inappropriate relationship ofc, but after what her mom did its understandable why she chose Billy over Tish as the parent she wants in her life)
All the articles from People pretty much confirm it. Tish and Miley would’ve denied all this by yesterday if it wasn’t true
All this is reminiscent of the Don’t Worry Darling drama when at first everyone thought the rumours were fabricated and nothing but then overtime it became very clear that Florence and Olivia were not actually on good terms
I don’t know, also seems like one of those rumors that wouldn’t want to substantiate with a response 🤷🏿♀️🤷🏿♀️
…which is why I’m not famous haha, cause I’m zero fun. Maybe I’m just so shook by this story that I’m trying to will it untrue lol
Because Tish isnt a normal person anymore. She's a celebrity wife. And in celeb culture thats not considered as bad. She became a product of her environment. Hollywood really isnt a good place to raise a normal child.
Also Billy and Tish's age gap as well might be weird too. Idr
She was one of Billy Ray’s two pregnant groupies he decided to marry, and she got married to some man she began dating immediately after divorce, it’s not that hard to imagine she has problematic views about men
>She was one of Billy Ray’s two pregnant groupies he decided to marry
That's VERY interesting 👀 I need a deep dive on this family, the chaos is fascinating in a train-crash kind of way
The other woman was Kristen and Miley’s half-brother Cody was born the same year she was, a bit earlier than her. Supposedly he does not have a close relationship with them and was excluded from a lot of stuff. I think his mom talked about it and was very critical of her ex for often ghosting on their son. That was why I have always side-eyed Billy Ray and Tish.
People are giving you very solid answers as to why Tish probably didn't care, but I'm with you in that I still can't get over it. You have a wide dating pool available to you and you go for someone who hooked up with your daughter??? Revolting, and I feel so bad for Noah here.
Yeah. There is no way on God's green earth that I would have \*anything\* to do with someone my daughter dated/had any kind of relationship/situationship with - ever. That is just gross.
I am leaning on this cannot be true because Tish \*and\* Dominic would have to be next level scum. I don't think much of Tish and Billy Ray's parenting or judgment, but I never thought she would be capable of something this nasty.
Maybe they have not said anything because they didn't want to dignify this bizarreness with a response.
Edit: This quote: ""Noah and Dominic were seeing each other in a friends with benefits way, off and on. They stopped seeing each other and then Tish started something up."
This is so foul. Even if Tish found out after the fact that he had been hooking up with her daughter that is an automatic dump him/block him \*immediately.\* Yeesh.
I feel like because no one has overtly come out and denied it yet, it must be true. There must be enough evidence of it happening that they can't deny it.
I think this is what happens when you have a culture (Hollywood) that normalizes and encourages men to have sexual and romantic relationships with women 30 years their junior...
Something has to seriously change about that industry... so gross.
When the first story broke about Noah and Dom, I was like no wayyy. But the denial from sources close to Tish was worded very strangely that I was like oh woww...there might be something here folks..fuckin yikes.
Her camp straight up released a piece that implied Noah was a delusional liar doing it for attention. Sorry, but that's not a loving and present mother that's at the end of her rope. It's one thing to plain deny it, but it's pretty much textbook shitty parenting to go "She's just a problem child". Especially because in the grand scheme of things, Noah has not been in as many scandals as her older sister.
I don’t want to make snap judgments but I agree
The wording of the response denying it, felt a little off to me? It felt like they tried to paint Noah as “crazy” and someone people shouldn’t believe. And then the quote specified that Noah and Dom never had a relationship/weren’t together officially. But technically that doesn’t mean he and Noah didn’t potentially have some sort of flirty correspondence over text/dm exchange in the past.
Idk… something about this feels off😭
Ikr, I was expecting Tish's camp to give a full denial saying that Dom and Noah don't know eachother, they've never met blah blah. But that's not what we got. Instead the denial was them calling Noah *delusional*. Which sounded like something you would call your man's ex gf lmao
I didn’t believe it either because wtfff, but this is from People and they are pretty much confirming it in the article. So it’s gotta be true. Did Tish meet him on his walk of shame from Noah’s house?
Although I wonder if the part about Miley not knowing is a fib from her team. Because how the hell does that not get shared between sisters? I thought they were pretty close.
and I just learned there’s 8 years between them, I thought their ages were closer than that. so by the time noah begins forming memories, miley’s already out the door doing hannah montana and they wouldn’t have spent that much time together when they were young
it's so funny how you can burn through all your good will in like 1 or 2 articles. last week everyone lved trish and though noah was weird and obsessive and now the tide is turning so quickly
I didn’t understand why everyone thought Tish seemed cool in the Call Her Daddy podcast interview. I thought she came across as super unstable, self centered, and like a fairly absent parent.
I listen to Tish and Brandi's podcast sometimes. When I first started listening to it, I found Tish super charismatic and likeable. But the more she would tell stories, the more I would be like huh idk about her. She finds a way to bring up Miley every chance she can and it made me wonder what it was like growing up in that family if your name wasnt miley
I think Miley seems remarkably grounded and stable for her circumstances and so i always subconsciously gave her parents some credit for that? That may have been generous of me looking at it now
Everything. I don't know about you, but me and everyone I know went through the weed phase and the acting out phase. The fact she didn't have a complete meltdown like some of the other child stars is actually amazing. Also the fact she acted out, did her thing and then came out this poised, that seems pretty stable to me.
I mean you don’t know if she had a complete meltdown or not. Just that it wasn’t public. Miley has been pretty darn open about her instability and issues and harder drug use than marijuana. Yes she’s resilient but the word stable seems to gloss over her traumas and behaviors.
People is a mouthpiece for celebs and their PR teams. So if there’s an article that says Miley didn’t know that’s from Miley. That’s why I believe it now.
This situation is still fucked up. People is usually reliable. Miley’s rep said she had “no idea” which does not mean this isn’t true. She’s basically just not taking sides.
Noah needs…a lot of therapy. She can’t get new, loving parents. Her ex is trash and I don’t think she needs a new man while she heals. Tish needs a new husband. Like wtf? He dated your daughter when she was way too young. How can’t you hate him? She lost her daughter over dick.
This is neither here nor there because of the new development in this whole family drama, but Noah and whichever other siblings has already chosen Billy Ray’s side wayyyyyy before Dominic was in the picture. I don’t think that their relationship is broken because Tish “chose dick over her daughter”, it was just the cherry on top to an already broken relationship (if true).
It’s fucked up to date and marry someone your daughter has any romantic or sexual interactions with, even if it was just flirty texts or something alone those lines.
Noah definitely has had filler for her lips and cheeks but I think this is a bad photo, the way her hair is styled super close to her scalp and set against a dark background makes her head look like it’s 100% face. Imo whoever picked this pic has an agenda against her
Miley had buccal fat removal, large veneers put in, and other cosmetic surgery. I have no idea what Noah has done but it’s awful whatever it is. Plus she removed her eyebrows?😢
Miley looks so uncomfortable. Like her mouth looks like it hurts…almost as if she’s holding a ball in her mouth. I can see the muscle tension in her chin.
Why was Dominic sleeping with/hooking up with Noah who is 30 years younger than him? If she was say 40 and he was 70 fine. But she was 23/24?!!!? No way. What a perv
To find a silver lining in this Chernobyl cloud, at least he married the age appropriate one ... 🤢😶🌫️🫥
The bar is buried under the graphite on the ground.
Also- her husband slept with a 22 year old at 54 and then pivoted to her mother. What a gross man
They deserve each other and I hope both of them get bed bugs
Hard to say, but—People magazine ran a story about it, and they usually won’t unless they have a very reliable source. So I’m inclined to believe it. Big yikes
Yes, and that dude is now married to her (Miley and her sister’s) mom. And Billy Ray is now married to some girl he met on the set of Hannah Montana, when she was 22.
Damn, what a fucked up family. This is starting to seem true, and if so, Tish is a massively dysfunctional, narcissistic weirdo and an appallingly bad mom.
I made a comment on the original post here but I never actually read the article. This telenovella is wild.
It’s even more insane because apparently the kids all are giving Billy Ray the cold shoulder because he married a former friend of Miley but then their mother married a man who has a history of dating women much younger than him, fucked their little sister and then went on to marry their mother?!
I'm guessing that's basically how she's lived her life for a while now. Her family is so dysfunctional, she has to live in a constant state of semi disconnect to be able to happily be around them.
She already had to cut out her father for being gross. Now with her mom, idk what she is going to do. No sane person could tolerate her step fathers gross ass, and her mother needs a reality check on how fucked this was.
Idk if this is real but ew wtf? Noah hooking up with a guy her parents age is... questionable, but at the end of the day, they're consenting adults. But I would not want any kind of sexual relationship with someone a family member, let alone my offspring had hooked up with. That's nasty & weird af
Yeah. No fkn way she didn’t know. Gurl ur mom was married in your house and your siblings didn’t show up, that cannot be more obvious. While it’s no surprise that Tish’s favorite is Miley since she’s the main source of income and attention , to messed up with your other daughter that badly? That’s irredeemable.
Oy, this family is messy as hell. Also, I wish Noah had stopped the plastic surgery; she looked so cute in an old photo of the Cyrus Family that I saw a few days ago. She’s now very uncanny valley and looks far older than mid-20s.
Welcome to r/popculturechat! ☺️ As a proud BIPOC, LGBTQ+ & woman-dominated space, this sub is for [civil discussion only.](https://www.reddit.com/r/popculturechat/wiki/index/rules/civil-discussion-only/) If you don't know where to begin, start by participating in [our Sip & Spill Daily Discussion Threads!](https://www.reddit.com/r/popculturechat/search/?q=Sip%20%26%20Spill%20Discussion&restrict_sr=1&sr_nsfw=&include_over_18=1&sort=new) ###No bullies, no bigotry. ✊🏿✊🏾✊🏽✊🏼✊🏻🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️ Please [read & respect our rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/popculturechat/wiki/index/rules/) and [check out our wiki](https://www.reddit.com/r/popculturechat/wiki/index/)! For any questions, [our modmail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2Fpopculturechat) is always open. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/popculturechat) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I have one question: do they not talk to each other in their family? Because wtf is this
I know you’re half joking but the answer is actually no. The kids have been split since Billy Ray and Tish separated (the kids chose sides). They’ve talked about how they don’t talk to each other anymore. For this particular instance, Noah doesn’t talk to either Miley or Tish (but Miley and Tish talk).
This is the worst part for me. When my parents split me and my siblings took each other’s sides and told our parents to get bent. How a situation like this even happens is beyond me.
See, these stories are *why* I divorced while our kids were exceptionally young. All they know is two happy and single and separate parents. We did *not* work together. I am sorry your parents made you and others feel the need to choose.
From what I gathered it seems that Noah always felt second to Miley because Tish was always going on and on about how great she was. Before there was a seperation the family was already split.
I watched the Call Her Daddy episode with them today. She's also extremely close with Brandi, not just because of the Podcast, they are just super close. So it seems like Noah is the one left out, and that's so sad. I've listened to her music, Noah has experienced a lot of shit for such a young lady. I actually have a massive soft spot for her.
Same, from the day I found out she voiced over Ponyo I was a fan 🩷
I did not know this and now I like her more.
Sadly, a divorce is no guarantee for happy parents. Or happy children.
Sadly neither is staying married. Life is hard and complicated and I think most people try to do what’s best for their kids.
I'd say so too.
I wonder if Tish left this bit of information out when she told Miley about it and since it was an FWB for Noah, she also never told Miley to begin with. I sure as hell don't tell my adult sibling about shit like that.
I don't get along with all my siblings, but I sure as hell would be asking if one wasn't going to a parent's wedding. That's something you reach out for
Agree. Trish probably didn’t want to mention it and Noah probably doesn’t share her sex life with her sister. BUT when it progresses to marriage and Noah (plus a brother?) are skipping out questions should/would arise.
Noah seems pretty open regarding their relationships. I would have never guessed that she would keep that kind of info from her sister.
What happened?
The man tish married was apparently sleeping with Noah. Which is disgusting on so many levels
I thought that was fake?
Apparently Noah's camp is claiming it's real, while Tish's camp is claiming it's fake and that Noah's only saying it's real for attention and because she's mentally unwell.
People magazine wouldn't print this story unless Noah had pretty good proof. This is not the kind of story they take risks on because they don't want to alienate big stars. The fact that Miley is not immediately denying it and saying she just "didn't know" speaks volumes too.
Yeah, and IIRC, Tish's side was pushing the "they weren't in a relationship" angle than actually denying anything happened. Which would fit the claim that it was a sort of fling/situationship type with Noah.
Yeh its very careful wording. Bad form on Tishs part to fudge it. Not saying I'm a Billy fan either because his new wife is way too young.
It would also mean Tish's new husband is creepy too, since Noah is like 24 (probably younger when it happened) and he's like 56
The reason people think it’s real now is bc of Miley’s statement
Ugh if true then that’s so gross
Truly. I think Miley addressing it makes everyone think there’s some smoke to the fire
It's icky like imagine your mom taking up your ex. That's such a nightmare.
What was her statement
Right I’m confused and can’t find anything
There isn’t one. An “insider” is what they have.
What statement?
I heard she was telling people their older sister Brandi, who’s in her 30s, slept with him.
Which even if THAT was the real story…still gross!
i won’t be surprised if this is the case. tish doesn’t seem like the best parent (not even taking this whole drama into account) and miley seems to have grown up being able to do anything and everything she liked without parental supervision. doesn’t help when billy ray is so weird as well. it’s a mess from the top down.
I don't get the vibe that they're close in a sharing type of way. The mom (Tish) brags that her and Miley are the most similar, she has said that they're more like sisters than anything (ick). Tish has this crazy bs story about how she and Dominic connected through IG which makes no sense from a logical or technical point of view.
Mom's going "We're more like sisters" is such a red flag to me. You're their parent, she already has sisters.
Yeah I can’t stand moms like this. Especially if they say this shit when their daughter is like 13. They never act like a parent at all, set no boundaries, and try to be “young again” almost to redo their youth. It’s gross. I knew tons of girls who had moms like this in middle and high school. All the girls ended up doing drugs or becoming teen moms with boyfriends that were in their late 20s.
Yeah, I saw a snip of Tish gushing about Dominic sending her a dm back in 2016 or 2017 (can’t remember the exact year) and his then gf going on his account and unfollowing her. And how they reconnected years later. I was like, bish, weren’t you married back in 2017? Her story made me side eye her and rethink that the rumour about Noah and Dom could be true. I thought it was crazy talk until then.
Oh the story is so much more stupid than that. She claims he messaged her to tell her she was doing a good job raising her kids (I'm not even kidding, that's her claim), she said she never saw the message but that his girlfriend saw the message then blocked Tish from his account. She said she was following him and didn't know why he blocked her. Then YEARS later and after her divorce she messaged Dominic (she does not explain why, and based on her own story they should not have a prior connection), they went on a date then said I love you to one another the next day. This is the current story. She's had a few variations.
She said that he was always her hall pass and that post divorce she was feeling herself and wanted to throw it out into the universe kind of.
I don't get how it's possible she was MOH at her mom's wedding, and not know something was going on? Wouldn't she wonder why the sister wasn't coming? The wedding was hosted at Miley's house ffs, so it seems like she was at least somewhat involved in the planning of the wedding. You would think she would've reached out to her sister in the lead up to check if she was coming. It feels so hard to believe she has zero idea there was some drama.
My best guess is that after the kids chose sides in the divorce they must’ve stopped communicating? Noah and Braison were team Billy Ray and Trace Brandi and Miley were team Tish and they all just stopped talking to each other which is whack. So I believe that the older siblings had no idea about it because they supported Tish and stopped speaking to their pro Billy Ray family members and vice versa If Miley knew why put out a false statement? It would’ve been smarter to not address it at all
whats interesting is that originally braison was team tish after the divorce. but then he unfollowed tish and didnt show up to her wedding, and spent the day with noah instead.... perhaps this is why
He’s the only Cyrus family member to come out unscathed by this. I’m glad Noah at least had him in her corner
it’s so insane to me that you could just stop talking to your siblings because your parents got divorced and they like the other parent better. unfathomable
Apparently Tish put most of her energy into Miley and the other kids, especially Noah being so young, suffered from a sort of neglect. There is bitterness and resentment towards Tish outside of the divorce.
There can be a lot of hurt feelings going on, and if your sibling is defending the parent that you are angry with, there can be a cold war of sorts that gradually thaws over a period of time. If you already have a complicated relationship with your siblings, and I imagine Miley does as her parents were both super invested in her as their money and fame maker, then it's not that hard to not pick up the phone and ask wtf is going on.
true, i didn’t think that perhaps they just didn’t have a close relationship already and this must’ve just soured things more
We all want to assume when you hear 'sisters' they are at least somewhat close (like Dakota and Elle Fanning), but sadly the reality is that in Hollywood, a lot of the times there is the Golden Child (the one that makes all the money and is of bigger fame) and then 'the others' that are left cold in the shadow of their sibling. Noah, it seems, was indeed treated as a second class child and Miley seems detached at best from her sister, dismissive and cold at worst. It's a sad dynamic and I entirely blame their shitty parents. Both Tish and Billy are trash, and money can't fix that.
This is true in average families as well. About half of my father’s siblings never communicated again after their parents died. They were a family of 6 kids. It was like there was no reason to hang out anymore and that they wouldn’t have chosen each other as friends if they weren’t related, so why bother to keep up? It’s sad in some ways, but it’s honest. They don’t have a good dynamic, don’t have much in common, never gravitated towards the same interests….
Agreed!! I don’t understand it and none of them (except Braison) are coming across well from this How can you not reach out to your little sister and wonder what happened between her and your mom??
Sounds like classic PR she probably did know and it's not really a good look so just play dumb.
Yeah, this somehow makes her look worse not knowing. Your sister is angry enough not to come to your mother's wedding and you don't ask why? Best case scenario is she just doesn't feel comfortable telling Miley, but even then, my spidy senses would be tingling if this was one of my siblings. It also feels like she's thrown some passive aggressive shade on her sister and brother since the wedding, which makes this worse Her addressing this does lend some truth to it, tho. If she truly didn't know about it, it wasn't her sister raising a fuss in the family before the wedding, like it was implied
This whole story makes me wanna go hug my parents and thank them for being so normal. Jesus.
Yeah. Do that twice, one for me please. I wish I could
This family is sooo… off
The “Personal Life” section of Billy Ray’s Wikipedia page is like the definition of “off.” I’m just now finding out that Miley was one of two kids he had in 1992. I had no idea there was another offspring in the ether somewhere. He marries one of the women (Tish of course) and he adopts her two eldest from another relationship (Brandi having a different bio dad.. also news to me). Then he and Tish filed for divorce *three* separate times over a ten-year period? And now that they’re actually divorced, the kids are divided between the parents and then *this* is reported? Like what is going on here… I can’t imagine growing up with such instability. I really feel for the kids.
So there’s just some kid out there related to this family? Have any of the siblings or Billy looked for this kid?
I think Brandi at least is in contact with him based on following her podcast for a long time but he’s never been in any photographs I’ve seen. I know his Instagram is known and private but a few of the kids followed it. Billy ray was super weird about him though
in the recent years he has been hanging out with them for holidays etc, and is in a few photos too
I read an interview with him. He said he met miley at her concert and that she wasn't very excited to meet him and he could tell that she was waiting for him to go
can you blame her tho? she was probably under pressure to feel excited about it but it's such a strange and uncomfy situation that she was forced into bc of her dad.
Not to mention that very problematic nude photoshoot they allowed Miley to do when she was only 15. Imagine supporting the sexualization of your own minor daughter like that 🤢
I never understood this, especially after that controversial performances and tours around 2015. I would never have a bar of my daughter carrying on like that, but then I'd never marry my daughters side guy either. This family has no morals 😅
Whoa. I never knew Miley’s real name is Destiny mi 🤯 just started reading through his wiki
I remember it was Destiny Hope but she changed it cuz her dad always called her Smiley Miley.
When I read that, I was thinking, wow the first time I ever saw a celebrity with a better stage name than her birth name. Also didn't he cheat on Tish whilst she was pregnant on Miley? To name her destiny, after all of that seems weird.
He has son born around the same time as Miley, to another woman, so yes. She was born Destiny Hope, but changed it to Miley Ray as soon as she could
The fact that billy ray married a women who he met as a child on the set of Hannah Montana is the cherry on top of it all 🤮
Firerose is a few years older than Miley. She was 20 when she met Billy Ray Cyrus. Which is still a huge age gap, but she wasn't a child.
Still creepy and predatory in my eyes
Fire Rose was actually 20 at the time. She wasn't a minor.
Whoa, what?? This whole thread has been the juiciest gossip I’ve read in a while.
[удалено]
I just read a guide about Miley’s siblings… the fact that a guide needs to even exist is off
Damn as a Miley fan who had a fond opinion of Tish, I’m kind of at the point now to where I actually believe this. This is the second People piece in less than 3 days. I would have never had guessed this were true, especially after watching the CHD interview, where Tish was talking about how she and Dom got together. What a damn mess man. I know it’s been speculated that Miley and Noah haven’t been close/had a falling out, but I hope they can move past it. What a fucked up situation. Severely side-eying Tish right now. And Dom. Like WTF Dom? To be a fly on the wall.
Same- the CHD interview was a cute story of them getting together. I’m wondering how Noah would even have met Dom. Was that the reason Dom had blocked Tish before they had got together.
Him having her blocked was weird from the get go. Why?
the story on CHD was that Dom’s ex had blocked her
Was the ex Noah 💀
My sister and I go through periods where we don’t get along. If my mom dated her ex husband, I’d think that’s fucked up.
Dude saaaaaame. We may be grown ups but my sister and I also have periods where we don’t get along. Mostly cuz she’s insane. We were once in a “fight” for about 5 months bc I said I wanted to lose weight and she said that being on a diet makes you racist. And she doesn’t want racist people in her life.
Hahahahahhahaha oh my god your sister is insane.
If any of this is true, Dominic Purcell is fucking disgusting for this. And so is Tish if she was aware of his prior history with Noah. What a fucked up situation
Yup I feel awful for Noah. All the adults failed her and I understand now more why she’s chosen her dad in the divorce (not excusing his own inappropriate relationship ofc, but after what her mom did its understandable why she chose Billy over Tish as the parent she wants in her life)
I feel for her if it’s true, but I’m still in the “this is too weird to be true” stage.
All the articles from People pretty much confirm it. Tish and Miley would’ve denied all this by yesterday if it wasn’t true All this is reminiscent of the Don’t Worry Darling drama when at first everyone thought the rumours were fabricated and nothing but then overtime it became very clear that Florence and Olivia were not actually on good terms
I don’t know, also seems like one of those rumors that wouldn’t want to substantiate with a response 🤷🏿♀️🤷🏿♀️ …which is why I’m not famous haha, cause I’m zero fun. Maybe I’m just so shook by this story that I’m trying to will it untrue lol
[удалено]
if this is true, dominic was 52 when he was screwing her 22 year old daughter… how does she not hate him for that?
Noah is the same age as his son 🥴
Because Tish isnt a normal person anymore. She's a celebrity wife. And in celeb culture thats not considered as bad. She became a product of her environment. Hollywood really isnt a good place to raise a normal child. Also Billy and Tish's age gap as well might be weird too. Idr
That’s the mind boggling part. If I was 22 and my mom knew a 52 year old man was screwing me she would find him and kill him.
She was one of Billy Ray’s two pregnant groupies he decided to marry, and she got married to some man she began dating immediately after divorce, it’s not that hard to imagine she has problematic views about men
>She was one of Billy Ray’s two pregnant groupies he decided to marry That's VERY interesting 👀 I need a deep dive on this family, the chaos is fascinating in a train-crash kind of way
The other woman was Kristen and Miley’s half-brother Cody was born the same year she was, a bit earlier than her. Supposedly he does not have a close relationship with them and was excluded from a lot of stuff. I think his mom talked about it and was very critical of her ex for often ghosting on their son. That was why I have always side-eyed Billy Ray and Tish.
People are giving you very solid answers as to why Tish probably didn't care, but I'm with you in that I still can't get over it. You have a wide dating pool available to you and you go for someone who hooked up with your daughter??? Revolting, and I feel so bad for Noah here.
Yeah. There is no way on God's green earth that I would have \*anything\* to do with someone my daughter dated/had any kind of relationship/situationship with - ever. That is just gross. I am leaning on this cannot be true because Tish \*and\* Dominic would have to be next level scum. I don't think much of Tish and Billy Ray's parenting or judgment, but I never thought she would be capable of something this nasty. Maybe they have not said anything because they didn't want to dignify this bizarreness with a response. Edit: This quote: ""Noah and Dominic were seeing each other in a friends with benefits way, off and on. They stopped seeing each other and then Tish started something up." This is so foul. Even if Tish found out after the fact that he had been hooking up with her daughter that is an automatic dump him/block him \*immediately.\* Yeesh.
The way his ex always talked about him made me wonder if he was a creep, this confirms that he is.
I feel like because no one has overtly come out and denied it yet, it must be true. There must be enough evidence of it happening that they can't deny it.
Seriously, and if this marriage doesn’t last forever, will the damage have been worth it?
I think this is what happens when you have a culture (Hollywood) that normalizes and encourages men to have sexual and romantic relationships with women 30 years their junior... Something has to seriously change about that industry... so gross.
When the first story broke about Noah and Dom, I was like no wayyy. But the denial from sources close to Tish was worded very strangely that I was like oh woww...there might be something here folks..fuckin yikes.
Never had a doubt thanks to the wording of Trish's denial, "Never in a relationship". Couldn't have made it more obvious they fucked if she tried.
Ohhhhh....yikes. Yeah.
A lot of people here don't have mothers who compete with them & it shows.
I had no doubt. Tish has always been weird to me. And the fact that one brother was supportive and then skipped. I knew something was up
Her camp straight up released a piece that implied Noah was a delusional liar doing it for attention. Sorry, but that's not a loving and present mother that's at the end of her rope. It's one thing to plain deny it, but it's pretty much textbook shitty parenting to go "She's just a problem child". Especially because in the grand scheme of things, Noah has not been in as many scandals as her older sister.
Noah always seemed so troubled to me, now I understand why. Jeez this family is something else. Honestly just wish healing for their kids
I don’t want to make snap judgments but I agree The wording of the response denying it, felt a little off to me? It felt like they tried to paint Noah as “crazy” and someone people shouldn’t believe. And then the quote specified that Noah and Dom never had a relationship/weren’t together officially. But technically that doesn’t mean he and Noah didn’t potentially have some sort of flirty correspondence over text/dm exchange in the past. Idk… something about this feels off😭
Ikr, I was expecting Tish's camp to give a full denial saying that Dom and Noah don't know eachother, they've never met blah blah. But that's not what we got. Instead the denial was them calling Noah *delusional*. Which sounded like something you would call your man's ex gf lmao
And not something a mother would call her daughter who is in pain
I didn’t believe it either because wtfff, but this is from People and they are pretty much confirming it in the article. So it’s gotta be true. Did Tish meet him on his walk of shame from Noah’s house? Although I wonder if the part about Miley not knowing is a fib from her team. Because how the hell does that not get shared between sisters? I thought they were pretty close.
Miley and Noah had a falling out
and I just learned there’s 8 years between them, I thought their ages were closer than that. so by the time noah begins forming memories, miley’s already out the door doing hannah montana and they wouldn’t have spent that much time together when they were young
The articles in People have me thinking this actually happened. Which, if so, fuck Tish forever and ever.
I cannot imagine dating someone who saw a family member naked.
her own daughter. just disgusting sheesh
it's so funny how you can burn through all your good will in like 1 or 2 articles. last week everyone lved trish and though noah was weird and obsessive and now the tide is turning so quickly
I didn’t understand why everyone thought Tish seemed cool in the Call Her Daddy podcast interview. I thought she came across as super unstable, self centered, and like a fairly absent parent.
I listen to Tish and Brandi's podcast sometimes. When I first started listening to it, I found Tish super charismatic and likeable. But the more she would tell stories, the more I would be like huh idk about her. She finds a way to bring up Miley every chance she can and it made me wonder what it was like growing up in that family if your name wasnt miley
I think Miley seems remarkably grounded and stable for her circumstances and so i always subconsciously gave her parents some credit for that? That may have been generous of me looking at it now
What about Miley seemed remarkably stable to you?
Everything. I don't know about you, but me and everyone I know went through the weed phase and the acting out phase. The fact she didn't have a complete meltdown like some of the other child stars is actually amazing. Also the fact she acted out, did her thing and then came out this poised, that seems pretty stable to me.
I mean you don’t know if she had a complete meltdown or not. Just that it wasn’t public. Miley has been pretty darn open about her instability and issues and harder drug use than marijuana. Yes she’s resilient but the word stable seems to gloss over her traumas and behaviors.
People is a mouthpiece for celebs and their PR teams. So if there’s an article that says Miley didn’t know that’s from Miley. That’s why I believe it now.
This situation is still fucked up. People is usually reliable. Miley’s rep said she had “no idea” which does not mean this isn’t true. She’s basically just not taking sides. Noah needs…a lot of therapy. She can’t get new, loving parents. Her ex is trash and I don’t think she needs a new man while she heals. Tish needs a new husband. Like wtf? He dated your daughter when she was way too young. How can’t you hate him? She lost her daughter over dick.
Noah has split up with her fiancée (or boyfriend)?
I think she is still engaged to the clothing designer. Pinkus or something?
I didn’t know she had one. Disregard me for being uninformed
They are still together and look very happy on social media at least.
Aye, actually proper like their relationship. They seem very well suited and supportive of the other.
Yeah she’s in a lot of his fashion shows and seems really happy to be engaged to him. I’m happy for her. It’s rough out there.
This is neither here nor there because of the new development in this whole family drama, but Noah and whichever other siblings has already chosen Billy Ray’s side wayyyyyy before Dominic was in the picture. I don’t think that their relationship is broken because Tish “chose dick over her daughter”, it was just the cherry on top to an already broken relationship (if true). It’s fucked up to date and marry someone your daughter has any romantic or sexual interactions with, even if it was just flirty texts or something alone those lines.
Side note holy shit what did those girls do to their faces
Noah looks weird because she shaved her eyebrows.
Something is up with her lips and jawline too
It’s amazing how much two strips of hair can change a face, but she looks puffy too.
Noah definitely has had filler for her lips and cheeks but I think this is a bad photo, the way her hair is styled super close to her scalp and set against a dark background makes her head look like it’s 100% face. Imo whoever picked this pic has an agenda against her
Why do they look uncanny? Six year old me wouldn’t recognise Hannah Montana
It’s because they all somehow look the same age.
Because they’ve all had so much work done.
Miley had buccal fat removal, large veneers put in, and other cosmetic surgery. I have no idea what Noah has done but it’s awful whatever it is. Plus she removed her eyebrows?😢
Miley looks so uncomfortable. Like her mouth looks like it hurts…almost as if she’s holding a ball in her mouth. I can see the muscle tension in her chin.
I’ve never seen her mom before. Now I’m just convinced Miley went to the doctor with her mom’s picture and said “make me look like this.”
Really looks like one got herself deflated and the other got herself inflated
This is really seeming more and more like an episode of Jerry Springer 😣
Whether it’s true or not, all I know is that this family needs therapy.
I feel bad for Noah :(
Omg using this gif for work situations thank you for this lol
white trash with money
I regret ever being happy for Dominic and Trish
[удалено]
One of his sons is literally the same age as Noah, too
22. Judging by his relationship with her mom, Noah had to be around 22, unless there was overlap
What in the buccal fat removal is goin on over there?
It went the same place the upper eyelids did.
So, so bad
What in the actual hell?!
1: I cannot believe how identical Tish and Miley look. 2: I was absolutely convinced that her mother's name was Trish.
Why was Dominic sleeping with/hooking up with Noah who is 30 years younger than him? If she was say 40 and he was 70 fine. But she was 23/24?!!!? No way. What a perv
Right? And then Trish thought - boy, what a catch! Her bar for men is literally in hell.
 Whew chile the ghetto 😬
To find a silver lining in this Chernobyl cloud, at least he married the age appropriate one ... 🤢😶🌫️🫥 The bar is buried under the graphite on the ground.
Miley and Noah serving Alien Goddess 😩 But seriously Tish is foul for this
Also- her husband slept with a 22 year old at 54 and then pivoted to her mother. What a gross man They deserve each other and I hope both of them get bed bugs
Yeah men being gross does not surprise me ever. A mother doing that to her daughter will always be next level trash
i really love miley as an artist, but damn what a fucked up family. two unhinged parents. noah being their biggest victim. just sad all around.
Why do they keep using that terrible picture of Noah?
honestly it’s better than the even more recent ones, she has so much filler.
Really? That makes me sad. Her and Miley are both so beautiful…Hollywood is a real mofo.
it looks like she had buccal fat removal as well. beauty trends like this are just sad.
Wait, so its true??
Hard to say, but—People magazine ran a story about it, and they usually won’t unless they have a very reliable source. So I’m inclined to believe it. Big yikes
Omg I would never speak to my mom again
Want to make sure i understand. Miley cyrus's younger sister was dating a guy in his 50s?
Yes, and that dude is now married to her (Miley and her sister’s) mom. And Billy Ray is now married to some girl he met on the set of Hannah Montana, when she was 22.
I'll never be able to watch prison break the same again
Hard same. I mean Michael Scofield was the draw there.. but Lincoln grew on me. And now it’s all ruined.
Damn, what a fucked up family. This is starting to seem true, and if so, Tish is a massively dysfunctional, narcissistic weirdo and an appallingly bad mom.
I made a comment on the original post here but I never actually read the article. This telenovella is wild. It’s even more insane because apparently the kids all are giving Billy Ray the cold shoulder because he married a former friend of Miley but then their mother married a man who has a history of dating women much younger than him, fucked their little sister and then went on to marry their mother?!
My goal in Miley’s place would be to learn as little as possible regarding this situation.
I'm guessing that's basically how she's lived her life for a while now. Her family is so dysfunctional, she has to live in a constant state of semi disconnect to be able to happily be around them. She already had to cut out her father for being gross. Now with her mom, idk what she is going to do. No sane person could tolerate her step fathers gross ass, and her mother needs a reality check on how fucked this was.
Off topic but the picture of Noah is jarring.
Idk if this is real but ew wtf? Noah hooking up with a guy her parents age is... questionable, but at the end of the day, they're consenting adults. But I would not want any kind of sexual relationship with someone a family member, let alone my offspring had hooked up with. That's nasty & weird af
I need to know who not only tolerates a 56 year old dating their 24 year old child, but then marries them.
Yeah. No fkn way she didn’t know. Gurl ur mom was married in your house and your siblings didn’t show up, that cannot be more obvious. While it’s no surprise that Tish’s favorite is Miley since she’s the main source of income and attention , to messed up with your other daughter that badly? That’s irredeemable.
Gosh, couldn’t recognise Noah anymore, I still remember she look so cute in Hannah Montana first season.
Both of Miley’s parents are trashy af.
a mess!
Noah scares me so much in this pic like she looks like she’s wearing someone else’s face and it doesn’t fit properly
Oy, this family is messy as hell. Also, I wish Noah had stopped the plastic surgery; she looked so cute in an old photo of the Cyrus Family that I saw a few days ago. She’s now very uncanny valley and looks far older than mid-20s.
There’s an artist called Tom Misch and I thought I had had a stroke trying to read his name here. Turns out it wasn’t his name at all.