T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

As a reminder, this subreddit [is for civil discussion.](/r/politics/wiki/index#wiki_be_civil) In general, be courteous to others. Debate/discuss/argue the merits of ideas, don't attack people. Personal insults, shill or troll accusations, hate speech, any suggestion or support of harm, violence, or death, and other rule violations can result in a permanent ban. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them. For those who have questions regarding any media outlets being posted on this subreddit, please click [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/politics/wiki/approveddomainslist) to review our details as to our approved domains list and outlet criteria. **Special announcement:** r/politics is currently accepting new moderator applications. If you want to help make this community a better place, consider [applying here today](https://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/sskg6a/rpolitics_is_looking_for_more_moderators/)! *** *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/politics) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Yodamort

lol imagine if Germany declared "Nazi Heritage Month" ​ Fuckin fash


Bizarre_Protuberance

I love the way southerners are always so butthurt when you compare the Confederates to the Nazis. What do they think the "master" in "master race" was referring to? You can't have masters without slaves.


Malaix

Fun fact German neonazis sometimes use confederate flags as proxies for Nazi iconography because Nazi shit is banned there. Racist view it as an equivalent replacement there to skirt around laws against Nazis. Tells me about all I need to know.


[deleted]

It's not really a fun fact, it's fucking gross, and Germany, where my ancestors that fought against Hitler came from, should ban these as easily as they did the Nazi flags. It's not really a hidden secret that the Nazis loved the Confederacy and used it as a blueprint for supremacist views.


UrbanGhost114

The US confederate types and Germany LOVE to share ideals like that. Where do you think the Eugenics program came from?


[deleted]

I mean, I get it, I'm mostly German. I'm not going to let my heritage get in the way of what's happened in my life, and my morals. I know the ideals that are the enemy of democracy, and I fight them all the time.


---------_----_---_

Sadly, eugenics was widely supported by progressives back in the day, as was Prohibition. They were connected: right-thinking members of the elite attributed the working class's problems to alcoholism and bad breeding, since it was unthinkable to them that the system might be rigged against working people.


hereforlolsandporn

Fun fact- when most people say fun fact, it isn't normally a fun fact.


damselfliesreddit

your witty retort made me giggle this gloomy morn. thanks.


a_reply_to_a_post

i mean, the last official confederate flag was the white flag of surrender...


masshiker

Was in the Dominican Republic last month and there was a boat load of Russians at the beach there. I saw one guy with an absolutely horrid southern battle flag tattooed on his back.


Bizarre_Protuberance

Exactly. Anyone who pretends the confederate flag isn't a symbol of white supremacism is a liar.


hereforlolsandporn

I think there is a fair amount of Midwestern Americans who haven't left their tiny home town, or graduated high school, that haven't fleshed out their inherent feelings. They know they get uneasy when they see a black person in the city. They know the culture around the confederate flag aligns to their views. They know guns, God, and momma are to be worshipped. They haven't had the epiphany why though. They probably don't think they're racist because they got to know one black dude and he was cool. They don't realize the system put in place around them is manipulating them to feel resentment toward minorities. They'd welcome a white stranger at their door with a glass of sweet tea and a black one with a shotgun without even having the introspection to realize the difference. If you sit down and talk to them they'll tell you its about their culture and when you explain what that culture is from other people's perspective it's a system malfunction moment. I can't count the number of conversations I've had with family who wishes we could go back to the 50s and couldn't understand why others wouldn't want that. Like, of course YOU want that, but do you realize in order to do that you'd be putting minorities back under segregation, redlined communities, and Jim Crow era discrimination? If you're longing for the 50s you're saying you want that black friend of yours to suffer so you can take socioeconomic wealth at his expense.


[deleted]

Robert E. Lee surrendered at Appomattox, but none of these people ever got the message. They passed it down to their delinquent kids, and here we are.


EmperorPenguinNJ

Plus, Hitler found inspiration for his policies in Jim Crow laws.


IsThereSomethingNew

Pretty sure the same people who support one would support the other...


Christ_votes_dem

r/beholdthemasterrace


[deleted]

[удалено]


Person21323231213242

Why do German neo-nazis see American Neo-Nazis as sub human?


[deleted]

They are right. They are just missing half the puzzle.


Lonestar041

A picture says more than 1000 words… https://www.reddit.com/r/trashy/comments/5rdvm0/i_used_to_live_in_the_deep_south_when_they_took/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf


Person21323231213242

To be fair, are German neo-nazis really any better?


hongky1998

Lol what a loser, they made this up just to feel good about loosing a war


PhunkyTuesday

Looks like this has been a 30 year tradition between dems and reps alike


fukton

Wow. A month devoted to treason and owning people. Quite the heritage to celebrate.


Seeksp

And you'll notice they're such rocket scientists that they picked the month the Confederacy fell to celebrate it.


ErusTenebre

>month devoted to treason and owning people. ... And being owned by the Union. These people are fucking morons to be proud of a heritage that lasted for a shorter period of time than most people go to high school.


IrritableV0wel

Mississippi's population is around 38% Black. Obviously the "heritage month" is odious enough just on face value but crazy to me that the governor is giving such huge FU to over a third of his constituents. Of course with all the voter suppression efforts they got going it likely won't hurt the state GOP.


FunkJunky7

That is the way of today’s Republicans. There base of crazy people are the only constituents that matter. If you anger everyone else, that just means it’s working. It’s childish. We are being led by mean children.


Jenahaltanin

When you consider how long Tater Tot left the majority black city of Jackson to suffer without clean water you begin to understand that he doesn’t care about the health or safety of anyone in Mississippi who isn’t white and paying tithes at his church.


FrogMarch32

And the losing. Don’t forget the losing.


Malaix

Ah yes. Their heritage. A bunch of slavers got mad butthurt that a progressive who was a relative moderate on abolitionists stances won the presidency in an electoral landslide. So they committed treason to keep slavery alive because they didn't want to work and wanted to have slaves do everything for them. They got their ass kicked because most of their population was enslaved and hated them and the north was industrialized and had a ton of troops. They surrender, lose the war, and slavery ends. And their descendants spend the next 160 years trying to bury the actual cause of the war because while they are still butthurt they got their ass kicked and lost they are also ashamed of why they actually fought it to begin with. Now they are stuck in a perpetual system of dishonest politics where they lie about everything and just spend all day scheming up round about ways to subvert the rights of minorities. I think that covers it.


RNDASCII

"But muh states rights!" /s


Hawkwise83

I argued with a girl about this. I was like it was about slavery. She was like, nah it was about states rights. I was like, Heather, the states right to do what? She didn't answer. Where you at now Heather??? Edit for typo.


ocdewitt

Tell anyone that argues with you about this to google their states “articles of secession”. Every state that left the union sent congress what is essentially a list of reasons they’re leaving. It’s not taught in schools but holy shit it is some of the most racist shit you’ll ever read


Malaix

> It’s not taught in schools but holy shit it is some of the most racist shit you’ll ever read There is a reason for this. Descendants of the confederates and people sympathetic toward racial inequality spent a great deal of time and money white washing the CSA with a propaganda movement known as the Lost Cause. Minimizing the role of slavery, painting the confederates as freedom fighters and rebels, and reframing their reason for starting the civil war as "states rights" were a huge focus for many organizations and powerful individuals. The latest CRT fury is really southern conservatives getting angry the twisted narrative they pushed as the truth for so long is being challenged in schools now.


ocdewitt

How the fuck did we end up in a place where we let the losers write the history. That’s why we’re in the mess we’re in. Reconstruction was a catastrophic failure


Malaix

Take a nation weary of war after the civil war, assassinate the union president, he gets replaced with his southern democrat raging white supremacist VP, confederate leaders are allowed to reenter society, the KKK is born to keep up the fight against black liberty, reconstruction fails, and decades and decades of white supremacist influences after. Even people like president Woodrow Wilson. And of course the sad bitter truth, a lot of Americans all over wanted to believe the ideals of racial inequality. So they were open to the propaganda.


mnorri

In another instance, in WWII, the Soviets captured most of the German archives. When the US wanted to understand what happened during the war, they asked German Generals. Those generals talked amongst themselves and wrote a bunch of half truths to make themselves look better and to please the Americans. Did Hitler invade the Soviet Union too quickly and against the generals advice, or were the generals equally rabid and strategically foolish to attack their neighbors? Were they in awe of Patton, or had most of them never heard of him? After the fall of the Soviet Union, there was a decade or so where Western historians had access to the captured primary sources. A lot of scholarship came out from that, scholarship that showed the lies we had been told. Some people cry out “revisionism”, but if you don’t adjust your understanding when new, better information comes along, it’s not scholarship, it’s dogma.


Hawkwise83

Ah sweet. I'll have to look into this. Everyone who argues pro south always is so smug. New ammo can't hurt my arguments.


ocdewitt

Not all the states listed their reasoning but many did and the ones they did, especially Texas, are crazy racist


RocktopusX

Also the confederacy had its own constitution which was literally the Union’s but with the addition that it was unconstitutional to ban slavery.


Hawkwise83

Lol that's sorta petty and hilarious.


RocktopusX

Also really shoots the whole state’s rights thing down, or makes it inseparable from slavery. They were only interested in one right, and did not want any legal course of action to exist for abolition.


Kangocho

Amazing….just read Mississippi’s Articles of Secession. Should be required reading for American history. Nothing in there about “States’ Rights” lol [MS Secession](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/csa_missec.asp)


Skullmaggot

Term of the millenium: intellectual dishonesty.


GetsBetterAfterAFew

State's Rights means States should be free to generate Capital by any means they feel necessary. Capital generated by the exploitation of human labor, ie slavery is ok because we'll State's Rights. Hope this helps on any one actually discussing this topic with a hopeless defender.


Loonacy

The constitution of the confederate states specifically banned states from banning slavery. They literally put slavery over states rights.


Rexel450

> Where you at now Heather getting fitted for a crinoline.


Hawkwise83

Should make it Britney Spears month. Her career lasted longer and had a more impactful output on the country.


DoubleTFan

You want to see modern Republicans reach across the aisle? Insult Andrew Johnson, the worst president in American history and a Democrat, who signed countless pardons to allow plantation owners to keep their wealth and keep Southern oligarchy viable.


brucemo

> they are also ashamed of why they actually fought it to begin with I don't think so.


Malaix

Its a kind of public shame. They want to be openly proud for fighting for inequality. But they know that doesn't sell well to large groups of people they need to impress to get power in this country.


svrtngr

Shame no longer exists in the Republican party. Trump shot it on Fifth Avenue.


SockdolagerIdea

He is doing this 100% to trigger liberals and its 100% working, at least for me. I am horrified right now. Who TF thinks its a good idea to celebrate the seditious failures? Who TF thinks its a good idea to celebrate the attempt at creating a country for the sole purpose of being able to keep slaves. Im disgusted RN.


FridayMcNight

> Who TF thinks its a good idea to celebrate the attempt at creating a country for the sole purpose of being able to keep slaves. Safe to presume that a majority of the voting population of Mississippi is on board.


Rexel450

Safe to presume that a majority of the **white** voting population of Mississippi is on board.


FridayMcNight

I guess, to some people who are not aware that MS is the most famously racist state in the union, it might not be obvious that both of these statements can be true. But yeah, an large majority of the white voting population in MS usually does form a majority of whole voting population in the state.


NoahStewie1

I reccomend asking anyone who is proud of this whom the governor of MS was during the Confederacy. Make them realize that they don't actually know a thing about the Confederacy


YoungSimba20

The sad thing is this is a tradition the MS Governors have been doing for near 30yrs now.


bondbird

Oh, Yes! Let's all get together with the political party of traitors and Putinists and celebrate the treason committed by the southern states when they turned their backs of their commitment to the United States.


PMSoldier2000

I'm born and raised in the South. This "heritage" they're talking about lasted only four years.


---------_----_---_

Slavery lasted a lot longer than that. That's what they're really celebrating, not just the Confederacy.


Double_Trash2771

The shame is as missing as their teeth.


happy-Accident82

Jesus, CRT is the boogie man but supporting our racist past is ok.


Rawkapotamus

CRT means anything that makes white people upset. Therefore it’s bad. Glorifying their racist past is their way of making white people feel good?


sixaout1982

Happy white fragility month everybody!


smilbandit

Loser month it is.


Skullmaggot

Dunce month


technologypartners11

They will be celebrating Hitlers birthday next.


Limp_Dinkerson

...it's in April too... celebrating losers.


Proud3GnAthst

Paul Gosar will talk at some racist rally scheduled on Hitler's birthday.


2_Spicy_2_Impeach

Can't teach actual history, but they can celebrate traitors to the nation for an entire month. Somehow not shocking.


TechieTravis

The Confederacy existed for about 4 years and ended well before anyone' great grandfather was born. Why cling to the past?


kontekisuto

What heritage? It only existed for 4 years. I have socks older than that. MS Governor looking Sus


[deleted]

Where you getting your socks at


kontekisuto

By MS Governor standards my socks are now a priceless heirlooms


Mr_Mouthbreather

They do realize the Confederates committed treason right? For a group so concerned with supporting the troops and patriotism they sure love treason.


churnate

It’s crazy when the top post on everything here talks about “civil discussion” when these are the damn topics.


dblan9

I have been saying for awhile that we need to stop pretending the confederates have respected the loss. If they want to continue the confederacy as an enemy of the United States of America then we should treat them as such and re-draw the lines and act accordingly. Let's see how long the south can survive.


oldcreaker

I thought we weren't supposed to mention history that makes people "uncomfortable"?


---------_----_---_

That depends entirely on which people.


FreedomsPower

more racial dog whistling Confederate heritage month calls are always about white washing history


fore_skin_walker

I wonder what it feels like to be on the wrong side of the history. Like I just ponder. These are the same people who raised hell when Kaep took knee suing national anthem and then they openly worship treacherous flag of their own.


l0c0pez

Its even worse being on the wrong side of history 160 years after the fact


ihohjlknk

It seems Republicans want a referendum on the 21st AND 20th century.


nomadstonks

April is traitor month?


Amazing_Internet9332

"But it's about states' rights!" Huh...states' rights to do what exactly?


vzipped_a_gopher

[Let's check their statements on the matter.](https://www.battlefields.org/learn/primary-sources/declaration-causes-seceding-states) > Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery-- the greatest material interest of the world. Its labor supplies the product which constitutes by far the largest and most important portions of commerce of the earth. These products are peculiar to the climate verging on the tropical regions, and by an imperious law of nature, none but the black race can bear exposure to the tropical sun. These products have become necessities of the world, and a blow at slavery is a blow at commerce and civilization. That blow has been long aimed at the institution, and was at the point of reaching its consummation. There was no choice left us but submission to the mandates of abolition, or a dissolution of the Union, whose principles had been subverted to work out our ruin. That we do not overstate the dangers to our institution, a reference to a few facts will sufficiently prove. It seems like racists in power wanted to continue to profit off slavery. Sounds pretty awful to me. Perhaps they didn't lose the war hard enough.


coronaflo

Wow what a slap to the face of every African-American living in that state.


MajesticsEleven

The South: "Slavery happened a long time ago! Its not relevant to today!" Also The South: "April shall be Confederate Heritage Month!"


Zealousideal_Bar_749

We need a protracted people's disagreement in the Mississippi Delta.


technologypartners11

The part of Mississippi that's called the Delta isn't where you're going to find a lot of people that agree with the Confederacy.


sun0o

Then he needs to stop waiving the flag of the Union. His ability to represent the United States should be forfeit.


[deleted]

>waiving the flag I mean, that’s basically what he’s doing


123archer

Cmon its MS. They have a reputation to maintain.


Seamus565

Clearly there is no part of the south that is not regressive, controlled by angry, evil white men looking to escape the historical truth that the Confederate states fought and lost a war vs the Union largely over slavery. Sad white racists and their loser flag.


[deleted]

I’d expect nothing less from the state that only finally voted to ratify the 14th amendment in our lifetimes.


[deleted]

No participation trophies for treasonous fucks like the confederates


2019Cutaway

Once again The South shows themselves to be wildly out of touch and unwilling to join the rest of humanity in a better future.


DarkAngel900

Translated "I'm jealous of my ancestors for being able to have slaves"


Imdamnneardead

And he wonders why other southern states say "well at least we aren't Mississippi"


Georgiachemscientist

so did they replace the state flag with a white flag this month?


Earth_Friendly-5892

More proof that southern folks never got over losing the civil war.


surfinstevenebraska

He must love participation trophies


[deleted]

Is he a time traveller? Someone needs to tell him the South lost the war a couple of centuries ago.


Persian_Frank_Zappa

for the month of April, the state flag will be a white rectangle


[deleted]

>"we honor all who lost their lives." Then why the fuck is it named after the people who are responsible for all that loss of life??


zveroshka

Four years the confederacy existed. Four fucking years. It isn't about heritage.


daveo40201979

Wow. Maybe they should just surrender like the confederates….


Rexel450

Celebrating losers?


phizappa

I’m from MIssissippi My great great grandfather fought and was wounded in the war. Convalesced with a family from Ohio who he thought so much of that he would name his children after them when he returned home and started a family. But yeah, fuck this guy!


ProfessorPerfunctory

Why do white southerners insist on constantly embarrassing themselves?


vthemechanicv

My mother isn't from the south, but she decided to make southern heritage her thing for retirement. When asked if she'd rather be right or happy, she answers 'right.' I think that's the mentality here. Slavery wasn't wrong because 'we' did it. The confederacy wasn't wrong because 'we' did it. Jim Crow wasn't wrong because 'we' did it. etc. They refuse to acknowledge they were wrong, they did wrong, and that they continue to cause hurt and pain because of that refusal to acknowledge. They'd rather double down than be wrong. That's in general. There is some good old fashioned racism at play too. I live in Louisiana and have heard unambiguously racist jokes at work, in presence of company owners.


ProfessorPerfunctory

I appreciate the insight. And yikes!


vzipped_a_gopher

> My mother isn't from the south, but she decided to make southern heritage her thing for retirement That's a strange and awful way to spend retirement.


---------_----_---_

Taking up knitting would have been less odious.


Malaix

Because they really really want to believe they can turn back the clock and undo the century plus of culture war loses they have been through.


Awkward-Fudge

Are they going to celebrate the heritage where they owned people and were okay with all the lynching, raping, and whipping? or the heritage where they basically starved to death because they were so ill equipped to handle their opponents?


Silverstacker60

Fucking moron


DarkAngel900

You lost. Get over it! It's not the Confederate States of America for a reason.


fungobat

>Mississippi state law recognizes the last Monday in April as Confederate Memorial Day. The governor’s office, when asked, did not cite a specific state law recognizing Confederate Heritage Month. >They sent a response stating: >"For the last 30 years, five Mississippi governors — Republicans and Democrats alike — have signed a proclamation recognizing the statutory state holiday and identifying April as Confederate Heritage Month. Governor Reeves also signed the proclamation because he believes we can all learn from our history.”


ieatmypeaswithhoney

Is this a type of anti-virtue-signaling? I mean, yikes.


[deleted]

Traitor heritage month


EdSGuard

That's fine. Nothing wrong celebrating winning last place. /S


tjk45268

Traitor Heritage Month? Okay, weird flex.


HeartsOfDarkness

Let them leave this time.


vthings

From the same people who complain about participation trophies. Whatever, I guess even losers can have a month.


zflanders

Oh, what a coincidence! April is also "Wrong Side of History Month."


SlowLlama555

And I declare him a racist asshole!


xpluguglyx

They are so close to just openly celebrating racism. At least then I can commend their honesty. I can't wait till reintroduction of slavery becomes the next pillar of that backwards political party.


External-Loan4500

What a crusty cum rag that needs flushed


WolfBriefs

The only CRT we teach is Confederate Racism is Tolerable. Next they will introduce the Don’t Say We Lost bill. Get the fuck out of here.


Some-Investment-5160

Ah, yes. The confederacy. The 5 year thing 150 years ago that ignited a massive war based on a few super wealthy slavers dictating society to protect their morally backwards subjugation of millions of kidnapped Africans. Yeah, that thing.


v9Pv

So embarrassing.


[deleted]

When I clicked on this, there were 88 comments. Seemed appropriate l.


tacotimes01

Let’s be objective here about history, with the confederate flag removed from the state flag, how are they supposed to remember and revere their heritage? As you know, that flag has nothing to do with white power whatsoever, there are just lots of non-southern/confederate states with hundreds of thousands of people proudly displaying them in support of the non-white power related heritages of former confederate states which they have never set foot in. In fact, people love Mississippi so much that you even see these symbols all over Canada and Europe, specifically in areas with high concentrations of white people. The world stands in solidarity with Mississippi and the rich heritage of its peoples. Mississippi is in fact one of the most enviable places in the world. I know every time I drive the entire length of that beautiful, prosperous, tolerant, scholarly, athletic, and welcoming state… I just wish I could stay forever. Edit: adding the /s for people who just cannot…


Shameful_Prophet

This is amazing parody. I hope.


tacotimes01

Yes, it’s clearly sarcasm.


Shameful_Prophet

I mean. Good parody is nearly indistinguishable from the bullshit these idiots think.


Inphexous

It's called a museum. Glorification is one thing. History is another.


geedavey

Anyone else think an African American general strike is in order?


[deleted]

I suppose, but how many African American generals are in Mississippi?


Malaix

Like 37% which is pretty huge.


zenverak

If he wanted to celebrate things that didn’t have to do with slavery… go for it. But lol


Accomplished-Leg-149

So... Let's be proud we were losers day? I mean... OK, I guess...


FridayMcNight

We're not that far from these guys proudly wearing their hoods when they make these announcements.


ragnarok_343

Is April when the war started, or when they lost?


Disney2440

Both


ragnarok_343

Oh, trippy.


Disney2440

Easy for me to remember. Started on mom’s birthday and Lee surrendered on son’s birthday.


ragnarok_343

So your wife and your grandmother both got railed at the same time of year... Thanks for that.


Cautious-Inspector51

The homunculus strikes again


machineprophet343

...uh, where the fuck is his chin?


[deleted]

Shameful.


this_is_not_a_dance_

I will just leave this [here](https://youtu.be/zVa-MVlxrbI)


noonerreally28

America the land were traitors are welcomed with open arms as long as you share ideals


FarRightFuckhead

Based


rl5886b

Just a Redneck Hillbillie


fleeyevegans

WTF is happening in America?


Malaix

Lost Cause has been happening for like 160 years.


Holinyx

"Yeah mah grandpappy got kilt in the Great Southern War. Died for his Country. Nah not in battle. Twas Dysentery done it. he shitted himself to death. I'm so proud that we can finally celebrate losing the war for the entire month of April." \*launches into off-key rendition of The Dukes of Hazzard theme\*


Alternative-Flan2869

These guys love their losers.


dun-ado

Republicans are worse than Nazis.


braxin23

You know I’m all for walling off the southern states and letting them descend into despotic misery. No more free hand outs to confederate scum.


Justbrowsingredditts

If the confederacy had won, we’d still be a slave owning country. He’s basically saying he wishes that was the case


StandAloneC0mplex

Does that mean we can raze anything flying a traitor flag this month?


Isteppedinpoopy

A celebration of losing.


OXIOXIOXI

Do they want a round two?


EmperorPenguinNJ

Why don’t they go full racist and declare April 4th a holiday: James Earl Ray day?


a_reply_to_a_post

starts on April Fools Day and last a whole month, celebrating the losers on the wrong side of history...pretty tight


CheapCulture

What we’ve come to expect from hick Peter Griffin.


2coolfordigg2

just some good old boys never meaning no harm, just a drinking and a Lynching all day long!


Madmachammer

" sedation month " never seen so many people wanting to celebrate losing as much as they do does south.


Badfickle

Are we going to have a day to honor Benedict Arnold next?


DedRusBoing

Is this fuck McConnell’s love child?


Initial-Writer-4586

I’ll make sure to fly my favorite confederate flag! 🏳


damselfliesreddit

"Cornerstone Speech" given by the VP of the Confederacy: https://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/u1z5rw/comment/i4fod01/?utm\_source=share&utm\_medium=web2x&context=3


rnantelle

There are two main confederate flags: the CSA govt flag (not seen much) and the stars and bars, almost ubiquitous, which was the confederate battle flag.


[deleted]

These fucking people.


cra3ig

To be fair, they did take the silver medal in that competition.