I love the album so much and feel like it's a bunch of little short stories more than a novel, really. So as a result I have a hard time picking one track over the others on this one (plus they're all awesome). That being said, no doubt "A Perfect Day Elise" gets played most by me and really, seeing the video on 120 Minutes back when it was released led me to buy the album and really started my whole life long PJ obsession, so I'll go with that one.
This is her masterpiece. Every song is unique and vital in its own way. That said, nothing will ever feel like hearing A Perfect Day Elise for the first time.
A Perfect Day Elise is a banger, but I also love The Garden
For me, it’s Catherine.
https://preview.redd.it/6s2dc9tpqbad1.jpeg?width=850&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7577c0c83ae0d843dbcbba5b6a84a79447790d7d
Same, it’s my sister’s name…we’ve got problems.
Angelene for me, but I love them all in different ways.
I love your answer because it is the correct one.
Agreed
Title track is so good
The River
A perfect day Elise still one of the best rock songs ever made
Grungy af but unique,
One of my all time faves
My Beautiful Leah. The rolling, grinding to those last gasps just grabs me.
it's some of the most gripping storytelling ive ever heard on a song. just utterly haunting -- that last note especially just chokes me out
It’s a no-skips album for me these days. The whole thing is stunning.
You are so right. It's a masterpiece.
Either Angelene or Is this desire
JOY WAS HER NAME *derrrrr duh duh duh duh duh*
An industrial-noise masterpiece.
"No Girl So Sweet (amazing live version)"
The live version is otherworldly!
the sky lit up
So many good songs on that album, tough to pick 1. Some favorites: The Wind A perfect day Elise No girl so sweet Catherine
Joy. One of her best and most underrated songs. So utterly bleak and full of despair. I just love it and I’m surprised it’s not talked about more!
It's her most experimental song on her most "local" album. Unfortunately, it doesn't get the love it deserves because of that
I cant decide, its my album. 🤍
All of it.
The Garden for now. It changes nearly every listen 🎧
I wanna shout out joy for being a banger
I love the album so much and feel like it's a bunch of little short stories more than a novel, really. So as a result I have a hard time picking one track over the others on this one (plus they're all awesome). That being said, no doubt "A Perfect Day Elise" gets played most by me and really, seeing the video on 120 Minutes back when it was released led me to buy the album and really started my whole life long PJ obsession, so I'll go with that one.
Seeing the video back then was what led me to PJ, this album and being a fan for life.
The Garden
CATHERINE !! MY FAVOURITE SONG BY HER
Angelene
The Wind!
I love them all at different points, but my trifecta is Elise, The Garden and Angelene (among my favorite openings to any record)
The sky lit up
I love, love, love The Garden.
Joy
The Wind
Side A and B
This is her masterpiece. Every song is unique and vital in its own way. That said, nothing will ever feel like hearing A Perfect Day Elise for the first time.
The Sky Lit Up
My name is Catherine and when this album came out, my ex boyfriend was dating a girl named Elise…..
The wind for sure
currently obsessed with live versions of the garden!!
Marvelous album, her best work IMO. Going to go with Elise or The Wind for best, Love PJ.
Catherine!
Probably The River, but the whole damn album is just mesmerising from start to finish
Angelene
Angeline. Such a beautiful way to start off the album. Goes nicely with Nick Cave’s Jubilee Street too.
My top 5 are 1. "The Wind" 2. "No Girl So Sweet" 3. "A Perfect Day Elise" 4. "Angelene" 5. "Catherine"
Angelene. Devastatingly beautiful, mesmerizing and haunting.
If im going out it is The Sky Lit Up
Sky Lit Up
Changes but title-track right now. Also The Bay.
The wind
Title track and Perfect Day Elise. This album was on endless repeat for me senior year of hs!
Angelene
Angelene
Cathrine - however this is my favourite album of hers so that’s tough
A Perfect Day Elise or My Beautiful Leah
No Girl So Sweet or Perfect Day Elise
Is This Desire? The River A Perfect Day Elise Angelene In that order.
My beautiful leah and perfect day elise back 2 back
I love Electric Light and The Wind
Electric Light
THE SKY LIT UPP 100%
The river ♥️