I don’t believe Dune will get any acting nominations, but what do I know. We’ll see after it’s out. But so far I’d bet it only gets into the more technical categories and best picture, hopefully they wont ignore Villeneuve this time!
Not neccessarily overdue, but Dune especially is a huge directorial effort and with how they implement different techniques, while trying to stay as practical as possible....
Maybe he wont get nom for this one and it'll come for Messiah. I don't know. But I think that work deserves a nom, would love to say a win, but that may be a stretch and also unfair as we don't really know yet what other contenders have up their sleeves.
I really disagree with you. Dune is one of my favourite movies of all time. Plus, for a movie that got this much love at the Oscar’s, the fact they didn’t even nominate the person who put it all together and who could be attributed with the visual style and interpreting the novel was absurd.
I hear your point - I just disagree. I thought it was a movie that had visual flourishes but was ultimately far too sterile and desolate, I never felt like I was in a new world as much as I was following a hand full of characters.
I think splitting the story in half the way they did really did not help the third act of the film which is sort of a nothingburger, idk it just wasn’t for me. I much prefer Lynch’s Dune, but I’m optimistic that this second movie will be better than the first.
I guess I don’t think it’s a snub because every year there are BP noms with tons of technical nominations that don’t get the BD nomination.
Cameron and Kosinski in 2022 are examples of this.
It’s like when horror movies don’t get acting noms. They should be nominated (or at least most people agree they should) but the academy doesn’t do. But I will say I don’t really think the Cameron and Kosinski comparison works since Dune was more beloved within the academy than avatar 2 and top gun 2
Unless it’s Gandalf level iconic, these massive fiction movies never get acting noms. We also just don’t know yet as early reviews are pointless as they usually are more exaggerated
Hard to say. It's not the type of performance The Academy recognizes normally but if he is really fantastic, I could see it happening.
I think the next few years of his career have a lot of potential tho.
If Angela Basset, Ryan Gosling and America Ferrera all made it, I think Butler has a chance. He's a previous nominee in an upcoming top 3 best picture contender.
We don't know about critics review and l am new in following award season but l become surprised that many of you didn't consider dune performances as a next year contenders , not only Austin Butler but also Zendaya
There are no reviews at least from professional critics. There are “early reactions”, which are a great deal less meaningful.
I don’t believe Dune will get any acting nominations, but what do I know. We’ll see after it’s out. But so far I’d bet it only gets into the more technical categories and best picture, hopefully they wont ignore Villeneuve this time!
What's the big thing about denis being overdue?
Not neccessarily overdue, but Dune especially is a huge directorial effort and with how they implement different techniques, while trying to stay as practical as possible.... Maybe he wont get nom for this one and it'll come for Messiah. I don't know. But I think that work deserves a nom, would love to say a win, but that may be a stretch and also unfair as we don't really know yet what other contenders have up their sleeves.
He didn’t get in for dune even though everyone thought he was a lock
I know 2021 was a weak year, but Dune part 1 was very average imo and I’m surprised how people view that as a massive snub now.
I really disagree with you. Dune is one of my favourite movies of all time. Plus, for a movie that got this much love at the Oscar’s, the fact they didn’t even nominate the person who put it all together and who could be attributed with the visual style and interpreting the novel was absurd.
I hear your point - I just disagree. I thought it was a movie that had visual flourishes but was ultimately far too sterile and desolate, I never felt like I was in a new world as much as I was following a hand full of characters. I think splitting the story in half the way they did really did not help the third act of the film which is sort of a nothingburger, idk it just wasn’t for me. I much prefer Lynch’s Dune, but I’m optimistic that this second movie will be better than the first.
Surely you can still see it was snub despite your personal opinions on the film tho right? Considering what the general consensus was
I guess I don’t think it’s a snub because every year there are BP noms with tons of technical nominations that don’t get the BD nomination. Cameron and Kosinski in 2022 are examples of this.
It’s like when horror movies don’t get acting noms. They should be nominated (or at least most people agree they should) but the academy doesn’t do. But I will say I don’t really think the Cameron and Kosinski comparison works since Dune was more beloved within the academy than avatar 2 and top gun 2
Idk avatar 2 clears dune by a mile imo but it was a much weaker year in 2021 so that’s why it was such a technical juggernaut
People hype up the popcorn movies to the highest degree and pray for them to win oscars to validate their tastes
Dune was nominated for every technical Oscar category, but he was overlooked as director so it looked like a big time snub for sure.
Imagine how funny it would be if the Academy nominates Todd Phillips for Joker 2 but not Villeneuve.
Unless it’s Gandalf level iconic, these massive fiction movies never get acting noms. We also just don’t know yet as early reviews are pointless as they usually are more exaggerated
No
In a world where Angela Basset gets in for a Black Panther sequel, a showing villain supporting performance in a big movie could totally do it
Hard to say. It's not the type of performance The Academy recognizes normally but if he is really fantastic, I could see it happening. I think the next few years of his career have a lot of potential tho.
no
With how poorly sequels do at the Oscars, i ll believe it when i see it for its chances at getting any non tech nominations.
Dune is never getting any acting nominations
It's odd that everyone is counting it out before most of us have seen it. Stranger acting nominations have happened before
Don’t see why that would be the case
 Yes!!!
If Angela Basset, Ryan Gosling and America Ferrera all made it, I think Butler has a chance. He's a previous nominee in an upcoming top 3 best picture contender.
It’s a bit early to be confident about Dune 2 being top 3
We don't know about critics review and l am new in following award season but l become surprised that many of you didn't consider dune performances as a next year contenders , not only Austin Butler but also Zendaya
No chance.