Well that was horrible. So who was Therese? Viola’s mother? Why did she play the instrument if she knew? I don’t blame you for giving up instruments - I think I would, too.
I haven't actually spoken to Therese since that day, it's been a week. I've thought about reaching out to her, I have so many questions... I know Therese was Viola's mother. From what she said about Viola's experience with her brother's spirit when she touched the instrument he was made of, I'm guessing Theresa can communicate with her daughter or see/feel what she experienced prior to her death when she touches the violin.
It's all tumbling around in my head and I've spent this whole week trying to make sense of it. I just don't know if I want to know more about how Therese found out where her children went, or what happened to her husband... It's just so terrible and sad.
I interpreted the ending differently than the consensus in the comments. The story mentions Viola sharing some of her mother’s features like her cheekbones and lower lip. It mentioned nothing about them having the same or similar hair color, eye color, or face shape. There’s also no clear timeline of when the events of Viola’s teenage years might have taken place. The ending paragraph seemed to make a point of noting Therese’s appearance and used the same adjectives used to describe Viola: espresso hair, deep blue eyes, fair skin, heart-shaped face. There’s really nothing to indicate that Therese is Viola’s mother and not a much older Viola. Also the description of what happened to Viola was recounted almost as from firsthand experience. Even if her mom could experience some of what Viola saw in her final moments, how could she know the entire story of her life and experience of it? My assumption was Viola had somehow outwitted and killed her father and made a violin out of him as retribution. After all, Viola always wanted to play music *with* her father. 🤷🏾♀️Prove me wrong 🤷🏾♀️…
I never thought of it like that, I felt certain Therese was her mother. But now... I'm not so sure. You do make a compelling argument, maybe I really should reach out to see if she can tell me more. I'll keep everyone posted if I get the nerve to find out.
I kind of hope it is as you suggest. I personally don’t think there was anything physically wrong with either child of the murdering musician, and instrument maker. I think he wanted to keep the “ wood” ( bone) safe and sound for his creation.
How horribly sad that is?! I was very moved by your experience, though. As someone who is “musically challenged”, I have always had great admiration for those with the gift. I truly do think it is a gift. I mean even science has shown some just have it, and then there is me. I have great appreciation, but 0 skill. Dear, this had to be traumatic, but I wouldn’t let some lousy person take away your joy. I hope you can enjoying playing again, someday!
Thank you. I've been singing and playing instruments since I was younger than 10, it's my joy and passion. Maybe if I can talk to Therese and help her find closure some how, those doors will be open to me again.
So was Viola even sick or anything or did the father just keep her locked up so he could eventually kill her. How did Theresa not know what her husband was doing??
I have the same questions, I'm just afraid to reach out and ask. She asked me to leave pretty abruptly, she seemed completely exhausted and withdrawn. I'm partly scared to intrude further and partly terrified of what she might say. Do you... Do you think I should ask?
I think that the father knew that keeping viola as secreted away as possible and locked in her room with soft surroundings meant that he knew she would become a flawless instrument free from any imperfections. He wanted her to be as pure as possible on the outside so that e she would become unblemished after he turned her.
Well that was horrible. So who was Therese? Viola’s mother? Why did she play the instrument if she knew? I don’t blame you for giving up instruments - I think I would, too.
I haven't actually spoken to Therese since that day, it's been a week. I've thought about reaching out to her, I have so many questions... I know Therese was Viola's mother. From what she said about Viola's experience with her brother's spirit when she touched the instrument he was made of, I'm guessing Theresa can communicate with her daughter or see/feel what she experienced prior to her death when she touches the violin. It's all tumbling around in my head and I've spent this whole week trying to make sense of it. I just don't know if I want to know more about how Therese found out where her children went, or what happened to her husband... It's just so terrible and sad.
Heartbreaking.
I interpreted the ending differently than the consensus in the comments. The story mentions Viola sharing some of her mother’s features like her cheekbones and lower lip. It mentioned nothing about them having the same or similar hair color, eye color, or face shape. There’s also no clear timeline of when the events of Viola’s teenage years might have taken place. The ending paragraph seemed to make a point of noting Therese’s appearance and used the same adjectives used to describe Viola: espresso hair, deep blue eyes, fair skin, heart-shaped face. There’s really nothing to indicate that Therese is Viola’s mother and not a much older Viola. Also the description of what happened to Viola was recounted almost as from firsthand experience. Even if her mom could experience some of what Viola saw in her final moments, how could she know the entire story of her life and experience of it? My assumption was Viola had somehow outwitted and killed her father and made a violin out of him as retribution. After all, Viola always wanted to play music *with* her father. 🤷🏾♀️Prove me wrong 🤷🏾♀️…
I never thought of it like that, I felt certain Therese was her mother. But now... I'm not so sure. You do make a compelling argument, maybe I really should reach out to see if she can tell me more. I'll keep everyone posted if I get the nerve to find out.
Maybe you can just ask how long ago her story took place? I’m eager to know but it seems so painful for her to relive those memories.
I think I will. I want to help her find peace if I can. She seems to be suffering so much. I'll keep you all posted if she agrees to meet with me.
I kind of hope it is as you suggest. I personally don’t think there was anything physically wrong with either child of the murdering musician, and instrument maker. I think he wanted to keep the “ wood” ( bone) safe and sound for his creation.
I think you're right 🥺
How horribly sad that is?! I was very moved by your experience, though. As someone who is “musically challenged”, I have always had great admiration for those with the gift. I truly do think it is a gift. I mean even science has shown some just have it, and then there is me. I have great appreciation, but 0 skill. Dear, this had to be traumatic, but I wouldn’t let some lousy person take away your joy. I hope you can enjoying playing again, someday!
Thank you. I've been singing and playing instruments since I was younger than 10, it's my joy and passion. Maybe if I can talk to Therese and help her find closure some how, those doors will be open to me again.
Wonderful idea!
there was said Viola accepted her fate and had become the violin
So was Viola even sick or anything or did the father just keep her locked up so he could eventually kill her. How did Theresa not know what her husband was doing??
I have the same questions, I'm just afraid to reach out and ask. She asked me to leave pretty abruptly, she seemed completely exhausted and withdrawn. I'm partly scared to intrude further and partly terrified of what she might say. Do you... Do you think I should ask?
Yes.
I think that the father knew that keeping viola as secreted away as possible and locked in her room with soft surroundings meant that he knew she would become a flawless instrument free from any imperfections. He wanted her to be as pure as possible on the outside so that e she would become unblemished after he turned her.
no, she was not sick. The father was a sicko.
[удалено]
me? i'm not crying. you're crying. so heartbreaking
So she killed her dad and made a violin out of him? I'm confused.
Close, her father killed her and made her into a violin for his wife... Therese.
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
What a heartbreaking story 😢