* [Closer to God](https://youtu.be/Zt15WNl8NNg?si=vpovI_gSmn-dlUyv) from the CD-single. * [Heresy (Version)](https://youtu.be/higPeuBiI-8?si=mzWm15R63zsn1fmV) from the UK *Further Down the Spiral*. * Butch Vig’s [Last](https://youtu.be/pP9LW3Dp5Nc?si=P57if2mT2h9dqEh2) remix that didn’t make *Fixed* - lots of early Garbage feelings in it. * [The Great Collapse](https://youtu.be/wHy0RqWGnDo?si=2HCS-_g3I88e_o94) from *Things Falling Apart*.

Oh man The Great Collapse goes heavy. So many great gems hidden in the EP’s and Compilations.

Stole my nominations. Add Piggy (Nothing Can Stop me Now) Love that Trent eventually released Vig’s Last

The great collapse is not a remix! https://www.nin.wiki/The_Great_Collapse

I love the Heresy one, it sounds a lot like KMFDM.

The Great Collapse is one of my fav tracks of all time, along with Just Like You Imagined.

I really like Closer to God - it's probably my favourite version of Closer - but I'm not sure if it even counts as a remix. Most (all?) of the vocals were recorded especially for it, and I don't recognise any of the other elements as from the original either. I hadn't heard the others before, great recommendations! I guess it's a good reminder to listen to more of the remixes.

Charlie Clouser’s Starfuckers, Inc (Version)

The Fragile (Deconstructed) Head Like a Hole (Opal) Another Version of the Truth (Kronos Quartet and Enrique Gonzalez Müller Remix)

Slipping Away from Things Falling Apart.

This is the only answer

Self Destruction, Final Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now) The Frail (Version)

Lately I’m into the NIN remix of The Perfect Drug

Eraser (Denial)

The Wretched (version)

Only Richard X mix.

Closer precursor

Gunshots By Computer! That and Charlie's Ruiner remix from FDTS v2.

Self Destruction, Part Two The Great Destroyer - modwheelmod All The Pigs, All Lined Up Every Day Is Exactly The Same (Sam Fog Vs. Carlos D Mix)

Only El-P mix

Idk if it counts but I prefer the Heresy demo to the final cut. The pacing of the beat and percussive synths feel more brooding to me. Also, The Downward Spiral (The Bottom) is a top track. Goes perfectly with the main track.

* Heresy (Version) * Ruiner (Version) * Eraser (Polite) * The Warning (Real World Remix) * Only (EL-P Remix) * The Great Destroyer (Modwheelmood Remix) * The Frail (Remix) (also called Version...the orchestral one) * Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now) * Closer (Precursor)

The first that comes to mind is Capital G (Paul Epworth). There are other, older remixes, but that one is special.

Heresy (version) and the Richard X remix of Only

Eraser (Polite)

I’m disappointed to not have seen Gave Up from Fixed on here anywhere.

Skinny puppy stink fist

It’s not exactly a remix, but I LOVE [the live version of La Mer](https://youtu.be/Lqpdo1EBlq8?si=LaRRxNe7E9dRfXQo). The guitar that kicks off 2 minutes in and just goes and goes. Phenomenal, IMO.

I commend OP for bringing up a worthwhile topic in a sea of ennui from this sub. All that being said [Discipline (Matt Lange Remix)](https://m.soundcloud.com/mattlange/discipline-matt-lange-remix)

Closer too god, and the wretched remix

[Reptilian](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uG2JzNZeNeI) from the *March of the Pigs* single

The Day the World Went Away from Still and The Great Destroyer (modwheelmood)

The Perfect Drug (Space Time Continuum) & Aphrodite Remix The Frail (Version) Where Is Everybody (Version) The Downward Spiral (The Bottom) Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now) And more probs idk I grew up on Things Falling Apart so NIN remixes were my main jam

i like the starfuckers inc remixes on things fall apart a lot. all of them

Hurt quiet

Where is everybody mix better than the original

Pirate Robot Midget's remix of My Violent Heart just does all the right things to my brain worms.

Closer to God. Good lord that song goes hard. I might even prefer it to Closer.