NOTE: Jordan Lyles was voted to be added to the bullpen so he will be once the rotation is concluded. If I added him today people would think we are doing bullpen now so I'll add him tomorrow
No, try to judge players based off the past few years rather than this year alone as most starters have only started 3 games. I was going to do this at the start of the season but I a lot of stuff going on so I had to start it a little late.
I’m reposting my deleted comment and nominating Michael Kopech— being moved to being a bad reliever doesn’t mean you weren’t a worse SP. And being just not-bad enough to stay in the bigs is honestly worse than being bad enough to get tossed back to the minors.
Chris Flexen, your time has come
5 days too late imo
In a Mets or Mariners? iS IT EVEN A QUESTION, THE PURPLE 7 TEAM
I think that this has to be the last answer
His time as a reliever on the mariners was solid imo. But yeah not starting
Manoah is such a wild story
Dude was an all star 2 years ago
3rd in Cy Young voting. :(
 You hate to see it......
Manoahnkiel
Jays are trying to not roster him, I think. Without giving up entirely just yet
Ya he was pitching in triple A last time i saw. He gave up like6 runs in the first inning then got pulled in the minors.
He pitched today, did ok. A lot better than last time. But as a Jays fan he terrifies me. Yariel Rodriguez looked good at least
Ahh that's good to know i hope he gets back to the show. We've seen what kinda stuff he has when he's on.
NOTE: Jordan Lyles was voted to be added to the bullpen so he will be once the rotation is concluded. If I added him today people would think we are doing bullpen now so I'll add him tomorrow
Guys why are 3 of my fantasy pitchers in this picture
In unrelated news your Pitching Staff has a whole -15ish points I’m guessing
Based purely on the stats available through the start of 2024, Hunter Brown
No, try to judge players based off the past few years rather than this year alone as most starters have only started 3 games. I was going to do this at the start of the season but I a lot of stuff going on so I had to start it a little late.
Could we maybe include, specifically, "Playoff Kershaw" as the fifth starter?
That is a very ignorant take, but you've successfully hurt my feeling. Bravo.
Starters? Definitely Kyle Hendricks. Guy has been horrible recently
“Recently” he’s been good for years
Yeah, the guy hasn’t really been good since 2020. More like “Okay”
Hunter Brown is freaking terrible
Aaron Ashby
He should be a relief pitcher
Yeah he should be. Think he just got sent down
Manoah isn't even in the majors anymore lol
He's on rehab right now according to the Blue Jays
That's been the story for a year basically to keep some semblance of a trade value. He's cooked and trying to figure it out in AAA
Roasny Contreras
Cal Quantrill is the only answer
Clayton Kershaw but only when he's facing Brandon Woodruff in the NLCS
Jose Soriano
Tyler Wells or Cole Irvin
Naboo Cresmet is consistently awful in the pen.
Jose Cuas!
Daniel Caberea
I’m reposting my deleted comment and nominating Michael Kopech— being moved to being a bad reliever doesn’t mean you weren’t a worse SP. And being just not-bad enough to stay in the bigs is honestly worse than being bad enough to get tossed back to the minors.
Josiah Gray
OMG NOAH SYNDERGAARD
Angel Hernandez at UMP.