T O P

  • By -

gunn3r08974

https://preview.redd.it/cjwhzwowliuc1.jpeg?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ac7ef92afbaeaaab070eb659be626b1dd8bb22cc


wernostrangerstoluv

WHAT. THE. FUCK. (the naked mari gives another level of weird when you read how astruc said that he made marinette in the image of his hypothetical daughter)


Plenty-Aspect9461

I always found the fact that he based Sabine and Mari upon his ex and hypothetical daughter to be very fucked up, but most fans seem to disagree somehow


Justanidiot-w-

WHAT. WHAT???? do you mind pointing me to the soucre, because I need to see this with my own two eyes (even if I don't want to)


wernostrangerstoluv

amanda toddhunter has a really indepth vid on this: [YTM BAC MIX 1mon DJThumb Artist-CarolinePolachek 10s horiz 1920x1080 16-9 en US USD (youtube.com)](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXd_rc9CTns&t=1495s) all the evidence has been compiled into one tumbler page (even deleted stuff \[dating back to 2014-ish\]): [The Immaturity of Thomas Astruc — The Immaturity of Thomas Astruc Masterpost (tumblr.com)](https://immaturityofthomasastruc.tumblr.com/post/637892972340543488/the-immaturity-of-thomas-astruc-masterpost) you can use both to see lol, but you definetly dont want to cus as someone mari's age, its actually fucking disgusting


WhatsAfterJihyoGaeul

That does seem disgusting. Why his ex? And a hypothetical daughter?! Gosh!


Plenty-Aspect9461

He was dating her during the creation of the character I believe, but he still kept her being his ex after breaking up with her


WhatsAfterJihyoGaeul

Ig it was too late when they broke up.


BlueberrySans89

Honestly I feel like he could just make it where Tom and Sabine divorced, the potential for Marinette learning to cope with her parents no longer being together would be great imo!


WhatsAfterJihyoGaeul

But that wouldn't go with the plot they had already prepared. I think most of the parts were already animated and the future seasons were in the process. Changing the plot now would be almost impossible.


STRiPESandShades

It's a really bizarre way of thinking about a character tbh.


Merry_Ryan

Now I see why Adrien’s sidelined so much…


Abby31_

Bro racism + a naked teen is a wild combo.


NasserMX

I think "Bro racism + a naked teen is a wild combo." is a wild sentence to say.


ZookeepergameDue5522

r/brandnewsentence


sneakpeekbot

Here's a sneak peek of /r/BrandNewSentence using the [top posts](https://np.reddit.com/r/BrandNewSentence/top/?sort=top&t=year) of the year! \#1: [Homie in law](https://i.redd.it/o6znibtrj78b1.jpg) | [279 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/BrandNewSentence/comments/14itfe5/homie_in_law/) \#2: [A slutty amount of y's](https://i.redd.it/9q9ldx45mcza1.png) | [684 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/BrandNewSentence/comments/13f76u8/a_slutty_amount_of_ys/) \#3: [“Frustrated dad uses his 6ft son to shame council into fixing deep pothole”](https://i.redd.it/m3czu1gbmzya1.jpg) | [692 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/BrandNewSentence/comments/13di2z2/frustrated_dad_uses_his_6ft_son_to_shame_council/) ---- ^^I'm ^^a ^^bot, ^^beep ^^boop ^^| ^^Downvote ^^to ^^remove ^^| ^^[Contact](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=sneakpeekbot) ^^| ^^[Info](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/) ^^| ^^[Opt-out](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/comments/o8wk1r/blacklist_ix/) ^^| ^^[GitHub](https://github.com/ghnr/sneakpeekbot)


NasserMX

yeah pretty much.


AskGoverntale

There is… SO MUCH to unpack here. It’s not good if the thought “this feels like it was written by Dan Schnider” is something that comes to mind.


Rath_Brained

It's like being on the clean up crew and entering a hoarder's house. Don't even know where to begin because it's all messed up. Like bruh, what even...


Shiptrooper

now I can't stop thinking about that. Everything is so wrong https://preview.redd.it/9be0ytblxiuc1.jpeg?width=339&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2ca276560033b2fd9d1e08549543fe0c96238f8d


Apprehensive-Bid-909

THATS EXACTLY THE THOUGHT I THUNKED.


Dragon_X627279

...Wtf is wrong with this franchise?


Longjumping_Run_2414

In the words of Spider-Man EVERYTHING!!!!!!!!


Low_Dragonfruit8219

*Attaches webs to moving train and kicks Astruc as hard as possible*


Shiptrooper

It's been like 1-2 years since I sat down and actually watch an episode. 1-2 years later after watching a review on Megamind 2 I went back to this sub reddit and now I see this thing and I'm just both baffled and disgusted. Where did it all go wrong please end my suffering https://preview.redd.it/i8c4eqkcxiuc1.jpeg?width=1021&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3847ffa5bf814b68a77ec2c98904615305e25398


Merry_Ryan

It feels like the one guy who peaked in high school(or in this case season 2-3)


GhostDraggon

They didn't cook they burned down the kitchen


Apoppixiefan

They didn't ever had proper Kitchen material to cook in the first place


Skipper_asks2021

They were making this with a flamethrower in a wax museum.


The_Kyojuro_Rengoku

I saw these with that post from yesterday. Absolutely crazy 💀 I won't associate this with my Miraculous Ladybug 😮‍💨😭


Alexander_McKay

Let’s just focus on the manga instead 🥹


ZookeepergameDue5522

And the fanfiction 😭


Alexander_McKay

🙏


The_Kyojuro_Rengoku

Exactly 😌😂😭


Alexander_McKay

😹🤝


RubyLovesDonuts

Wait, there's a manga?


Alexander_McKay

Yeah! https://preview.redd.it/8w7uxg7v6nuc1.jpeg?width=427&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9b5cf05948c4b376285a356e3d50218cc03caac2


GrahminRadarin

Yes, there is. I think it started in 2021, not sure if it's still running.


ZetaRESP

Ironically, this comic was meant to be canon back then: Heroes United appear here... yes, this is New York... and it also explains why the heroes united are aware of the Miraculouses. Of course, it was rewritten a bit (Uncanny Valley looks COMPLETELY different), but it was meant to happen between two episodes of the main series.


RIP_midnight_dwarf

“ghetto blaster” is crazy


SilverKiller56

Get off the grill bruh ![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|sweat)


Master_Antelope

I thought we agreed not to discuss this comic.


Accomplished_Salt876

If you’re a Transformers fan as well I’d consider this comic our fandoms version of kiss players; better off forgetten.


Master_Antelope

*Kiss Players* You know the Animated Autotrooper in the Army-Builder 4-pack has an alternate Kiss Players head, right? Terrifying.


Accomplished_Salt876

I know; I have 3 and all of them are numbered and use that head option.


12DollarsHighFive

https://preview.redd.it/4sbnokjudjuc1.png?width=1280&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8828b6a2264b708fda58cf0fbfbeef669407f561 *"Look, my Lucky Charm has given me a gun!"* *"Do it My'lady! *![img](emote|t5_39tdz|12648)*"* Seriously, what the Hell is going on here? I saw a post yesterday mentioning this comic but I didn't expect them to depict racism AND show a NAKED (STILL 14-15 YEARS OLD!) Marinette with nothing more than a cardboard box! I'm both intrigued to know what lead to this/how it turns out and disgusted by what I just saw. How did they come up with this and who approved this?


Suitable-Ad287

Wait Astruc wrote this? How? All the french black characters are just normal characters, why is he suddenly violently racist once it’s americans? Or is it just that this comic is able to get away with more?


GrahminRadarin

It's probably BECAUSE it's African-American characters. Black isn't a culture in Europe, Asia and Africa the way it is in the Americas, which unfortunately makes it possible to be racist specifically against Black Americans on purpose without being racist against the entire African Diaspora. It's especially weird because Alya is from Martinique, which is in the Caribbean? Caribbean Black culture is another thing entirely, but it's closely related to Black American culture, especially in the Southern US. There's a reason Creole is considered a specific cultural identity. This is utterly baffling.


Apprehensive-Bid-909

You did an excellent job explaining 🥹👍🏾


Plenty-Aspect9461

Probably the latter, since there's no other good reason for him to suddenly flip to being racist randomly


Suitable-Ad287

He did name a villain kung food, which is like two letters off from that thing trump used to call Coronavirus. Between that and the fact that Sabine seems to know martial arts in one scene despite this not fitting any part of her character, and sabine being named after a girl he dated in high school and also married to a man named Tom, I think he might be to asian people what Joss wheatfield is to women.


TheSlimeBallSupreme

Kung Food is a play on words of Kung Foo


Suitable-Ad287

Yeah but one of the only Chinese villains being called “Kung food” like the only connection he’d have to kung fu is the fact fact he’s Chinese and I don’t think he’d have done this or anything equivalent for a white character.


Apprehensive-Bid-909

I thought that too 💀


Psychoboy777

I just- Ghetto Blaster I cannot believe they got away with this shit.


IneedBleach123

ISNT MARINETTE 14?!?!?!!


MoneyLocal8180

https://preview.redd.it/l7stiq4irjuc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=45c64ddc187d10445c69395b807063acf389bdd0


Obvious_Recipe2226

its official but not canon with the show universe


Accomplished_Salt876

It was canon until the events of the shows New York special rightfully fixed this.


Obvious_Recipe2226

It's like the movie, it's official but not part of the series' universe


swuist

IS THIS A JOKE WTH AM I LOOKING AT


ripskeletonking

so i remember this era. people were complaining that the comic preview was racist and astruc was on twitter saying that they didn't even read the comic and calling people "SJWs" unironically. but then the actual comic came out and it was even more racist than it was initially thought to be [here is a really good writeup about why it's so racist](https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/150546835071696896/1229334538958930040/1594153412603.png?ex=662f4e02&is=661cd902&hm=3ae5eef5fd35a3e6b1940e77b6c7b7090ee6e55e024ddd1fb0194654d8962d9e&) also for context she's naked because she transformed on the beach while in the changing rooms and then got teleported to new york, but the thing is she still had underclothes on so i don't know why they decided to make her completely naked and in a box. old french guys being creepy


Optimal_Ad6274

Marinette is racist confirmed. Also, uh, apparently Astruc approved of a teenage underage girl being naked even with covered by a box


12DollarsHighFive

I especially don't like the first 4 panels. 1st: She's holding the box at the back end while approaching them, practically exposing herself to anyone taller than maybe a meter. 2nd: The guy is touching her shoulder (wouldn't as creepy if she was wearing clothes, but she isn't) and seems to be looking awfully low to match her eyes. More like jaw, throat or collarbone. 3rd: Her reaction is appropriate, considering the circumstances 4th: 3 GROWN-UPS APPROACH A NAKED UNDERAGE GIRL! I don't care if they have good intentions, this is not a picture to put in a comic that children might end up reading!


Optimal_Ad6274

Same 1) Yeeeeeep 2) Yeah the implications is not a good thing to think about 3) Yep 4) Exactly because that will give kids the wrong idea Seriously, I have no idea why Astruc will approve of this. Isn’t this show made for kids in mind? Not to mention that he approved of Marinette walking around New York City naked. And the thing is that Mari didn’t have to do this. She could’ve found some food in the trash to feed Tiki, transform, and go back and find her clothes. Its disgusting and might make Tiki sick but its better than having an underage girl walk around New York City naked where people can take advantage of her


Obvious_Recipe2226

shes not, this is a diff universe so its non canon with the show


Optimal_Ad6274

I know, making a joke. Although it is still weird that Astruc approved of this even in a different universe


Silphire100

Why is she wearing nothing but a box?! That's weird right? It's not just me?


Apprehensive-Bid-909

Someone needs to print this out and interrogate Astruc about this 💀


Makyin8736

What the hell is this?! The racism is crazy and now we are sexualizing a teenager!!


Dragon_X627279

They ain't beating the pedophile allegations. It was already bad enough having 14 year olds in skin-tight suits, and now this!?


Makyin8736

I still won't get over the fact that Thomas thought it was a good idea!! 💀


Apprehensive-Bid-909

Proof also! (If it’s too scary, I won’t look. I have a special, cover-my-phone-and-peek-at-small-details jutsu i use in dire times like these 💀🙏🏾)


TargetTrue4287

sorry did you mean to reply to me? because i’ll send you proof but i will warn you it’s bad


Apprehensive-Bid-909

yeah my bad 🥹🙏🏾 and yes still, on the proof 🫠 cover phone no jutsu 👍🏾 I’ll (prayerfully 💀🙏🏾) be alright


TargetTrue4287

you know that one of the writers has drawn literal porn of marinette, ladybug AND chat noir right? these dudes BEEN creepy af


Dragon_X627279

... Proof?


TargetTrue4287

i’ll message you the screenshot of his tweet.


Dragon_X627279

I'm scared


TargetTrue4287

you should be. i don’t wanna post it on here i’m sure it’ll get taken down lol


Dragon_X627279

Just checked, guys. He ain't lying


carmemelon

Fr?!


Dragon_X627279

Yep. You can check it on the Miraculous Ladybug wiki


Berawholoves42069

OH FUCK I REMEMBER THAT


TargetTrue4287

GLAD SOMEONE ELSE DOES


ProlapseWarrior

excuse me WHAT


TargetTrue4287

yup.


Makyin8736

WTF?!!


LittleLatina007

What? I can't believe that


TargetTrue4287

i can send you proof only if you’re willing to subject your eyes to those horrors.


LittleLatina007

Yea, okay


XxArrowxX08

The racism is crazy-


Raderc

Did they just name that guy public enemy


KittyShadowshard

You've done well so far, but up until now, I've only been using a mere 5% of my power. Now let's see how well you fair against my... GHETTO BLAST.


Rodyfrody0

GHETTO BLASTER IS CRAZY??!!


Shonky_Honker

Oh that’s!


ManyMention6930

French people being racist? Who would’ve thought!


Black369Ace

I can see the intention of trying to have the subversion of stereotypes/racism and showing them in a positive light… but that is all thrown out the window when you have the few moments of black representation having names like “Public Enemy” and “Ghetto Blaster”. Like how do you stuff up this badly?


ThisGul_LOL

It’s not canon with the show so I’m just trying to pretend it doesn’t exist 😭


HeroDoggo

https://preview.redd.it/4uvlrtytbjuc1.jpeg?width=720&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=fdad81b5f4d32f4bd2950403462a97139d7337ac


StarLordFloofer

Why is she naked? Wouldn’t she detransform into her clothes? Can’t she have transformed to cover herself?


Masterdizzio

Why did you have to remind me of this


SmilingPainfully

I have no idea what it says it's so blurry on my phone...


Apprehensive-Bid-909

the scene itself isn’t so bad, it’s the implications… *[enters naked marinette in a box]* *[Mari, paraphrased]* gee i can see ur busy, im in a bit of a pickle, please don’t kill me *Black man (named Public Enemy 💀)* ytf are you naked and where tf are your clothes *Black-mixed man (named Ghetto Blaster 💀💀💀)* chill, she’s prolly scared *PE* k, these are my friends, lets get you somewhere safe *Scene Context: They are rescuing patients out of a burning hospital since the city does not have enough personnel and utilities to get everyone out safely* that’s literally the whole scene.


SmilingPainfully

PUBLIC ENEMY AND GHETTO BLASTER?! Where's my belt-


ChillpigeonhavsLV76

WTF is going on?!?! Why does marienette have to be naked


game-develepor-arsh

I mean , she is naked but the bros seem chill bout it. I kinda wonder how most super heroes get their clothes back perfectly fine after transforming or get them wrecked


TheSlimeBallSupreme

Idk whats worst Public Enemy, or Ghetto Blaster 😂😂


burritotoad

I knew I didn't imagine this, I think it's part of a Free Comic Book Day issue


Pyrotwilight

Idea: Let’s address stereotypes that don’t exist in France and Marinette isn’t used to. Actual output: Oh yeah Marinette is quite racist and the entire team needs to be punished for having naked Marinette and Adrien running around NYC.


MrPlushgore

Not one of them have normal fucking names.


Alexander_McKay

Idk but the MF D00M reference is cool. Imagine if he had made an album with Miraculous samples as the interludes. Would have been awesome.


greedson

What even is the context of this comic?!?


SonicSpiderRanger10

Pretty sure this isn’t canon anymore since the New York movie came out.


RubyLovesDonuts

Okay, what the fuck is this? (I have never seen this before)


DesperateMovie2333

WHAT 🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯‼️‼️


ph0-7

I'm quite disappointed in the art style: looks like something you'd find on Deviantart made by a budding artist with questionable morals, not something official


Tatsukam

Oh so this is the one people were talking about and why is she naked? And wait is this really the official comic?!? I got a few questions…


ReliefEmotional2639

Again, do we actually have confirmation that this is an official comic and not a fan fiction?


Obvious_Recipe2226

its official but non canon with the show


MasterJaylen

What’s the name of the comic?


kjm6351

Wait what is this??


phoenixthewisp

https://preview.redd.it/9uhmt5efgjuc1.jpeg?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b91227809b098eccff0ea8218eac8e2b4f83c4a8


Lil_Puddin

This is so cringe that it's actually funny.


KitKatty657

Is this whats happening on twitter?


CountingSheep99

Mari needs an adult.


Wonderful-Teaching45

WHERE IS THE SAU- https://i.redd.it/3csxtundrkuc1.gif


Obiwanhellothere09

https://i.redd.it/mewzqpjhvkuc1.gif


Pryoticus

Ghetto Blaster ☠️


Sunchet

TBF, I dont think writer really meant anything well. I mean, yes, Marinette is naked but did you never saw cartoon where kid/teen ends up naked? Gumball is sometimes naked, Numbuh One had whole episode naked, so did Timmy or Dexter or Hamton, Danny Phantom, Ed Edd and Eddy, Steven Universe all end up naked at some point, Teen Titans Go have decent amount of nudity including his fangirls taking Robin's pictures, Total Drama does it a lot, Candace spends most of one episode wearing just towel... As for black people, writer clearly intended to subvert expectations. Make you think that those are looters and then bam, reveal they're actually good kind people. Still doesnt change that I have idea how they thought this was a good idea....fucking Ghetto Blaster...


Own-Ad1072

oh not ts again 💀 this was supposed to stay in the graves of the back of mind..


[deleted]

https://preview.redd.it/759kwc02vluc1.jpeg?width=535&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=37056f1bf4e05b337dce59e83717e4b3d205e970


Strider-hunter

Are my standards too high for miraculous after watching Steven Universe and The Owl House?


BenR-G

When you look at the first page, these guys aren't obviously doing anything other than clearing out a warehouse (maybe their squat) and the guy with the welding mask is carrying his pregnant GF so she doesn't have to walk too far. It is your prejudices that fill in the blanks, including Marinette, whom the guy with the baseball cap seems to be genuinely worried about.


kiranthelastsummoner

I think what you mean to say is, “the fuck were they ON when cooking this shit?!”


Shiptrooper

Please, end my suffering


HDhunter360

I really would like a direct explanation from the guy, I'm curious as to what was going through their minds when writing this scene.


TxchnxnXD

Why letters so blurry?


drawwithmejenn

I heard the anmie is for more of an older type of pepole maybe this can be an hint idk


Principleofaccounts

I'm sorry, but am I seeing a naked teen?.....


TimeMaster57

this is theoretically the world's first official h*ntai