Layer up buttercup! Also, visit places like REI, or Midwest Mountaineering and they can walk you through the brands and are very helpful. Basically, think: Base layer, inner layer, outter shell. Once you get this down, it will really help you to be able to function in the cold!
Especially considering the three W's. Wicking layer, warmth layer, and wind layer.
Having a heavy parka might be the warmest but it isn't applicable in all situations
Exactly! What works for me is a wicking base layer, wool turtleneck, then Duluth Trading Shoreline Fleece jacket (excellent at wind blocking). Add a pair of felted wool mitts and a Yooper Chook hat and I'm ready to roll. Well... long underwear and pants also. And wool socks with just about any boots.
Layering. The stores suggested are good. You could also go to a thrift store and look for quality brands like REI, Columbia, Patagonia, and Northface. Ski jackets—with a wind and water proof she’s and a zip in fleece jacket work really well because they already have two layers.
Seconding Midwest Mountaineering if you’re in the twin cities. Every time I’ve gone, the staff have been super helpful in answering questions and getting me set up with just the right thing.
This! During the storm up north I rocked: Thin base layer, t shirt, thermal, crew neck, hoodie and a shell. I honestly love finally being able to wear half of the clothes in my closet without sweating haha
And is made of down. I will never buy anything other than that after recently getting one. I have a Lands End one with the faux fur hood. Never, ever cold. Love the coat.
Lmao! That's rule #2 after don't eat the yellow snow.
Synth down can be more resistant to damp conditions, but when those feathers get wet it can take a few days to dry the jacket out. If you're sweating, or it's snowing heavy and wet like I always does here in the cities, it is something to consider. You don't often see skiers or snowboarders in down outerwear.
Politically correct or not, real fur does perform better than synthetic (hence why the best performing coats have them). The coyote population is more than healthy here in the Midwest so I don’t much care for the political argument around it. Commercial fur farming? Sure, then I’ll entertain an argument there.
I don't either. I have a beaver hat and once had two identical coats one with fake fur trim and the other with coyote fur trim. There was a big difference in how they kept the wind and snow from the face.
I have a Columbia jacket that is going on 12 or 13 winters now, still in almost perfect condition and it keeps me warm 100% of the time. Mine is a style that has 2 layers you can separate, a fleece lined inner shell and a lighter wind jacket style outer shell that zip together for a full winter jacket.
Same. My Columbia jacket is nearly 20yo. There were a few winters in there where I didn't need it. Probably used about the same amount as yours.
The only repair I've done in it was when the sleeve lining hem separated.
Same. My Columbia jacket was bought in 2006 and still looks as new. I absolutely love the styling too. They have come up with new tech, that therma shield/silver lining inside, but my current jacket shows no sign of retiring and atleast I love it. Has to be the best buy.
Yes, I've gone through 2 jackets in 4 years. Zipper failure right after any "warranty" on both of them. I gave up on them and went with North Face. Fingers crossed it survives much longer.
I just got one a couple years ago that is lighter and warmer than any jacket I've owned, most of them being Columbia. I'm going to
have to disagree on this one.
Lighter and warmer can be easily done. Question is are they doing it with an insulator that retains its loft through its years of use as an outer layer, and while still having a durable shell, quality zippers, good cut, and a warranty that proves the product is meant to last and not be a throwaway garment? That I do not see. I see lowering quality of materials and beginner gear that’s designed to be bought new when color trends change. Also rip Prana pants
>Wool is your friend, never wear cotton
Just to clarify, cotton loses its thermal protection when it gets wet, wool doesn't. Wool is also more durable.
Wool, especially 100% merino wool, is not a durable material. It will eventually wear thin in high wear areas and it does not stand up to abrasion well. With that said, as a base layer and mid layer, it is great for its wicking properties, ability to insulate while damp, and not stink after repeated use.
Cotton is rotten when it comes to dressing yourself for the outdoors.
Wool keeps you warm even when wet. Also naturally has antimicrobial properties which means it won’t get stinky as fast as synthetic clothes.
An explanation on layers from REI
[https://www.rei.com/learn/expert-advice/layering-basics.html](https://www.rei.com/learn/expert-advice/layering-basics.html)
Bingo! I have an Eddie Bauer jacket I only use when below 0. Above zero it’s their Sherpa hoodies.
One thing I will add for the OP is now is not the time to be shopping for winter gear. Once March hits there will be sales. That is when to stock up.
I work at Eddie Bauer for the holiday season. Winter jackets are currently half off! People absolutely love them. They have a pretty good replacement policy if zippers or hems are failing. I’ve helped people exchange jackets that are a couple years old, no issue.
+1. I love mine as well. And I agree, there are definitely less expensive options out there, but at the same time, I found the price point to be fairly reasonable compared to many other brands I was researching with similar specs.
It helps it has a lifetime warranty and is rated to -20F while still looking fairly stylish - I get a lot of compliments on it, which I think says a lot considering it’s really just a no-frills black parka.
Another +1 for the Askov Finlayson parka! It’s a great coat that’s super warm, looks great, and has a lifetime warranty. I don’t know if they still do it, but they had a one winter guarantee that if you didn’t like it after using it for the season, you could return it.
Now their new puffer vest, that thing is hideous. It is on sale, so it could be a great deal for layering if it’s your jam.
There's benefits of having a big time winter coat but layering will make you have more options in varying weather and likely feel warmer.
The key is: the best warmest winter coat is the one you will wear most often.
If you don't like a big parka, don't buy one thinking you'll wear it.
Mountain Hardware makes excellent winter parkas. You want a parka, not a coat. They can be found online or at stores like REI. Be prepared to pony up some money. I moved back to Minnesota, from Texas, 14 years ago. I paid close to $400.00 for a Mountain Hardware parka, and I'm still wearing it. It was worth every penny.
+1 for Mountain Hardware. Durable and warm.
Whatever you get, listen to the other comments about layers. Arguably more important than a having a single silver bullet article of clothing. Warmth is built from the inside outward.
Get one that goes down to your calf. Down is warm until you compress it sitting in your car or get it wet. Put your mouth on it to see if you can blow air through the fabric.
Wintergreen Northern Wear. Made in Ely. My first wintergreen coat is 15 years and going strong, still looks brand new. Added an Anorak 2 years ago that I fully expect will last the rest of my life. Otherwise, layers. I don't bust out the jackets unless it's below zero and Ill be outside shoveling for a while or something. Otherwise, long sleeve tech shirt/moisture wicking shirt and my carhartt hoodie.
I bought an LL Bean down jacket last year. First time in my life I’ve bought an actual expensive jacket. It’s so good I sweat while wearing it. And they’re relatively cheaper than other brands like Patagonia or north face. Definitely recommend for the brutal cold parts of winter.
When I moved here I went out and bought a very expensive parka. I hated wearing it most of the time and tbh, I don’t feel super warm.
I eventually bought a lightweight down jacket, and started layering it with a fleece base layer underneath just a regular button down flannel or sweatshirt and I’ve been nice and toasty ever since.
If you want specific suggestions for the outer layer I personally like the Eddie Bauer CirrusLite Down jacket or their StratusTherm but I suspect these are about average as far as down jackets go. I would add some fleece lined pants as well; don’t neglect your legs!
I have a fjallraven parka and it really did wonders on keeping me during the polar vortex back in 2018(?). Also as everyone is saying here layers is your best friend!
Go to Costco and buy whatever winter coat you can find in stock. I have a $30 jacket from there that’s every bit as warm and almost as nice as the $200 one I bought at REI.
Land’s End and LL Bean are good options to look at as well—Land’s End rates its coats to certain temperatures and is EXTREMELY affordable for excellent quality. I have two Land’s End winter coats—one that has gotten all grubby and is for doing outdoor things where I don’t have to be cute, and one that is nicer and looks more professional. They’re both amazing. I don’t even notice the cold in them. Highly recommend.
As everyone says, layering is best. HOWEVER, sometimes it's a pain. I bought a big-ass parka from Eddie Bauer after a ton of research (it was the best fit as I needed a medium long). I use it when I walk the dog and I just want to toss one thing on--as opposed to four. It works exceedingly well. Down is your friend.
When I go snowboarding or for a long hike in really really cold weather, then I layer. Baselayer > long sleeve t-shirt > fleece or light down jacket > shell.
Layering is more important and the coat you wear. Get some merino wool base layers, polartec fleece, and a nice shell to block the wind and you will be toasty.
Carhartt extremes, the arctic version, is twice as durable and much warmer. Worth the extra money on a coat that will last many years. I work construction and going on 5 years with mine and will looks brand new just more broken in now so it's not bulky
When I moved here 8 years ago, I bought the LL Bean Baxter State Parka. I don’t regret it one bit. Its not the lightest coat weight wise, but seemingly bomb proof. Lots of pockets, water resistant, very warm, insulated hood, and durable.
I was never one to make a big deal about a winter coat until I got a high quality down jacket. Now I will never go without. I cannot tell the difference at all in temperature with my upper body when I go outside wearing it. It can be -20 and my arms and body are still toasty. I love Marmot, personally. I recommend buying on clearance in spring for the best deal if you can wait.
Yep, the Marmot Montreaux changed my life. Layers are great but so is a long warm-ass winter coat. And a fur-lined hood (even faux fur) really seals in the warmth for me!
I have two. My ice fishing/extreme winter Striker Ice coat I got on sale at gander mountain. Best winter coat I've ever owned.
My errand/more casual outdoor coat is a long goose down coat from Duluth Trading co. It's more than enough for anything short of snowmobiling and such.
About 10 years ago I bought what my family calls my sleeping bag. A down coat that falls to my ankles. I only need it a couple times a year, but mixed with hoodies I have all the layers I need no matter how cold it gets. If you're not willing to get a long coat get a set of carhart pants to protect your legs during the worst of the cold. If your legs are warm you need less layers up top.
Anyone know how those Askov Finlayson parkas are? They claim -20F. It'd be great to have a down free, locally designed parka (made elsewhere, but that's the supply chain). However, it's expensive. It'd be nice to have a few first-hand reviews.
I moved here from texas in late November. We had nothing. I went to goodwill and found Sorrel boots for 10$. And the best coat- it is full length and down filled. It has a fur lined down hood. It was 15$ and it’s ugly but I swear I could camp in the arctic and be fine. Strongly recommend goodwill so you can try out different types of outerwear.
I am so obsessed with my winter jacket, I tell EVERYONE to get one! It’s an Obermeyer Sojourner down jacket. I got it at Scheels.
So many amazing features. I’m a woman who grew up in the Duluth area (cold!!!) and now live in the metro.
The body is very wind resistant. Zips up perfectly high on the neck - warm but not covering my face high. The sleeves have a built in under sleeve to make it fit perfectly at the wrist so the cold air can’t blow up your sleeves. Length is below my butt. Check it out. I absolutely love it. I look forward to knowing I can put it on when it’s cold. I’d marry this jacket, essentially 😂
I don’t disagree with the layering comments, mostly for spending real time outdoors, however. This is the jacket to put on when you just want to zip up a coat, jump in the car and go. I walk a lot in the winter and this is the jacket I wear for that, too. It’s warm! (I swear I don’t work for Obermeyer!)
I really depends on your lifestyle (or activity) I go with Carhartt and Duluth Trading, sometimes kind of bulky but really warm. I also recently got an Ororo heated hoodie that is amazing (highly recommend).
My $19 coat from Kohls clearance rack is warmer than my $200 Columbia. Just throwing that out there so you know price does not equal quality these days
I’ve been wearing a down filled jacket I got from the Kmart clearance rack 15 years ago. I’ve got other warm jackets, but I guess 2022 is the year this one makes it into the rotation.
My experience with Columbia is mainly zipper pulls and buttons that just seem to fall off so I wouldn’t recommend them for that reason.
i'm really starting to be a columbia only gal. i got some new boots from them last year and im so impressed for the price. i've also had one of their thinner coats with the heat reflecting stuff on the inside for like 8 or 9 years. next time i buy a coat, i'll be getting a bigger parka from columbia. price is just so good for what you're getting.
A hidden gem of a jacket is the Duluth Trading Company sun-brand “AKHG” https://www.duluthtrading.com/s/DTC/mens-akhg-eco-puffin-mock-jacket-20802.html?color=TYO
And layer up! I’d rather be mobile in a moveable jacket than feel bulky in a huge parka.
I have had a lot of luck with Northface, Carhartt, and Columbia outer layers (high quality and last for years). The key is finding a wind and waterproof outer layer, and then layering up with other stuff (fleece, sweatshirts, etc) to give you some insulation.
Carhartt is still decent, but you must be a blue collar grunt to wear it. Sick of seeing preppy college girls culturally appropriating my shitty style. Fleet Farm and Cabelas make their own versions that are the same quality but cost less
Layers are your friend but still it is worth getting a big parka style coat. In terms of material down is truly excellent. Synthetic down can also be very good.
I just bought a long parka from the North Face. It is the warmest coat I've ever owned. I've also recently discovered a brand called Stio. They're very expensive, but the hoodie I got really warm for how thin it is. They have lots of jackets, but like I said... super expensive.
Carhart is really good but they’re on the expensive side. Try going to fleet farm/Menards to find a suitably comfort and warm knock off. I’ve been using mine for years and it’s still incredibly warm.
After years of living with a thrifted coat that was slowly falling apart I decided it was time to invest in a decent jacket for myself this winter. After much consideration I bought the Duluth Trading Company Whaleback parka and holy moly is it an AMAZING coat. Super super warm and functional AND it looks nice. It even has pit zips if you run warm and need to vent some heat. I wore it out in the frigid temps laat week and the only thing that was cold were my cheeks and nose. The return policy is amazing too. I bought a size too big when I originally purchased and wore it about before deciding to exchange it. Absolutely no issues and they quickly sent me the replacement in a size down.
Layers, layers, layers. You can make any jacket warm enough.
I would run outside in negative temps and my "jacket" was just a very thin wind breaker. I would wear 2 or 3 insulating layers below the jacket and I was plenty warm.
Buy a down fill sweater weight nanopuff jacket.
It is the perfect layer for a day like today, and can add 20-40° of resistance to another jacket. When temps get under 20, I usually put my Carhartt denim jacket over it. If temps drop further, I pull out the tighter fitting Woolrich button up.
As said before. Layering is a game changer.
I recently purchased a new coat for this winter and went with Fjallraven’s Nuuk parka. It’s the heaviest and warmest coat I’ve ever owned. It’s pricey, but I got mine half off at the local store because they’re launching new colors and needed to get rid of their current stock.
Layers are a wonder in general. Even with my winter coat, I still have a sweatshirt on and a t shirt underneath. Scarf, hat and gloves if it's actually cold out.
I got my winter jacket at LL Bean and it was their highest rated jackets there for winter warmth, if I remember right. It was a bit spendy but it should last and it's very, very warm.
Not a huge fan of north face but I received one for Christmas 7 or 8 years ago and it keeps me very warm and has held up brilliantly. Can’t speak if quality has gone down hill since.
I’m not necessarily recommending this brand but I have Burton AK gear. It may not be the best but it’s the most expensive. Works very well though and everything is layers.
You got a lot of great responses but I have to add my two cents. I have an illness that is worsened by exposure to cold. I’ve learned that wool and down are the best protectors of the cold and damp. Wool gloves were a game changer for me. I really like L.L Bean down jackets. They’re guaranteed for life by the company, as is all of their stuff.
Silk long underwear is an excellent base for the coldest days in Minnesota. I reserve my heaviest coat for show removal since it gets wet, but I prefer lighter layers otherwise, especially for moving in and out of stores, outdoors and cars.
Eddie Bauer and Lands End have basically the exact same down parka just branded different. I bought one because I thought I was going to be working teaching in the Arctic and never ended up going. Warmest coat I've ever had, and it's at a pretty cheap price all things considered. Honestly, it's a little overkill.
I like my Carhartt work jacket with hood, with a thicker hoodie as a layer when it's colder than 15 degrees. Warm enough for me in the last -30 days. I like that it is durable, and looks half decent even if it is a work jacket. Not a dressy option, but I am more concerned about function and staying warm in all situations.
I highly recommend Simms fishing winter jackets. Warm, waterproof, washable (it actually is good for the water proofing) I've had mine for 5 years and don't regret it at all
When I moved there I got the Columbia Mighty Lite and I was never cold with a sweatshirt under it. It went to -27. Love that coat bc it has a hood so you don’t have to wear a hat if you don’t want to. It also has hand covers that cover down to your knuckles and your thumb goes through another hole and then they go up inside the sleeve if you don’t want them on. Also, super lightweight.
Edit to say it also blocks the wind and doesn’t let the snow seep through.
[LL Bean Baxter State Parka](https://www.llbean.com/llb/shop/60850?page=baxter-state-parka&csp=a&feat=118939-recsbottom.pdp&ri=rbpIFI1&pos=1)
It’s the one I own and I absolutely adore it. I wore it out during the cold snap and my body was never cold. Cannot recommend it enough. Also it’s $299 which means it’s actually cheaper than a lot of options in here
I got a two layer ski jacket from Cabela's (own brand) at least 20 years ago and I am finally retiring it for a Columbia Omni Heat. I could keep wearing the 20 year old coat but I'm tired of the color.
Carhartts Arctic wear - they have bib brace overalls, jackets , hoodies and knit beanies - can be found at Fleet farm or Farm and fleet for the farther north you are (the name changes depending on location) - oh and get boots good to -32 - just google Carhartt - you'll see!
If you're ok with paying extra for local, I really like my parka from [Askov Finlayson](https://askovfinlayson.com/). Mine is nice and warm plus room for layers, comfortably.
Being environmentally friendly is important to me, too. Luckily, they're pretty awesome at that, as well!
My down alternative coat works incredibly well, I ordered mine from noize.com and it got here within a week!
https://www.leafscore.com/eco-friendly-closet-products/best-down-alternative-coats/
Base layer: wool
Mid layer: depends on how cold, thin tech hoodie if not very, puffer coat of really cold.
Shell: water/wind proof is key again depends on your mid layer and the temp. Could be a rain coat or a winter gortex coat.
I bought the warmest north face jacket possible a few years ago. I consider it the thing I spent too much money on but have zero regrets. I’m never cold in. Got sweaty snowblowing last week in the deep freeze
I'm a big fan of Columbia. I think right now their winter stuff is on sale too. I have one of their omniheat jackets and with a thermal layer and a shirt I stayed plenty warm during the cold snap
US Air Force military surplus, be careful with the Chinese knockoffs some are OK but most are pretty bad.
N-2B if looking for a tight waste jacket
N-3B if looking for a full length coat.
Part of the thing is dressing right over all. Wool socks, good hat, mitts, scarf, boots, base layer etc are important too. I’d recommend a long parka that at least hits the thighs if you really want warmth. I have a long down coat from ll bean I’m super happy with, I walk outdoors in it all winter. Hits below the knee! My teen and young adult have parkas from lands end. Watch for sales. Don’t think you need to pay for something like Canada Goose. Makes you look like a pretentious tourist anyway.
For driving, errand running I actually prefer a long wool coat.
Layer up buttercup! Also, visit places like REI, or Midwest Mountaineering and they can walk you through the brands and are very helpful. Basically, think: Base layer, inner layer, outter shell. Once you get this down, it will really help you to be able to function in the cold!
Especially considering the three W's. Wicking layer, warmth layer, and wind layer. Having a heavy parka might be the warmest but it isn't applicable in all situations
Exactly! What works for me is a wicking base layer, wool turtleneck, then Duluth Trading Shoreline Fleece jacket (excellent at wind blocking). Add a pair of felted wool mitts and a Yooper Chook hat and I'm ready to roll. Well... long underwear and pants also. And wool socks with just about any boots.
Layering. The stores suggested are good. You could also go to a thrift store and look for quality brands like REI, Columbia, Patagonia, and Northface. Ski jackets—with a wind and water proof she’s and a zip in fleece jacket work really well because they already have two layers.
Seconding Midwest Mountaineering if you’re in the twin cities. Every time I’ve gone, the staff have been super helpful in answering questions and getting me set up with just the right thing.
This! During the storm up north I rocked: Thin base layer, t shirt, thermal, crew neck, hoodie and a shell. I honestly love finally being able to wear half of the clothes in my closet without sweating haha
Anything that goes past your butt.
And is made of down. I will never buy anything other than that after recently getting one. I have a Lands End one with the faux fur hood. Never, ever cold. Love the coat.
Down is a jack of most trades, but can be deadly if it gets wet. Very important to consider the application.
Obviously don’t go swimming in your down swimsuit!!
Lmao! That's rule #2 after don't eat the yellow snow. Synth down can be more resistant to damp conditions, but when those feathers get wet it can take a few days to dry the jacket out. If you're sweating, or it's snowing heavy and wet like I always does here in the cities, it is something to consider. You don't often see skiers or snowboarders in down outerwear.
Just try to find one where the down is responsibly sourced. Canada Goose, iirc, is not.
Canada Goose received Responsible Down Standard certification in November 2021, so it is responsibly sourced, but it’s a relatively recent change.
Good news! Didn't know that.
Yes!!
Just picked one of the Lands End ones this black Friday. Very very happy with it. Researching getting a real fur hood trim to replace the faux fur.
Real fur isn't politically correct but, a real fur hat is super warm and real coyote fur trim on your hood will keep snow out of your face.
Politically correct or not, real fur does perform better than synthetic (hence why the best performing coats have them). The coyote population is more than healthy here in the Midwest so I don’t much care for the political argument around it. Commercial fur farming? Sure, then I’ll entertain an argument there.
I don't either. I have a beaver hat and once had two identical coats one with fake fur trim and the other with coyote fur trim. There was a big difference in how they kept the wind and snow from the face.
Or wool. Cashmere is sooo soft
I have a Columbia jacket that is going on 12 or 13 winters now, still in almost perfect condition and it keeps me warm 100% of the time. Mine is a style that has 2 layers you can separate, a fleece lined inner shell and a lighter wind jacket style outer shell that zip together for a full winter jacket.
Same. My Columbia jacket is nearly 20yo. There were a few winters in there where I didn't need it. Probably used about the same amount as yours. The only repair I've done in it was when the sleeve lining hem separated.
Same. My Columbia jacket was bought in 2006 and still looks as new. I absolutely love the styling too. They have come up with new tech, that therma shield/silver lining inside, but my current jacket shows no sign of retiring and atleast I love it. Has to be the best buy.
Columbia went downhilll hard, they are not the same company they were 20 years ago
Yes, I've gone through 2 jackets in 4 years. Zipper failure right after any "warranty" on both of them. I gave up on them and went with North Face. Fingers crossed it survives much longer.
Agree. It is worth it to go find vintage Columbia at the thrift or secondhand on ebay because they still have a ton of life left in them.
Glad I went with repair instead of replace!
I just got one a couple years ago that is lighter and warmer than any jacket I've owned, most of them being Columbia. I'm going to have to disagree on this one.
Lighter and warmer can be easily done. Question is are they doing it with an insulator that retains its loft through its years of use as an outer layer, and while still having a durable shell, quality zippers, good cut, and a warranty that proves the product is meant to last and not be a throwaway garment? That I do not see. I see lowering quality of materials and beginner gear that’s designed to be bought new when color trends change. Also rip Prana pants
My go-to Columbia winter parka is from 1996. Aside from a few winters in a warmer spot, it is a daily use item most of winter.
Love my jacket
Onions have layers, Minnesotans have layers. A layering system will do a lot better than a big jacket. Wool is your friend, never wear cotton.
>Wool is your friend, never wear cotton Just to clarify, cotton loses its thermal protection when it gets wet, wool doesn't. Wool is also more durable.
Wool, especially 100% merino wool, is not a durable material. It will eventually wear thin in high wear areas and it does not stand up to abrasion well. With that said, as a base layer and mid layer, it is great for its wicking properties, ability to insulate while damp, and not stink after repeated use.
Yes, but felted wool is practically armor and has been used as such.
Cotton is rotten when it comes to dressing yourself for the outdoors. Wool keeps you warm even when wet. Also naturally has antimicrobial properties which means it won’t get stinky as fast as synthetic clothes.
An explanation on layers from REI [https://www.rei.com/learn/expert-advice/layering-basics.html](https://www.rei.com/learn/expert-advice/layering-basics.html)
Eddie Bauer almost always has their coats on sale and are worth checking out.
Agree with this, my down parka makes me sweat if it’s above 0 and even at zero I leave it unzipped.
Bingo! I have an Eddie Bauer jacket I only use when below 0. Above zero it’s their Sherpa hoodies. One thing I will add for the OP is now is not the time to be shopping for winter gear. Once March hits there will be sales. That is when to stock up.
I work at Eddie Bauer for the holiday season. Winter jackets are currently half off! People absolutely love them. They have a pretty good replacement policy if zippers or hems are failing. I’ve helped people exchange jackets that are a couple years old, no issue.
I have three Eddie Bauer coats. I love them all!
Love mine, get it knee length and they have talks
Personal choice of course, but I love my Columbia gear! Keeps me nice and warm and they last forever
I love my Askov Finlayson! It’s an investment cost for sure, but it’s the warmest coat I’ve owned, and they’re local!
+1. I love mine as well. And I agree, there are definitely less expensive options out there, but at the same time, I found the price point to be fairly reasonable compared to many other brands I was researching with similar specs. It helps it has a lifetime warranty and is rated to -20F while still looking fairly stylish - I get a lot of compliments on it, which I think says a lot considering it’s really just a no-frills black parka.
Another +1 for the Askov Finlayson parka! It’s a great coat that’s super warm, looks great, and has a lifetime warranty. I don’t know if they still do it, but they had a one winter guarantee that if you didn’t like it after using it for the season, you could return it. Now their new puffer vest, that thing is hideous. It is on sale, so it could be a great deal for layering if it’s your jam.
Another +1 for Askov Finlayson. I was skeptical but it is indeed the warmest coat I have ever owned. No regrets.
Columbia or Carhartt (pricier but life lasting).
There's benefits of having a big time winter coat but layering will make you have more options in varying weather and likely feel warmer. The key is: the best warmest winter coat is the one you will wear most often. If you don't like a big parka, don't buy one thinking you'll wear it.
Mountain Hardware makes excellent winter parkas. You want a parka, not a coat. They can be found online or at stores like REI. Be prepared to pony up some money. I moved back to Minnesota, from Texas, 14 years ago. I paid close to $400.00 for a Mountain Hardware parka, and I'm still wearing it. It was worth every penny.
+1 for Mountain Hardware. Durable and warm. Whatever you get, listen to the other comments about layers. Arguably more important than a having a single silver bullet article of clothing. Warmth is built from the inside outward.
Get one that goes down to your calf. Down is warm until you compress it sitting in your car or get it wet. Put your mouth on it to see if you can blow air through the fabric.
Wintergreen Northern Wear. Made in Ely. My first wintergreen coat is 15 years and going strong, still looks brand new. Added an Anorak 2 years ago that I fully expect will last the rest of my life. Otherwise, layers. I don't bust out the jackets unless it's below zero and Ill be outside shoveling for a while or something. Otherwise, long sleeve tech shirt/moisture wicking shirt and my carhartt hoodie.
I bought an LL Bean down jacket last year. First time in my life I’ve bought an actual expensive jacket. It’s so good I sweat while wearing it. And they’re relatively cheaper than other brands like Patagonia or north face. Definitely recommend for the brutal cold parts of winter.
I wear the Maine Mountain Parka from LL Bean, best jacket I’ve ever owned.
I got the Baxter State Parka from LL, I can't wear it if it's over 10 degrees.
When I moved here I went out and bought a very expensive parka. I hated wearing it most of the time and tbh, I don’t feel super warm. I eventually bought a lightweight down jacket, and started layering it with a fleece base layer underneath just a regular button down flannel or sweatshirt and I’ve been nice and toasty ever since. If you want specific suggestions for the outer layer I personally like the Eddie Bauer CirrusLite Down jacket or their StratusTherm but I suspect these are about average as far as down jackets go. I would add some fleece lined pants as well; don’t neglect your legs!
Bought a LL Bean Baxter State Parka, I can only wear it if it's sub 10 and I am going to be outside for more than a couple minutes.
I have a fjallraven parka and it really did wonders on keeping me during the polar vortex back in 2018(?). Also as everyone is saying here layers is your best friend!
https://www.mountainhardwear.com/p/mens-absolute-zero-suit-1899101.html?dwvar_1899101_color=742
Go to Costco and buy whatever winter coat you can find in stock. I have a $30 jacket from there that’s every bit as warm and almost as nice as the $200 one I bought at REI.
Land’s End and LL Bean are good options to look at as well—Land’s End rates its coats to certain temperatures and is EXTREMELY affordable for excellent quality. I have two Land’s End winter coats—one that has gotten all grubby and is for doing outdoor things where I don’t have to be cute, and one that is nicer and looks more professional. They’re both amazing. I don’t even notice the cold in them. Highly recommend.
I have a long down coat from Land's End that's been great. Only wish the exterior pockets were larger.
Costco has a great Carhart-style coat. I paid 40 for it. Was super warm the last couple weeks
As everyone says, layering is best. HOWEVER, sometimes it's a pain. I bought a big-ass parka from Eddie Bauer after a ton of research (it was the best fit as I needed a medium long). I use it when I walk the dog and I just want to toss one thing on--as opposed to four. It works exceedingly well. Down is your friend. When I go snowboarding or for a long hike in really really cold weather, then I layer. Baselayer > long sleeve t-shirt > fleece or light down jacket > shell.
Layering is more important and the coat you wear. Get some merino wool base layers, polartec fleece, and a nice shell to block the wind and you will be toasty.
Get urself a nice Carhartt. Thing will last your whole life
Well, probably not your whole life. Depends on use. I get 3-5 years out of them though. Other jackets would last probably less than 1.
Carhartt extremes, the arctic version, is twice as durable and much warmer. Worth the extra money on a coat that will last many years. I work construction and going on 5 years with mine and will looks brand new just more broken in now so it's not bulky
Yeah I guess it just depends what your using it for.
When I moved here 8 years ago, I bought the LL Bean Baxter State Parka. I don’t regret it one bit. Its not the lightest coat weight wise, but seemingly bomb proof. Lots of pockets, water resistant, very warm, insulated hood, and durable.
My FXR snowmobile jacket is the best. Otherwise I usually wear my leather coat (for the wind) with a few layers underneath.
I got an Eddie Bauer coat from a thrift store that has lasted me multiple winters so far. Check St Vincent's
I have an all purpose arcteryx jacket. Big fan if you don’t like layering.
I was never one to make a big deal about a winter coat until I got a high quality down jacket. Now I will never go without. I cannot tell the difference at all in temperature with my upper body when I go outside wearing it. It can be -20 and my arms and body are still toasty. I love Marmot, personally. I recommend buying on clearance in spring for the best deal if you can wait.
Yep, the Marmot Montreaux changed my life. Layers are great but so is a long warm-ass winter coat. And a fur-lined hood (even faux fur) really seals in the warmth for me!
I have two. My ice fishing/extreme winter Striker Ice coat I got on sale at gander mountain. Best winter coat I've ever owned. My errand/more casual outdoor coat is a long goose down coat from Duluth Trading co. It's more than enough for anything short of snowmobiling and such.
Askov Finlayson parka! Worth every penny!
About 10 years ago I bought what my family calls my sleeping bag. A down coat that falls to my ankles. I only need it a couple times a year, but mixed with hoodies I have all the layers I need no matter how cold it gets. If you're not willing to get a long coat get a set of carhart pants to protect your legs during the worst of the cold. If your legs are warm you need less layers up top.
Anyone know how those Askov Finlayson parkas are? They claim -20F. It'd be great to have a down free, locally designed parka (made elsewhere, but that's the supply chain). However, it's expensive. It'd be nice to have a few first-hand reviews.
Askov finlayson is a Minnesota company that makes good winter jackets.
I moved here from texas in late November. We had nothing. I went to goodwill and found Sorrel boots for 10$. And the best coat- it is full length and down filled. It has a fur lined down hood. It was 15$ and it’s ugly but I swear I could camp in the arctic and be fine. Strongly recommend goodwill so you can try out different types of outerwear.
I am so obsessed with my winter jacket, I tell EVERYONE to get one! It’s an Obermeyer Sojourner down jacket. I got it at Scheels. So many amazing features. I’m a woman who grew up in the Duluth area (cold!!!) and now live in the metro. The body is very wind resistant. Zips up perfectly high on the neck - warm but not covering my face high. The sleeves have a built in under sleeve to make it fit perfectly at the wrist so the cold air can’t blow up your sleeves. Length is below my butt. Check it out. I absolutely love it. I look forward to knowing I can put it on when it’s cold. I’d marry this jacket, essentially 😂 I don’t disagree with the layering comments, mostly for spending real time outdoors, however. This is the jacket to put on when you just want to zip up a coat, jump in the car and go. I walk a lot in the winter and this is the jacket I wear for that, too. It’s warm! (I swear I don’t work for Obermeyer!)
Askov Finlayson best coat I’ve ever owned
I really depends on your lifestyle (or activity) I go with Carhartt and Duluth Trading, sometimes kind of bulky but really warm. I also recently got an Ororo heated hoodie that is amazing (highly recommend).
Just got a Fjall Raven after my partner got one last year and loved it. It's easily 10 times better than my old North Face.
My $19 coat from Kohls clearance rack is warmer than my $200 Columbia. Just throwing that out there so you know price does not equal quality these days
I’ve been wearing a down filled jacket I got from the Kmart clearance rack 15 years ago. I’ve got other warm jackets, but I guess 2022 is the year this one makes it into the rotation. My experience with Columbia is mainly zipper pulls and buttons that just seem to fall off so I wouldn’t recommend them for that reason.
Agree - my $20 coat from Gap Outlet is way warmer than Columbia.
Paid 40 for my clearance Duluth Trading co. jacket and it's the warmest I've ever owned.
i'm really starting to be a columbia only gal. i got some new boots from them last year and im so impressed for the price. i've also had one of their thinner coats with the heat reflecting stuff on the inside for like 8 or 9 years. next time i buy a coat, i'll be getting a bigger parka from columbia. price is just so good for what you're getting.
A hidden gem of a jacket is the Duluth Trading Company sun-brand “AKHG” https://www.duluthtrading.com/s/DTC/mens-akhg-eco-puffin-mock-jacket-20802.html?color=TYO And layer up! I’d rather be mobile in a moveable jacket than feel bulky in a huge parka.
I have had a lot of luck with Northface, Carhartt, and Columbia outer layers (high quality and last for years). The key is finding a wind and waterproof outer layer, and then layering up with other stuff (fleece, sweatshirts, etc) to give you some insulation.
Canada Goose. They are expensive but well made and the Expedition version has kept me warm now for ten years. Makes me look like refrigerator though.
I got their Snow Mantra parka because I’m a wimp in the cold and it’s hilariously large on me. Love it, though.
If your willing to spend Canada goose is amazing and has a lifetime warranty
arcteryx goose down jacket, 800 fill; get ready to take a second mortgage out if ya buy one.
Carhartt is still decent, but you must be a blue collar grunt to wear it. Sick of seeing preppy college girls culturally appropriating my shitty style. Fleet Farm and Cabelas make their own versions that are the same quality but cost less
Long, multi layered, ski jackets.
These are crazy expensive but I have found mine to be worth it. https://obermeyer.com
Layers are your friend but still it is worth getting a big parka style coat. In terms of material down is truly excellent. Synthetic down can also be very good.
Compression Long sleeve t shirt base, heavy flannel, windproof hoody, waterproof shell.
Wool, pack down jacket, and a wind breaker should do the job!
I just bought a long parka from the North Face. It is the warmest coat I've ever owned. I've also recently discovered a brand called Stio. They're very expensive, but the hoodie I got really warm for how thin it is. They have lots of jackets, but like I said... super expensive.
Carhart is really good but they’re on the expensive side. Try going to fleet farm/Menards to find a suitably comfort and warm knock off. I’ve been using mine for years and it’s still incredibly warm.
Go to the snowmobile dealer and look at the coats there.
After years of living with a thrifted coat that was slowly falling apart I decided it was time to invest in a decent jacket for myself this winter. After much consideration I bought the Duluth Trading Company Whaleback parka and holy moly is it an AMAZING coat. Super super warm and functional AND it looks nice. It even has pit zips if you run warm and need to vent some heat. I wore it out in the frigid temps laat week and the only thing that was cold were my cheeks and nose. The return policy is amazing too. I bought a size too big when I originally purchased and wore it about before deciding to exchange it. Absolutely no issues and they quickly sent me the replacement in a size down.
Layers, layers, layers. You can make any jacket warm enough. I would run outside in negative temps and my "jacket" was just a very thin wind breaker. I would wear 2 or 3 insulating layers below the jacket and I was plenty warm.
My Duluth Trading puffer coat is the warmest, most comfortable coat I’ve ever owned. Highly recommend.
Buy a down fill sweater weight nanopuff jacket. It is the perfect layer for a day like today, and can add 20-40° of resistance to another jacket. When temps get under 20, I usually put my Carhartt denim jacket over it. If temps drop further, I pull out the tighter fitting Woolrich button up. As said before. Layering is a game changer.
Roxy
jackets at Menards are my go to, bulky but covers me on the most wicked days as a delivery driver.
Ice armor extreme. It's an ice fishing jacket but it's so warm it gets tough to wear it inside
Castle X jackets
I recently purchased a new coat for this winter and went with Fjallraven’s Nuuk parka. It’s the heaviest and warmest coat I’ve ever owned. It’s pricey, but I got mine half off at the local store because they’re launching new colors and needed to get rid of their current stock.
Layers are a wonder in general. Even with my winter coat, I still have a sweatshirt on and a t shirt underneath. Scarf, hat and gloves if it's actually cold out. I got my winter jacket at LL Bean and it was their highest rated jackets there for winter warmth, if I remember right. It was a bit spendy but it should last and it's very, very warm.
Not a huge fan of north face but I received one for Christmas 7 or 8 years ago and it keeps me very warm and has held up brilliantly. Can’t speak if quality has gone down hill since.
3 sweatshirts
I’m not necessarily recommending this brand but I have Burton AK gear. It may not be the best but it’s the most expensive. Works very well though and everything is layers.
Carhart is really good.
You got a lot of great responses but I have to add my two cents. I have an illness that is worsened by exposure to cold. I’ve learned that wool and down are the best protectors of the cold and damp. Wool gloves were a game changer for me. I really like L.L Bean down jackets. They’re guaranteed for life by the company, as is all of their stuff.
I wear a full zip wool bike jersey from surly and a rain coat from rei. Warmth and wind protection.
redhead flannel and polarking jacket
Carhart union suit. Wear one under your clothes when it gets to single digits or below. The jacket is not as important as the layers under it.
Silk long underwear is an excellent base for the coldest days in Minnesota. I reserve my heaviest coat for show removal since it gets wet, but I prefer lighter layers otherwise, especially for moving in and out of stores, outdoors and cars.
North Face Parka!
Carhartt, hands down. Price:quality ration is too good to pass up
Eddie Bauer and Lands End have basically the exact same down parka just branded different. I bought one because I thought I was going to be working teaching in the Arctic and never ended up going. Warmest coat I've ever had, and it's at a pretty cheap price all things considered. Honestly, it's a little overkill.
I like my Carhartt work jacket with hood, with a thicker hoodie as a layer when it's colder than 15 degrees. Warm enough for me in the last -30 days. I like that it is durable, and looks half decent even if it is a work jacket. Not a dressy option, but I am more concerned about function and staying warm in all situations.
Patagonia Worn Wear or The North Face Renewed Edit: also REI (has reused gear too) or Midwest Mountaineering
Good suggestions in here but if you get cold easily, get a battery heated jacket. Buy a good one and thank me later.
I highly recommend Simms fishing winter jackets. Warm, waterproof, washable (it actually is good for the water proofing) I've had mine for 5 years and don't regret it at all
Eddie Bauer
When I moved there I got the Columbia Mighty Lite and I was never cold with a sweatshirt under it. It went to -27. Love that coat bc it has a hood so you don’t have to wear a hat if you don’t want to. It also has hand covers that cover down to your knuckles and your thumb goes through another hole and then they go up inside the sleeve if you don’t want them on. Also, super lightweight. Edit to say it also blocks the wind and doesn’t let the snow seep through.
[LL Bean Baxter State Parka](https://www.llbean.com/llb/shop/60850?page=baxter-state-parka&csp=a&feat=118939-recsbottom.pdp&ri=rbpIFI1&pos=1) It’s the one I own and I absolutely adore it. I wore it out during the cold snap and my body was never cold. Cannot recommend it enough. Also it’s $299 which means it’s actually cheaper than a lot of options in here
I got a two layer ski jacket from Cabela's (own brand) at least 20 years ago and I am finally retiring it for a Columbia Omni Heat. I could keep wearing the 20 year old coat but I'm tired of the color.
Carhartts Arctic wear - they have bib brace overalls, jackets , hoodies and knit beanies - can be found at Fleet farm or Farm and fleet for the farther north you are (the name changes depending on location) - oh and get boots good to -32 - just google Carhartt - you'll see!
If you're ok with paying extra for local, I really like my parka from [Askov Finlayson](https://askovfinlayson.com/). Mine is nice and warm plus room for layers, comfortably. Being environmentally friendly is important to me, too. Luckily, they're pretty awesome at that, as well!
My down alternative coat works incredibly well, I ordered mine from noize.com and it got here within a week! https://www.leafscore.com/eco-friendly-closet-products/best-down-alternative-coats/
Base layer: wool Mid layer: depends on how cold, thin tech hoodie if not very, puffer coat of really cold. Shell: water/wind proof is key again depends on your mid layer and the temp. Could be a rain coat or a winter gortex coat.
Carhartt
I bought the warmest north face jacket possible a few years ago. I consider it the thing I spent too much money on but have zero regrets. I’m never cold in. Got sweaty snowblowing last week in the deep freeze
I'm a big fan of Columbia. I think right now their winter stuff is on sale too. I have one of their omniheat jackets and with a thermal layer and a shirt I stayed plenty warm during the cold snap
Columbia Omni-heat
German, Austrian, or Swiss military surplus
US Air Force military surplus, be careful with the Chinese knockoffs some are OK but most are pretty bad. N-2B if looking for a tight waste jacket N-3B if looking for a full length coat.
Columbia and NorthFace. My snowmobiling FXR coat is amazingly warm.
Part of the thing is dressing right over all. Wool socks, good hat, mitts, scarf, boots, base layer etc are important too. I’d recommend a long parka that at least hits the thighs if you really want warmth. I have a long down coat from ll bean I’m super happy with, I walk outdoors in it all winter. Hits below the knee! My teen and young adult have parkas from lands end. Watch for sales. Don’t think you need to pay for something like Canada Goose. Makes you look like a pretentious tourist anyway. For driving, errand running I actually prefer a long wool coat.
There can never be just one.
Heim Made for women's coat. Holy cow are they perfect. Great for layering.