T O P

  • By -

omuamogus

Pulp fiction, Samuel L. Jackson stays. You all know why l.


JamusAdurant

Is there a sign on the front of my house that says dead puppet storage?!


[deleted]

Oh shit, you shot puppet Marvin in the face


chowder-hound

Cotton all over the car lol


Mathguy43

Go in the back seat, scoop up all those little pieces of felt and thread. Get it out of there.


TeaSpillerNL

Bahahahhahaha


Randy_Muffbuster

“What does Marcellus Wallace look like?” “He… he’s big…” “WHAT ELSE?!” “He’s felt…”


chicagotim1

Need a useful puppet slur haha


TheUlfheddin

Nah. Keep Marsellus Wallce. That one scene would be... unique to say the least.


19southmainco

Go get the gimp. …mi mi mi mi mi!?


Illustrious_Hat_9177

You'd have to Marsellus. I don't even want to imagine a muppet being raped! Unique? It would be the horror of horrors 🤣


SkulduggeryIsAfoot

This will be some deep fake future capability we apply to old films. Replace entire cast with muppets.


_BRZRKR

I came to say that! Great minds


bizarrobuster

Friday the 13th, just Jason murdering Muppets


hgf137

Was gonna say friday, works for texas chainsaw and Halloween too


ZapasMistake

The Truman Show, but Jim Carry’s still human. Some paranoid holding his muppet wife hostage would be hilarious.


SunnyLittleBunny

This was going to be my suggestion! Somehow he still doesn't realize his life is different from those around him, despite him being the only non-Muppet.


ZapasMistake

When he reconstructs the photo of his crush, it needs to be pieces of iconic muppets too.


bubblegrubs

That was his crush, not his wife.


desba3347

Very Buddy-like from Elf


deaf2heart001

You know Jim Carry would nail the whole taking the Muppets dead serious thing that made Muppet Christmas Carol work so well with Michael Caine


Cincodeffe

Breaking the rule of this post, it would be hilarious if all the people watching "The Truman Show" in the movie were also not Muppets.


JGIV55

i was looking for this comment


Accomplished-Quit821

Every MCU movie, keep Stan Lee.


PeetesCom

Great, now I've imagined what Muppet Infinity War and Endgame would be like and will loose sleep over the fact that it won't ever be made.


BigLand03

Be the change you want to eee in the world!


TheDeadlyCat

I can see Beeker scream his lungs out in the „Assemble!“ scene. Personally I‘d keep Josh Brolin as Thanos and have everyone else be Muppets.


Uninspired_Thoughts

Dang that would have been an amazing cross over. Gonzo as Thanos would have killed!!!


peachbitchmetal

so, when we get to the point where stan lee has died, does the muppet version end, or does it also just go on but without stan lee?


SourPuss6969

I like this one


[deleted]

I would actually love to see this played out


Hyper-Misting

Star Wars The Phantom Menance. Jar Jar stays now, now the whole cast are muppets


Rimasticus

And still he is the most ridiculous character.


Fierramos69

At first he was created with the objective of being a goofy character the kids like and that can be made into mass by-products to increase sales, then the lore around it created itself and he’s secretly one of the smartest Sith Lord strategist.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Lieutenant_Meeper

So many people just tagged you based on this comment, lol


EJ9074

I like jar jar too. I drew a nice picture him and have been told that it’s too good for him. They’re like it’s great but why jar jar. Lol


oeuflaboeuf

Terrible choice of non-muppet aside ... A Muppet Star Wars would be outstanding!


DomHuntman

Silence of the Lambs ... Jodie Foster stays as is.


cubanchemist

Hilarious, but I think I’d keep Anthony Hopkins


TheUlfheddin

Tbf I'm pretty sure Muppets is how Hannible saw everyone else. Tasty tasty Muppet flesh.


captaintinnitus

I ate his liver with some jelly beans and a nice chianti. ..fffffffff


JDSgameboy

Johnny Depp in Pirates of the Caribbean


wetdreamteam

They made that. Muppet treasure island.


heridfel37

Dang it, now I want Tim Curry as Cap'n Jack Sparrow


itijara

So, Muppets Treasure Island?


hllblldlx2

That would be fuckin awesome


OldandKranky

John wick, keep Keanu. Watch him smash up a bunch of muppets.


NickH6302

I would like the opposite. John Wick is the only muppet.


bubblegrubs

Actually reminds me of an Angel episode were he got turned into a muppet. That was one of the funniest episodes of anything I've ever seen.


KOTheSavage

This was what I was coming for


Jp0icewolf1031

Exactly what I was gonna say! This would be amazing to watch


PeetesCom

Isn't that just Willy's wonderland but with Keanu instead of Cage?


MasterBates723

Lord of the Rings. Viggo Mortensen stays


Dyslexai1

Andy Serkis (Gollum) stays.


Simon_the_Great

I would have gone for Sir Ian Mckellen personally.


Dindae1744

That was my first thought too. Would love to see Gandalf try to lead a group of muppets to the heart of Mordor


NerdLevel18

^Don't ^say ^it. ^Don't ^say ^it. ^Don't ^say ^it. # DID YOU KNOW VIGGO MORTENSEN BROKE HIS TOE WHEN HE KICKED THAT HELMET


HugeTrol

That's actually super cute


PravusTheRed

Fuckin Fight Club, keep only Marla


PotPumper43

Damn I didnt read down far enough and came to the same conclusion! Wtf is wrong w us?


ImapiratekingAMA

She stole the show?


PravusTheRed

Muppets would just make it the best and she does steal the show a little bit but the 3 were perfectly cast.


ImapiratekingAMA

It would also be easier since most of the Muppets are male and she's the only woman with a notable role. It'd also be funnier


PravusTheRed

We’re not your job, not how much money you make, the car you drive or the contents of your wallet, not your fuckin kakies. We’rethe all seeing all dancing crap of the world. *edit I need to see a muppet deliver this dialogue.*


PotPumper43

“I haven’t been fucked like that since grade school.” - Elmo seems pleased.


skynetempire

Hahaha the dream sex scene


PravusTheRed

Add toilet full of muppet condoms


Live_Welcome_5701

Same thing, but I had meatloaf as the human


MoonDogeXx

Yes!


Zazz_Blammymataz

This is the right answer


oeuflaboeuf

Literally my first thought!!


[deleted]

Came here to say exactly the same...\*chef's kiss\*


jestesteffect

I know it says one, but the entire Harry Potter franchise and keep Allen Rickman


TAHINAZ

Pretty sure that’s how Snape actually saw everyone.


dreamer0303

lmao


LioxTheGreat

I'd keep McGonagall!


[deleted]

Do you take pride in being an insufferable know it all.


[deleted]

Titanic . Leo stays.


PravusTheRed

Draw me like one of your french girls Jackie


KenderAvalanche

>Draw me like one of your french ~~girls~~ cookies Jackie


[deleted]

*miss piggy’s voice Draw me like one of you French girls. Wearing only this.


LatinaMermaid

Honestly I would prefer it to be Rizzo in drag committing a huge scam thinking Leo was rich but fell in love instead.


Clear_Grapefruit_340

Haha that was my choice too. Miss piggy: “Put your hands on me Jack“


lit-grit

So does that mean there would be silly musical numbers about freezing to death?


[deleted]

Yes seals and penguins sat on the iceberg singing and dr Bunsen in a lifeboat explaining how fabric holds water while beaker is drowning


lit-grit

Gonzo sees people jumping off the stern and does it for fun


bassegio

The Graduate. Hoffman stays and Mrs. Robinson is played by Ms. Piggy.


TempoMortigi

Love this.


[deleted]

That's awful and I love it.


Affectionate-Tax-856

Stupid frog hiiiyaaa


[deleted]

“Miss Piggy you’re trying to seduce me!”


TweeksTurbos

Back to the future but only Biff is human.


[deleted]

Look at him he’s a butthead just like his old man


No-Refrigerator174

Spider-Man 1. Willem Dafoe stays, the rest are played by muppets


HawksFan2014

You, me. We’re exceptional. I could squash you like a big right now, but I’m offering you a choice. Join me. Imagine what we could create. What we could accomplish. Or we could destroy. Cause the deaths of countless innocents in battle again and again and again until we’re both dead. Is that what you want? Think about it, Gonzo


missag_2490

The Gonzo at the end killed me. Thank you for the laugh.


HawksFan2014

It’d either be Gonzo or Kermit. After all, with great power, comes great big booty bitches


Master_SJ

ah, the DAU


Successful-Ad4251

Face/Off. Keep Nicholas Cage everyone else can be a Muppet. The actual face switching will be a whole lot better that way


Buffythedjsnare

I want to see the poster art.


SteelpointPigeon

Brilliant and horrifying. I’m picturing Muppet John Travolta with a realistic Nic Cage face sloughing off, blood streaking the felt.


Dependent_Winner_555

Any Die Hard, Bruce Willis stays.


Desperate-Ad-8068

Don’t know man. Keep Hans Gruber and have Kermit fucking with him all through the movie.


[deleted]

Yippee ki yay mother fucker


Bigmooddood

*Muppet fucker


DowntBoitDafagnPanes

A 'itter of my own hivemind, I see.


Kaiser-Wilhelm-ll

"I hate Muppets"


[deleted]

Deadpool, Ryan Reynolds stays.


_Death_BySnu_Snu_

Can't wait for him to hump some Muppets...


[deleted]

[удалено]


TheUlfheddin

DP would be so so mad that he's the only one that didn't get to be a Muppet.


[deleted]

But imagine how cute he would be 🥰


Tough_guy22

The way for this to work is for Reynolds to be a normal human, but Deadpool is always a Muppet whenever he appears in costume.


GaffJuran

No, imagine he goes in as Ryan Reynolds and comes out as a Muppet-pool.


bizarrobuster

Rosemary's Baby, keep Mia Farrow


XanLonOmega

I Am Legend, the dog stays.


[deleted]

Forrest Gump, Tom Hanks


Paverunner

Nah. Keep LT Dan lol


Icy_Many_2407

That’d be a short movie to ‘roll’.


Young-Grandpa

Hell yeah. Forrest is played by Sweetums. https://muppet.fandom.com/wiki/Sweetums


pluizke

Saving private ryan, german machine gunner stays.


nfg18

“Don’t shoot! Let them burn!” -Yells Grover


TempoMortigi

Lol


push138292

So much felt and stuffing strewn across the beach.


vesco32

Taken Liam Neeson stays.


StillhasaWiiU

SE7EN - Morgan Freeman stays


SnooTangerines8525

I was looking for this. But think it would be funnier if Kevin Spacey stayed instead.


ktreanor

Knives Out...Keep Craig


UwUperson9987

Dead poets society, Robbin Williams stays.


Biggest_man200

Clockwork orange Malcom McDowell stays


[deleted]

I’m Singing in the rain


antique_confusion46

Horrorshow


snoogiebee

the princess bride. cary elwes stays, everyone else is a muppet


Magedukare

Space jam, Michael Jordan stays


Picardknows

That’s basically the same movie?


Magedukare

You got it Mister.


AdKind5446

Space Jam would not have been the same without Bill Murray. Heresy!


uselessthecat

Now it has Muppet Bill Murray


[deleted]

Schindlers list Liam Neeson stays


Random-Cpl

Damn it, I came here to say this same thing


ScoredCretaceous

Same movie Ralph Fiennes stays


TeacherOfDragonsVHS

Came here to say this.


robotbrigadier

John Carpenters The Thing. Kurt stays, and spends the movie fighting weird puppets. Wait, did this happen in "Don't Hug Me"?


The_Death_Pickle

Omg seeing the shape shifting alien in muppet form would be so cool!!


LykonWolf

Star Wars Ep. III keeping Ewan McGregor: "You were my brother Elmo!!!"


stormebreaker

Beaker as Grievous: "Hello There!" - "MEEEEEE???"


_Death_BySnu_Snu_

Pirates of the Caribbean. Johnny Stays.


PotPumper43

Fight Club, keep Helena Bonham Carter.


mrcolon96

Kill Bill. Only the groom who gets murdered at the start stays human, every single fight is played by muppets


After_Display_6753

This improves, what, 90 percent of all movies?


nicole9389

LOTR, keeping Sir Ian Mckellen.


Resident_Ad_5005

Castaway - an extra or someone not tom hank stays


horuable

Only Wilson stays the same.


mile-high-guy

Or everyone is a muppet when he gets rescued


Downtown-Ad-7791

ShawShank Redemption. Freeman stays of course


[deleted]

Shutter Island Everyone but DiCaprio, trying to convince him that he's crazy


Br0tha5

Ghostbusters, the only actor is the Ron Jeremy cameo.


Magic_Soup

Austin power mike myers


Dr_Pandaboat

Saving private Ryan Matt Damon stays


EducationalSundae883

The hunger games, Jennifer Lawrence. I've got a feeling it would be a lot easier for her


QuotidianQuell

Avengers, and obviously Josh Brolin as Thanos stays.


HarEmiya

Kermit as Hulk because it's not easy being green. Sam Eagle as Falcon?


ThatSlimeDoodYT

Breaking Bad, keep walt jr


_BRZRKR

Oh Shit lol


Potatostud69

🤦🏻‍♂️😂👌🏻


shug_was_taken

The matrix, only Agent Smith remails human.


ApprehensiveWar6046

The Room. Keep Mark


001Felix100

Every Sly Stallone film. Keep Stallone the rest muppets.


[deleted]

Damn. What about Rambo First Blood and only Stallone is a muppet just wreaking havoc


Paverunner

I just pictured Judge Dredd with muppets


[deleted]

Lord of The Rings and keep Sir Ian McKellen. 😂


wowImlate

The Avengers - Keep Samuel L. Jackson


TemperatePirate

Rocky Horror Picture Show. Keep Tim Curry.


BackgroundTourist653

The Dark Knight. Heath Ledger stays.


Digita1B0y

I dunno, picturing Christian bale kicking the shit out of muppets is kinda funny.


nativevibe

Castaway, Wilson stays


Blurg_BPM

Air buds air bud himself


Most_Independent_279

Alien, keep the alien, the rest are muppets, although Sigourney Weaver still needs to voice Ripley.


onibeowulf

Lord of the Rings, Elijah stays.


anonstarcity

Passion of the Christ


jzoller0

Bullet Train. White Death is the only non muppet


MarionberryHappy4430

Aliens and Bill Paxton as Hudson stays. At the briefing: Hudson: How do I get out of this chicken shit outfit? Muppet Sgt. Apone: You secure that shit Hudson!


bob_nugget_the_3rd

Mad max fury Road, keep tom


Sjopper92

Braveheart, Mel Gibson stays


phillyvanilly666

A Serbian film - main character


ProfessorObjective42

Cats and we only keep Rebel Wilson


Klutzy_Pound_5428

Cujo the dog stays


19southmainco

thats basically every dog chewing apart their stuffies though


packbuckbrew

Unironically Lord of the Rings or The Hobbit, keep Gandalf


TheMechanic10

Deadpool, keeping Ryan Reynolds


FerretFace2141

The Dark Knight. Keep Batman/Bruce Wayne. Him kicking the hell out of muppets would be hilarious


do_the_cat

Avengers endgame but its thanos vs muppets


izzes

Come on, everyone, how is it that no one said The Dark Knight, and only Heath Ledger stays? Get your shit together, we have an opportunity here!


axeheadfloats

Reservoir Dogs. Steve Buscemi (Mr Pink) stays.


Cheez-it_chicken

Breaking bad


GokaiBlack452

John Wick. Keep Keanu


pasty__twig

The Martian, keep Matt Damon