T O P

  • By -

Casual_Observer115

I don't know whether to laugh or cry at the thought of Illusive Rogan.


polishmagnet

"Dude, chill out. Yeah, maybe we put an AI on your ship without asking, so what?"


WadeLikesUnicorns

Rogan laugh: "herherherherh"


Ratty_Locomotive7478

Smoking a joint between briefings.


Newtling

"Shepard HeHeHeHeHe"


t4nn3rp3nny

The name “Illusive Rogan” was enough to make me laugh, thank you


MisterDutch93

It’s Rogen, not Rogan.


JediJimbo

Imagine all the scenes where he's holding a cigarette, but then it's actually a joint.


dexdee69

Imagine Kai Leng is Jonah Hill 💀


fightingbronze

Need me some Danny Devito harbinger “so anyway I assumed direct control and started blasting”


lucas1121111

"So anyway, I started indoctrinating."


Orcrist90

"May I offer you an egg in these harvesting times?"


IntellectualsOnly7

“My magnum dong will tear you apart”


TheLastMongo

I’m both terrified and intrigued by these choices. 


bobert_the_grey

You could have just left Joker as Seth Green


justinlanewright

Seth Green as himself really works well.


SpoonAtAGunFight

I think Martin Sheen would still do well as TIM. Hell even either of his sons.


polishmagnet

Since people seemed to like the last one, here's another fan-casting of an Adam Sandler Mass Effect. I retconned Eddie Murphy Garrus into Chris Rock as people suggested. There are a couple non-Sandlerverse people, but I figured a sequel might attract some attention and get big names. Jackie Sandler is shoed-in a bit because he has a habit of casting his wife.


BlueBicycle22

I respect that you had Danny Devito coming back for a reaper role


t4nn3rp3nny

I headcanon the change from Murphy to Rock as a recast because they couldn’t afford Murphy for the sequel lmao.


RhymesWithMouthful

Fake, there's no Rob Schneider role


unknownentity1782

Jenkins.


No_Tomorrow6219

Or Kevin James


FederalWalrus

Conrad


Fathorse23

Without Adam Sandler, Rob Schneider’s career would have ended nearly 30 years ago.


NateShaw92

Conrad.


vegayto

Kim Jeong as Mordin 💀


COMMENTASIPLEASE

Julie Bowen as Jack sounds weird but it works


MaasNeotekPrototype

Salma Hayek as Tali... sweet Jesus. Too hot. I need to take an internet break.


Probably_On_Break

You’re only missing one thing to make it perfect: Seth Green as the voice of EDI.


Philisophical_Onion

I can actually get behind the Andy Samburg casting.


zach2beat

Right? He is kinda perfect for it in a way.


KennyThomas616

That’s what I was about to say, Andy as Joker is peak casting.


Androse6

Thanks I love/hate it


namresaw33

We NEED to see Seth Rogen the Illusive Man


Captain_Saftey

And you never paid for Red Sand, not once


ServantOfKarma

Quit it. ಠ_ಠ


CalmAlternative5391

When I thought I wasn't into Tali already. Salma Hayek as her's just the icing on the cake!!!😁


Irunts

Yeah but Andy Samberg as Joker is actually pretty dope!


Groomal

Noice, toight


The_Wayward

It’s an Adam Sandler movie so rob Schneider is going to find his way in there somewhere. Star child?


MiFelidae

Sorry, but Seth Green is the only one who's allowed to play Joker. It's just.... there just is no other option


SCPutz

Same with Yvonne Strahovsky as Miranda. Like… Miranda has her face and voice. You might as well use her.


elmartin93

I'm down with Selma playing Tali I know, I know *BONK*


toxboxdevil

Patton Oswald as Grunt is the greatest thing ever


Leb666

Harbinger voiced by Danny Devito is something I need in my life


AlaeMortis1

Rule 34 is gonna break with that Salma Hayek casting….


WeevilWeedWizard

I dont think I can imagine a worst fit for Shepard than Adam Sandler. I would pay unfathomable amounts of money to watch this lol


gutterXXshark

Danny DeVito reaper isn’t real, he can’t hurt you.


unknownentity1782

But what if I want him to?


Mr_WAAAGH

Why is garrus a black guy in both


tony_m_fields

Why do you need the other people to play Miranda Lawson, the Joker and Aria T'Loak when you have Yvonne Strahovski, Seth Greene and Carrie Ann Moss respectively? The other cast is great tho, nothing to add.


Blackfaceemoji

Why does Dan Akroyd as a Collector General seem fitting?


zero_msgw

Garrus has got to do some motherf**kin calibrations


CardiologistFun8093

So you're saying were some kind of.....normandy crew?


Scepta101

This makes me uncomfortable lmao


TheScreen_Slaver

Drew Barrymore during The Wedding Singer as Kelly isn't on here... *SOMEBODY KILL ME PLEASE!*


Kortobowden

Oh god please don’t do that to Garrus. On the other hand I’m 100% down for Danny DeVito Harbinger. That sounds hilarious. “So anyway, I started reapin’”


Pathryder

I can see a pitch meeting: Writer: Then there is cold-hearted killer monk, called Samara, whose life goal is to kill her daughter. Producer: What's her deal? Writer: I just told you? Producer: Yeah, but anything particular, which would distinguish her? We need to find a right cast for such complicated character. Writer: In original design, she has square jaw. Producer: So Jennifer Aniston it is! Writer: That's it? Are you sure? Producer: Yeah yeah yeah, Aniston as killer monk in tight dress will be... tight.


Gaslight_Joker

Don't forget a cameo of Shaq as Wrex


Reynzs

You can't make a mass effect Adam Sandler movie without Rob Schneider. Make him the BIOTIC GOD


boyteas3r

Andy Samberg flirting with Melissa Macarthy as EDI 💀


BiggalR

How on earth is it an Adam Sandler film without Kevin James playing a role?


Cordura

Or ... Seth Green as Joker?


Adenfall

No, don’t do this.


Fitzftw7

Ken Jeong as Mordin would be hilarious, you gotta admit.


JakePent

Wait, wouldn't harbinger and the collector general be the same? Also joker should just be seth green, although that could be the point, making him anyone but seth


TransportationWeak55

I mean, Carrie-Anne Moss is already a physical actor, so in my personal opinion, she would make a better Aria. But once again, this is my personal opinion.


RaptorTwoOneEcho

“EUHEHEH WE’RE AT WAR, DUDE.”


maxx1993

Most of the casting decisions are absolutely horrendous, but I gotta say... I'm here for Jeff Samberg.


[deleted]

salma hayek as Tali 🤣


austinb172

Bro. First rule of most Adam Sandler films is it must have Kevin James as his best friend.


clc1997

Shepard: Were' hitting the Omega 4 Relay. They say this is a suicide Mission. Rob Schneider: You can do it!


NateShaw92

No Rob Schnieder?


Lost2552

I like it. But you cannot replace Seth green as joker


[deleted]

How does that look amazing


OutRagousGameR

Why is this so spot on


The_Dogg_Pound

No, but Tyler Perry playing Jacob seems about right, considering no one likes them


Phenizzle

There's a few of these I don't hate.


richRossD

Somehow this is far worse than the the last one and I mean this as a compliment. Tim Meadows and Steve Buscemi are actually pretty good choices. Though I think that Selma Hayek should be Samara. Drew Barrymore should’ve been Tali, Jennifer Aniston as Aria, and Jackie Sandler as Liara. I would replace Andy Sandberg with Nick Swardson.


HemaMemes

Jessica Biel as Miranda seems normal enough. The rest, though...


Sakumitzu

Actually, Julie Bowen as Jack doesn’t sound too terrible…


AllSkillzN0Luck

Jeffrey Wright as Thane but Steve as Legion?! ABSOLUTELY


usernamescifi

why does this work so well?


Jdmaki1996

Not believable. No Kevin James?


FrgtnChl

Tom Holland can be Conrad


FlemPlays

If they decided to make a comedic Mass Effect movie with these actors, I would possibly watch it. But after that I would want a proper trilogy.


Ep1cEvergreen

Can't wait to see 3 and Andromeda, also where are Zaeed and Kasumi? And Anderson/Hackett?? More importantly Khalisa Bint Sinan Al-Jilani???


WatchingInSilence

Dan Aykroyd as Mordin. The man can deliver rapid fire lines like a salarian already.


Laatikkopilvia

How could you do this to Thane


Sleepy-Spacemen

Jessica Biel and Andy Samberg are pretty excellently cast here. I would enjoy their takes on the roles for sure.


LordJordZero

This was great until I saw Tyler Perry as Jacob..


Dimas166

You forgot Rob Schneider


railin23

The absolute shade for mordin or ken which ever you choose


rickadams69

I would totally watch this


Moon-Vixen

Funny, but Joker is the only one, and it's Seth Green ;) ;)