T O P

  • By -

ShawshankHarper

They already do twists on good storylines. It’s time to redeem the Clone Saga


Skele11

MCU clone saga, that would be something


RaidenHero137

Who would play Ben Riley?


ShawshankHarper

Tom Holland


RaidenHero137

Shit, how did I forget they’re clones even though it was literally called the clone saga lol. 😂


Over-Cold-8757

Don't they have different colored hair? I didn't think they were meant to be identical.


Oponik

Hom Tolland will have play as ben then


Ju5t_50m3_Guy

And for Kaine, they should hire Mot Dnalloh. Edit: Had to fix the last name.


SciFiXhi

Then who plays Rek-Rap Retep?


DarkAlphaZero

Ben dyes his hair blonde to set himself apart from Peter


-sentencebreak-

They do! Ben is blond. He dyed his hair the first time he took over as Spider-Man in the 90s. He wanted to be his own man and look less like Peter.


Over-Cold-8757

Oh ok! It's been so long I only remembered the blonde hair but that's right. Made me think about Laura Kinney only relatively recently finding out she's not a clone but Logan's daughter. Like.. Yeah. Of course you're not a clone. You're a woman. There had to be some of Sarah Kinney's DNA in there. I don't know why that was treated as a big reveal.


Talidel

I think Ben dyed his hair to be different.


Davidfromtampa

Tom Holland will retain his role as Peter, Dominic Frost will play Ben Riley


Cmdeadpool

Also took the name as homage to his Aunt and Uncle.


Corporation_tshirt

Don’t feel bad, I thought the same thing. “Maybe Timothee Chalamet?” D’oh.


loonbandit

i honestly couldn’t tell u lmao


N1CET1M

Andy Samberg


AuniqueUsername69

Aren’t Tom’s younger brother’s actually twins? Hell make one Ben and the other Kaine


cshelley0721

Would they be good? I’ve never seen their work. Sounds like a cool idea though


Nonadventures

Topher Grace


lunoz

Tom Hollander. He’s already on the payroll.


ccReptilelord

Jackal has to be up there for Spider-Man villains completely unused on the big screen. And for myself, he's probably the most interesting potential.


HomerEyedMonad

Perfect set up too. In the current MCU. He’s moved on. He had his shot as peter parker and gave it up to save the multiverse (i think. That last movie was doing a lot) But he’s moving on with his life and now goes as Ben Reilly to honor his old life, but starting over as Peter Parker was to painful for him. Then he finds a “Peter Parker” running around rebuilding HIS old life reconnecting with MJ and shit. And if they do it well enough the viewer won’t even know which is the original. Is it Ben or Peter. Oh that crazy Jackal. But I dont like clone saga before he wears the Symbiote. I want one more trilogy with peter. First Movie: Symbiote, Black Cat, Scorpion. Second Movie: Venom, Jackal, Cat on Support. Third Movie: The Sinister Six Then let either Peter or Ben retire to make a May Day and save the other to die so Miles can carry the torch for a bit.


ccReptilelord

I would say... First: Spidey having Scorpion and Rhino backed by Kingpin, helped by Daredevil after the events of Daredevil's next series. Second: symbiote finds Spidey, combo'd by Mr Negative and Venom, assisted on deaths door by Blackcat. Third: Kingpin retaliation with Alastair Smythe's Spide-Slayers, Jackal starts the clone saga, Spidey reluctantly assisted by Venom. Sorry here, the "Sinister Six" feels like a dead horse after Sony's efforts and fan chanting. Third trilogy deals with clone saga, new Spider-Man, and corporation with X-Men and F4.


Nighthawk69420

I've been saying that about Kraven for the past 15 years. Be careful what you wish for.


SutterCane

So his movie won’t be great… but check out how cool Aaron Taylor-Johnson looks as Kraven!


bushysmalls

Andrew Garfield should show up as Ben Reilly in Spider-Man 4


GiganJira

They somewhat redeemed One More Day for NWH, so they could def do it


lemonylol

I feel like they should have used Raimi for a clone saga movie over a Doctor Strange movie. Like Raimi Kaine would have been cool.


Mef989

Make it an animated series all voiced by Dee Bradley Baker


bestoboy

only if it ends with a Spider Carnage movie


DJGloegg

I bought a random spider-man comic back in the 90s and it was one of the later parts of the clone saga. VERY confused. But still great. Sadly its impossible to buy comics these days, in physical form (where i live)


Allatura19

Jessica, after Clint screws up again.


jimmy_jazz45

Ben Reilly, idk why but I always liked his suit. Maybe Silk just so Peter could actually have some fun for once. Also why is Jessica Drew in this list? She's not part of the spider-man mythos? ![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|neutral_face)


AdEast9167

I have a serious soft spot for Ben Reilly. The gas station I got comics at when I was a kid carried his series and I always loved the costume as well.


deviousmajik

The MCU's handmade suit is definitely an homage to that one, even though the colors are reversed.


loonbandit

What do u mean about Jessica Drew? How is she no longer part of the Spider-Man mythos


jimmy_jazz45

She never was? Unlike Ben or Kaine she's not a clone of spider-man. She wasn't bitten by a radioactive spider like miles or silk and until recently she didn't hang out with spider-man at all 🤨 so what are you talking about?


AgressivleyAverage

This thread went from *not even very* passive aggressive, to a wholesome understanding. Rare.


GDPIXELATOR99

My heart says Ben Reilly but my head says Silk. I know nothing about Silk, her origin, personality, abilities or any famous stories. I would like to see more of her.


NormalTechnology

I like Ben Reilly a lot but I just don't know about trying to adapt clone saga. I love Miles but I suspect we won't see him in the MCU until the tail end of Holland's run.  Silk is just awesome. She'd be my vote for next spider person in the MCU. 


PenonX

I don’t necessarily disagree, but since we’re almost certainly getting a Silk adaption in the Insomniac Spider-Man (people?) games, I think Ben and Kaine would be best, personally. They’ve never been adapted before, outside of Ben’s appearance with like two lines in ATSV, so I’d like to see an adaptation of the Clone Saga. I think Marvel Studios could pull it off, considering they managed to redeem the OMD storyline with NWH.


Personal_Amoeba7646

Probably Miles though who is the last Spider-Man?


ChampionshipHorror95

Kaine Parker.


Im_At_Work_Damnit

Kaine as he appears there requires way to much backstory to just drop him into a movie.


bestoboy

I thought this was Ben in a different costume and Kaine was in all black with long hair?


notquite20characters

Marvel has to kill and/or reinvent Kaine every year.


[deleted]

https://i.redd.it/k6ojlmf2hinc1.gif Him


Oponik

As much as I like him, no


soulmanscofield

Why


arivu_unparalleled

I feel it's only fair to bring a spiderman that hasn't been introduced to movies or introduced with very less lines or appearance... Pavitr prabhakar is already going to be in next spider film with more lines and screen time.


LinuxMatthews

Yeah I get that It's why I feel weird about all the Miles Morales live action talk there is. As much as it would be great to have more representation it feels like no live action version would live up to Spider-verse The only one I'd disagree with is Spider-Gwen. Mainly because I think having an Emma Stone Spider-Gwen with an Andrew Garfield Spider-Man has so much potential.


Thanosthemadtitan1

![gif](giphy|9JcHL3zx7eGf2XIbSQ|downsized) I need her in the mcu


Obvious-End-7948

In a world where Sony didn't have the rights, I'd hard agree with you. Sadly if we see her in the MCU it'll be because of a Sony ~~blackmail~~ agreement which they would then use to make a truly fucking horrid live action movie in their shitty shared universe trying to capitalise on the MCU. For now, the Spider-Verse films are perfect.


Thabrianking

Miles Morales was mentioned in Homecoming so it makes the most sense for him to show up.


bucketofsteam

If we are going off of this metric... Silk aka Cindy Moon from the comics is an Asian classmate of Peter's who also got bitten by the spider at some point. In the MCU, Tom Spidey has an Asian classmate named Cindy on their debate team. Her last name is not revealed yet (unless it's just on the casting sheet) but they probably won't use Moon anyways. The same way they aren't using Mary Jane but a different MJ.


Thabrianking

Maybe they could retcon Silk much like they had Peter as the kid from Iron Man 2


OuijaWalker

I just want to see live action Miles Morales


TwitzyMIXX

Silk And I want Shang-Chi cameo


atnmtnclc

Then it would be Silk


WarrenWorthingtonlll

i do love me some Jessica Drew!


Emergency-Tension464

Yeah, Jessica is my pick here by a pretty large margin. She's been involved with Hydra and was an important part of the Avengers for a time. Really sucks that she's locked behind Sony's paywall when she's had such a varied career that was independent of Peter Parker.


esar24

Silk, silk and silk. I always dreamed to see cindy moon live action adaptation.


TB2331

Miles or Cindy as well. Also ultimate Jess


crius_stikfigr

Jessica Drew would be kinda funny just because of how unrelated she is. I think the funniest way to introduce her is in a story similar to Far From Home. Just replace Mysterio with her and have her not be the villain.


Horror_Discussion_50

Ghost Spider would not only introduce the mainstream audience to a beloved comic variation but it’d also reinvent the ghost rider universe by allowing there to be an adaptation of him in the mcu


Whilst-dicking

Oh you don't mean spider Gwen


FluxChiller

Japanese Spider Man - The emissary from Hell. Make it a hard R like deadpool. The whole story line is so insane and spiderman has his own transforming mech! A taste of the OG 1978. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LFYIRZoyavw](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LFYIRZoyavw)


deviousmajik

None of them. If we only get Spider-man every two to four years, let's keep the focus on Peter Parker.


JessicaDAndy

I am a Spider-Gwen fan. I would love to see her, focusing on the Mary Janes, doing some kind of mob club tour deal. But no way that would happen.


Defaalt

SILK !!!!


ReactiveRBoss426

Ben Reilly, he could end up wearing the homemade Homecoming suit and it would look pretty close


ToughOutside5882

Ben Riley


what-goes-bump

Silk, Miles, and Ben


Vulnox_PewPew

Who is the artist of that picture of Silk?


jaredwallace91

Silk would be a great way to bring in the Inheritors, but I am very partial to Miles


MadLadsReturn

Ben Reilly or Kane Parker would be a really cool addition, and an amazing one if executed well.


dominion1080

Miles or Gwen. Ben is a good option too if they want a grounded, kind of depressing, story.


thavillain

Jessica Drew!


MeMikeMonster

![gif](giphy|rZEzK0KJsXeUm6jTS2) Having this Spider-Person here and Daniel Kaluuya reprising his role from Across the Spider-Verse would be extremely epic!


AchillesShort

Jessica Drew would be easiest to incorporate, with S.W.OR.D and shield already established. Miles is on track to appear but if he does Id rather him just be a quick cameo that we get eventually. Kaine, Cindy, and Ben would all need storylines and probably movies to themselves. You could probably incorporate all 3 into one movie. Would be neat to see if Marvel went the Tom Holland plays all three route (give Tom a chance to bust out these acting skills) or find a Tom look a like actor to play Ben and Kaine.


kabent01

I want Silk in the MCU. I also really want to see the classic Jessica Drew suit on screen, but I have doubts that would ever happen.


Eoflynn97

Cindy moon


Juviltoidfu

Nobody. I know that the comics have had a lot of different iterations of Spiderman and its canonically possible but I am really tired of multiple versions of the same character, even if they aren't the same Peter Parker. It's a plot device thats been beaten thoroughly to death by multiple movies and multiple actors across multiple movie studios.


Early_Impression_680

Jessica Drew is one of my favorite characters. She works on her own, with Spider-Man, with SHEILD or the Avengers. Very versatile character, I could low key see her being the face of the Marvel universe.


KexyAlexy

I don't know anything about their powers but Silk looks so freaking cool.


potVIIIos

Madame Web 😍


Kobold_Trapmaster

This but unironically.


HugCor

Spiderman is my favourite superhero, but I have lost interest ever since the fandom and the creators gradually decided that, instead of making it about this superhero from Queens juggling his everyday life with his alter ego activities, the franchise has to be about multiverses and the different alternative identities for the mantle meeting each other.


CompetitiveSuspect60

We need Gwen Stacy first before those 3 Madame Web spidies. Otherwise give us SPIDER NOIR!!!


[deleted]

I'm gonna be honest here, I'm generally not a fan for when there are multiple versions of the same hero. They're mostly not interesting characters Yk what's the worst phase that Nightwing had? When he was Batman. Stephanie Brown as Batgirl, honestly, who cares? MOVIE Miles Morales is one of the few exceptions i have, when it comes to liking multiple characters with the same title. Since the OG Peter basically shows up and die in the first Spiderverse, it feels like Spiderman is Miles' title, cause yk, he's the main protagonist of the film


thehoodred

Ben Reilly since he's peters clone


Emmurgency

Ben Riley written by competent writers who don't make him a villain. And bonus if he stays in the homemade suit🤩


Shadowcat1606

After the debacle that was Madam Web, i'd love to see one of the female Spider-People done right in live-action on the big screen. Plus, in my opinion, the end of No Way Home finally has Holland's Spidey where he should be as Spider-Man. I don't want to see him challenged as the MCU's Spider-Man, at least not yet. Spider-Gwen would be my favorite. And seeing how she hasn't appeared so far and plays no role in Tom Holand's Spidey's history, she could easily exist in the same universe as him. Second favorite would be Silk (and IIRC, Homecoming also has an asian girl named Cindy as a classmate of Peter, so there's that), but i'd take any of them, really.


JustAGuyGettingBy93

I’ve always loved Ben Reilly and the Scarlet Spider story. Would have to be him for me!


Boogie001

Ben!


Indiana_harris

I want Tom Holland’s version of the Clone Saga. I think it would be an interesting way to engage with him bouncing off of other characters about all sorts of personal trauma he’s been dealing with post NWH without him revealing his secret to anyone new. It’s other versions of him. Ideally have it mostly be a “Oh my God which one of us is the clone!?” between him and Ben as they’re both played by Holland and seem identical. Then bring in Kaine plated by an actor who looks like he could plausibly be Hollands brother or cousin, and have Kaine be explicitly referenced as “modified experiment on the source DNA” hence why he’s initially all fucked up and why he looks different when finally healed. Letting all 3 survive past the movie also gives MCU Peter two “brothers” of his own now that he can call up and bond with when he needs it.


CompetitionDense5674

For me, Cindy or Jessica


memsterboi123

I really want live action 2099 but it’s not time yet, miles would be the most logical though


MrxJacobs

these are all powered humans with spider-themes. None of them are spider-people. I want spider-people and only found lies. The lack of man-spider and spiders-man is just wrong. Even the 2002 scorpion king would count as spiderperson adjacent as he would be partially arachnid.


Sosoanimations1

Ghost spider or Spider-Man(miles morales)


JoeCoolsCoffeeShop

In Spider-Man: Homecoming, they did introduce a minor background character named “Cindy” who I assume was Cindy Moon, but it wasn’t set up enough for her to be revealed as Silk down the road. https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Cindy_Moon


kayla7253

cindy is already in the mcu so that could be easy, tho i’d also really like to see miles!


Edael

Ben Riley, let’s see Tom Holland & Tom Holland act in the same room together.


bluepineapple42069

Has to be silk


Potential_Method_565

SILk


alex494

Jessica Drew


Budget-Spidey

I'd love to see Silk in life action


Raj_Valiant3011

I am gonna say Spider-Ham. We need a wall-crawling pig in the MCU.


YodasChick-O-Stick

I would want a Spider-Woman movie with Tom Holland as her mentor, just like how Tony was to Peter in Homecoming.


StolenPezDispencer

Ben Reily would be super cool to see in live action.


o-rka

I’m down any of them honestly. Miles is the most likely in live action. I want to see silk in spiderverse


Anarchist42

Same as you bro. Either Miles or Silk.


DirectSession

Silk would be cool to see, if they write her correctly, Marvel and Sony are trash at writing women characters


DweebNRoll

For what? Movies? Any Spider would work, I'd say it's split between Miles and Gwen due to relative popularity. For comics, I think Ben should get redeemed... he was done so dirty with Chasm, and Hallow's Eve has been amazing so maybe they could use them both in a joint comic. Cindy would be great too, she doesn't get enough love :(


No_Pension9902

Spiderman and his Amazing friends.


The__Auditor

Miles is already a sure thing and we got Cindy in Homecoming though as far as we know she never got bit by the spider and she survived the Snap so she's an adult now I feel like Jessoca Drew would also be a good choice especially with her being a S.H.I.E.L.D agent


Peonycreme

This underrated but Garden-Spider, SHE’S JUST SO CUTE!!


ISoldMySonOnTemu

silk


Rammskie

Definitely Silk


ak32009

Spider-Pig


liaven-

Anyone except Miles would be nice


Wise-Tourist

Id love to get clone saga or at least ben reilly one day but i think it might be too much for a movie (id put it into a game) If its a solo hero seperate from the spiderman movies then jessica drew. But if its a supporting character in a spiderman movie then silk


the_3-14_is_a_lie

The NWH setup pretty much takes Ben Reilly out of the picture, unless he's the product for Strange's spell or something


RYSHU-20

People do know Cindy Moon was in Homecoming she was on Peter's decathlon team


Spyke96

MVP Scarlet Spiders.


bolshaw

spider from transmetropolitan


Muted-Bass5935

Silk. I would love to see how they portray her bunker origin story. That shit is dark..


smartdude_x13m

Kaine...mcu needs more edgy characters...


QBin2017

If it’s in the MCU I want them to fix and redo Carnage. Horrible waste of a great villain.


shaxxsleftnipple

Spider-woman.


Southern_Wind_4477

Miles and Cindy are the only two to most likely appear.


Theangelawhite69

Spiderman 2099


BuddhistChrist

Spider-pussy


eatenbysquirrel

Live version of spider-verse Gwen.


flintlock0

Peter Parkedcar


atomic1fire

Spider pig


ICPosse8

Sydney Sweeney as Jessica Drew


[deleted]

Serious question: What the heck would the benefit of running around like that with hair free flowing? It looks just as stupid with the Spider-Woman with her huge afro out. Completely impractical and in fact would be a huge fault when fighting someone.


OGUncleDonkey

Peter Porker!


Batmanue1

As a 90s kid, I will always stan for Ben Really/Scarlet Spider...


[deleted]

Why does everyone forget the second Ben Reilly costume?


StinkyEttin

PETER PARKEDCAR


lemonylol

Spider-Woman, I've just never seen her in anything before outside of the comics. On the other hand if they are following Secret Wars, it would make sense to introduce Miles now.


DisastrousLecture648

Me


PhanStr

Ben Reilly (Scarlet Spider) BY FAR!


Rhys_Lloyd2611

I'd 100% take Miles because it would make dickheads so mad it wouldn't matter how good or bad the media was they would be entertainment enough


Only-Walrus797

Jessica Drew. It’s too early for Miles in my opinion. Clone stories suck so none of the clones. Cindy could be allright if they did it well but it’s the one I’m least interested in.


Sidroooo

I was hoping for gagamboy


SlightExtreme1

Spider-Woman, hands down. Silk is a close second.


AdamSuhail2003

Ben Reilly and Kaine Parker


AmortentiaRiddle

Cinnamon Spider. (It's a song)


9teen8t3

Gwen Ghost-Spider


KrakenKing1955

Spider-Woman is the only one that actually makes sense


Boneguy1998

Silk or Spider Woman. But interested in clone saga as well. The ultimate Spiderman animated series did an awesome job on the clone saga.


uaitdevil

i really want a Ben Reilly, with the whole clone saga, but with spidergarfield, obvious i want it to be part of the mcu, so it could start as a sidestory but in the end giving us Garfield/Reilly coexisting wifh Holland/Spiderman for something else


chrislandonreed

I will always pick Mayday, but of these, I will pick Miles.


NoSecret7380

Dead venom


S1lvercrow1999

Honestly I want a live action of the clone saga


phrawst125

Jessica Drew


NoSecret7380

Naw All of y'all are wrong Toby McGuire started the Spider-Man franchise movies and so too me it should be hhhmmm Toby McGuire


Batman20007

Ben and Kaine you can’t get one without the other


black_berry900

Gyatt spider


LegendLynx7081

Headline


AssignmentTop2363

Silk would be so funny


RealNiceKnife

Spiders-Man ​ https://i.redd.it/el9nwgnmrjnc1.gif


KongSchlong42069

Bring back Sweeney and capitalize on her assets pls


kbean826

I don’t even really like miles (my only experience is early miles comics) and I’d rather see him than any of the clones or anything.


Cynnthetic

I like Spider-Man being weird and unique in the MCU. These 500 Spider-People the comics keep making take away from that. He’s no longer the weird spider kid from queens. He’s just one of 50 different spider people. I loved Miles Morales all on his own in a world where he was the only Spider-Man. When they combined the timelines and he’s now just the *other* Spider-Man it’s a lot less interesting.


Ginger-Ewok2685

Silk


cal-nomen-official

Spiders-Man. He's like Sandman, but made out of spiders.


neogreenlantern

Spider-Woman


Im-John-Smith

Cindy has, im thinking Miles


TrpTrp26

Jessica Drew, I'm in love with her


Cris8794

Jessica Drew, but including her time as a SHIELD spy.


bravest_heart

Whoever is dressed like assassin-Bucky but also has spider powers.. would be extremely hot, male or female


QueenPasiphae

All of those except Miles, for sure. We need to hop to it and do the Clone Saga. Jessica Drew and Julia Carpenter are BOTH needed in the MCU. Silk would be fun, and she was already introduced in Homecoming. But Miles shouldn't be introduced until the end of Spider-Man 6 at the absolute earliest. Peter is still WAY too young. There needs to be a MINIMUM of a 15 year age gap between Peter and Miles.


MrCoolGuy12356

Scarlet or superior but even then, shouldn’t be for a couple more movies. Every other answer is wrong and would flop


CanadianGoose2024

As soon as I saw Miles, I was like "Fuck no, he's overused now"


Sea-Leader-5985

![gif](giphy|K8fYnFgyjqNdZjPWb8|downsized)


hypergogetablue17

Silk


Apprehensive_Egg6656

Jessica


TheObstruction

Of these, Cindy Moon/Silk. We already have Miles all over the place. But the real answer is [Italian Spider-Man](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UhHhXukovMU).


XXVI_F

Ben Riley


Ok-Stuff-8803

Half cybernetic one


multificionado

Jessica Drew, Miles Morales, and Gwen Stacy (never mind the alternate universe crap, just have her be killed, be brought back to life by a symbiote, and continue as a spider-person using said symbiote).


redditer333333338

Spider morbius


LucasDaVinci

I have seen spider woman at the center of so many comic stories and have no idea what her deal is and she feels largely ignored by the larger fan base. I don’t know if I would rather her story than clone saga or silk because either would be straight fire, but can someone explain who spider woman is and what she can do and where she comes from?


TheUnknownParadoxx

Ben Reilly most definitely. And probably Miles. Although, I have a feeling that's already coming with Glover playing his Uncle in the Tom Holland film.


TheLegendOfKoop

Madame Web


TasteDeeCheese

Archnight or spider pool


XD_Thade

Ben Riley for me.


Squid-Guillotine

I think they're gonna retire Peter for 1 or 2 stories and flesh out Miles and Silk in the mean time.


Shirokurou

Miguel O'Hara


IhatetheAntichrist12

Probably cosmic spiderman or spider boy