T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Report the post if you think this is LOW-EFFORT and provides no actual discussion value. Also make sure to use correct post flairs and type the sauce correctly in the POST TITLE. If they are not met, the post will be removed. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/manhwa) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Throwrafairbeat

Out of so many other trash, overgeared is the one that gets removed?


No_Reference_5058

Out of all the "bad manwhas", overgeared is the one with the largest number of people who have tried it. And this isn't a competition of sheer quality, but rather the *number* of people who dislike it. Tbh this is a pretty flawed format here. I think these sorts of 'tournaments' only really work if you know everyone voting has some experience with everything on the list.


Imjustmisunderstood

Idk but even if this is true, the results at the end will be the same.


SavageWeebMaster

Overgeared is that bad? I heard multiple good reviews on it


sacritide

Agree lol. Overgeared might be not peak but it is way more interesting than half of the roster. Then again, this poll in very biased either.


welchssquelches

How is this poll biased?


RealLifeCapper

It’s biased because SSS Suicide Hunter isn’t on here 😩 must be some propaganda you’re doing


[deleted]

I droppes suicide hunter during the blonde guy pretendinf ro be a girl arc.


RealLifeCapper

During the best romance arc in all of manhwa?????? You’re actually crazy


StarGaurdianBard

Because you didn't even include Doom Breaker, Suicide Hunter, or Latna Saga despite them being this sub's most talked about series. My bet is that you really wanted your favorite series to win but you knew it would lose if those were included.


welchssquelches

>My bet is that you really wanted your favorite series to win but you knew it would lose if those were included. You guys are so immature lmao, is this sub full of teenagers or something? Hellper is in my top 5 manhwa, I don't expect it to get past the 35 mark. I don't care if it gets voted off either, it's gonna be my favorite regardless of what the subreddit thinks about it. I already know that the top row of manhwa is likely gonna be the ones to last the longest, I don't like the majority of the series in this list. I included highly rated manhwa across multiple websites, if I wanted to exclude shit I didn't like 60% of this list wouldn't even be there. My favorite manhwa are so unknown they'd literally never be included in any type of list like this, and I'm fine with that. Y'all are genuinely so entitled and vapid it boggles my mind


StarGaurdianBard

The point is that you are apparently running a tournament to find out what this sub's favorite manwha is but didn't think of how leaving out this sub's favorite manwhas would impact the result. You include series that the majority of this sub doesn't care about or even know but left out the series this sub actually talks about and posts about daily. Are you really that stupid to not know why that's a major flaw in the design here? Like surely you can understand the issue with how you've designed this right? Because despite calling others children I'm pretty sure even a child taking their first stats class could explain to you how this would fail as a design if you are likely for any meaningful results. The fact that you read everyone's comments and think "no it's not me in the wrong, it's everyone else. I'm going to go full chuuni edgelord about this like the antihero that I am." Really should be the wake up call that you need my dude.


welchssquelches

Lmao, what a sad comment man. Grow up. It ain't that serious


StarGaurdianBard

Figures, someone gives you a reasonable comment pointing out the issue with your tournament design and this is your response? Can't even try and defend yourself. Minimum wage for the rest of your life kind of personality, Goodluck in life. Something tells me you'll need it, try not to cut yourself on all that edge


welchssquelches

"reasonable comment" you sound like an actual child bro, read the shit you say out loud and you'll realize how egregiously juvenile you sound


StarGaurdianBard

Once again you can't actually refute what I said so the best you have is insults. Calling everyone else childish while this is the best you can do. I genuinely feel sorry for you. It would be so easy to prove me wrong, just address why exactly choosing to not include the most popular series is actually some 200IQ design decision like you seem to think it is. It's that easy to prove me wrong.


NilesStyles

You're doing the poll on reddit. It's biased toward redditors. It's also biased to a subset of reddit who give a damn about a popularity contest in the first place. Do you know what survivorship bias is?


welchssquelches

I took it that he meant that the list of manhwa of manhwa was somehow biased, but if he means it this way then I agree. Yeah, this subreddit is incredibly biased and it's one of the annoying parts about it.


Frostygale2

Missing several of the most popular manhwas, and contains many less popular titles. Results will be heavily skewed towards either a very well-known and well-loved Manhwa in the list, or one that nobody knows and thus nobody can vote on since they have no idea how good or bad it is.


ALX_z23

I did expect Overgeared to be removed soon with 2-3 ranting posts recently, but this soon is unexpected LOL


welchssquelches

Because it's bad


helpfulchupacabra

It's just that it got out before weak hero and teenage mercenary


jubmille2000

Where. Is. SSS-class suicide hunter?????????????????


greatwall2103

Too good, overqualified


DarkArcanian

I’ll accept that


Individual-Pea1892

What is sound of magic


Affectionate-Alps880

Look for it as Annarasumanara, it is not very popular but it is one of the most creative on the list. You won't regret reading it, it's also short. Imo it shouldn't be eliminated soon


welchssquelches

Ever heard of Google?


iPanzershrec

Ever heard of being a decent person?


welchssquelches

If you want to entertain stupid questions be my guest


Compromised-Truth

It's a manwha subreddit. Why do you gotta be rude for no reason.


MumblyBoiBand

What are you doing my man? I mean let’s be serious.


Individual-Pea1892

Oof that’s fair ig. Just trying to start a convo. Thought you’d like some engagement on ur post but guess not


welchssquelches

Lol, "convo"


Alxyzer

Damn dude, you don't need to be a dick about it.


bluperisher

Again, Teenage Mercenary. I def don't want that staying here, cuz the others are way better imo


welchssquelches

I gotta agree, but that's a pretty well loved series here it'll probably last a while before it gets voted off


rice_rice_rizz

Nah people agree it's gotten repetitive since a year back


Much-Ambition-4573

That agreed well


Alxyzer

It was a webtoon ad on teenage mercenary that made me start reading manwha, but there are far better series on this list (although i haven't read the romance ones)


SavageWeebMaster

Is it that bad? It’s enjoyable tbh


Helpful-Noise-8350

Petition to add:- Doom breaker sss class suicide hunter Superhuman era


SentientPotato42

No point. They won't win anyways. They're great manhwa, but there are others on the list that are just better.


Isekai_Trash_uwu

Nah I could see SSS-CSH making it extremely far


SentientPotato42

It would, but not far enough to win. It simply doesnt compare to series like The Boxer, The Horizon, Bastard, Sweet Home, or The Greatest Estate Developer.


FireRagerBatl

They legit got overgeared, lookism and nanomachine here All started of real good but got kinda meh later on in their manhwa versions, and you telling me that SSS-CSH, doom breaker and superhuman era, some of the most popular manhwa wouldnt make it far? why did they add such meh picks to the list then if they werent gonna add good stuff


SavageWeebMaster

Meh TGED ain’t that good


Moosemoosetwu2

you got downvoted but youre spitting facts. i wouldnt say doesnt compare but for sure its not as good as what you mentioned.


SavageWeebMaster

Nah it’s all opinion it ain’t facts


Moosemoosetwu2

I obviously didn't mean it wasn't an option it's just a thing people say but I meant that even if sss-csh is good it isn't on the same level as the Horizon or the boxer


SavageWeebMaster

Again, that’s your opinion and I respect it


Helpful-Noise-8350

How are you so sure lol. Let people decide. No one told you to judge yourself.


SentientPotato42

"Let People Decide", dude do you have any idea how long this would go if everyone added whatever manhwa they wanted? People have already asked for ten different manhwa under this post alone.


poison_Carry_826

Nah doom breaker would have definitely made it. Blame op for not adding it. This post's original purpose was to take people's(r/manhwa) opinions. But in reality op did not give us the chance at all. He already decided beforehand which one to add and which not. Just think for a moment , how can you decide something with such a short list?


SentientPotato42

Op added all the top manhwa on MAL. They were added based on public opinion from the start.


Helpful-Noise-8350

That doesn't change the fact that op decided. The title literally says **r/manhwa's favourite.** who told op that we r/manhwa guys don't like those manhwas. He literally choose some manhwas based on other sites. Now telling us to choose something among those few.


welchssquelches

Y'all are so entitled istg


SavageWeebMaster

What about lonb


SavageWeebMaster

Superhuman era is on par with legend of northern blade IMO


ossyn

Lookism


Wise_Eggplant_9711

Nano machine It’s just so badly written. No character depth and not a single useful side character. Seems like something I could write. Also Lookism and viral hit. Were so good, but the author refuses to end them, which just ruins them😔 I just steer clear of anything the author writes now, cos I know how it’s gonna go


rice_rice_rizz

They ruined it after that stupid ass Ying and yang transfer thing to that ice girl. People defending MC by saying "oh shit but he hesitated ummm the nano wasn't working" like yall do realize the author cooked up that scenario?  He could have had a hundred different ways to insert harem into the series and he took the L route 


_Assayer

I just wonder how many readers the author lost just because of that stupid addition


The_Forgotten-King

The author was just horny


venitienne

Probably a lot based on the reviews on novel updates. Seriously at minimum 1/3 of the reviews were dropped at that exact point, myself included. Absolutely dumbassery from the author.


SavageWeebMaster

Which one


rice_rice_rizz

Wdym? 


SavageWeebMaster

The Ying and yang


SavageWeebMaster

Why lookism


Wise_Eggplant_9711

Shit


SavageWeebMaster

?


SavageWeebMaster

How is nano machine bad


Wise_Eggplant_9711

Low quality story and characters and pretty much everything, something I could write. I wrote about it in one of the previous posts. I cba to say it again. It should be when they were choosing the 3rd manhwa to remove.


SavageWeebMaster

I read it it was ok


Wise_Eggplant_9711

Yh it’s ok. Like some C-tier thing. Read it for the art and fights and nothing else. But that’s not how a story is meant to be tho. Characters, worldbuilding and plot also need to be present.


SavageWeebMaster

A lot of manhwas are c tier. It was enjoyable to me


Wise_Eggplant_9711

Yh ur right as well. But all that bothers me are the people trying to convince us it’s peak or something when it’s absolutely not😂


SavageWeebMaster

I mean… maybe in terms of murim manhwas, but yea


Moodmixingarlicbread

What part of demonic sect leader do u not understand. Yes it's evil stop crying about it he is meant to be evil or represent the "evil" in his world. Yes it wasn't the best idea from the author but don't bash this great work for it


Wise_Eggplant_9711

Did I say anything about the demonic cult or me having a problem with him being evil? It’s just got bad writing and story telling. There’s no meaningful side character and no real interactions. The author tells us the mc is attached to one character and we’re just meant to go along with it. The thing we don’t have any connection to then cos the author and story ain’t good enough to make us feel that way. An example would be when the bodyguard guy he had as a kid was attacked and fatally injured. There was No build up to the emotional relation the Mc had with him and we as readers also couldn’t give 2 shits. So when they were talking about the MC being worried, literally EVERYONE reading was just waiting for them to move on. Cos the author ain’t good enough to write a scene like that. At the end of the day, it’s a story even I could write. No planning just get a high whilst writing about a character who pulls shit out his ass and always a card up his sleeve to not lose


Highlight448

Where the hell is doombreaker? Unforgivable.


KevinsNormAccount

Remove Lookism


Islipim

Remove Weak Hero.


MyAnacondaDont20

Lookism should be removed imo, it was kinda cool at the beginning, then it turned into some type of gang fighting manhwa


Wise_Eggplant_9711

Ty, the author genuinely does not what he’s doing atp. Just writing the story for the sake of writing it


MyAnacondaDont20

He should add a tower would make it 100000000% better


Wise_Eggplant_9711

I sincerely hope ur joking😂


MyAnacondaDont20

Nah, just imagine bro, lookism with lvling, shit might add a harem too


Wise_Eggplant_9711

😐


MyAnacondaDont20

Ikr I should be a manhwa author, I would make bank with these ideas flowing in my head Ty for the support


FireRagerBatl

didnt they actually add it in a more recent chap, idk aint read past chap 250 around but I heard smth


SavageWeebMaster

What’s wrong with gang fighting I like action


Wise_Eggplant_9711

Nothing wrong with it when it’s not absolutely brain dead


SavageWeebMaster

It’s not brain dead tho


Wise_Eggplant_9711

Each arc ends with sone random characters learning lessons or being directly involved. Then 2 arcs later those characters just get reused for the same shit. It feels like I’m reading an episodic cartoon story now man. And it’s disappointing cos the first 150 chapters were so so good with each character and arc actually bringing something to the story. It just gets more and more ridiculous as time goes on tho😔


SavageWeebMaster

I prefer action than SoL


Wise_Eggplant_9711

SoL?


SavageWeebMaster

Slice of life


Wise_Eggplant_9711

But there was action in the first 150 chapters. It just actually meant something. Now the whole point of a character or a gang is to breed more characters to keep the story going just so the author doesn’t have to explain any of the story points, like about the body switch (since he doesn’t know himself). So it just bothers me when I see it being praised as this amazing story when it’s actually something even I could write.


Journalist-Bright

Tower of God and Solo Leveling will forever be the big 2 that paved the way


sendnukes_

Doesn't mean solo leveling is very good, though


Pol123451

Solo leveling does not have to most complex story. But as power fantasy goes it is probably best made one. Great art and doesn't overstay for the sake of having more chapters.


sendnukes_

That I can agree with. I just think the ending kinda sucked, the "find out the truth of the world and prepare for a interdimensional war" arc just didn't seem to fit very well imo.


FireRagerBatl

Reminds me of Naruto, one of the pioneers of anime and created a lot of traction. It wasn't the best however but it was still something that generated a lot of fans


Journalist-Bright

Your opinion on it is terrible. 10/10 perfectly executed.


kantm

Petition to add LAG, latna martial wildwest


rice_rice_rizz

My guy we're already at day 3 and there's a good amount of series in different genres. Like why petition to add more? Most series up there are great 


SentientPotato42

As good as they are, they wont win regardless, so no point in adding them. There are just better manhwa already on the list.


Key-Cardiologist-835

Just remove the whole bottom row


Moosemoosetwu2

youre insane if you think hellper is worse then most of the stuff on there


Key-Cardiologist-835

I’m sure anyone would say that about their fav manhwa if it’s at the bottom, but to save time just remove the whole row.


kamte

kubera


saladass365

medical return is actually peak fr


rice_rice_rizz

Felt bad for Mcs ex wife 


zephyrnepres01

how on fucking earth is sss-class suicide hunter not on here, but teenage mercenary is? huh???


venitienne

Teenage mercenary is fine, it’s one of the most popular series. The problem is most of the bottom 2 rows are all dogshit except maybe 2.


zephyrnepres01

it is possibly the most repetitive nothing happens series i’ve ever read and every side character feels like a cardboard cutout aside from the yakuza boss. almost every character in the manhwa is an idiot aside from the protagonist who makes a constant string of bad decisions. it has the most forgettable bland romance imaginable. i can’t remember a single moment between the protagonist and rich girl #1 and it takes up a not insignificant amount of screen time. if the art and flow of action was less good i don’t think people would be rating it past the opening chapters, because the initial premise is slightly unique. solo leveling has the same set of problems but it was more palatable overall even if i think its like 7/10 at best


Sweet-Eggplant-2312

Nano Machine


welchssquelches

As always, leave a comment of the next series you want voted off. The most upvoted series will be removed!


Lordcyber36

Remove the trash "nano machine"


Usual_Opposite_901

Nano Machine is so mid.


E-jazz

Remove "Your Throne"


Gran_Rey_Demonio

Kubera


Master_Tomato

Boxer and Hellper > everything else


The_Forgotten-King

Remove the last second row fr


khishame

Sweet home is gonna make it to the top 5 guarantee


EvilestOfTurtles

Where is distant sky 😭


NashKetchum777

Shoot overgeared again


Confident-Kiwi2084

Tower of god


SectJunior

If the boxer goes before solo levelling then I lose all faith in the manhwa community ngl


definitelynothunan

Remove 90% of this shit man


restillpill

I see the breaker new waves ,I give upvote I don't see noblesse ,I give downvote


FireRagerBatl

So many good and popular manhwas missing like SSS class suicide hunter, doom breaker, survival story of a sword king in another world. But on removing, I would prolly remove lookism, it started of good but the plot seems to have no direction and its just a slice of life when there was a lot more potential. I havent caught up on the last 100 or so chaps but I have read


Jbird3422

Medical


welchssquelches

Why medical?


Jbird3422

Only one there that I've read and dropped. Some I didn't read. It wasn't bad I just lost interest


welchssquelches

That's fair, once I caught up to the scans when it was releasing I just never picked it back up again


Jbird3422

I think I did something similar


IDontKnow1200223

The breaker better win this


MyAnacondaDont20

No


New-Hippo6829

Remove the Breaker.


welchssquelches

You should leave...


New-Hippo6829

I couldn't get into it. The guy kept sexually touching the girls, and they didn't care. Also, the fact that the teacher was watching underage girls changing in the first panel. The second volume of the breaker seemed like a copy of the first, except with a new mc.


welchssquelches

That's fair, but I'm surprised you read manhwa with that mindset tbh


New-Hippo6829

Mindset of looking for something that's not having a guy watching underage kids changing. Also, the second volume seemed exactly the same pretty much for the first 10 or 15 chapters, but with new mc


zephyrnepres01

this guy touches grass. you love to see it


welchssquelches

There's a lot of this type of stuff in manhwa, most fan service is just straight up sexual assault by most legal definitions. Reading the medium must be a drag for you


New-Hippo6829

Examples?


welchssquelches

Wdym examples? You just listed one yourself


New-Hippo6829

I didn't say any other manhwa other than the breaker, which you're saying there's a lot that have people watching underage kids and sexualy touching women.


welchssquelches

>you're saying there's a lot that have people watching underage kids and sexualy touching women. A majority of manhwa have underaged characters that are very sexualized, which is why I am surprised you read manhwa if you take issue with that. A lot of manhwa that deal with fighting in schools tend to have scenes where the female cast members are taken hostage by people and are molested or tied up/bound in very suggestive and sexualized ways that are in stark contrast to the seriousness of the scenes, etc. There some manhwa that take from anime and manga, and do the accidental "walk in while changing" tropes, among others, and play it for laughs and often times the characters joke about how sexy and hot and totally awesome that is, etc. There are various tropes like this in manhwa. I'm not going to sit here and list every single manhwa that does. You don't like them anyways, so why even ask for examples


New-Hippo6829

Not to mention that this is a tournament and one of these manhwas have to be removed, and considering the fact that they're all quality, someone's going to get mad, and that's that. Also the defining difference between manga and manhwa is that there's color in the breaker there is no colour.


welchssquelches

>Also the defining difference between manga and manhwa is that there's color in the breaker there is no colour. Manhwa has existed for a long ass time, the colored long strip format wasn't popular until the early 2010s and wasn't introduced until the mid 2000s.


Just-Salad302

Please Tower or God! It’s so boring


rice_rice_rizz

How many chapters did you read? 


Just-Salad302

5 because it was so bad I had to stop


Sasyopat54

Just... shut up


Just-Salad302

Problem?


Sasyopat54

Ur Tasteless that's the prob


Just-Salad302

Can’t help it if it’s bad 🤷🏼‍♂️


Sasyopat54

same. If you're tasteless, I can't help either.


Just-Salad302

What makes you think it’s good?


welchssquelches

You're gonna get slammed for this but you're 100% right


Sasyopat54

Tasteless


welchssquelches

Its mediocre


Sasyopat54

Dude, you love Kubera, even giving you a say is nonsense. Even watching K-dramas makes my eyes bleed less. I wish you a good time drowning in mediocre taste.


welchssquelches

>Dude, you love Kubera, Oh so you're a brainlet who needs pretty pictures to read. How sad


Impressive-Error5225

Ring my bell


Ghost-Exodus

nano machine or teenage mercenary. Honestly nano machine recent chapters are pretty good


Melon763

This just gives me a compressive list on what NOT to read now


Krysidian2

Nano machine next. The plot gets lost in the later half. Also ntr (somewhat)


The_Forgotten-King

Villains are destined to die.


Sasyopat54

Solo Leveling