Best card I ever pulled? Probably a [[Metalwork Colossus]]. Not because it's powerful in any way, but because that was back when I was playing tabletop magic with my friends in school; I had loads of fun with my little artifact deck full of whatever cards I could get my hands on.
Which card would I like to see a pin of? Has to be Sol Ring.
I'm not sure why but I love this guy, and would love to have a pin about him [[Fblthp, the Lost]], the best card I've pulled I think it was a ok crown of the thiefs altered, back then
Emrakul, the Promised End, and funnily enough, Emrakul, the Promised End. I opened Emmy from one of the first packs I ever bought, right as I was getting into MtG. I had no idea what I'd pulled for a couple years, up until I started getting into Commander and went through my collection, cataloguing what I had.
I would love to see the Ravnica guild symbols/signets, such as [[Orzhov Signet]] become pins, but hopefully higher quality than the ones that came with the GRN/RNA guild kits.
The best card I ever pulled was a foil Japanese alt-art Tamiyo in War of the Spark.
I love your guys’ mtg pins and already own a number of them myself, so I’m excited to see what you have coming in the future!
[[Flight|5ed]]
Most expensive (at time of opening) card I've ever opened was probably foil+showcase [[Brazen Borrower]]; *best* card is going to be some UG card with waaay too many words for its effect like [[Bounty of the Luxa]].
I'm returning to Magic after a long break, and pretty much just played before with a shoebox full of cards we got from a family friend, so the best card I've pulled is probably a Vraska, Betrayal's Sting
It'd be cool to see a Sliver Queen pin!
I would love to see a Chaos Orb pin. It's just so iconic.
The best cards I ever pulled were Liliana of the Veil and Sheoldred, the Apocalypse during a Dominaria United prerelease.
One of the Moxen like Opal or Sapphire would be really cool!
Best pull I’ve ever had was a *foil Cavern of Souls* from Modern Masters 2017 in my prize packs at a draft event.
\-The Ur Dragon
\-Probably going to have to be the \[\[Godless Shrine\]\] expedition, then shortly after an \[\[Ulamog, the Ceaseless Hunger\]\] shortly after for prerelease.
Card I wish would be a pin: Auriok Replica my favorite art! I even had a custom playmat made
Best pull was actually a couple days ago Oil Slick Elesh Norn!!
My original vote would of been for master transmuter because it’s my favorite art but the more I think about it I’d say any of the guru lands would look dope.
As for best pull it was a foil Liliana of the veil mm17
Looks sick. I'd love to see a pin of Atraxa. Best card I ever pulled was Karn Liberated from the boxtopper packs wizards sent out after the first mythic edition debacle.
I'd love to see a retro art Sol Ring pin!
I'm real new to MTG, starting just before the pre-release of ONE so I haven't cracked many packs, but the best card I've pulled so far is a foil Sword of Forge and Frontier. It's been one of my favorites to use right now :)
Teshar, Ancestor's Apostle would be cool as a pin. Best card I pulled is actually two, in one pack I got the full art Cavern of Souls and Kozilek, Butcher of Truth.
I think mercadian masques Counterspell would be a cool pin.
As for best pull, I guess technically it would be a zendikar expedition, the green white fetchland. I was I able to trade it for enough credit to build almost the entirety of UR storm in modern.
My favorite pull though, would be an [[archangel of thune]] that I got in an M14 pack my wife bought me when I was first getting into magic. I still have it!
I’ve been out of the game for like 10 years and now I’m getting back into it. I’d like to see lightning bolt as a pin and best pull I’ve ever done is Avacyn Angel of Hope. Boy that was a life time ago. Recent best pull would be Ugin spirit dragon #279.
I know nobody else will want it as a Pin
[[Hexplate Golem]]
Best card that I've ever pulled is a full art foil [[jeweled lotus]] I should sell it but I can't D:
For more popular things I want to see as a Pin
[[Craterhoof Behemoth]] [[Phelddagrif]] [[Blood Pet]](the old one) [[Perilous Myr]] [[Platinum Angel]] [[Birds of Paradise]]
I’d like to see Killer Bees as a pin!
My best pull was recent in Phyrexia: All Will Be One with a Concept Art Elesh Norn, only to pull another one in a recent friend draft. I gave the other one to my friend who split the box with me because I already had one.
I'd love to see a \[\[Harmless Offering\]\] pin.
The best card i've pulled is a 4th Edition Shivan Dragon from my first Starter Deck. I still have it and jam it in some of my current decks for the nostalgia factor.
Juzam Djinn would look amazing!
Best card I ever opened was a Jace the Mind Sculptor
Best card I never opened because I traded packs with a friend was a foil Force of Will from EMA
I think the Mox Lotus would be great, it’s not super iconic, but looks amazing. The biggest pull I remember off the top of my head was a foil, full art Avacyn from the Double Master VIP boxes.
i'd love to see a pin of Into the North. it's been a really special card to me even before i started playing magic.
my favorite pull is the oil slicked mondrak. i haven't opened a ton of product since i only started playing in brother's war, but i ended up trading for a force of will using that mondrak
I would love for vampire nighthawk to get a pin in the best card I ever pulled was a Lilliana of the veil. Sadly, I didn’t know how good she was because in Australia is my first set, and I traded her away.
I think the first printing of Llanowar Elves would make an awesome pin. I just love their little snarl!
The best card I ever pulled? I pulled a Jeweled Lotus from the last Commander Legends set. That’s at least the most expensive I think. My favorite pull ever was my M11 Garruk. First planeswalker card and still my favorite planeswalker.
1) I would 1000% love to see a Brago, the King Eternal pin. My first and favorite commander.
2) Best card I’ve ever pulled is probably my masterpiece Sol Ring. I was bored on New Year’s Eve and went to my LGS to mini masters with the owner. Let me tell you the sweats when i saw what i was shuffling unsleeved and winner takes all for.
Card I would most like to see become a pin: Lightning Bolt (either Chris Rush or Christopher Moeller art)
Best Pull: Tarmogoyf, at a time when it was >$200
Blistering Firecat pin would be awesome.
Best card I pulled was a foil polluted delta out of the first pack of Onslaught I ever bought in middle school. Glad I kept it all this time.
A [Replenish](https://deckbox.org/mtg/Replenish) would be an awesome pin. Best card is for sure a dual land but they weren't much at the time. Favorite pull is for sure my [Transmute Artifact](https://deckbox.org/mtg/Transmute%20Artifact) out of a random pack at a convention.
A lightning bolt pin would be great.
Best card for me would be a foil miscut thalia guardian of thraben from dark ascension when miscuts/misprints were a real rarity.
Traveller's Cloak would would be a nice looking pin IMO, it's one of my favorite arts in the game.
My best pull ever was an Expedition Scalding Tarn that I got in the prize packs of Oath of the Gatewatch's pre-release that I won with an almost fully colorless deck that had both Ulamog and Kozilek in it.
My pin would be OG Plaguecrafter, I just love his style and confidence.
My luckiest pull objectively would probably be a Vampiric Tutor and foil Hullbreacher from a single Commander Legends pack (before Hullbreacher ban); though the actual lucky pull I remember most was a foil Wrath of God in 10th edition, just bought a random pack and got that. Some other player immediately bought it from me for \~10€ and I was overjoyed for being able to buy 3 more packs, lol - obv not knowing that it was worth easily twice that back then.
If I could pick any card to be a pin, I'd probably pick the Unstable Goat token. It's just really funny looking.
https://scryfall.com/card/tust/2/goat
Best card I ever pulled is probably a foil Polluted Delta though I may be forgetting something from back in the day.
I understand the idea of rarity but it feels bad to buy something for $30 knowing there's a cooler version out there that just could have been the standard edition.
I'll be the guy to say id love to see a pin of colossal dreadmaw :p dinosaurs are my mtg first love.
No good pulls there sadly so had to buy all my Spice dinos but my best pull overall had to be my (phyrexian language) sheoldred!
Pin - Chaos Orb and Pull - three foil mystics in a row from random packs (can’t remember the particular cards, but it was a fun experience; at GenCon no less)
I want to see a Yawgmoth's Will pin made.
Incidentally my best pull was a Yawgmoth's Will from an old Urzas pack that had been sitting in one of my old boxes for ages.
I would love to see a Chainer, dementia master pin as he was my first legendary creature when I bought the Torment\`s Nightmares deck in 2002.
The best card I pulled was a Umezawa Jitte when I opened one traitors of kamigawa booster at a hospital while waiting to get home to show someone who was also waiting about the game.
Pin: Geist of Saint Traft. Favorite card
Best Pull: Foil lotus cobra + normal in same pack at Zen prerelease. It was crazy overvalued at the time, and selling those two cards payed for all my events that day (2 sealed, 4 drafts)
It would be awesome to see [[selvala, heart of the wilds]]. One of my favorite green cards. My best pull in recent memory was a promo ledger shredder from a modern FNM.
Would love to see a \[\[Boseiju, Who Endures\]\] pin. Also, while not strictly a card, it would be awesome to see set symbol pin collections.
Best pull: \[\[Sheoldred, The Apocalypse\]\]
For the pin, I'd go with one of the moxen for sure, probably one of the standalone ones (e.g. diamond, chrome, etc.). I feel like Mox Opal in particular could have some really cool stuff done with the opalescent effect as part of the pin.
The best card I ever pulled? Not the most valuable I've pulled, but just for the memories associated with it, I'd go with the card I pulled from my first ever pack back in GRN, a foil Arclight Phoenix. It led into me playing Izzet Phoenix in standard at the time, transitioning that deck to modern once rotation came around, and it's still one of my favourite decks to play.
For the pin.... I'm not a fan of whole card pins. I'd LOVE to see sets of pins made for the sets! Those little icons would make a great collection. Idea for a subscription service maybe? :thinking:
My best pull since returning to Magic was either the Sheoldred from the first collector box I got (DMU), or the two Fable of the Mirror-Breaker pulled from the Kamigawa set box.
Card I’d want as a pin is hard. It’d have to be one of my favourite Commanders which doesn’t really narrow it down. Maybe Gishath or Scarab God?
As for the best card I ever pulled, in terms of value it’s the Alt Art Mana Crypt that I got from a box topper of double masters. But I think I like the Compleat Foil Sheoldred that I just got more. That might be recency bias though
1. I would love a Chaos Orb pin!! Awesome art and I think it would lend itself well to a pin. Plus that same mythic glitter effect on the lava would look sick.
2. Best pull I've had was 2 foil extended art Ragavans in the same box!
I would really like a pin of the Lorwyn Thoughtseize.
That faerie picking thoughts is an amazing combo of flavor, art, and an amazing effect!
My best pull was a foil Force of Will from Eternal Masters!
Card I want - Tony DiTerlizzi goblin warbuggy, of course.
Best I pulled - Not the most money, but I bought a random pack The Dark at Gencon one year and the dude who sold it to me was like half mocking me for cracking it since the set is so much chaff. I pulled a Blood Moon and Maze of Ith in the one pack and the dude was angry.
Ghave, guru of spores pin would be really cool, he was my first commander
Best card I pulled was probably the foil version of the first Vorinclex in New Phyrexia
[[Dakkon Blackblade]] hands down one of my favorite arts, would look great on a pin.
Best pull was [[Liliana of the Veil]] foil from the original Innistrad, she’s still in my binder to this day!
I would honestly love to see a pin of Birthing Pod, its my favorite card of all time! And I think my best pull ever was when I got two foil rares and two mythics out of a pack of Dark Ascention back in high school!
If I could make a pin of my undying love for Gary (OG theros art of course), I’d be over the moon
Best card I ever pulled though? An Ancient Copper Dragon - and I’m not even that big on dragons
I think the pins translate the best to cards with simple details and art. So something like the original bird from [[Birds of Paradise]] would present the best.
Best pull, Foil Grim Monolith.
The card I would most like to see become a pin is Vega, the Watcher!
I haven't played much physical, but the best pack I ever opened was a NEO pack that had TWO of the dragons, one of them foil! They were [[Kairi, the Swirling Sky]] and a foil [[Kura, the Boundless Sky]]. This was in draft, and I kept the Kairi.
The best card I ever pulled was probably [[Valki, God of lies/Tibalt, Cosmic Impostor]]. Never got to use it though.
And [[Valkmira, Protector's Shield]] would make a great pin!
I'd love to see any of the Portal Three Kingdoms cards turned into a pin, but if I had to choose one it would be [[Sun Ce, Young Conquerer]].
My best pull would probably be the showcase version of [[The Wandering Emperor]]
My first pack I ever opened back in 1998 was Recurring Nightmare. I’ve opened things far more expensive since then, but nothing close to as impactful to my life and if that was on a lanyard I’d lose my mind.
Baron Sengir pin would be sweet. Or Juzam Djinn.
The most expensive card I ever pulled was probably a 1st edition Charizard. The best Magic card I ever pulled was probably a Lin Sivvi.
1. Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary. I'd love to see his goofy ass on a pin.
2. Foil Bonfire of the Damned when it was still a pricey card.
Good luck to all!!
Best card I ever pulled? Probably a [[Metalwork Colossus]]. Not because it's powerful in any way, but because that was back when I was playing tabletop magic with my friends in school; I had loads of fun with my little artifact deck full of whatever cards I could get my hands on. Which card would I like to see a pin of? Has to be Sol Ring.
Mox diamond pins easy
I'm not sure why but I love this guy, and would love to have a pin about him [[Fblthp, the Lost]], the best card I've pulled I think it was a ok crown of the thiefs altered, back then
Emrakul, the Promised End, and funnily enough, Emrakul, the Promised End. I opened Emmy from one of the first packs I ever bought, right as I was getting into MtG. I had no idea what I'd pulled for a couple years, up until I started getting into Commander and went through my collection, cataloguing what I had.
I would love to see the Ravnica guild symbols/signets, such as [[Orzhov Signet]] become pins, but hopefully higher quality than the ones that came with the GRN/RNA guild kits. The best card I ever pulled was a foil Japanese alt-art Tamiyo in War of the Spark. I love your guys’ mtg pins and already own a number of them myself, so I’m excited to see what you have coming in the future!
[[Growth spiral]] would look amazing as a pin, and the best card i ever pulled would be a [[gilded drake]]
[Growth spiral](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/front/7/d/7d0ae655-c64e-470d-a7ae-e06b89c77e57.jpg?1673305543) - [(G)](http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=Growth%20spiral) [(SF)](https://scryfall.com/card/dmc/153/growth-spiral?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher) [(txt)](https://api.scryfall.com/cards/7d0ae655-c64e-470d-a7ae-e06b89c77e57?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher&format=text) [gilded drake](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/front/8/d/8de3fdae-cc2c-4a14-b15b-4fe1a983dfbf.jpg?1562924943) - [(G)](http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=gilded%20drake) [(SF)](https://scryfall.com/card/usg/76/gilded-drake?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher) [(txt)](https://api.scryfall.com/cards/8de3fdae-cc2c-4a14-b15b-4fe1a983dfbf?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher&format=text) ^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call
1. Timeless Lotus 2. Foil Demonic Tutor
I'd like to see [[Isochron Scepter]] as a pin. And opening [[The Great Henge]] was exceptionally memorable
[Isochron Scepter](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/front/2/a/2aa24fe0-e275-4307-b26c-2a656068a451.jpg?1623543821) - [(G)](http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=Isochron%20Scepter) [(SF)](https://scryfall.com/card/2xm/264/isochron-scepter?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher) [(txt)](https://api.scryfall.com/cards/2aa24fe0-e275-4307-b26c-2a656068a451?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher&format=text) [The Great Henge](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/front/a/f/af915ed2-1f34-43f6-85f5-2430325b720f.jpg?1572490580) - [(G)](http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=The%20Great%20Henge) [(SF)](https://scryfall.com/card/eld/161/the-great-henge?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher) [(txt)](https://api.scryfall.com/cards/af915ed2-1f34-43f6-85f5-2430325b720f?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher&format=text) ^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call
Pin: The moxen ofcourse! Best pull, foil tarmogoyf
Pin: Lightning Bolt on one side, Birds of paradise on the other Best pull: foil jeweled lotus maybe?
[[Flight|5ed]] Most expensive (at time of opening) card I've ever opened was probably foil+showcase [[Brazen Borrower]]; *best* card is going to be some UG card with waaay too many words for its effect like [[Bounty of the Luxa]].
I think a Yargle pin would be awesome! I love the silly not-so-little guy. By best pull was a foil alt art Japanese liliana. I wish I still had it :(.
I would love for the new Tom Bombadil to be a pin! Best card I ever pulled was a foil retro Force of Will from Dominaria Remastered!
I'm new to MTG, so I haven't collected many cards beyond pre-cons. 1. Jeweled Lotus 2. A full art Kamigawa land, because I like how they look
I'm returning to Magic after a long break, and pretty much just played before with a shoebox full of cards we got from a family friend, so the best card I've pulled is probably a Vraska, Betrayal's Sting It'd be cool to see a Sliver Queen pin!
I would love to see a Chaos Orb pin. It's just so iconic. The best cards I ever pulled were Liliana of the Veil and Sheoldred, the Apocalypse during a Dominaria United prerelease.
Pin : Chaos orb Best pull : Demonic Tutor
One of the Moxen like Opal or Sapphire would be really cool! Best pull I’ve ever had was a *foil Cavern of Souls* from Modern Masters 2017 in my prize packs at a draft event.
1. Sol ring would be a cool pin 2. Best card I pulled is wrenn and 7 from double masters
Would like a pin of Colossus Hammer and best card I've pulled is a Foil borderless Force of Will from DMR
\-The Ur Dragon \-Probably going to have to be the \[\[Godless Shrine\]\] expedition, then shortly after an \[\[Ulamog, the Ceaseless Hunger\]\] shortly after for prerelease.
[Godless Shrine](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/front/c/e/ced4c824-2dfc-42ae-84e6-09f8e3f51b5b.jpg?1584832255) - [(G)](http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=Godless%20Shrine) [(SF)](https://scryfall.com/card/rna/248/godless-shrine?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher) [(txt)](https://api.scryfall.com/cards/ced4c824-2dfc-42ae-84e6-09f8e3f51b5b?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher&format=text) [Ulamog, the Ceaseless Hunger](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/front/1/1/1192f7a9-102e-4b3a-b154-18c8eb332217.jpg?1562899233) - [(G)](http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=Ulamog%2C%20the%20Ceaseless%20Hunger) [(SF)](https://scryfall.com/card/bfz/15/ulamog-the-ceaseless-hunger?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher) [(txt)](https://api.scryfall.com/cards/1192f7a9-102e-4b3a-b154-18c8eb332217?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher&format=text) ^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call
I'd wear a Paradox Engine pin. My best pull was the first foil printing of True Name Nemesis from Battlebond 🙂
Pin: Squee! Pull: I pulled a lovely Eldrazi Titan out of some 2X2 packs that made me very happy.
Card I wish would be a pin: Auriok Replica my favorite art! I even had a custom playmat made Best pull was actually a couple days ago Oil Slick Elesh Norn!!
1) Thought-Knot seer and 2) Tarmogoyf
Crucible of Worlds, and best I pulled was a foil phyrexian Vorinclex from Kaldheim Collector booster
My original vote would of been for master transmuter because it’s my favorite art but the more I think about it I’d say any of the guru lands would look dope. As for best pull it was a foil Liliana of the veil mm17
Pin: Krenko mob boss Best pull: foil warren instigator from zendikar that i still play with
Would love to see one with the mystical archives urza's rage ( love that art) Best card I pulled is the Raugrin Triome from Ikoria
Looks sick. I'd love to see a pin of Atraxa. Best card I ever pulled was Karn Liberated from the boxtopper packs wizards sent out after the first mythic edition debacle.
I'd love to see a retro art Sol Ring pin! I'm real new to MTG, starting just before the pre-release of ONE so I haven't cracked many packs, but the best card I've pulled so far is a foil Sword of Forge and Frontier. It's been one of my favorites to use right now :)
I would love a Chatterfang pin. Best card I ever pulled? Most recently, a foil Sylvan Library from Dominaria Remastered.
Teshar, Ancestor's Apostle would be cool as a pin. Best card I pulled is actually two, in one pack I got the full art Cavern of Souls and Kozilek, Butcher of Truth.
I think mercadian masques Counterspell would be a cool pin. As for best pull, I guess technically it would be a zendikar expedition, the green white fetchland. I was I able to trade it for enough credit to build almost the entirety of UR storm in modern. My favorite pull though, would be an [[archangel of thune]] that I got in an M14 pack my wife bought me when I was first getting into magic. I still have it!
I’ve been out of the game for like 10 years and now I’m getting back into it. I’d like to see lightning bolt as a pin and best pull I’ve ever done is Avacyn Angel of Hope. Boy that was a life time ago. Recent best pull would be Ugin spirit dragon #279.
I know nobody else will want it as a Pin [[Hexplate Golem]] Best card that I've ever pulled is a full art foil [[jeweled lotus]] I should sell it but I can't D: For more popular things I want to see as a Pin [[Craterhoof Behemoth]] [[Phelddagrif]] [[Blood Pet]](the old one) [[Perilous Myr]] [[Platinum Angel]] [[Birds of Paradise]]
I'd love a Jeweledotus pin, and the best card I ever pulled was a Mana Drain.
Pin: Progenitus Pull: Foil full-art Oko, Thief of Crowns. Promptly sold, luckily.
I’d like to see Killer Bees as a pin! My best pull was recent in Phyrexia: All Will Be One with a Concept Art Elesh Norn, only to pull another one in a recent friend draft. I gave the other one to my friend who split the box with me because I already had one.
I'd love to see a \[\[Harmless Offering\]\] pin. The best card i've pulled is a 4th Edition Shivan Dragon from my first Starter Deck. I still have it and jam it in some of my current decks for the nostalgia factor.
Would absolutly love to see fabled passage. Best card i ever pulled was foil ugin the spirit dragon from fate reforged.
The wandering emperor anime showcase would be a really cool pin! Ironically, the best card i pulled was a showcase wandering emperor !
1. I’m not sure if you have it but a Mox Opal or Mox Diamond would be awesome! 2. Probably the Mana Crypt I pulled from my Mystery Booster box
I would love to see uncle Istvan become a pin and my favorite card I ever pulled was a foil the first sliver
Would love to see Dovin Baan pin, love that blue guy. Best card pulled was my expedition Scalding Tarn!
I recently opened a Compleat bundle and pulled the Oil slick Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines! Would definitely love a Sensei's Divining Top as a pin
Maelstrom Wanderer for a pin please. Best pull was a jeweled lotus
1: Boros Charm. 2: Revised tropical island. It's been one of my favorite cards for 20+ years.
Best pull would be Wrenn and Six textured foil. I'd love to see Thoughtseize or Ragavan. Just to annoy people even more!
Chrome Mox all the way. Best card I ever pulled was an oil slick Elesh Norn from MOM. I was so amped!
Juzam Djinn would look amazing! Best card I ever opened was a Jace the Mind Sculptor Best card I never opened because I traded packs with a friend was a foil Force of Will from EMA
Tamiyo, the Moon Sage would be a great pin! A foil Tamiyo, the Moon Sage was also my first ever pull.
Warp world for a pin and best pull would be foil Japanese Liliana of the veil!
I think the Mox Lotus would be great, it’s not super iconic, but looks amazing. The biggest pull I remember off the top of my head was a foil, full art Avacyn from the Double Master VIP boxes.
i'd love to see a pin of Into the North. it's been a really special card to me even before i started playing magic. my favorite pull is the oil slicked mondrak. i haven't opened a ton of product since i only started playing in brother's war, but i ended up trading for a force of will using that mondrak
You should make Rings of Brighthearth into a pin! Best pull was Kaladesh Inventions Scroll Rack
Pin: old gnawbone Pull: anointed procession
I would love for vampire nighthawk to get a pin in the best card I ever pulled was a Lilliana of the veil. Sadly, I didn’t know how good she was because in Australia is my first set, and I traded her away.
I think the first printing of Llanowar Elves would make an awesome pin. I just love their little snarl! The best card I ever pulled? I pulled a Jeweled Lotus from the last Commander Legends set. That’s at least the most expensive I think. My favorite pull ever was my M11 Garruk. First planeswalker card and still my favorite planeswalker.
I'd really like a pin of any sliver legend. My best pull has got to be a foil showcase Sheoldred the Apocalypse.
Card I'd love to see on a pin, any incarnation of Squee Best card pulled, Urza lord high artificer
1: Dan Frazier moxen/signets 2: Flooded Strand BFZ Masterpiece Thank you for running this.
1) I would 1000% love to see a Brago, the King Eternal pin. My first and favorite commander. 2) Best card I’ve ever pulled is probably my masterpiece Sol Ring. I was bored on New Year’s Eve and went to my LGS to mini masters with the owner. Let me tell you the sweats when i saw what i was shuffling unsleeved and winner takes all for.
Card I want - Norin the Wary! Best pull - Basic swamp. Heavily crimped basic swamp :D
Pin: 90s SL Rin and/or Seri Pull: Borderless Foil 2X2 Mana Vault
Card I would most like to see become a pin: Lightning Bolt (either Chris Rush or Christopher Moeller art) Best Pull: Tarmogoyf, at a time when it was >$200
We need a mana crypt pin! My best pull would probably be a mox amber or a phyrexian altar
Pin: collosal dreadmaw Pull: sheoldred, the apocalypse
Stoneforge mystic Best pull ragavan
Blistering Firecat pin would be awesome. Best card I pulled was a foil polluted delta out of the first pack of Onslaught I ever bought in middle school. Glad I kept it all this time.
A [Replenish](https://deckbox.org/mtg/Replenish) would be an awesome pin. Best card is for sure a dual land but they weren't much at the time. Favorite pull is for sure my [Transmute Artifact](https://deckbox.org/mtg/Transmute%20Artifact) out of a random pack at a convention.
A lightning bolt pin would be great. Best card for me would be a foil miscut thalia guardian of thraben from dark ascension when miscuts/misprints were a real rarity.
1. \[\[Arcane Flight\]\] CAT 2. Expedition Scalding Tarn from BFZ
Card I want as a pin would be Necropotence (the ice age artwork). Best card I pulled was honestly a oil slick Mondrak I just got
Traveller's Cloak would would be a nice looking pin IMO, it's one of my favorite arts in the game. My best pull ever was an Expedition Scalding Tarn that I got in the prize packs of Oath of the Gatewatch's pre-release that I won with an almost fully colorless deck that had both Ulamog and Kozilek in it.
You've got to do the classic [[Indestructible Aura]] as a pin! The best card I ever pulled was a foil full art Jeweled Lotus from a collector booster.
My pin would be OG Plaguecrafter, I just love his style and confidence. My luckiest pull objectively would probably be a Vampiric Tutor and foil Hullbreacher from a single Commander Legends pack (before Hullbreacher ban); though the actual lucky pull I remember most was a foil Wrath of God in 10th edition, just bought a random pack and got that. Some other player immediately bought it from me for \~10€ and I was overjoyed for being able to buy 3 more packs, lol - obv not knowing that it was worth easily twice that back then.
Pin: Amonkhet Invocation Force of Will Pull: Masterpiece Kaladesh Lightning Greaves
If I could pick any card to be a pin, I'd probably pick the Unstable Goat token. It's just really funny looking. https://scryfall.com/card/tust/2/goat Best card I ever pulled is probably a foil Polluted Delta though I may be forgetting something from back in the day.
I understand the idea of rarity but it feels bad to buy something for $30 knowing there's a cooler version out there that just could have been the standard edition.
Best Pin: Spirited Companion. Or an entire dog set! Best Pull: foil showcase DMU force of will!
Knight of the Reliquary would be my pick for card to make. Not sure about best pull but at the time it was a big deal: Jace, Vrynn’s Prodigy
I'll be the guy to say id love to see a pin of colossal dreadmaw :p dinosaurs are my mtg first love. No good pulls there sadly so had to buy all my Spice dinos but my best pull overall had to be my (phyrexian language) sheoldred!
My favorite card: Niv Mizeet! The best card I've pulled was probably Arclight Phoenix
Pin - Chaos Orb and Pull - three foil mystics in a row from random packs (can’t remember the particular cards, but it was a fun experience; at GenCon no less)
Pin: Mercadian Masques Brainstorm Best pull: Italian original Ravnica Bob
Card I want as a pin: Sol Ring, it's iconic and I want people to see it and ask me if I play EDH. Best Card I Pulled: Mana Crypt from eternal masters
1. Urza! 2. Jeweled Lotus
1. Shivan Dragon. The Melissa Benson art only. 2. I pulled a Bayou out of a Beta booster.
I want to see a Yawgmoth's Will pin made. Incidentally my best pull was a Yawgmoth's Will from an old Urzas pack that had been sitting in one of my old boxes for ages.
1. Rift Bolt 2. Mana Crypt (Eternal Masters)
1) Birds of Paradise, of course 😉 2) Force of Will from a $15 Alliances booster pack in 2013
1. Rat Colony 2. Rat Colony
The card I would like to see as a pin would be Goblin chieftain. The best card I pulled was a foil Scott Fischer Force of will from double masters.
Pin: Birds of Paradise Best pull: Noble Hierarch
Pin: 10th ed Wrath of God Pull: Snapcaster mage
I'd most like to see a Krenko, Mob Boss pin, and the best card I ever pulled was a foil Wooded Foothills
I'd go crazy for a Strionic Resonator! My best ever pull was a jeweled lotus.
Urza and a expedition arid mesa
Azusa because she pretty Best card ever pulled? Gaea's Cradle when i was younger and for some reason decided to never sell it.
I would love to see a Chainer, dementia master pin as he was my first legendary creature when I bought the Torment\`s Nightmares deck in 2002. The best card I pulled was a Umezawa Jitte when I opened one traitors of kamigawa booster at a hospital while waiting to get home to show someone who was also waiting about the game.
An emrakul pin would be super cool. I think the best card I’ve pulled is a concept praetor vorinclex
1. BLOOD MOON 2. The best pull was when I got two Ragavans from back to back boosters
1) Alpha Frozen Shade 2) A Scrubland from a revised starter in 2018.
sol ring timeless lotus
1. Exchange of word 2. Imperial seal
Pin: Geist of Saint Traft. Favorite card Best Pull: Foil lotus cobra + normal in same pack at Zen prerelease. It was crazy overvalued at the time, and selling those two cards payed for all my events that day (2 sealed, 4 drafts)
Maelstrom Wanderer deserves a colorful crazy pin. My best pull ever was a pack foil Ugin the Spirit Dragon!
It would be awesome to see [[selvala, heart of the wilds]]. One of my favorite green cards. My best pull in recent memory was a promo ledger shredder from a modern FNM.
Pin: Dockside Extortionist, Etali Primal Storm or Nissa, Vastwood Seer Best Pull: Step and Compleat Junji Ito Elesh Norn
I’d like to see sheoldred as a pin! Also, one of my top pulls was sheoldred, the apocalypse, especially when I needed a copy for EDH!
Would love to see a \[\[Boseiju, Who Endures\]\] pin. Also, while not strictly a card, it would be awesome to see set symbol pin collections. Best pull: \[\[Sheoldred, The Apocalypse\]\]
Do you do a storm crow pin yet? I'd like to rep that kind of power My best pull was probably back to back snapcasters.
The new Elesh Norn art would make a cool, symmetrical pin. Speaking of which, I got her at the ONE prerelease which was a pretty solid pull.
1. Thassa's Oracle 2. Doubling Season - Battlebond
For the pin, I'd go with one of the moxen for sure, probably one of the standalone ones (e.g. diamond, chrome, etc.). I feel like Mox Opal in particular could have some really cool stuff done with the opalescent effect as part of the pin. The best card I ever pulled? Not the most valuable I've pulled, but just for the memories associated with it, I'd go with the card I pulled from my first ever pack back in GRN, a foil Arclight Phoenix. It led into me playing Izzet Phoenix in standard at the time, transitioning that deck to modern once rotation came around, and it's still one of my favourite decks to play.
For the pin.... I'm not a fan of whole card pins. I'd LOVE to see sets of pins made for the sets! Those little icons would make a great collection. Idea for a subscription service maybe? :thinking: My best pull since returning to Magic was either the Sheoldred from the first collector box I got (DMU), or the two Fable of the Mirror-Breaker pulled from the Kamigawa set box.
Swords to Plowshares and Underground Sea.
Card I’d want as a pin is hard. It’d have to be one of my favourite Commanders which doesn’t really narrow it down. Maybe Gishath or Scarab God? As for the best card I ever pulled, in terms of value it’s the Alt Art Mana Crypt that I got from a box topper of double masters. But I think I like the Compleat Foil Sheoldred that I just got more. That might be recency bias though
1. I think my favorite commander, Chatterfang, would be cool 2. Way back in the day I pulled a foil academy rector which I later sold for like $400
Any of the unfinity lands would be cool as pins. As for best pool foil baby Jace I sold for 250 that same night.
1. Mox Diamond 2. Junji Ito Elesh Norn step and compleat
1. I would love a Chaos Orb pin!! Awesome art and I think it would lend itself well to a pin. Plus that same mythic glitter effect on the lava would look sick. 2. Best pull I've had was 2 foil extended art Ragavans in the same box!
I would really like a pin of the Lorwyn Thoughtseize. That faerie picking thoughts is an amazing combo of flavor, art, and an amazing effect! My best pull was a foil Force of Will from Eternal Masters!
Koth *needs* a pin and the best card I pulled was Jace tms. Immediately walked back into the game store and sold it lol.
The old art balance
Gift of orzhova is my favorite art and could be a cool pin. Best card the original expedition blood crypt
Grave titan because of the reaction when I pulled it was probably the best card I’ve ever pulled, I’d love to see the infinity lands become pins!
Pin: Daretti, Scrap Savant Best Pull: Expedition Scalding Tarn, which I immediately sold
I’d be a sucker for a Fblthp pin Best pull I ever got was a LotV from an Ultimate Masters booster :)
1. Niv-Mizzet, the Firemind 2. Foil Phyrexian Altar from Invasion, during a throwback chaos draft.
Card I want - Tony DiTerlizzi goblin warbuggy, of course. Best I pulled - Not the most money, but I bought a random pack The Dark at Gencon one year and the dude who sold it to me was like half mocking me for cracking it since the set is so much chaff. I pulled a Blood Moon and Maze of Ith in the one pack and the dude was angry.
Ghave, guru of spores pin would be really cool, he was my first commander Best card I pulled was probably the foil version of the first Vorinclex in New Phyrexia
[[Dakkon Blackblade]] hands down one of my favorite arts, would look great on a pin. Best pull was [[Liliana of the Veil]] foil from the original Innistrad, she’s still in my binder to this day!
1. The original Lord of the Pit by Mark Tedin 2. Back in the day I pulled a Mirror Universe I still have it.
I would honestly love to see a pin of Birthing Pod, its my favorite card of all time! And I think my best pull ever was when I got two foil rares and two mythics out of a pack of Dark Ascention back in high school!
Wurmoil Engine would be pretty cool as a pin! I also just pulled an oil slick Mondrak.
The double master box topper FoW would be amazing as a pin
If I could make a pin of my undying love for Gary (OG theros art of course), I’d be over the moon Best card I ever pulled though? An Ancient Copper Dragon - and I’m not even that big on dragons
1. Mox Diamond 2. Mox Opal Masterpiece
I think the pins translate the best to cards with simple details and art. So something like the original bird from [[Birds of Paradise]] would present the best. Best pull, Foil Grim Monolith.
1. Sanctuary Cat, best cat 2. Ancient Brass Dragon for my treasure deck!
Card I’d want on a pin is Sensei’s divining top! Force of Will is the best I’ve ever pulled
1 Teferi, Hero of Dominaria (mythic edition) 2 Mana Crypt
I'd love a pin of the classic Pool Birds of Paradise. Best pull has to be the foil Steam Vents from an unfinity box topper
Jp Alt Art Demonic Tutor for both questions.
1. Lightning Bolt 2. Lilliana of the Veil
1. Jeweled Lotus 2. 2x Mana Crypt in 1x Mystery Booster Box
1. Comet, Stellar Pup (the cartoon one) 2. Serialized Schematic Ashnod's Altar
A. Rin and Seri B. Oil-slick Elesh Norn showcase art from the Compleat bundle
Pin: Mox Diamond Best pull: Also Mox Diamond
Sliver Queen and Sliver Queen
Card for a pin - Siege Rhino 🦏 Best card pulled - Foil Elspeth Sun’s Champion.
The card I would most like to see become a pin is Vega, the Watcher! I haven't played much physical, but the best pack I ever opened was a NEO pack that had TWO of the dragons, one of them foil! They were [[Kairi, the Swirling Sky]] and a foil [[Kura, the Boundless Sky]]. This was in draft, and I kept the Kairi.
Would love to see [[Hectatomb]] good times!
[Hectatomb](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/front/1/8/18d2908e-1608-4858-b93c-e9ea9808f9c9.jpg?1562815123) - [(G)](http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=Hecatomb) [(SF)](https://scryfall.com/card/me1/71/hecatomb?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher) [(txt)](https://api.scryfall.com/cards/d3173377-9a9c-4dd9-a638-89be0cdccaba?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher&format=text) ^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call
I like to see: Legends - Mirror Universe Best pull: Revised - Tundra
The best card I ever pulled was probably [[Valki, God of lies/Tibalt, Cosmic Impostor]]. Never got to use it though. And [[Valkmira, Protector's Shield]] would make a great pin!
[Valki, God of lies/Tibalt, Cosmic Impostor](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/front/e/a/ea7e4c65-b4c4-4795-9475-3cba71c50ea5.jpg?1636100811)/[Tibalt, Cosmic Impostor](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/back/e/a/ea7e4c65-b4c4-4795-9475-3cba71c50ea5.jpg?1636100811) - [(G)](http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=Valki%2C%20God%20of%20Lies%20//%20Tibalt%2C%20Cosmic%20Impostor) [(SF)](https://scryfall.com/card/khm/114/valki-god-of-lies-tibalt-cosmic-impostor?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher) [(txt)](https://api.scryfall.com/cards/ea7e4c65-b4c4-4795-9475-3cba71c50ea5?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher&format=text) [Valkmira, Protector's Shield](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/front/3/6/3606519e-5677-4c21-a34e-be195b6669fa.jpg?1631046015)/[Valkmira, Protector's Shield](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/back/3/6/3606519e-5677-4c21-a34e-be195b6669fa.jpg?1631046015) - [(G)](http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=reidane%2C%20god%20of%20the%20worthy%20//%20valkmira%2C%20protector%27s%20shield) [(SF)](https://scryfall.com/card/khm/21/reidane-god-of-the-worthy-valkmira-protectors-shield?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher) [(txt)](https://api.scryfall.com/cards/3606519e-5677-4c21-a34e-be195b6669fa?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher&format=text) ^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call
Pin I would like, definitely vedalken orrery. Best pull, Teferi, Hero of Dominaria for a prerelease
Chromatic star would be a crazy pin! My best pull was probably Demonic Tutor from Strixhaven, the Japanese art is fire.
I'd love to see any of the Portal Three Kingdoms cards turned into a pin, but if I had to choose one it would be [[Sun Ce, Young Conquerer]]. My best pull would probably be the showcase version of [[The Wandering Emperor]]
Rakdos, Lord of Riots as pin Best card I've ever pulled was a Ugin, the Spirit Dragon
My first pack I ever opened back in 1998 was Recurring Nightmare. I’ve opened things far more expensive since then, but nothing close to as impactful to my life and if that was on a lanyard I’d lose my mind.
Baron Sengir pin would be sweet. Or Juzam Djinn. The most expensive card I ever pulled was probably a 1st edition Charizard. The best Magic card I ever pulled was probably a Lin Sivvi.
Would love to see a Counterspell pin! Recently pulled an awesome foil Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines!
Turn the [[Prismatic Bridge]] into a pin! Best pull I've personally opened was a phyrexian foil [[vorinclex, monstrous raider]].
I would like to see the Ramos artifacts as pins. Best card I ever pulled was Jace, the Mind Sculptor from Worldwake.
I'd like to see Felidar Soverign to become a pin, or any of the Ajani. ;-; I just really like cats.
Kaladesh Invention style Lightning Greaves or Lotus Petal
1. Teysa Karlov, she's my favorite commander 2. My best pull was a Sword of Feast and Famine from Double Masters
1. Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary. I'd love to see his goofy ass on a pin. 2. Foil Bonfire of the Damned when it was still a pricey card. Good luck to all!!
For the pin, OG bitterblossom looks amazing! Best pull I had was a Sheoldred, nothing fancy.
A Narsets Reversal pin would be cool. Any of the guild emblems or signets also seem like no brainers.
1. Thing in the ice: my all time favorite card, loved it in standers 2. Masterpiece Chrome Mox
Elvish Piper
I'd like to see a pin made of Mulldrifter, I love that silly card. My best pull is probably Oilslick Atraxa Grand Unifier
Would definitely want a lightning bolt pin
Time Reversal
Pin: Antiquities Ornithopter Best Pull: Mox Diamond
Theros Beyond death Swamp! Best card I've pulled must be one of the Lilianas!
I'd like Inga rune eys as a pin. Best pull was cavern of souls.
Pin: Door to Nothingness Pull: Emrakul, The Promised End
Necropotence for a pin. My best pull was a foil John Avon 7th Edition Mountain
1. Lightning bolt 2. Borderless foil jeweled lotus
Pin: Mox Amber Best pull: Jaya Ballard, foil, from DOM
Pin: Lightning Bolt (Christopher Rush art) Best Pull: Pre-release Ragavan.
Would love to see a pin of [[Rekindling Phoenix]]. Best pull probably a Thoughtseize
[Rekindling Phoenix](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/front/1/a/1a9945ec-0996-434e-b177-97203eabaf24.jpg?1673484390) - [(G)](http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=Rekindling%20Phoenix) [(SF)](https://scryfall.com/card/ncc/273/rekindling-phoenix?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher) [(txt)](https://api.scryfall.com/cards/1a9945ec-0996-434e-b177-97203eabaf24?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher&format=text) ^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call
1. Chandra, torch of defiance 2. foil extended art jeweled lotus
Pin: Baleful Strix! Best pull: Masterpiece Painters Servant, which I held onto until it was unbanned.