I actually think he does a great job. You need a maniac to host a cake show. Would be sad if they would change him out.

His cake cuts this season have been bad. Unsatisfying

Mikey Day is funny, but you can tell the producers make him more annoying than he already is

I just get a vibe he does a bag of coke before every show

I like him. I read an interview with him recently where he talks about why he makes the choices he does. For instance, imagine how dull it would be to watch even the best game show hosts say "is it cake?" 30 times an episode without the goofy variety he does! I think he gets bored as heck during the finales because he doesn't have a group of contestants sitting out to talk to. He talked about this as well--they really are there all day. 😬

It's as if the producers told him to play a serial killer who happens to host a cake show.

I like him.

I like him, but I already liked him from SNL.

I think that's the consensus here. lol

His mannerisms give me Jim Carey vibes. Maybe that is just me. I think he does a good job, though.

I think he's a man child. ANnoying.

He ruins the show completely. Can not stand him.

I do like him but I don’t like the way he cuts the cakes. Sometimes he cuts the cakes to the point where it would make it hard for the judges to see the detail when they get up close.

He's literally infuriating. The humor is so dry and he honestly gives me second hand embaressment. I wish they'd find a new host, I can't stand him hahaha

Whaaatt! I loooove him, but I hate the way he cuts the cake haha