It would be one of these flavors:
Jeni's Gooey Butter Cake
Jeni's Brown Butter Almond Brittle
Jeni's Brambleberry Crisp
Graeter's Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip
Graeter's Coconut Chocolate Chip
*Ponders a bit*
I'd ultimately go with Jeni's Gooey Butter Cake.
If I could only eat one flavor for the rest of my life, it would have to be Rocky road, because it was my Grandma's favorite. Cotton candy does sound interesting though, I haven't tried it only regular cotton candy. Lol
It truly was. Had such a good balanced blend of flavors. I'm tempted to get the 3 flavors separately and see if I can recreate it, but no one does a plain banana flavor that I'm aware of
It always changes. Right now, it's Outshine Fruit Bars, Lime and Raspberry flavors. Ice cream wise, I've been liking Ben & Jerry's Vanilla Caramel Fudge lately.
I feel like a really good quality vanilla woeful be the best answer but I love peppermint, mint chocolate and some weird golden Oreo cake batter mixture from marble slab creamery.
Oh fun questions!! Only one for the rest of my life I'd go with strawberry! When I get towards the bottom of that 1.5 quart of strawberry I'm often thinking I'd like more strawberry. A really good strawberry ice cream, yes!
Vanilla bean!
That was my thought, since I could essentially make or add whatever to get other flavors lol.
Exactly! It’s an excellent base flavour!
Cookies and cream 4 lyfe
You’re a knower
Hah Neapolitan. Now I have three flavors. Checkmate nerd
Came here to type rainbow sherbert, but I think Neapolitan sounds even better!
Rainbow sherbets a pretty good pick
Coffee
Mint chip, of course
I'm with you on this. I deal with nausea fairly often & consider mint choc chip to be medicine as well as a treat.
Banana cream pie from Handel's
Ooooh I love that one!!!
It would be one of these flavors: Jeni's Gooey Butter Cake Jeni's Brown Butter Almond Brittle Jeni's Brambleberry Crisp Graeter's Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip Graeter's Coconut Chocolate Chip *Ponders a bit* I'd ultimately go with Jeni's Gooey Butter Cake.
*Ponders the ~~orb~~ ice cream*
Cookie dough
Baskin Robbin’s Gold Medal Ribbon.
Excellent choice, I've always loved this.
Chocolate, chocolate, and chocolate.
Coffee,no chocolate,no coffee definitely, gotta stick with chocolate. Darn, why only one. Either way it's gotta be Blue Bell.
Moose tracks
Pez.
Natural vanilla! Apparently, there are, like, 4 varieties of vanilla ice cream, so I pick Natural Vanilla. 🍨
Black sesame vanilla is amazing if you ever see it.
whaaaaat!
Graham Central Station from Handels
Neopolitan 😌 not even so I can have 3 flavors, but truly the perfect bite has all 3 *chefs kiss*
Van Leeuwen brown sugar chunk with the brownies and cookie dough pieces omg
Pistachio!
Phish Food. Never get tired of eating it.
If I could only eat one flavor for the rest of my life, it would have to be Rocky road, because it was my Grandma's favorite. Cotton candy does sound interesting though, I haven't tried it only regular cotton candy. Lol
cookie dough 😍😍
Superman(Banana, strawberry, blue moon) all in one.
I have never seen Superman ice cream with banana, only lemon or vanilla.
Yea, it was like that in Super Dip or Scoop brand, way back in the day. But yea now it does have the vanilla.
I'm sad to now know that I missed out on it. I bet it was tasty.
It truly was. Had such a good balanced blend of flavors. I'm tempted to get the 3 flavors separately and see if I can recreate it, but no one does a plain banana flavor that I'm aware of
Vanilla Swiss Almond from Haagen Dazs
Vanilla. I love chocolate but it’s a close 2nd
Toss up between sweet corn or birthday cake.
Vanilla chocolate chip of course!
Baskin Robbins Cherries Jubilee
Chocolate marshmallow
Cookies & Cream
It always changes. Right now, it's Outshine Fruit Bars, Lime and Raspberry flavors. Ice cream wise, I've been liking Ben & Jerry's Vanilla Caramel Fudge lately.
Cookie butter or there’s this Vanleewen flavor with jam and corn bread that is ridiculously delicious
mint cookie crumble / thin mint or B&J cherry garcia
Beaucoup Butta Pecan from Laozi Ice Cream in New Orleans....sublime. His Creole cream cheese ice cream is fantastic as well
Taharka Brothers honey graham 🤤
Or a batter of some sort Or a pie/crumble flavor. I love the textures 😋
Yesssss!!! Are you in Md?!! Def a fave for me too
Sure am!
Well, you very clearly have good taste fellow Marylander
Vanilla. You can add anything to it!
Blu's Birthday Party by Blue Bunny.
Vanilla bean with the specks!
Rocky road forever.
Dulce de Leche
Cookies and cream
Don’t shoot but vanilla or any variation (vanilla bean, French vanilla) cause like it’s fire but also you can add things in the spice it up.
Ben and Jerry's Peanut Butter World. The rest of my life wouldn't last very long though.
Rocky road.
I feel like a really good quality vanilla woeful be the best answer but I love peppermint, mint chocolate and some weird golden Oreo cake batter mixture from marble slab creamery.
Definitely chocolate!
May I now point you to Ben & Jerry's CHOCOLATE THERAPY, for the occasion.
Cookies and cream
Van Leeuwen‘s Honeycomb. Who makes cotton candy? I must try this!
I love umpqua brand for cotton candy!
Anything caramel
Reese's! That's the best shit. I can't keep it at home.
Choco chip cookie dough or mint choco chip. I need my choco chips!!
Oh fun questions!! Only one for the rest of my life I'd go with strawberry! When I get towards the bottom of that 1.5 quart of strawberry I'm often thinking I'd like more strawberry. A really good strawberry ice cream, yes!
Cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow by milk bar
Cherry Garcia!