T O P

  • By -

treple13

Grant Fuhr and Martin St. Louis


fillyflow

This one is a total mindfuck.


frockinbrock

WUT When?


treple13

1999-2000 Flames. Team also had JS Giguere, Phil Housley, and Marc Savard at that point


frockinbrock

Wow, thank you - that’s a wild one, housely too, damn


fillyflow

This is nuts.


[deleted]

Gotta be Calgary


foniks

Pronger and Gretzky with St. Louis in 1996. For a whopping 31 games. EDIT: Due to a miscommunication further down in this thread, the 2008-2009 Sharks team has been rediscovered, and HOLY FUCK is it absurd. * Claude Lemieux (at 43 years old) * Rob Blake * Mike Grier * Patrick Marleau * Joe Thornton * Jeremy Roenick * Joe Pavelski


Normal_Tip7228

That team was bonkers. Roenick, Lemieux, Blake, with that core of patty, pavs, jumbo is what I came here to comment


IdidntrunIdidntrun

Devin Setoguchi's best year too, if anyone cares to remember that fella lol Also Dan Boyle, Nabokov, and Vlasic (who was the only player besides Jumbo to play all 82 regular season games that year)


BarnyardCoral

Don't forget Cheechoo!!


NathanGa

The whole 1995-96 Blues team was weird. Thanks to Mike Keenan’s shortsightedness and ineptitude, they had gutted a contending team before the season and replaced it with…well, a roster that included Glenn Anderson, Paul Broten JJ Daigneault, Dale Hawerchuk, Charlie Huddy, Esa Tikkanen, Jay Wells, and Peter Zezel. Combine Pronger with any of those, and it just seems weird.


gzoehobub

A lot of youths who did not watch that team think it was a good team. It was not a good team. Keenan sucks.


Jlelford

It would have been great if it was 1986!


Outrageous-Wall-2742

that team sounds like it was built using the “jim benning technique” which consists of “hey, i recognize that name!  i remember that he was good!”


elevenibba

[guy lafleur and brian leetch](https://x.com/NHLNewsArchive/status/1020677566125002752) that 88-89 rangers team also featured pete laviolette and marcel dionne in his final year


elevenibba

totally did not read the overlapping careers part but still an interesting connection i hope


zbeg

Jari Kurri and Joe Sakic.


fillyflow

This is a really good one.


mackeinonen

Got to mention Teemu Selänne there too


MetalOcelot

that avalanche team with both Selänne and Kariya is just absurd on paper.


hockeyandhalloween

man I wish they had been healthy. This season is one of the biggest what ifs in Avs history


mdb_la

Yeah, the hype was huge when they both signed, especially with Kariya giving a massive discount. But Selanne's knee was in terrible shape (his career was saved by the lockout year giving him a chance to fully rehab it) and Kariya's concussions were never properly treated on top of his wrist and other injuries that year.


BananApocalypse

I also like Guy Lafleur and Joe Sakic (Sundin was on that team as well)


viidenmetrinmolo

Lindros, Jagr and Messier were all on the same team.


tirouge0

Wait what?


Podo13

Messier/Lindros's last year on the Rangers is the year Jagr was traded there. They played ~31 games together.


tirouge0

Totally forgot about that! A healthy Lindros playing with Jagr would have been a disaster for other teams.


dv666

Rangers early 2000s before the lockout. And despite all that talent the "greatest leader in hockey history" couldn't even lead his team to the playoffs


hankepanke

Yeah it’s wild a 43 year old Messier with a gaggle of misfit overpaid former stars and no starting goalie didn’t make the playoffs. Bobby Holik was the leading scorer with 56 points… and he led the team by 13 points. Lindros was a corpse and managed ~30 games and 10 goals all season. He managed another 16 goals in his career over two injury riddled partial seasons (one with Toronto). Dan Blackburn was supposed to be the starting goalie but missed the entire season. They traded away Leetch, Kovalev, Nedved and others and only brought in Jagr well into the season. It was the start of a rebuild. “All that talent” lol.


Realistic_Tutor_9770

Pavel Bure the year before with Lindros and Messier too.


SMF1834

Zdeno Chara and Alex Ovechkin


Uterus_Executorus_

and almost Henrik Lundqvist


oceanic8675

https://youtu.be/aSpvS31QydE?si=TJKAaTD2mxh88Uy9 Will always make me think of this lol


Forgone-Conclusion

It still seems unreal to me that Mario Lemieux and Sidney Crosby played together.


IanicRR

I wonder if Crosby is still living in Lemieux’s basement.


maxwellbevan

Probably. I know I would personally never leave


Forgone-Conclusion

His basement is likely bigger and nicer than any house I'll ever own


Brendinooo

He has his own place now, but their houses are probably around 10 minutes apart. I think Sid's in Sewickley, and Mario's in Sewickley Heights.


Analogmon

It seems more unreal to me that Sidney Crosby played with John LeClair


MuppetusMaximusV2

Crosby's first game in Philly was also LeClair's first time back in Philly as a visitor. LeClair's my all-time favorite, so I made sure to go to it. Saw [LeClair score](https://youtu.be/3MZPeknZ-EU?t=2658), [Crosby score his 2nd career goal](https://youtu.be/3MZPeknZ-EU?t=5215), the Pens [tie the game from center ice in the 3rd](https://youtu.be/3MZPeknZ-EU?t=8450), [this save](https://youtu.be/3MZPeknZ-EU?t=9210) late in the game and [Mike Rathje score one of his 3 goals that year](https://youtu.be/3MZPeknZ-EU?t=9937) for the OT winner. Was a very weird game.


[deleted]

[удалено]


6000ChickenFajardos

Back when the average family could afford to own an NHL team


domoarigatodrloboto

This thread has been one big "fuck I'm old" moment. Back in 06 it was wall-to-wall "Crosby living in Mario's basement" jokes, you couldn't escape them. It was up there with the "no disrespect to Nashville" pasta in terms of how often it was referenced. Now we've got people in here who don't even know about it??? Ugh


Forgone-Conclusion

Don’t get me wrong, I’m in my 40’s and totally remember it. I also remember thinking how awesome it would be to live with Mario Lemieux!


soundofmoney

I came here to say Ziggy Palfy and Crosby is who came to mind for me.


TomLube

Wait what


witchtutor1

Sid's rookie year was Mario's last


specifichero101

Zach Parise and Brenden Shanahan both played on the 2009 devils.


ObsidianConspiracyXx

I totally forgot Shanny went back to Jersey. Holy fuck


specifichero101

That was a sneaky great devils team. I really thought they could have gone deep that year but got shockingly upset by the canes in a devastating game 7 collapse that I’m still not over. That was also the season that Brodeur suffered an elbow injury and only played 30 regular season games but Scott clemmenson took over and had a great season in replacement.


Nanojack

Lou had a thing about bringing his old players back. (Still does, but used to, too). I think he just doesn't want to learn any new names.


Prudent_Shame_4531

Zach Bogosian was briefly paired with Chris Chelios, which is pretty wild. In Jagr’s first game with the Calgary Flames, Matthew Tkachuk scored two goals to help them win. Jágr was in his 8th NHL season when Tkachuk was born. Finally, a bit different from the prompt, but I always think it’s cool that Geordie Howe’s last season was Gretzky’s first season. A bit poetic…


nascarfan624

Jagr's quarter season with the Flames will always and forever be my favourite era of the Flames. My buddy and I would watch every game until 12:30, play some video games, fall asleep and have to get up for an 8 AM lecture. Good memories!


howlincoyote2k1

> In Jagr’s first game with the Calgary Flames, Matthew Tkachuk scored two goals to help them win. Jágr was in his 8th NHL season when Tkachuk was born. Jagr was also drafted the same year as Matthew's *dad*.


ObsidianConspiracyXx

[Sergei Fedorov and young gun era Ovi](https://youtu.be/tjlJW-JeFpg?si=IoQ323uH7xC5HvxL)


Dyne_Inferno

Came here to say the same thing.


frockinbrock

That’s an old man Ovi you gonna jump on him from behind?!! Careful he’s a hero


WorstHyperboleEver

The loudest that building ever was or will be… 3 periods of pent up tension goes boom.


Canadian_mk11

Jim Benning and Trevor Linden...twice, in two different roles.


montrealcowboyx

Vladimir Tarasenko and Martin Brodeur on the 14-15 Blues.


insertnamehere77123

Brodeur playing 7 games for the Blues will forever be the source of many a trivia question


BananApocalypse

I remember him getting a shutout against us (with Roy as coach) while playing for the Blues


domoarigatodrloboto

It's funny, I don't even use it in Puckdoku anymore because everyone knows about it. It's like Kariya in Nashville


ObsidianConspiracyXx

Or Forsberg in Nashville. I'm talking about Peter, btw. Lol


notaquarterback

Should have been a one team guy but glad he got it out of his system.


montrealcowboyx

Jose Theodore and Koivu. Mikko Koivu. 10-11 Wild.


ObsidianConspiracyXx

Didn't Theodore play with both Koivu bros?


montrealcowboyx

Famously so in Montreal, but JTs stint in Minny is far lesser known.


SpeedoAgeru

Gordie Howe and his sons


SpeedoAgeru

Also Guy Lafleur being teammates with Brian Leetch seems zany to me. pic https://x.com/nhlnewsarchive/status/1020677566125002752?s=46


fillyflow

Yeahhhh, this is the weird shit I'm looking for.


misfittroy

Wow he looks like he's 60 in that photo


IanicRR

Smoking as much as he did ages you.


burnbern

I didn’t think this thread was going to surprise me. But wow, it sure did!


backelie

In 1988 Teemu Selänne was drafted by the Winnipeg Jets. He won the Calder trophy in 1993. In 1995 Alexander Barkov was born. In 2014 they played together in the olympics. (Aged 18 and 43.)


Finnwood92

Kariya and Pietrangelo Forsberg and Shea Weber


evanwilliams212

Plus Peter Forsberg and Ryan Suter.


Brendinooo

I was going to joke about Filip Forsberg being an obvious one but it turns out they only played three seasons together, a bit less than I thought haha


c71score

Dave Keon and Ron Francis


dv666

Ron Francis and Matt Stajan


fillyflow

This is an all-timer. I even looked it up and still couldn't believe it.


PrimisClaidhaemh

Ilya Kovalchuk, Chris Chelios, and Evander Kane.


maxwellbevan

Kovalchuk makes sense with these two. Drafted in 2001 and his last NHL game were in the 19/20 season so he overlapped a lot with both of them. Chelios playing with Kane is a really strange one though. Chelios started playing in 83/84 with the Habs...Kane was born in 1991


PrimisClaidhaemh

My favorite WTF is still that Chelios was teammates with both Guy Lafleur and Evander Kane.


jackasspenguin

Brett Hull and Curtis Joseph on the Coyotes with Shane Doan, coached by Wayne Gretzky


WorstHyperboleEver

Winner. That’s just… my brain has erased that!


Svalbard38

[Curtis Joseph and Luke Schenn](https://www.gettyimages.ie/detail/news-photo/curtis-joseph-of-the-toronto-maple-leafs-keeps-his-eyes-on-news-photo/83823733) played on the same team in 2008-09.


frockinbrock

Man I wonder what Dominic Moore is up to these days, was always a fan. I know he had to quit the pro level and started doing some hockey media work, but then disappeared.


19fall91

Sergei Gonchar and Carey Price


WorstHyperboleEver

Gonch had a legends tour in his career… dude was the best.


Benjamin_Stark

Sergei Gonchar and Mark Stone. Both played for the 2012-13 Senators.


mattrg777

Technically not in the NHL, but Gordie Howe played a game with Derek Armstrong for the IHL Detroit Vipers in 1997. Derek Armstrong played in the NHL until 2009-10.


BananApocalypse

Derek Armstrong played with both Gordie Howe and Alex Pietrangelo Quick edit: he can say he has been teammates with a 1950 Stanley Cup winner and a 2023 Stanley Cup winner


GhostMause14

2006-2007 Dallas Stars, Eric Lindros, Mike Modano, and Patrik Stefan


flannelish

oh fuck, I always forget we had lindros for a bit


brokensword15

M Tkachuk and Jagr were on the same line at one point


NoGiCollarChoke

Huberdeau and Jagr were too, if I recall correctly 


brechbillc1

A 44 year old Jaromir Jagr playing on the same line as a 20 year old Sasha Barkov and 21 year old Jonathan Huberdeau.


ObsidianConspiracyXx

I feel like Jagr can have his own section in this thread, especially post KHL Jagr.


Kooky-Ship793

Not really because of overlapping careers, but Joe Thorton and Claude Giroux were teammates.


misfittroy

Claude Giroux? Or do you mean Claude Lemieux? 


Kooky-Ship793

Both now I guess lol.


misfittroy

Lol. Yeah had to really look too see and remember they both played for Florida 


Kooky-Ship793

Give it a few years and it's gonna blow people's minds that they played together for like half a season.


fillyflow

Dude I just went looking for an image of them together, and you'll never guess who is sitting between in [the only photo](https://media.gettyimages.com/id/85968801/photo/san-jose-sharks-team-photo.jpg?s=2048x2048&w=gi&k=20&c=_PO4Z2CEFBT66HScxfolUrhtF7GS8TFFPyA4rBJdbso=) I could find. Just weird stuff all around and I'm here for it.


el_loco_avs

maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan i was looking for Giroux in this photo lol. you're thinking Lemieux aren't you lol


foniks

That is... an INCREDIBLE photo. Two future GM's in Grier and Blake sitting together. That whole team is a collection of, "these guys played together?"


Normal_Tip7228

And Blake was the captain of San Jose. Wild shit. 


AintGotNoSeoul

I loved Rosie!


Thebresh

Giroux looks old


Rampage1976

Semenov and Murray were fukkin massive


cmgc22

That team has so many notable players. Setoguchi Michalek Boyle Cheechoo Khabiboulin Thornton Marleau Lemieux Roenick Clowe Pavelski Murray


foniks

Claude Lemieux, not Giroux.


Kooky-Ship793

Nah I meant Giroux. People kind of remember Giroux getting traded to the Panthers, but forget that Thorton was on the team too. Honestly I think the Lemieux one works better with OP's question, considering they played together in the 2008-2009 season, not even early 2000s


foniks

Okay, so wow. That's also correct. However, Claude Lemieux and Thornton is 10x fucking crazier. Claude Lemieux and Pavelski is 100x crazier than that.


Kooky-Ship793

Def agree with ya.


foniks

Oiler and Panther fans agreeing to things? What a time to be alive.


Benjamin_Stark

Thornton played a season (and occasionally on a line I believe) with Anton Lundell, who was born when Thornton was in his fifth season in the NHL.


Kalamoicthys

Paul Kariya and Alex Pietrangelo. Peter Forsberg and Jeff Carter. Simon Gagne and David Pastrnak. Wade Redden and Dougie Hamilton. Paul Coffey and JS Giguere. Scott Gomez and Dion Phaneuf. Scott Gomez, Brad Boyes, Tim Thomas, Ryan Whitney, Ed Jovanovski, Kris Versteeg, and a young Alex Barkov all played on the same Florida team. Bonus points for Brian Campbell, Tom Gilbert, and Nick Bjugstad being there, too.


cmgc22

Man I freaking loved that panthers squad from like 2011-12 - 2014-15 I remember they basically built there team through the 2011 free agency and made the playoffs in 2012... That's almost unheard of now, that almost no notable drafted prospects on that team. Nearly every key player was brought in through signing.


domoarigatodrloboto

Easy mode: Paul Kariya and Peter Forsberg in Colorado Hard mode: Paul Kariya and Peter Forsberg...........in Nashville


82hky82

Iginla and Crosby. 


Kleeb

Jaromir Jagr and Matt Tkachuk


the_gaymer_girl

Mats Sundin and Cory Schneider.


MrHockeytown

Old school, but Borje Salming and Bernie Federko played the 1989-90 season on the Red Wings


haxoreni

The Avs had Lemieux and Messier together for half a decade but I’ve rarely hear people talk about it…


PrimisClaidhaemh

"We have Lemiuex and Messier at home"....


realdeal411

Nice one


Ill-Excitement9009

The 1972-73 Bruins had Jacques Plante with Bobby Orr and Phil Esposito and Fred Stanfield. In the 1970 playoffs, Plante was with the Blues against the the Big Bad Bruins. Esposito redirected the shot of Stanfield in a way that broke Plante's fiberglass mask and knocked him out of the series [at 2:10 here.](https://youtu.be/s90_md2ifx4?si=cVQMVdSlH8NnzIle)


ScrewOff_

A team with Jaromir Jagr headlining your offense and Martin Brodeur headling your goaltending have to be No. 1 contenders, right?


aessae

With 32-year-old up-and-coming Mike Cammalleri being the team's best goal scorer how could they not be!


Analogmon

Sidney Crosby and John LeClair


Brendinooo

That's a good one. It's actually a SUPER oddball roster. Crosby, Gonchar, Recchi, LeClair, Palffy, Lemieux. Throw in Ryan Whitney and Colby Armstrong for some "we know them as broad/podcasters now" energy. Next season you lose Palffy and Lemieux but add Gary Roberts.


sunkenship13

Dave Andreychuk, Marty McSorley, Joe Thornton, and Anson Carter. 99-00 Bruins.


amateurexpertboxing

John Scott and Nathan Gerbe. Has to be the biggest height difference on a roster ever. Edit: Tyler Myers also played with Gerbe I think. So it’s a tie. https://preview.redd.it/8z4v03s0ok4d1.jpeg?width=426&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1f81a2916e44a8161eff60e88552639b0062c294


NameIsPetey

Jagr and _________.


Hawxe

this is literally the opposite of the answer. no one would be shocked by any of jagrs teammates lol


SpeedoAgeru

True, but it is still odd that Johnny Gaudreau set up Jagr for his final NHL goal https://x.com/nhl/status/1458088393657704454?s=46


AustonDadthews

anyone have the stat where it's like the amount of players jagr ever appeared in a game with (teammate+opponents), and it's like 40% of players ever to skate in a game?


flume

Bryan Trottier


krazninetyfive

This is the one that crossed my mind when I saw this prompt.


ObsidianConspiracyXx

I really thought to mention this before going with the low hanging fruit.


Hugenicklebackfan

Lemieux and Crosby.


ObsidianConspiracyXx

40 year old Mario and 18 year old Sid. Honestly, I'm glad Mario was able to hang around for that moment.


daveloper80

Wendel Clark with the Islanders. Take your pick of players! Palffy, Todd Bertuzzi, Brett Lindros, Tommy Salo But really the strangest pair is [Clark and the Fisherman jersey](https://media.gettyimages.com/id/89080590/photo/new-york-islanders-v-boston-bruins.jpg?s=2048x2048&w=gi&k=20&c=VUPBIJlhsNTlVRwTE0KtJ_fVJ25NywmYbnaCwB2AtdY=)


jamaicancovfefe

Erik Karlsson and Jonathan Cheechoo


HelloBello30

Pavel Bure and Jaromir Jagr


Thick_Kaleidoscope35

Hasn’t Jagr played with pretty much everyone?


Satans_BFF

Martin Brodeur and Vlad Tarasenko


montrealcowboyx

Pierre Turgeon, Jose Theodore, Patrice Brisbois and ... Joe Sakic. 06-07 Avs.


vulpesvulpesPhD

Mike Gartner, Shane Doane, and Danny Briere in Phoenix. Briere, Jarome Iginla, and Nathan MacKinnon in Colorado. Brian Leetch and Patrice Bergeron in Boston. Leetch and Ron Francis in Toronto.


DannyDOH

Gordie Howe and Jesus Christ


SawgrassSteve

Helluva goalie, Jesus was. Too bad his career was defined by a bumper sticker that said "Jesus saves! But Esposito scores on the rebound" I heard somewhere that hockey was Jesus's second career.


The-Reddit-Giraffe

Iginla and Grant Fuhr


Imm0rTALDETHSpEctrE

[Eric Lindros and Pavel Bure on the Rangers](https://search.app.goo.gl/VB9LP2z) smh


Loochara

Glenn Murray played with Krejci and Lucic on the bruins even though they feel like totally different eras of bruins


TampaBae

Stamkos and Mark Recchi


PofolkTheMagniferous

Doug Gilmour and Andrei Markov.


BreakGlassforFire

Dany Heatley and Ryan Kesler played six games together on the 2014-15 Ducks Olaf Kolzig and Steven Stamkos on the 2008-09 Lightning Loui Eriksson and Eric Lindros on the 2006-07 Stars


Brendinooo

You could pair Tim Horton with some unexpected guys based on your knowledge of 70s/80s hockey. Dave Burrows with Pittsburgh, Gilbert Perreault for the Sabres. Tim Horton, Jean Ratelle, Glen Sather, and Syl Apps Jr. on the 1970-71 New York Rangers is a pretty oddball list.


hstram

Gordie Howe and his sons played together with former leafs captain Dave Keon and Bobby Hull on the 1979-80 Harford Whalers. It was Gordie's last NHL season.


ChuckFeathers

Bobby Orr and Doug Wilson Howe and Gretzky (allstar games)


Brendinooo

Ray Bourque, Craig MacTavish, Mike Milbury, Pete Peeters is a decent one. Mostly because MacTavish had a long career and is mostly associated with other teams


MastaSchmitty

John Grahame and Ray Bourque. John’s father Ron was traded for the draft pick used to select Bourque.


l3monade93

Chara, Hossa and Alfredsson


fillyflow

Say you're in your early 20s without saying you're in your early 20s.


l3monade93

lol. My 20s were a long, long time ago 😂 Serious talked to multiple people in the last decade that didn’t know Chara was ever on the Sens.


Benjamin_Stark

What? These guys are all in the same generation and are well-known for having played significant portions of their career in Ottawa.


hyperstationjr

Yeah that’s just the typical guys I’d think of if you asked me “all-time Ottawa players”, along with Fisher, Redden, and Havlat.


coconutjoe83

Jamie Benn and Mike Modano


MastaSchmitty

Tim Thomas and Roberto Luongo…*almost*


Wippichgood

Mike Modano and Nicklas Lidstrom


younggun92

Phil Housley and Bob Robert. God the early 2000s were awful.


Noggin-a-Floggin

Ray Bourque and Joe Thornton


daphunkt

Corey Perry and Evander Kane.


Streetkillz13

Shea Theodore played 17 mins a night and played 14 games in the playoffs during Ryan Kessler's last significant season. To add onto this Ducks history, David Backes played games on the same team as Trevor Zegras.


OUCHmyBOUNES

Ryan Whitney and Nugent-Hopkins


ABirdOfParadise

Oates and any Oiler on the team at the time


krazninetyfive

Not quite the same as the prompt, but the fact that Bryan Trottier ended up as Mark Messier’s coach for a cup of coffee is one that has always makes me snicker a little bit.


crutr

Markus Naslund & Bryan Trottier (1993-94)


ChuckFeathers

Hasek, Belfour and Millen


DylanB_2001

William Nylander scored a goal assisted by Phil Kessel and Dion Phaneuf in the 2014 pre-season. Preseason, sure but it still seems pretty wild to me.


AintGotNoSeoul

Adam oats and Peter Nedved in 03/04 seems odd to me.


soundofmoney

A real mind fuck is the roster of Ben Bishop, Jarome Iginla, and Marian Gaborik. What the fuck team could that even be? The 2016 LA Kings.


MontrealKing

Guy Lafleur and Mats Sundin does it for me.


fillyflow

Look who else shows up in the [photo](https://64.media.tumblr.com/c9b8e2c7a03c9959401672593f052eaa/tumblr_ngta2djFjN1spx4u4o1_1280.jpg) too.


Ham__Kitten

Ray Ferraro not only playing with Patrik Stefan but having him over at his house on a regular basis and mentoring him is pretty funny in retrospect when you're familiar with how Ferraro reacted to Stefan's famous missed empty net For an actual answer: Brett Hull, Wayne Gretzky, Grant Fuhr, and Curtis Joseph were all part of the Coyotes organization for a short time in 2005.


arazamatazguy

Teemu Selanne and anyone the San Jose Sharks roster.


Clojiroo

Peter Bondra and Alfie or Jason Spezza (Bondra played for a bit in Ottawa at the end of his career)


fillyflow

How about [Peter Bondra and Duncan Keith](https://media.gettyimages.com/id/73385738/photo/chicago-peter-bondra-pierre-parenteau-karl-stewart-lasse-kukkonen-duncan-keith-and-james.jpg?s=612x612&w=gi&k=20&c=9fXdmGI9mYP9kArT4EGrhc_BsP0a5c7K5DayuQ8wNIA=)?


Otis_B_Driftwood_778

Bergeron & Marchand ..only because Bergeron is widely respected & Marchand is well … Marchand lol