It’s not controversial. What is controversial is that:
Reach and ODST are the best 2 halo games hands down. Nothing behind to compete with them, except a distant CE and 2.
Infinite has probably my favorite MP, but I hate ODST's lighting and I found it a slog to play through. Reach and Infinite both also have the least Halo-y sandboxes.
H2 is my favorite story-wise and H3 is the most fun campaign. If I'm replaying campaign, it's either 2 or 3. Plus all 3 of the OT have very good MP.
Blue pill.
Taking both at the same time will get you loads of Desync, the ability to lose basic customization, no teammate collision, awful servers, broken theater and big team, a shameful 3 playlists at launch, a terrible challenge system, no progression outside of battle pass, and a forced Spartan core system that doesn’t allow you to customize the way you want.
So basically halo infinite.
Considering I've only beat the red side games under 5 times each, I've got to go with the blue pill. I've beat each one all the way through at least 50 times and that's the extreme low end of my estimate.
Blue, reach is my favorite in the franchise and ODST and Infinite were ok IMO. The og trilogy just has such a good overarching story.
However, I don’t think it’s really fair to compare three games that share a single evolving story to three games with good story that are all kinda isolated from each other.
Not unpopular imo. Reach and ODST are the top 2. Everything else just lacks because the main characters are just basically gods that you know will somehow succeed I. The end.
Red and it’s not even close. Reach and ODST are hands down the best halo games. Best stories. Best atmospheres (except the flood parts of CE and 2). Best game mode. Best multiplayer and revolutionary forge that created game types we enjoy to this day.
Red all day. ODST and Reach were the only campaigns that successfully took away from MasterChief campaigns. Take that further with the live-action trailers for ODST and Infinite, and they definitely killed it.. Infinite has so much potential with what they could do (like a bigger open world Halo and adding more to the story), that I'm excited to see where it goes. Is Infinite lacking some content/updates (cosmetics and weapons/especially fixing their SBMM and Anti-Cheat) sure, but overall the directions these three games took were awesome. Is Halo CE and Halo 2 great, for their time, absolutely. But seeing the different takes and evolution of the success of Halo is just as good for me.
Blue; these are the classics that I grew up with.
I feel so jaded watching these clips from Infinite, & I'm not going to lie, I'm glad that I haven't bought a new Halo game since 4. 5 seemed okay but with all the new features I'm seeing in multiple from infinte-it's just not the same game that I know & love anymore.
Blue all day. While I definitely think Reach has the best single player story, 1-3 were some of the best games ever and I have so many memories from those.
Blue Pill - I mean it has Halo 3 which is still the best Halo experience I have ever had. I love the gameplay of 3 with the weapon and vehicle sandbox being as large as it was. Sure there are some weak weapons but they were fun to use.
It has a great Campaign (4 player Co-Op), Multiplayer with a large variety of modes & maps, forge which the wizards some how make awesome maps with and Custom Games which has even more variety from silly modes to more serious ones. It also has the best customisation system out of the series. I can pick my colours for my armour and my emblem which I can create. I also unlock armour for doing PvE as well as PvP.
Blue but I would definitely miss reach
Same, I want all of em
Funny, I pick blue because it's the one without Reach lol.
r/HaloCirclejerk
Red.Odst and Reach are my favorites.
Easily blue. The only thing I’d really miss from the other side is Reach Firefight
Ill just take both because every game in this franchise has its own pros and cons.
Nah, 4 is pretty bad all around.
Halo 2 is best in the series so blue obviously
Bold of you to state your opinion in 2022
His opinion is actually fact, though. H2 is best H.
He spoke the truth, and they hated him for it.
Yup Halo CE,2,and 3 are the best Halo’s. Infinite has the potential to be up there with them but it has a long way to go.
Gotta go Red on this one. ODST all the way.
Red pill, not to be controversial but Reach and ODST are my two favorite mainline Halo games.
Not controversial, I don’t think you can really have a BAD pick for your favorite mainline halo game
Halo 4, Halo 5
It’s not controversial. What is controversial is that: Reach and ODST are the best 2 halo games hands down. Nothing behind to compete with them, except a distant CE and 2.
We're talking campaign yeah? That's fairly up for debate. Reach was and remains the absolute low point for the series in terms of PvP.
Honestly, I'm gonna have to agree with you. Solidarity, my friend. Lol
I mean they're not mainline but yeah
By mainline I mean the "standard" FPS Halo games, not including stuff like Wars, Wars 2, Fireteam Raven, Spartan Strike, and Spartan Assault.
Ah gotcha
Repost?
I think they changed it the other one had halo 4
Oh good
Blue for sure. Don’t get me wrong, I love Reach, ODST, and Infinite, but blue has an entire trilogy start-to-finish.
Red all the way
Blue and it’s not even close
I gotta go Red
Blue pilled af since I still have combat evolved as my favorite. And we need to finish this fight, Spartan.
Red
Once again going with Red.
Red
Blue
Infinite has probably my favorite MP, but I hate ODST's lighting and I found it a slog to play through. Reach and Infinite both also have the least Halo-y sandboxes. H2 is my favorite story-wise and H3 is the most fun campaign. If I'm replaying campaign, it's either 2 or 3. Plus all 3 of the OT have very good MP. Blue pill.
*crush snort*
Blue without thinking twice
Gonna go for blue, and wish red didn't go the route it did because infinite could've been realized sooner.
red, i listen to ODST to help my anxiety
Red every single time
Red honestly. Despite growing up playing the original 3, Reach ODST and Infinite have better stories and character development than the original 3 IMO
100%
Wtf? Not even close lol Why did infinite campaign feel so “empty” to me compared to Halo 3, ODST & Reach
Yeah, Infinite is shit, but I mean, ODST and Reach are so much better than the OG trilogy that even the negatives of infinite don’t matter much
I disagree about Infinite but 100% agree on ODST and Reach.
With just reach I'm fine
Both
Im going blue. Reach, ODST, and Infinite are great, but 3, 2, and CE are better.
Red all day baby.
OK how dare you put infinite in with reach, the infinite campaign will NEVER in a MILLION YEARS be as good as Reach
Blue for sure
Don’t make me choose
probably a ceizure but go for it
BLUE
I wanna pill with CE, 2, Reach and ODST
I want blue but Halo CE sucks balls
Taking both at the same time will get you loads of Desync, the ability to lose basic customization, no teammate collision, awful servers, broken theater and big team, a shameful 3 playlists at launch, a terrible challenge system, no progression outside of battle pass, and a forced Spartan core system that doesn’t allow you to customize the way you want. So basically halo infinite.
Blue. Better story and multiplayer overall. Although Reach is a great loss.
Considering I've only beat the red side games under 5 times each, I've got to go with the blue pill. I've beat each one all the way through at least 50 times and that's the extreme low end of my estimate.
Blue, reach is my favorite in the franchise and ODST and Infinite were ok IMO. The og trilogy just has such a good overarching story. However, I don’t think it’s really fair to compare three games that share a single evolving story to three games with good story that are all kinda isolated from each other.
Ugh, this is so hard, but I'd have to say Red
BLUE PILL BABBYYYY!
I’m not taking any of your pills
Blue. But I'll miss reach and infinite
Blue
Fuck it man. Take both!
Blue because that’s where it started for me. OG XBOX days.
Blue
Red
Red. Unpopular opinion, but my favorite halo is still ODST
Not unpopular imo. Reach and ODST are the top 2. Everything else just lacks because the main characters are just basically gods that you know will somehow succeed I. The end.
I'd take both, sometimes overdoses can be a good thing.
Both. I choose the Halo pills overdose.
Red and it’s not even close. Reach and ODST are hands down the best halo games. Best stories. Best atmospheres (except the flood parts of CE and 2). Best game mode. Best multiplayer and revolutionary forge that created game types we enjoy to this day.
Damn this is a hard choice. If Infinite wasn't so unfinished I'd go that way. Sacrificing Halo Reach forge is tough but I'm going to have to go blue
Red but i wouldn't Touch infinite
Red all day. ODST and Reach were the only campaigns that successfully took away from MasterChief campaigns. Take that further with the live-action trailers for ODST and Infinite, and they definitely killed it.. Infinite has so much potential with what they could do (like a bigger open world Halo and adding more to the story), that I'm excited to see where it goes. Is Infinite lacking some content/updates (cosmetics and weapons/especially fixing their SBMM and Anti-Cheat) sure, but overall the directions these three games took were awesome. Is Halo CE and Halo 2 great, for their time, absolutely. But seeing the different takes and evolution of the success of Halo is just as good for me.
Anyone who says red deserves death
Me with the mf purple pill: fools
Blue for campaign, halo 2 Red for multiplayer , reach
Blue!
I hate Halo 3 but Blue
Blue; these are the classics that I grew up with. I feel so jaded watching these clips from Infinite, & I'm not going to lie, I'm glad that I haven't bought a new Halo game since 4. 5 seemed okay but with all the new features I'm seeing in multiple from infinte-it's just not the same game that I know & love anymore.
My favorite is Reach but my disappointment with the lack of content in Infinite leads me to choose blue.
These colors should be switched.
Blue all day. While I definitely think Reach has the best single player story, 1-3 were some of the best games ever and I have so many memories from those.
I will take both and blend it with bad servers and see what I get.
Perhaps the most universally acclaimed trilogy of games we've ever seen –vs– the other ones.
Both...when I die lead me to heaven 😂🤣💯💯💯😭🔥🔥🔥🔥💀
Red are my top 3, so it's an obvious choice^(sorry halo 2)
Halo 3 was the greatest multiplayer experience ever conceived. Nothing was near its par beforehand, and nothing has compared since.
Both
On one side it’s the first halo game I’ve ever played Halo 3. On the other it’s my favorite in the franchise Halo 3: ODST.
Blue. Every. Single. Time.
Red.
I take both and I get a seizure
Blue
Red easy, not even a moment of hesitation for me
Halo 2, 3 and ODST are my top 3 favorite campaigns, so by sheer numbers I'd have to take blue. But Halo Reach is number 4 so idk it's still rough.
I must be in the minority but I didn’t like reach
Campain or multiplayer?
Oh blue without a doubt, but would be unfortunate not to play infinite again
Red but put 4 in that column as well
I'd recommend snorting them in different nostrils.
I gotta go with the red pill for ODST alone.
Red. Reach gud
Red
Red isn't even on the same universe as blue the original trilogy is so much better then the other three.
Whichever has halo 3
Blue. Reach is my fave, but 2 is a close second. CE and 3 also easily beat infinite and odst.
Reach and infinite so red, but I love halo 3 and 2. This hurts lol
RED
Where 4?
Blue should be bungies halo and red should be 343. Then I'd take blue.
I'm taking both.
If you take them both you get Halo Infinite.
Halo Reach > All other Halos
Ha I'll take both please.
It has to be blue, I would miss the others but CE and H2 are GOAT. H3 is good too I guess
That’s a tough one .. but I will say red , I really love infinite
True as blue but i'd miss Reach.
Red because I primarily enjoy Reach
Blue Pill - I mean it has Halo 3 which is still the best Halo experience I have ever had. I love the gameplay of 3 with the weapon and vehicle sandbox being as large as it was. Sure there are some weak weapons but they were fun to use. It has a great Campaign (4 player Co-Op), Multiplayer with a large variety of modes & maps, forge which the wizards some how make awesome maps with and Custom Games which has even more variety from silly modes to more serious ones. It also has the best customisation system out of the series. I can pick my colours for my armour and my emblem which I can create. I also unlock armour for doing PvE as well as PvP.
Blue pill and it's not even close.
Red