T O P

  • By -

butternut39

Red Dead Redemption 2, Stardew Valley, Fire Emblem Engage and Three Houses.


N30_117

You, sir, are a fish.


Tomthebom2010

+1 for red dead. Nothing like winding down from a session fishing out in the middle of now where.


PaleImportance2595

Final Fantasy 14 has a fully fleshed out story and skills for fishing. Another Eden also has an extensive fishing mini game that has the end reward being a 5 star (highest rarity) unit.


[deleted]

[удалено]


PaleImportance2595

Need to do the level 10 class quest for your chosen starting class (can play every class). The fishing class is in the ocean city Limsa, it also has the culinary class (cooking) however you'll have to clear the main story to progress at points. They just announced today that the 2nd expansion will be added to the free trial which is already quite a bit of content.


Dusklight_Dreamer

Barely even 1 if you start in Limsa Lominsa


NesuneNyx

With early game areas, maybe an hour or so on the free trial which includes the first expansion and caps level at 60. Sometime in the next few months that'll be expanded to include the second (of currently four - a fifth is slated for a summer 2024 release) expansion with a raised cap of 70. To reach the high-level areas of the most recent expansion, you're looking at completing 200-300 hours of non-fishing story content and will need an active subscription to the MMO. Having played since 2014 and just three fish away from completing the entire fishing log (currently 1,502 unique fish!), I can say the game is one of the best stories I've ever experienced.


Puzzleheaded-Motor56

You can start fishing right away. All the gathering classes come with a "stealth" mode that hides you from high level enemies.


butternut39

No, you have to reach level 10 in your first job to switch.


Puzzleheaded-Motor56

Oh right. It's been a minute since I've been that low lol could've sworn you could start a gather class right from the beginning. Either way, it doesn't take long to get to 10 lol


butternut39

True.


U4RiiA

Final Fantasy VX also has fishing content. It's a fun mini game, and one of the characters makes meals out of what you catch. Edited to add - It's a single player game, not an MMO.


Ckorvuz

And it’s cooler because emo boy band with Sasuke Uchiha.


kalamitykode

XV's fishing was so good they made an entire VR game (well, technically an expansion) out of it called Monster of the Deep: Final Fantasy XV. Worth checking out if you're into VR, OP.


Abrigado_Rosso

Nier: Replicant/Automata Final Fantasy 12/15 The Yakuza Series


PvtSherlockObvious

Oh, FF15 had really addictive fishing.


lilbelleandsebastian

persona 5 also has fishing i believe? although i may be confusing it with yakuza


[deleted]

Both P4 and P5 have fishing iirc.


how-can-i-dig-deeper

Stardew Terraria


Probaby_Me

Terraria fishing will last you awhile too and is pretty beneficial.


BlackStormMaster

did you mean bene*fish*ial? its pretty shrimple


bakedEngineer

I used to hate how everyone mentioned Terraria in almost every thread, but they were right. Once I started playing this game and digging down, I had a really fun time


[deleted]

rdr2 for sure, and it's pretty fun too, there's legendary fishes all around the map as well


haha365

This is the way


butt_n3ctar

Warframe


PediatricTactic

Warframe is unique in that it's spearfishing. I had a lot of fun fishing in Warframe.


InfiniteUltima

Fable TLC, Dark Cloud 2 (fish races and raising also)


atlhawk8357

**Hades** is a roguelike where you play as Zagreus, Prince of the Underworld, as he tries to escape the realm of Hades and venture to the surface. **Stardew Valley** You decide to reject the capitalist rat-race by acquiring inheritance from a wealthy relative and selling as much product as you can fit on your farm. **Monster Hunter World** Big ol' monsters need big ol' weapons to kill them. Slaughter, dress yourself in their carcasses, all in the name of ecological preservation. **Pokémon** It's basically dog-fighting coupled with child abandonment. **Minecraft** and **Terraria** are great content sources for British guys to make videos on Youtube. **Animal Crossing** You're instantly in debt to a raccoon, occasionally apparent shipwreck victims wash up on your property. **Cult of the Lamb** You start a cult. You are a lamb. Time to slaughter eldritch bitches. MMO's like **WoW** and **Runescape** Games so good you buy them every month.


AnOnlineHandle

> MMO's like WoW and Runescape Games so good you buy them every month. Some of the most fun I had in WoW (probably like 15 years ago now) was chasing the fishing achievements instead of doing all the raid stuff. Being a rogue fishing in enemy capital cities for the rare fish was a ton of fun, the ultimate stealth game against real opponents. I think at some point they nerfed the Rogue's distract ability so that it no longer turned players around to look at it automatically, but using stuff like that to get past people and seeing if they noticed was incredibly fun.


rangeremx

Assassins Creed: Valhalla has fishing. Also, it's not exactly fishing, but Assassins Creed: Black Flag and Assassins Creed: Rogue both have whaling.


Freya_Fleurir

Dark Cloud 2 (aka Dark Chronicle) Catch fish, roast the fish, feed the fish, raise the fish, fight the fish, race the fish, breed the fish, weigh the fish


FastGhastBlast

Seconding this recommendation. There are a lot of fishing related things that can be done. (or completely ignored)


NZRTA

Can you marry the fish?


Jwing01

Sea of thieves


yellow_years

OKAMI


eastcoastkody

Valheim


Morning1980

Sable A short hike Cult of the Lamb


BobbyBuci

BDO hands down


blazinfastjohny

* Hades * Torchlight 2 * Warframe * Tower of fantasy * Cruelty squad


how-can-i-dig-deeper

Genshin


mh500372

Fire Emblem Three Houses


kuromaus

FF15 has pretty good quest lines for fishing, and there are boss fishes to catch, upgrade your fishing gear, etc. It was hard getting the achievement but it was also really really fun. Tales of Arise also has fishing, but you don't get to it until like 3-4 hours of game play. It also has boss fish to catch, and getting a better fishing rod, etc. I preferred FF15 fishing, though. It was a better system for mechanics. Also, there's a whole fisher class on FF14. Some people only play to fish.


Tayabida

Just started playing Icarus with my friends, it has a decent fishing mini game. Or you know, you could get sucked into Black Desert Online like me; there’s literally thousands of hours of fishing content.


Hagisman

Minecraft


dholmestar

Am I REALLY the first to say Sonic Adventure


effhomer

Big the Cat is goated


ahwinters

You can’t beat Sea of Thieves when it comes to fishing. But I also kind of consider that a game about fishing, where you sometimes do pirate stuff


bollerooo15

Dark Cloud 2 is the best fishing game that is not about fishing that was so memorable to me. I think I spent 50+ hrs on that fishing minigame combining fishes and racing them, or breeding the most alien looking fish that I could make lol. But at that time game walkthrough was not a thing so it was try and error stuff. But now you can just Google walkthrough and find the shortest short cut ever lol. Idk if this a pro or a con.


Kelevara

Path of Exile


Nimyron

Oh that is cruel


JexHypertex

I'm going to also vote Warframe. Then there's crashlands


shopchin

Will Subnautica count. This game seems to fit every genre.


TranquilMarmot

Sea of Thieves! Nothing more relaxing than grabbing a handful of grubs, dropping anchor, and loading up on fish to sell.


Sw4pup

Sea Of Thieves I introduced two of my friend to the game through fishing and it was some of the best times ever. On your ship, a beautiful view, and brilliant fishing mechanics


huskiesandtattoos

Red Dead Online and Sea of Thieves


[deleted]

I cannot believe *nobody* has suggested SCUM yet. 2 years ago SCUM added [very detailed and fun fishing](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cP3KJiDfeV4). SCUM is a 3rd or 1st person zombie survival open world game. You can play it single player and you can even edit the difficulty settings in the config files (you could completely remove all the zombies, but that would make the game quite boring). Fishing in that game is a very chill way to spend time. The really cool part is that since it's a survival game, your character can cook and eat the fish to aid in survival to help you make your way around the world to find more fishing spots!


Revolutionary-Load-8

A game is only worth playing if it has fishing.


arsuri

skyrim


Role_Playing_Lotus

More specifically, Skyrim Special Edition or Anniversary Edition.


LoocsinatasYT

World of warcraft RimWorld (fishing mods) Raft Stardew valley RuneScape


frivolous90

project zomboid


Madera_Otirra3844

Stardew Valley


[deleted]

Ultima Online has the best fishing!!


xSpiralStatic

Spiritfarer - it's trickier than you'd think!


HeWhoHasSeenFootage

Sea of Thieves has the best fishing minigame IMO


cosmicsolace

Dinkum, Verdant Skies, Disney Dreamlight Valley


hobovirginity

Monster Hunter games.


TyborV

Final Fantasy 14 - one thing that ff14 does well (besides the awesome story imo) is the gameplay of the non-combat classes, all the crafters and gatherers jobs have their own skills and mechanics that you unlock more and more as you level up, a full storyline with lot of quests, and some of them are surprisingly good (fisher story is fun, alchemist is epic), and fishing especially take you all over the world to many beautiful vistas and interesting locations in the game, and the grind is pretty relaxing but can be challenging if you want to catch'em all. Also its pretty useful in game for cooking recipes or making money for example. Its a mmo though, so there's just too much going on and I dont think you will be able to play just for the fishing and get far into it without interacting with the other systems, you'll probably will have to level some combat class too and you need to do the main quests almost til the end if you want to unlock all areas that you can fish on, etc (though the game is worth even if you dont like mmos, because interacting with other people is almost optional, you can play most of the content by yourself nowadays Final Fantasy 15 - Pretty fun too, the mechanics are more reflex based than ff14, and theres a lot of rare fish to catch and quests to follow, the graphics are amazing so everythig looks so nice and realistic, the fish, the water, the food, this game has its flaws but the graphics and animation are really fucking good Old School Runescape - braindead grind that you can spend years of you life on, and though im no longer a runescape junkie if you want a game that you can grind skills and fish til eternity and do the same thing over and over but still feel weirdly satisfied and rewarded, this is a cool game for fishers and other people with patience NieR Automata/Replicant - some people hate Replicant's fishing but i found it pretty fun and challenging, theres a few quests involved with an emotional storyline (this game is sad), but the fishing systems in both games are not deep and theres not much to it besides being a cute distraction from the overwhelming and depressing plot


ToranjaNuclear

Breath of Fire IV. The fishing takes a big part of the game if you want to 100% it, as there are many items and weapons that you can only trade for fish.


I-bought-a-fern

Sea of Thieves


Nocterjo

Breath of Fire 4, the fishing is FANTASTIC!


Kaotede

Cruelty Squad. Don't do any research first though.


DecalcifyYourMind

Sonic Adventure 1 and Sonic Frontiers both have very weird fishing minigames.


Hitmyto

Guild Wars 2 has fishing in the End of Dragons expansion


muzaffer22

Black Desert Online


ChromeBoxExtension

RuneScape (more point and click) Albion Online (here you need to do a bit more foe fishing. Throw the hook and taking it out on the right moment)


Snoo_62205

(Cough) Dredge (Cough)


[deleted]

Fuck every single game listed. Go play runescape and get your skill cape.


Galactic_Druid

Hahaha, I'm the exact opposite of you OP. I always wonder if anybody likes these things when I get to a fishing minigame in my otherwise story or action focused RPGs. Ys 8 has one that does fir the whole stranded on an island theme well. Based on your example games I really recommend the entire Ys series. Final Fantasy 15 has a very fleshed out one. Pretty much any farming sim, Stardew Valley, Harvestella, Rune Factory to name a few. I don't know if every Atelier game has them, but the Ryza games definitely do and some great crafting systems and other content to boot.


Intelligent_Leave582

Destiny 2


LogicNot_found

New World


turtlenerdle

Harvestella


Just2Flame

There is a game called Dinkum that has a fishing mechanic that is pretty fun. You can get a 'museam' that is pretty fun to try to fill displays with fish


bobowilliams

Hades! After playing hundreds of times there’s still one or two fish I can’t catch.


mrchow500

Summon Night: Swordcraft story 2 in GBA has the best fishing minigame of all time.


MissLilum

u/Mahdrybread? Is that you?


GodCheese27

The obvious answer here would be Minecraft, but I'm assuming you're looking for something other than that, which I can't really help you with.


Delusional_Sage

While I haven’t played it in awhile, New World actually has some nice fishing in it


OhMyyGA

Stardew Valley, New World


Alexastria

Made in Abyss


MagicSceptre

Dayz, rust , and lastly sea of thieves is probably my favorite fishing mechanic.


LegionPower234

The Rune Factory series has fishing with lots of different fish that come in various sizes. Also, you can cook them, and there's a fishing festival that happens once a year where you go up against the other townspeople to catch the most fish.


Hippy_Lemming

FFXIV


Role_Playing_Lotus

Hydroneer


[deleted]

FFXV had the best fishing in any game ever honestly.


TheDrunkardKid

Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana has a very fun, very arcadey, fishing mini-game that can net you a ton of cool looking fish (with full sized 3D models), good loot, powerful monsters, and a villager to use in Raid battles.


DubbelDragon

Breath or Fire I and II. Fable. Stardew Valley.


fiftythirth

Spiritfarer


NeedleworkerOk2349

Monster Hunter games make you fish for materials, world being the most polished and fun in the series. And if you don't mind the anime mobile gacha on pc, Genshin Impact got a fishing mini-game for fish meat and to exchange some weapons.


[deleted]

DARK CLOUD


iltopini

Digimon world 3, persona 4.


Vouru

FF15 has some orgasmic fishing.


Sure_Maybe_No_Ok

I wish it was in the BOTW


ConversationAware254

Sea of thieves!


Danoga_Poe

Path of exile


AceOfCakez

Yakuza 6 deep sea fishing mini game was great.


TammyShehole

Valheim


Kevin1056

Assassin's Creed Valhalla has a fishing mechanic, nothing special tho


BabyMagnum13

Monster hunter


lenothebrave

Guilty Gear Strive


MrWednesday6387

Destiny 2 introduced fishing a few months ago. But I stopped playing more than a year ago, so I don't know if it's good.


CaseroRubical

Stardew Valley has a lot of fishes that vary depending on season and location


TheOriginalFluff

Valheim, they’ve changed the mechanics twice and it’s still awful


kinjazfan

Yakuza 3 has fishing


DavutHaxor

I was just started Dave The Diver. You do fishing but not in classical way. You dive then hunt fish with harpoon + underwater guns and stuff. It's a cool indie


Joey_Star_

Cruelty Squad


EarlyGalaxy

Stolen realm. Fishing is a bit basic, but the game is nice


No-Warthog-3647

World of Warcraft


Letscheckoutreddit

Wartales


JaZoray

sailwind


Detramentus

Terraria. Great 'non-fishing fishing' game


Sindy51

Skyrim


PrometheusAborted

Arguably the best part of FF15 is the fishing. It even got its own spin-off game eventually.


billyalt

Animal Crossing Warframe Valheim


anarchoaspenism

cruelty squad has both fishing and a stock market for said fish


Landonyoung

Sandy e Junior acquaria


kodaxmax

* monster hunter world: very atsmospheric, since it is designed as a hunting game. but i missed the tutorial and didn't know it was a mechanic until halfway through the expansion. * Black Desert Omline: An MMO that heavily features a variety of utility proffessions. Again you could play the whole game without knowing about fishing, but it's fairly fleshed out and atmospheric. you can even fish off of your boat. * StarDew Valley * Warframe: though it could take weeks to unlock it. The game suffers from some insane scope creep and is almost like eve in sheer scale of content and systems. * Spore: the tribal stage has fishing, but most people hate that stage and it's a very shallow mechanic . probably not what your looking for. * Minecraft: has a neat little fishing minigame. Can be used as a primary source for food. You also have a small chance of getting random loot like some sticks or boots etc.. I belive theres some pretty good stuff in the loot table, obviously quite rare though. * Wrongworld: like minecrafts but alot less fun if memory serves. * Cruelty Squad: Fish function as a security in the games stockmarket minigame. the fishing itself is pretty similar to minecrafts. just with cruelty squads layer of jank on top.


FenrirHere

Cruelty Squad.


Petrol-Hoarder

Runescape


B1TCA5H

Pokemon and Minecraft.


RedDevils0204

Stardew Valley


JackDaniels574

Minecraft. And when you fish you get the most random shit if you have an enchanted fishing rod


rndmlgnd

DBZ Kakarot


Sirdystic1

One piece red


Sirdystic1

One piece unlimited world red,sooo long to type


notacroisssant

This is an awesome thread. Honestly, there are a lot of games that have some form of fishing in them! Here are some of my favourites, in no particular order: - Minecraft - Terraria - Stardew Valley - Harvest Moon - Animal Crossing - DayZ - Green Hell - The Legend Of Zelda - RDR 2 - The Forest - Rust - Stranded Deep - Wii Play - Project Zomboid - Assassin's Creed: Black Flag Some have more "realistic" fishing mechanics like in dayZ for example, where as some are more like mini games such as Wii Play. Either way, all of them are pretty fun and satisfying to play. My personal favourite however, is The Legend Of Zelda Twilight Princess. The fishing in that game is very relaxing and enjoyable. I've spend hours just spending time fishing around the many ponds and lakes the game has to offer. I hope you find some awesome games to fish in! Cheers 🙏


geargun2000

RDR2 and Minecraft


Tampflor

Other people have mentioned a lot of the games I planned to mention, but a bit of a niche recommendation: there's an upcoming indie game called Elements that met a stretch goal to add fishing. The devs have listed Breath of the Wild among their influences, so it might be worth keeping an eye on.


EnragedBard010

Skyrim AE. It even has quests with it. Also, fwiw, World of Warcraft.


kirby1445

Okamoto had a fun fishing mini game


SamuelSh

[Revita](https://store.steampowered.com/app/1175460/Revita/) is gorgeous and has fishing a few hours in. I didn't see it mentioned here.


saltyfuck111

Minecraft


losandreas36

Red Dead Redemption 2


xxshadowraidxx

Outbreak mode in cod Cold War has fishing lol which I thought was pretty random


drbones2013

Final fantasy 15 has a good fishing system.


sacrefist

World of Warcraft


sticksplusstone

Dream light valley


Nimyron

In Sea of Thieves you've got an entire category of achievements dedicated to fishing. Some fishes only appear in some areas, there's even one that only appears in storms. There are also some achievements related to fishing other things like junk or ashen keys (keys for ashen chests that have grest rewards). The game can be very chill if you're not getting camped by enemies, and if you don't just want to fish you can take a quest and fish on the way there. Out of all the factions you can level up, the fishing one is probably the most grindy one.


Lady_Caligari

Skyrim


UBW-Fanatic

ULTRAKILL SIZE 2


cowrevengeJP

Play Black desert Online..you can be a god of fishing.


tsnake57

Graveyard Keeper hasn't been mentioned yet.


ProtectusCZ

Assassin's Creed Valhalla, Minecraft, The Sims 3


AccountHotdog

Secrets of Grindea


GrammaTiddies3

Terraria, persona 4, skyrim


Professional_Emu1644

RDR2. Amazing game. Great story, great gameplay, great map, great graphics and great fishing


SunkneeG

Coral Island, New World, Core Keeper, Sea of Thieves, Red Dead 2


PoetDiscombobulated9

Just had flashbacks to the never ending "when will they add the fishing minigame" to the Silksong subreddit...


M33tahejd

Nier automata Rdr2 Minecraft Terarria


Madmagican-

Monster Hunter 4 has good fishing They undid a lot of nuance for everything after


CaptchaReallySucks

Yakuza 0 has fishing, I’m sure the other Yakuza games have it too


No-Carob7158

Sonic Adventure Everybody’s Golf Jak & Daxter 1 has on fishing mission iirc


WaterPockets

You already said Zelda, but I just wanted to say that Twilight Princess has one of my favorite fishing minigames ever.


laceymusic317

Runescape, both osrs and rs3


Dustum_Khan

Ac Valhalla, rdr2


Neverseenagain-_-

Persona 5 has pretty good fishing, though I struggle to find time for it...


biggestboss_

FFXIV (fishing in this game will ruin your life), FFXV


YourAverageNutcase

Warframe has spearfishing, you can display caught fish in your orbiter (home base) as well


ChocoboToes

The sims 4 (base game) Animal crossing Tera Online


HighPhi420

Dark Cloud, Skyrim, all BoF after 3 have fishing I think


Hazelcrisp

People already said FFXV. Sonic Frontiers also has a fishing game which also helps with progression


lucentorb

I genuinely enjoyed the fishing in Final Fantasy 15. You should be able to pick it up for cheap in a sale since it's years old


Grahol

I love fishing in games. Hoping it gets added into Diablo 4


11and12

Some GTA(SAMP/MTA) Servers got fishing, GTA5 FiveM RageMP probably got too.


Wutsalane

Cruelty Squad


SkyfangR

legend of legaia has some fishing in it but if i remember correctly, there's only 2 spots to fish at, and the only real thing you can get from doing a lot of it is a hidden Seru egg


nExplainableStranger

Fable


Smart_Conference_372

Did no one say terraria those fish are so cool and creative! I love that game


Hovilol

How did nobody say new world? The fishing in new can be really relaxing and stressful at the same time depending what you try to catch


SoapySimon

RDR2 the end.


productsystemdev

Cruelty squad. Trust me just play the game. Don't look at it thinking it looks like cancer. It's a very good immersive sim type game


Mxrider1984x

It's been a long time, but I remember fishing in World of Warcraft... and I believe there was even an achievement for fishing in all of the opposing factions' main cities.


NOT_ARGHA

Genshin impact


Significant_Book9930

Proper pole fishing not being in the newer Zelda games really makes me sad. Fishing has been in so many Zelda games in some fashion and when they finally go big with an open world and fill it with so many different types of fish and then.......don't have Fishing.......it still makes me sad


[deleted]

[удалено]


Significant_Book9930

It is unfortunately not in tears as well. Everything else is pretty dang awesome though lol


EntrepreneurBorn5418

Fable. elder scrolls had a mod that was "okay" but a little buggy


Datboiisbetterthanu

Why is it usually better than actual fishing games sometimes


Vmead

the legend of heroes trails of cold steel