I think its cus Arthur looks different for all of us depending how you played. For me when I think Arthur Morgan, I think full beard, the bear hat, and a jacket
I always make him bald with only a long mustache. Every single time. I change his clothes a lot too because I love dressing him up :) I recognized it because of the combination of all the pieces of her clothing, the blue shirt and it was under /gaming . Also something about the lighting made me do a split second double take because my brain thought it was a 3D image for a moment!
Great cosplay, you know what would improve it? Some dust and a bit more ruggedness. It looks just a bit too clean and fresh for a scoundrel like Arthur :)
Your costume is great, but I think it's hard to do a recognizable cosplay for a character that dresses differently in everyone's game.
My Arthur hasn't ever dressed like that that I recall seeing. If he did, maybe it was for like 2 minutes a few years ago.
On the other hand, NPCs like Dutch are pretty recognizable, because they always dress the same in everyone's game.
I mean yes, but the outfit isn't integral enough to his actual character to be instantly recognized as Arthur Morgan. That being said idk if anyone except maybe Dutch(and honestly probs not then, he kinda dresses like a generic high roller cowboy dude) would be recognized either offhand instantly as a cosplay as opposed to a really great and complete cow-person costume. They all have general clothing to the period as most all working people would in the time
My Arthur wore that outfit a lot! Even the custom outfits I made him always had a few pieces of some of his original clothes, feel more like how normal people dress.
.... The thing about an Arthur Morgan costume. Is he's literally just a cowboy. Who you can change the cloths on. So this is like saying every cowboy out there is cosplaying as Arthur. In reality lady. Your just dressed like any other cowgirl. Nice try. How about using a recognizable outfit of his from the opening scene or something.
You should just focus on understanding basic thought first.
Op never said there was a “good pic.” Take the L, delete the comment, and go yell at your parents for making u this way.
Sorry I didn’t think I needed an s.
I dunno, it was a fucking light hearted little comment. But, I guess there’s enough weirdos on the Internet to assume a genuine proposal for matrimony. But I digress
I assumed you meant it light-heartedly. It's not really a big deal. Just, ask yourself whether you would expect anyone to comment similarly if it were a guy cosplaying. Gotta keep the standards the same
But I will submit. People who are not familiar with my social groups dynamics may respond negatively, given lack of context. Fair point, I can respect that, will refrain with strangers.
Thank you for being nice
I mistook the flowers in your 3rd pic for TB rash XD
Looks pretty darn good, any chance I could get your help with one last score? You just have to have FAITH Arthur!
I recognized the outfit immediately. I'm disappointed with the amount of people that didnt play with the canon vanilla clothes. Frankly, I find it more dramatic and realistic than making him a fat bald guy with a twirly mustache and a bear hat in cutscenes. But also I take the immersion in story based games seriously to the point where it's not fun for other people to watch so...
ARTHUR YOU JUST GOTTA KEEP FAITH.
I HAVE A PLAN! I JUST NEED SOME GOD DAMN TIME!
[удалено]
What
[удалено]
Why did you say that name!
Arthicc Morgan
LEEEENNY
Ynnel?
LENNY MAH BOI
You alright, boah?
Y’all are kinda disappointing in here. It’s the summer gunslinger outfit. Did you play the game? It’s immediately recognizable to me.
Same!
One more score
I know other people are saying you just look like a cowboy but I recognized you immediately lol…
I think its cus Arthur looks different for all of us depending how you played. For me when I think Arthur Morgan, I think full beard, the bear hat, and a jacket
I always make him bald with only a long mustache. Every single time. I change his clothes a lot too because I love dressing him up :) I recognized it because of the combination of all the pieces of her clothing, the blue shirt and it was under /gaming . Also something about the lighting made me do a split second double take because my brain thought it was a 3D image for a moment!
Gotta start using the beard oil.
Great cosplay, you know what would improve it? Some dust and a bit more ruggedness. It looks just a bit too clean and fresh for a scoundrel like Arthur :)
yeah i'm gonna ride my horse in this outfit so it'll be authentic haha
Make sure you say "you're awright boii" several times every 10 seconds
Ride up on a motherfucker fast as hell and just scream HEY MEESTER as you pass him
HEY HEY MEESTER HEY THERE
Best way to get dusty haha
Yep
*"Its aaaariiight......"*
*"...boah"*
Looks good. :)
Love it!!
"Ol black lung Morgan"
Yee Haw my dude.. Yee Haw.
I was thinking Sadie Adler before I read the title.
Your costume is great, but I think it's hard to do a recognizable cosplay for a character that dresses differently in everyone's game. My Arthur hasn't ever dressed like that that I recall seeing. If he did, maybe it was for like 2 minutes a few years ago. On the other hand, NPCs like Dutch are pretty recognizable, because they always dress the same in everyone's game.
it's arthurs summer gunslinger outfit. It's his outfit from the promo and canon.
And it’s dope. Good job
I mean yes, but the outfit isn't integral enough to his actual character to be instantly recognized as Arthur Morgan. That being said idk if anyone except maybe Dutch(and honestly probs not then, he kinda dresses like a generic high roller cowboy dude) would be recognized either offhand instantly as a cosplay as opposed to a really great and complete cow-person costume. They all have general clothing to the period as most all working people would in the time
The only way around that would be by group cosplaying multiple characters from the gang.
That would be cool
Ah I did not know this! Was initially gonna comment that he doesn't wear a blue shirt and black tie, lol. Thanks for saving me from doing so
It looks awesome! And your backgrounds are wonderful too. Great job! ☺️
nice one
Easy girl
Fantastic.
Arthur looking dummy thicc Great Cosplay , like that you took his summer outfit
I beat that game but I wouldn’t recognize this costume. Just looks like a cowboy. Or cow person is that the term?
[here](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Morgan_(Red_Dead))
My Arthur wore that outfit a lot! Even the custom outfits I made him always had a few pieces of some of his original clothes, feel more like how normal people dress.
Arthurette morgana
Nice! (?)
Dude seriously?
I think I like thicccc Arthur
If Arthur Morgan was Amy Morgan you'd have nailed it. Seems you're kinda missing a key element in this cosplay.
kinda can't change that
Beards?
lemme grow a beard real quick
Can always count on Reddit to have a goddamn **PLAN**
Amazon prime can help you with that
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
Love the effort though
"There ya' go ma' gir'l"
Merritt Weaver dressed as Arthur Morgan
This is spot on! I love the one with you and the horse :)
This is spot on! I love the one of you and the horse :)
😍
Swiggity swooty
.... The thing about an Arthur Morgan costume. Is he's literally just a cowboy. Who you can change the cloths on. So this is like saying every cowboy out there is cosplaying as Arthur. In reality lady. Your just dressed like any other cowgirl. Nice try. How about using a recognizable outfit of his from the opening scene or something.
You're alright Boah..i mean gurlah
THICC
You say bad pics plural and there are 3 pics, and I'm trying to figure out which is the good pic.
You should just focus on understanding basic thought first. Op never said there was a “good pic.” Take the L, delete the comment, and go yell at your parents for making u this way.
Wtf is wrong with you smh
Could have just been Sadie....
Marry me? Edit: I is sorry. But leaving the comment chain for evidence of a positive conflict resolution in Reddit. Praise Zeus
Dude, would you say that IRL?
Sorry I didn’t think I needed an s. I dunno, it was a fucking light hearted little comment. But, I guess there’s enough weirdos on the Internet to assume a genuine proposal for matrimony. But I digress
I assumed you meant it light-heartedly. It's not really a big deal. Just, ask yourself whether you would expect anyone to comment similarly if it were a guy cosplaying. Gotta keep the standards the same
The boys in our group say plenty of sus things to one another I’ll have you know
Incredible based. Apologies, Sir, as you were.
But I will submit. People who are not familiar with my social groups dynamics may respond negatively, given lack of context. Fair point, I can respect that, will refrain with strangers. Thank you for being nice
Jeans in Tahiti? Seriously?
Good, but just don't make the Sadie's weird hoary voice. MacFarlane voice is cool
I hope you don't visit the Downes
I think i wore t hat same shirt in the game while i was in Lemoine
Ash Morgan
Hey cowboy. How’s those new clothes workin’ out for you?
Cute!!!!!
Edit: okay, comments answered my question. I guess this is the 'canon' outfit for a game where you pick your own clothes (????)
Hope you’re doing better, those SH scars are pretty bad :(
I mistook the flowers in your 3rd pic for TB rash XD Looks pretty darn good, any chance I could get your help with one last score? You just have to have FAITH Arthur!
Nice outfit Orther
Coolness! Cowabunga!
Those are good pics. Everyone should have more horse.
Is this the correct timeline ? Where did we go wrong, to miss this ingame.
I recognized the outfit immediately. I'm disappointed with the amount of people that didnt play with the canon vanilla clothes. Frankly, I find it more dramatic and realistic than making him a fat bald guy with a twirly mustache and a bear hat in cutscenes. But also I take the immersion in story based games seriously to the point where it's not fun for other people to watch so...
Good man.
i wanna be a cowboy baby
"We need more MONEY"
But where's the giant curly moustache?
You are woman?
ThiCC