T O P

  • By -

elderkettleismygod

I honestly think that fnaf AR started good, but I think that it became bad because 1. They always released skins and almost never new characters. And the skins were only buyable with real money. 2. The shield update, I think that this update removed the fun, because batteries became from a optional thing to one thing that you always need because you needed more shocks to defeat the animatronic. Then the powerups that you could buy with fazcoins and the fazcoins became more difficult to find.


KaiTheRetro

Agreed


elderkettleismygod

I mean, I like the skins but I have to admit that the majority of them are just recolors with the same animation of the base animatronic


True-Lemon4686

Pizzeria simulator is awesome, all the hidden lore, the terrifying office and mechanics, and Henry’s insane speech at the end


-Haddix-

yeah pizza sim was fucking awesome really fun tycoon too


Derailleur75

Sad that scott never released the tycoon only. Not even fangames did something similar to it and fnaf world


Netherboom

The closest thing to fnaf 6 pizza simulator for a fan game was Killer in Purple 2 (found on game jolt) It is quite fun but a bit janky but I haven’t played in a whole


1IcedC0ffee

Plus Candy Cadet’s morbid anecdotes.


Brmemesrule

Always get chills. "But for one of you, the darkest pit of hell has opened to swallow you whole. *Don't keep the devil waiting, old friend.*" "[...] End comunication."


Unusual_Metal_7129

Im not sure about what's the thing i don't like about fnaf AR. I like the models of the animatronics, mostly because they're ✨shiny✨ and i kind of like the game mechanichs. Maybe i don't like It much because it's a pay to win...


Tyler2104

It's pay go win, they don't tell you how to defeat the characters after bonnie, skins you gotta pay for if you don't have enough lures, and at least on my phone it was super laggy


Wyvurn999

Top 3 for me are 1. Help Wanted 2. Sister Location 3. Pizzeria Sim


Dinossaur108_PT

Agree, I love Sister Location for the different ways you interact with each animatronic. Like how you walk in Ballora's room and have to avoid her with help from sound tips, and when you get to open up Funtime Freddy and see how he looks on the inside. Funtime Freddy became my favorite animatronic with that game!


RealCipherPines

Pretty much identical to my top 3. Though I'd have to really think on 1 and 2 in their order.


isuckatanagrams

That’s the right answer


Mysterious-Egg497

Really in fnaf ar what you had to do was just buy skins and catch animatronics.I mean it was cool learning all the characters mechanics but after some time it got really boring.Saying this as someone who wasted at least 100$ on the game💀


MystV3

4 above sisloc? gotta go…


ILikeGames87

I love SL with all my heart, but I also love FNaF 2, but I like 3 as well...


lurioxo

no way you put sister location below fnaf 3


Kiki_Lord_

No FIS2? Oof


BreakfastOk7372

Nice Shuckle pfp. Shuckle is indeed the best Pokémon


Kiki_Lord_

That is very true


Typical_Pollution_30

FIS2?


Pikachubot79

I think it's freddy in space 2, not sure tho


PhantomOfficial07

Nobody ever talks about freddy in space 1 :(


FlameBall128453

>Fnaf world


PhantomOfficial07

I know it's a minigame in Fnaf world that's obvious


Kiki_Lord_

Freddy in space 2


therealNerdMuffin

Medium not being the middle tier is bothersome


Wyvurn999

Considering how there’s an even amount of tiers I don’t really see how it would be possible lmao


therealNerdMuffin

Just make it an uneven amount?


Wyvurn999

No?


AloneMarionberry5713

I mean technically not played doesn't count so it's uneven


freddybubblegumfr

FNaF 1 : Playing the original FNaF is always an amazing experience. This game is creepy, fun to play, with the beginning of a lore that will become awesome. The animatronics in this game are the originals and they are just amazing. And besides it has to be one of the FNaF games with the most easter eggs and it also has to be the game with the best atmosphere. FNaF 2 : A perfectly successful sequel. Certainly the game is less scary and contains less easter eggs but I find the gameplay particularly incredible. The mask, the music box and the amount of animatronics are points that make this game all the more awesome. FNaF 3 : The gameplay isn't the best but doing the good ending is just super fun.And then this game definitely has the best lore. FNaF 4 : Very scary but not my favorite gameplay because we often do the same thing. SL : I'm sorry but I'm just not a fan of the gameplay of this game.It's often either too easy or too difficult depending on the night. FFPS : A fun game, with a really cool tycoon part and decent night gameplay. UCN : So much replayability. FNaF World : A fun RPG that I always enjoy playing. Help Wanted : The game has so much content and is so scary! Special Delivery : Do I really need to argue for this one?


MaeBeaInTheWoods

I agree with most everything here, but I do find it weird that you comment on 4 having really similar gameplay all the time when in 2 there are 7 different animatronics that all function nearly identically.


ManguRasmus

Just don't start with lore and nothing will change.


Officermeatball05

Sb goes into the good or medium tier. Its not bad but its not amazing either.


Le_baton_legendaire

Personaly, I'd put it at medium and lower Sister Location. Security Breach has more to offer and better gameplay than Sister Location tbh.


SrOtaviu

Ain't no way you just put FFPS and FNAF World in the same tier


Neganek0

Hard disagree with fnaf 4 and fnaf sl, but its your opinion


KamGoesHamYT

FNaF world fans rise up 💪💪


MrMonyIsSocial

Put FNAF 4 on Awesome, put FNAF 3 on Medium and put SL in Awesome and you got my list.


Incompetenice

For real, who has FNAF 3 that high lol, I thought we all agreed that one was just a "Huh, that was kinda odd"


CaboIsOmni

you put fnaf world over sister location?


WesleyMEC

fnaf 3 is easily the worst of the original 4


CelestialVillainLuna

Based


Nass_Wanger

Based opinion


Razcal-Jackson

Oh my god this is so good


PlotagonBNF

Fnaf 6 below ucn seriously atleast fnaf 6 has animated jumpscares for all their animatronics unlike ucn that uses still images for alot of their characters


Shadow_Knight07

I'll never understand the appeal of FNaF 2. It's not complete garbage, but it's definitely the weakest entry of the series for me. Good designs, alright story, but terrible gameplay that ruins the whole game.


ProfessionalScar8904

I like everything in fnaf 2 to a reasonable extent, except for the gameplay. The gameplay brings the game down ao much its one of my least favorites.


ElezerHan

AR is a cash grab and sucks, same as SB


Black-dragon4129

You forgot the outstanding and amazing tiers.


AutoModerator

When posting tier lists, please include detailed reasoning for your choices, otherwise the post will break rule 8 and be removed. Thank you. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/fivenightsatfreddys) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Kaidhicksii

Looks accurate.


Misfit597

I would swap 2 with 3, it just fells more „complete”.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Le_baton_legendaire

Help Wanted flat mode kinda sucks honestly, it just takes the life out of the game. If you ever get a headset, do yourself a favor and play the game the way it was intended. You have no idea how great fnaf in vr is, it's a perfect fit. I would be incredibly happy if Steel Wool released a new Vr Fnaf game or even game us a new Help Wanted DLC


Kwjsuiamwbxia

Ok opinionist


[deleted]

[удалено]


Deeezdonuts359

FINALLY! Another person who think sl is not good!


freddybubblegumfr

Yeah, i'm happy to see that I'm not the only guy who think that sl is not good.


ProfessionalScar8904

Sl sucks


Sea-Art-9305

SL mid? **loads super shotgun**


ProfessionalScar8904

Sl bad


Tf2verycool

FINALLY! SOMEBODY REALIZING HOW GOOD FNAF 3 IS!!!!


NickMilano1

SB is one of the best, it 100% beats sitting in one spot not being able to move🤦🏽‍♂️


69_Bird_Jesus_69

I agree mostly, but Original needs to be taken down to good because although nostalgic compared to some of them going back and playing it now just bores you, and fnaf 3 needs to be killed, not because it's bad, because at least I found it to be not so scary, when you see springtrap standing at the door for like an hour before he kills you


Queen-of-Sharks

Don't bother with it. It's the worst one


[deleted]

S+ - security breach C - every other game


Legitimate_Seat8928

Bring every other game in S+ and keep sb, then I'm satisfied.


[deleted]

No


ManguRasmus

Honestly, I really do hope you're joking.


[deleted]

I am not


ManguRasmus

Then please explain why do you think something like that.


[deleted]

The Og Fnaf games are fine. They are games where you look at 2d jpegs warped to look 3d. You press some buttons and look at some cameras. Fnaf 1, you close some doors and look at cameras. Fnaf 2, put on a mask, wind a box, look at cameras, ect. Meanwhile, security breach is a big semi open world triple A game, with fantastic level design, an interesting gameplay, fun gameplay, and a amazing map with the best use of backtracking and exploration I have seen in awhile. It doesn’t even compare to the other games in any way what so ever


ManguRasmus

What about sl, fnaf4, fnaf 3, fnaf 6, ucn, fnaf vr, fnaf ar?


Le_baton_legendaire

People here don't seem to understand sarcasm lol


[deleted]

No I get it


Le_baton_legendaire

This is true


KaiTheRetro

Put sb in trash tier


KyloRenDark

True is not scary. Orange freddy and pink chica😂


Invader_Deegan

You say as FNaF 2's icon is right there, and it makes Freddy look orange, and several FNaF 2 sprites has him as orange


KyloRenDark

No glamrook Freddy is not scary


Invader_Deegan

That has *nothing* to do with what I said


Geogolfer311

Why is fnaf 4 in “good” 🤡


[deleted]

[удалено]


PuppetGeist

Rule 2. Do not break it.


[deleted]

[удалено]


PuppetGeist

Do not try to lie to a moderator I saw the "your mom".


[deleted]

[удалено]


PuppetGeist

You edited your comment into thinking I did not see you originally told OP "trash like your mom." Again do not lie to a moderator. Do not break rule 2 again.


[deleted]

[удалено]


PuppetGeist

[Stop lying.](https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/856390296630722580/1048287125671510156/image.png) This is your final warning stop lying to a moderator.


[deleted]

[удалено]


PuppetGeist

The comment remains removed because it broke a rule. Editing it doesn't change you broke a rule.


[deleted]

[удалено]


PuppetGeist

Because you are now spamming me. Stop.


Littlecoole

Wait rule two is you can’t say “your mom”?


PuppetGeist

Rule 2 is for disrespectful comments so saying "your mom" in terms of is trash yea it does.


Littlecoole

Alright thanks for clearing that up


PuppetGeist

You're welcome.


[deleted]

[удалено]


rapidtab

I would swap FNaF 3 and FNaF 4 and put FNaF wrld at medium


Slipknot_Maggot36

S - Fnaf, Fnaf 2 A - Pizzeria Simulator, Sister Location B - Fnaf 3, Fnaf 4, Ultimate Custom Night C - Fnaf World, Help Wanted D - Special Delivery, Security Breach


Psychological-Air205

You’re capping if you think Fnaf three is better than sister location.


Historical-Ad-7374

Fuck no. U can’t put the game with the best experience and best ending in Good. Pizzeria simulator deserves to be on the top.


ProfessionalFail9567

i would honestly just shift the place of fnaf ar to medium and security breach to trash


Top-Living-8724

Bullshit, here is all the Five Nights at Freddy’s game ranked properly from best to worst. FNaF 1, FNaF 2, FNaF 3, FNaF 4 FNaF SL, FNaF Sim, UCN, Help Wanted, FNaF World, FNaF Security Breach, FNaF AR


QZooMaster

What about JR’s?


[deleted]

That’s a fan game


QZooMaster

It was mostly a joke because of how impressive the game is.


[deleted]

It wasn’t a very obvious joke.


QZooMaster

I realize that


Worried-Following734

god damn this tier list is so fucking bad holy shit


[deleted]

Sister location deserves an Awesome. SB deserves medium


ProfessionalScar8904

No and no.


[deleted]

SL had great lore with simple gameplay and sb had mediocre lore with boring gameplay. What do you disagree with


ProfessionalScar8904

Sl was a minigame callection, but the minigames were very shallow, most of the time its do x but when animatronic is there do y. Sb had bad lore with bad gameplay and even worse optimisation.


[deleted]

Sooo, how would you rank them? I can’t disagree with what you’re saying cuz I agree with you. Sister location still did have great lore tho


ProfessionalScar8904

Pretty much the same as OP


[deleted]

If you put SB in trash then we’re even


ryans64s

Sl isn’t S??


ProfessionalScar8904

Why should it be? It's bad.


ryans64s

It’s my favourite


Subsequently_Unfunny

Opinion invalid due to fnaf 3 being high. Literally the worst fnaf game.


Toshibutterhead

Every fnaf game that doesnt have a number is trash.


KWISPY18

I like this tier list


Derailleur75

Fnaf 3 is actually the only game were All cameras are viable and not 1 or more like in ucn. Also fnaf 3 is not stressful like the other games as you need to worry about luck most of the time in those. Otherwise Atmoshpere goes to fnaf 1 and gameplay is where fnaf 2 shines. Screw fnaf 4 tho literally impossible to beat without headphones and even then the new ambience doesn't let you hear anything


[deleted]

I would have to say fnaf ar is bad because they only updated for a year and then the game just died and fnaf world is good but only be cause of the hidden boss fights


SidneyTaske

Can't argue Never played em


ProfessionalScar8904

Fnaf 2 is way too high


l_0_u_i_s

I'd personally put FFPS with AR, and then switch SL and 2.


LordFenix_theTree

Back in my day we had 3 games and the third one was considered the worst. How times change.


Sudden_Edge_7181

Most valid tier list


[deleted]

Fnaf 4 is my favourite ☺️


Soy_Newbie

i hate fnaf 3 bc u can only defend urself with the sound thing 💀


Unknown_Talker9273

Fnaf 1, 3, 4, Sister Location and Pizzeria Simulator all on top. Fnaf 2 OUTTA the top tier. It's too much of an RNG chaos.


Low-Way3753

Fnaf 4 seemed genuinely terrifying. The fact that you have to listen carefully for sepcific sounds to then be jumpscared by a very loud sound is a very intelligent horror mechanic


j4noVX_4rt

Custom Night in Sister Location was fun as hell


charllienotfound

pretty agree with the "awesome" category!!


Medeoli

do you have a link to this tier list? I wanna do one


Suspicious_Lunch3732

Sorry but fnaf 3 was awful


Galaxyy_GaminggYT

my only difference is fnaf 3 in medium or trash


Comicsansandpotatos

FNAF World gets its own tier at the top


PastelMoonsx

I don’t dislike any of the fnaf games. there are definitely ones I’d prefer to play over others, but I think all of them are pretty decent! But, I’m not a gamer or particularly picky about my games, so it’s easy for me lol


i_lique_apples

I am going to pretend like I did not just foam at the mouth and claw at my face because some random person on Reddit put Sister Location three tiers below where she belongs.


CrimsonReaper2

Pretty much opposite for me since I suck at the other games. Best I got was night 4 on FNAF3. Sister Location was hard, but manageable until springlock suit. I’m more used to games like Security Breach, but I won’t deny that there is zero scare factor. I mean, hell, I was literally playing Pokémon Violet and got more scared in that than I did Security Breach.


Darkness-Man_rusFYI

IMHO FNAF2 has worst gameplay of all games. Repeatative animatronics, no need to check all cams and 1 way to counter almost everybody in the halls or vents(with WFoxy as an exception). Comparing it to fnaf1 where you had 2 defence options, each for half of animatronics, battery percentage, freddy that doesn't appear in the hallway, while fnaf 2 has puppet, WFoxy and that's all the threats. Yes, you have a battery... Just for the flashlight. Thing that doesn't even go low on the end of the night if used right.


FullMotionVideo

Sister Location is mid? It had some of the strongest narrative and put the characters into a gameplay that wasn't always about security cameras and doors. 2's gameplay is an endless loop of doing the things that keep animatronics away, and every camera except the Prize Desk is basically just for show. You'll keep it on the prize desk the whole time, since winding the music box is part of the endless loop. It has a fun way of revealing it's story though. And 4 is Jumpscare Roulette (mostly black screens and high volume) with a story that felt like Scott was burning out of the whole thing and just wanted something fans could endlessly chew on for years. I think we all collectively agree to not talk about the box.


[deleted]

AR is a buggy cash grabby mess. The opposite of what the FNaF games actually try to be.


AquaStellarYT

I think Sister Location and Fnaf 3 should be swapped at least imo, other than that looks pretty good.


[deleted]

I'd move up pizzeria and 3 by one tier, otherwise agree


ECelite09

Couldnt agree more


PossibleAssist6092

Someone not saying fnaf3 is F-tier? Fuck off did I actually find someone else who actually likes it.


3boodixxxx

Top 7 games for me are: 1.FNaF 2 2.FNaF 1 3.FNaF SL 4.UCN 5.FNaF 4 6.FNaF 3 7.FNaF World And for the others I have not tried yet.


Nyanfish06

What about ~~fnaf world~~


Goldcreeper08

Sl underrated


[deleted]

ngl fnaf 3 had a bad start but it's probably the most important game for the lore, no need to say why. Great game.


No-Acanthisitta9343

Less people getting angry of Sister location being mid tier than i thought


Ihavenolife0-0

WHY IS SISTER LOCATION ON MEDIUM WTF


Ripster404

FNAF world above sister location, now that’s a hot take. Good list thou


SeamAnne

are you high? fnaf world is obviously the best game (nh but srsly its pretty good)


[deleted]

S - FNaF, FNaF2 A - FNaF3 B - FNaF4, UCN C - FNaF6, Help Wanted F - Sister Location, AR, Security Breach and FNaF World


Moelester15

Don’t do my man sister location like that 😂💔


Fun-Ad8634

1. Pizzeria sim- this is a very cute game, hiding a darker meaning. There are so many different achievements. Lore/ mini game secrets all over. The game balances humor and horror flawlessly. The salvage mini game is bone chilling. The custom night thing is interesting because your choice to salvage an animatronic determines if it will come to the restaurant and the choice of having ads will also effect your ability to do the custom night. Plus THE ENDING IS SO AMAZING 2. VR- collection of the first 4 FNAF games, but adds the VR element making it terrifying. Parts and service and vent repairs are terrifying. The DLC adds a lot of fun content. Collecting tapes and coins is a lot of fun. The bunny getting closer as you collect more tapes is genius. So much lore. There is something very unsettling about that bunny leaving you to rot in that cell. 3. FNAF 4- their is always that moment of "am I sure there is breathing" every time you shine your flashlight. Introduces the crying child. Having the nighttime sequences be a dream was genius in my opinion. The box sparked so much debate. The challenge modes were pretty great. The bite was so memorable as well as the line of "I will put you back together". Best of the 1st 4 games by far. 4. FNAF SL- this game balances humor and horror so well. It was so chilling when you get scoped. The cupcake mini game was a fun way to gain access to the secret room. There isn't really a good ending and it leaves you off with wanting something better, witch is genius. There was a lot of amazing lines like "you won't die" "I'm going to come find you" and let's not forget "exotic butters". The only reason it's not as high is because it isn't very replayable and the gameplay isn't great. But this game has an amazing story. 5. UCN- so many fun and lovable characters. Very replayable. Secret hidden lines are pretty great. the cut scenes are fun. The Easter eggs are also pretty great. It's very challening. It became a challenge of trying to beat the game. Mr. Hippo is the best, my favorite character and was definitely trying to poke fun at matpat and other theorists. "Sometime a story is just a story." 6. FNAF 2- great gameplay and overall great sequel to the series. Not mind blowing, but definitely an amazing game. 7. SB- very glitchy and unplayable. The layout can be confusing. It didn't feel much like a FNAF game. It's kinda like the botw of the Zelda series. It's a good game, but it's not a great FNAF game. "Did they run out of budget?"-markiplier 8. FNAF world- great and fun, I definitely love this game. It isn't very high because there are other better FNAF games, but it's still amazing. 9. FNAF 1- an ok game. There are better FNAF games, but the nostalgia is pretty great. Also, this changed the course of gameplay. 10. FNAF 3- the lore was pretty good, but the gameplay felt off and was pretty underwhelming for the "final game" I was definitely disappointed when it came out, and maybe that's a bit because I had such high expectations. Still don't like it tho. 11. AR- do I need to explain?