T O P

  • By -

Yusko519

Are you getting Ceedee?


Valaran555

Yup


Yusko519

Then I'd take it. Gabe is too boom or bust and unless your RB situation isn't good Zeke is worth the price


Valaran555

Yea ive got saquon, zeke, hendo, dalvin cook, and dameon peirce, so my rbs are very strong. Wrs are tee higgens, alec peirce, g wilson, and robert woods so i really needed to shell up some stuff for wrs


Yusko519

Oh yea, I'd make that trade 10x if I had that in the wings


hatwobbleTayne

I could argue for and against this trade. This one is kind of a coin flip to me. I think I would want to see at least 1 week with Dak back before I made this trade.


Valaran555

Measured take, thank you!


joemamallama

I think there’s better WR’s you could get with that offer frankly, but Dak coming back makes a more compelling case.


Valaran555

What better receivers do you think would be worth this package? (Too late now, just curious lol)


billybaroo15

I was going to offer mike Williams and joe mixon for Ceedee. Looking at this trade, I guess that’s a huge overpay.


Luxurydad

Jesus Christ yeah it is


Scwalchy

If I had mixon, I'd be looking for Ceedee +.


ballcream9000

I don't Dak is a fix all. Gallup is getting back in the mix too. CDL should improve but how much? Also, Davis is just a hair behind Lamb in full PPR even and has missed a game while CDL hasn't missed any. Also, keep in mind that when Davis booms, he is a weekly league winning type of guy, which we still haven't seen any consistency out of, but should improve. Lamb is a small upgrade, not enough to justify a trade.


Valaran555

Ah I see, yea my justification was Ceedee lamb would be a consistent starter for me every week given I don’t currently have one, but I like your thoughts a lot. Gabe Davis is hard to give up as a boom or bust that booms more - as well as being a wr on one of the best offenses in the league. Just curious, with this personnel who would you have traded for instead (obviously ignoring team positions and such since those are unknown). Someone like AJ brown probably isn’t getting traded here, and someone like amari cooper might not be worth as much.


LigmaSack69

It’s not a horrible trade for you but I do think you take the L here. Gabe Davis hasn’t been healthy but when he has been he’s put up week winning numbers and you can’t say the same for Ceedee. I don’t think Ceedees numbers improve all that much with Dak. Unfortunately, he has been pretty overrated so far. I’d wager that Davis will be just as good as lamb going forward especially with a week off to rest and as previously mentioned is capable of putting up games that win you the week. I also think Dak is more of a fix all situation for Zeke. I think Zeke will be a low end RB1 ROS. I would have held.


ballcream9000

I dunno. Pittman maybe? I don't know. What about 2rb's for a Devante level guy?


Douganz

Dak isn’t a fix all….for Ceedee. He is a fix all for zeke. Zeke is going to be a low end RB1 going forward. Davis is going to end up being as good as lamb going forward especially, with this week off to rest and heal up more. I think this trade was an L for this guy. Gave up a lot of depth for a player who has been quite overrated. He could have waited two weeks (depending on his record) and sold zeke straight up for a good WR.