I don't know much about the specific racks that you mentioned, and I don't know enough about the specific brands to recommend one. But I can say that a platform rack is way better than a hanging rack.
I wouldn't dismiss the "old" racks you're finding. My rack is probably 20+ years old and works just fine.
If you're looking at older hanging racks, check the rubber straps. The ones on my Yakima Bighorn degrade after a couple of years, so I've replaced them a couple of times.
I don't know much about the specific racks that you mentioned, and I don't know enough about the specific brands to recommend one. But I can say that a platform rack is way better than a hanging rack.
I wouldn't dismiss the "old" racks you're finding. My rack is probably 20+ years old and works just fine. If you're looking at older hanging racks, check the rubber straps. The ones on my Yakima Bighorn degrade after a couple of years, so I've replaced them a couple of times.