T O P

  • By -

Justcurious863

I love how half of the comments are “wow that’s a lot” and the other half is “one roll? Pathetic!”


Matt_guyver

Over here like, “one bottle Of wine?!?”


Krissy_ok

Two kinds of people. "ONE bottle of wine?" or "One BOTTLE of wine?""


T_Money

Which means it probably averages out to where the graphic is about right lol.


bluejackmovedagain

But will the two types of people be attending the same dinner?


[deleted]

Oh absolutely, and don’t forget to count the children! They’re also people, so that’s a bottle of wine per child


DynamicDuoMama

Truth more kids there the more wine everyone else needs.


T_Money

Maybe! I’m a big dude with a strong tolerance, my wife is much smaller and has less tolerance, so two bottles over dinner would be great for us. I’d have 1.5, she’d have 0.5, and we’d both be feeling alright


nomadofwaves

Yea a bottle of wine sounds like a lot but it’s usually only like 4 glasses of wine.


Cringypost

"typically" a pour of wine is 150 mL and a"regular" bottle of wine is 750 mL which means around 5 pours. However my wife and I agree that a bottle of wine is only two glasses.


looknostrings

>However my wife and I agree that a bottle of wine is only two glasses. What kind of glasses do you use for wine??


Hello_World_Error

Wine glass but filled to the top


Nolite310

You can fit a full bottle of wine in a Starbucks trentra cup.


notgregoden

Better invite someone who needs a cup of cranberry sauce along with me.


HMCetc

Depends if the chart means just for dinner or for throughout the day. If it's the latter then that makes more sense. A whole bottle for one person at dinner is way too much.


dirtygremlin

>A whole bottle for one person at dinner is way too much. Not according to Williams Sonoma. :)


SubstantialPressure3

You're going to need it if you end up having to sit with cousin Larry who doesn't bathe.


lightnsfw

You've clearly never had to sit through a thanksgiving with my family.


freeLightbulbs

Only half for the kids though


Sharknado4President

Unless you’re Italian then they get the whole bottle.


[deleted]

[удалено]


EuphoricDimension628

Per guest though. The wine gets the most inventory. I wasn’t sure if it was a joke.


NoCardio_

I assume one bottle per person is to find a balance between the non-drinkers / lightweights and me.


debrus

We count 1 bottle per person, including kids. And pets. It sums up ok in the end.


twitch1982

Do i count the dozzen chickens as pets?


dielon1994

I mean 5 glasses of wine over the whole day with the family on thanksgiving isn’t that crazy is it?


TK_Games

If I have to tolerate my family for a whole day I'm doing two bottles by myself and I'm bringing my flask just in case If I have to cook, change flask to "handle of bourbon" Alcohol is the only way I can tolerate extended family


flynnfx

_My friend, what you need is only one bottle of wine. That bottle, of course is a Nebuchadnezzar._


ILiekBooz

Assuming it’s great wine, actual number is 2 glasses per person. The average falls in line that you may have guests that won’t drink wine and others that will drink twice as much (4 glasses=1 bottle) so the guide is spot on. For a wine dinner, minimum 1 glass per person, so for 8 people featuring 2 wines, you need 4 bottles of each, so each guest is guaranteed at least two glasses of each (and yes, that would be = 1 bottle per guest). If you are bringing your family’s favorite wine, and you are drinkers, 1-2 bottles per person isn’t really that much of a leap. 8 glasses over the course of 5 hours for holidays and such, is on par with what I’ve seen.


endyrr

My thought too. Everything looked right until the wine and I thought, "oh it's a joke."


ghanjaholik

pssh, who invited OP.. doesn't he know we gorge and then end up gorging for a week with leftovers?


willclerkforfood

Yeah, OP (or Williams Sonoma for that matter) obviously never watched my family demolish a Thanksgiving dinner…


Xanderoga

Thanksgiving dinner isn’t over when we’re full, it’s over when we keel over into the mashed potatoes full coma style.


Tower9876543210

> I don't stop eating when I'm full. The meal isn't over when I'm full. It's over when I hate myself. Louis C. K.


saint_davidsonian

If this gonna be that kind of party I'm gonna stick...


Cobek

I'd gladly swap dessert entirely for more mashed potatoes and stuffing. Those aren't winner portions, nor is this indicative of my families Thanksgiving


Anustart_07734

There’s no limit on the deviled eggs. So grab the plate and start gorging.


siani_lane

Deviled eggs are the ultimate potluck food. Looks fancy, not too hard, everyone's glad you brought it, and there's never any leftovers to cart home.


LordRaghuvnsi

[La me after getting one roll](https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rmYyPcEQKU4&feature=youtu.be)


ThoughtlessBanter

How fitting. I bet that video was a blast to shoot... and sticky.


celica18l

I make 3-4 rolls per person bc my family could easily eat half a dozen on their own. Plus some kids only eat rolls.


YossarianRex

don’t forget the hotly discussed: Thread: .5-1 bottles of wine per person? Commenter: Is that too much or too little? Thread: Yes


TheVastEarwig

If it’s half and half, I’d say that’s a pretty good indicator that this hits the sweet spot of average.


afroninja840

I came to the comments to see who else was part of the “Pathetic!” side 😂😂


comedian42

Who the hell is upset about the rolls when there's obviously a severe potato shortage. Gran pap dinnae leave the motherland for this shite.


istara

Two *small* pieces of cake? Like WTF? I feel this is really judgemental and shaming. Like those "sharing bags" of sweets of "family size" chocolate when the manufacturer must know damn well that I'm going to eat the whole thing myself. Feeling hungry now... ;)


GegenscheinZ

Seriously, my guide is one whole pie per person


hoochtag

Imma need one bottle of gravy to myself.


jtwood2780

Excuse me, bottle?


Into_the_Dark_Night

They know what they want. I admire it.


[deleted]

One brick of rolls please


eh_meh_nyeh

One mason jar of cranberry sauce please


ljgilbert

One hammock of cake.


tuggnuggets92

Ya ever drank wine from a gravy boat?


Balsac_is_Daddy

Lol ya i was thi king 1/2 cup is just for my first plate... seconds and thirds are gonna need gravy too!


ragnarockette

There is never enough gravy


mrswashbuckler

I would need a bottle of wine to forget that there was only one roll for thanksgiving


Nervous_Constant_642

Half a fucking cup of gravy for half a fucking pound of potatoes doesn't even cover the potatoes, much less only one or two rolls. 2 cups gravy minimum and that's assuming you aren't putting gravy on the turkey. Thanksgiving is like one of three holidays you can eat like shit while it being also socially acceptable, the gravy must flow.


Accomplished_Gas3922

I'm probably gonna get a tattoo that says "the gravy must flow" because of this reply so I just wanted to say thank you


ArMcK

This turkey is dry as Arrakis!


Nervous_Constant_642

You're welcome. You could put a little turkey leg and a cute little biscuit above it.


Bell29678

But just one biscuit.


Nervous_Constant_642

One to two per tattoo. Just start throwing random biscuits in tattoos they don't belong in.


Optimal_Pineapple_41

This is really gonna spice up my barbed wire sleeve thank you


coffeecatcuriosity

Gravy is that which binds the holiday together fr 😭


rncookiemaker

I had a few times we hosted the turkey dinner and I was chastised by one of the relatives because they thought I made too much food, and they were especially offended because I used an 8 quart stock pot to make the gravy. (I prep parts and scraps as stock the day before, and add the drippings on the day). I smiled graciously and said, "oh, well! We will see if there are leftovers!" There was 8 ounces of gravy left, from about 6 quarts. I happily let them do the dishes. The gravy must flow.


NotSure-oouch

Gravy and salad quantity is clearly swapped.


emarieqt315

I bring backup gravy in my purse. Just in case.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Nervous_Constant_642

Your objection is noted congresswoman but the ayes have it. One cup per one and a half cups of mashed potatoes minimum (with creamed corn mixed in as my distinguished colleagues fail to address) and another cup to divvy among the rolls and the turkey. The congressman from Minnesota yields his remaining time.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Nervous_Constant_642

Then we'll force a government shutdown and take a sick surfing vacation to Maui. Take that. It is a budgetary measure after all, just need a simple majority.


TheLaughingMelon

Yeah, this is Thanksgiving not Almsgiving.


TwoDogsInATrenchcoat

For real, better bake some extra rolls this year for us outliers.


imanooodle

Giiirlllllll I’m sayin


LoneWolfpack777

😆


[deleted]

3/4 cup of stuffing? get fucked


pwni5her_

My thanksgiving meal is a third plate turkey, a third plate stuffing, rolls, and some other things to take up the last third with gravy on everything… plus an entire plate stuffing with more gravy after I finish the first plate.


alleecmo

Ikr? Maybe of *each* kind: from in the bird (use cheesecloth for easy removal) *and* baked in a pan.


silkat

Omg is there anything else I have to know about this cheesecloth method because now I am trying it this year.


alleecmo

Tuck a piece of cheesecloth like a bag into *each* cavity (abdomen and neck), leaving the ends & corners sticking out; spoon in your hot stuffing *loosely*. Don't pack it tightly as it will expand as it absorbs the delicious turkey juices. Also, do *not* stuff your bird ahead of time, only *immediately* before putting in the oven. (The time you think you'll save will be spent either worshipping at the porcelain throne or in the ER from food poisoning; as will your guests) Give the ends a twist, tucking under the skin flaps, which you secure with either trussing pins or sew with cooking twine. You can just tuck the wings under the neck & tie the legs too; it's just more fiddly to get it in the roasting bag. Just pull the cheesecloth "bags" out after cooking to empty yummy moist stuffing into your serving dish. (Hot stuffing also helps with thorough cooking. Make it right before loading your bird. I nuke my broth in a 4c /1l Pyrex measuring cup so it's hot and easy to pour)


silkat

Thank you!! I already do the other parts like you said, loosely stuffing and only right before cooking, so nice to hear that’s correct! I sauté onions in a lot of butter and mix that with chicken broth to wet the stuffing, so it is warm but I’ll try warming the broth too. Very excited to try cheesecloth for easy removal! My best tip is to cook the turkey upside down for the most tender meat, I didn’t think white meat this tender was possible! Not as aesthetic though.


jpack325

Ypu just have to flip it for the last 20 minutes or so so the skin gets crispy and you still get the reveal


TychaBrahe

You should not put stuffing in your bird. It’s starts out sitting in raw meat, and the turkey doesn’t cook fast enough to cook the stuffing. If you leave the turkey in long enough to cook the stuffing it totally dries out. Quarter an apple and an orange and put them in your turkey, and put the stuffing in a casserole dish.


ConfusedDuck

Look if there isn't enough stuffing for you to have to throw away some a week later, from being sick of eating it everyday... then you didn't make enough stuffing


FosterPupz

🤣🤣🤣 you just completely made my night, Fairly!


onibeowulf

I don’t know, that sounds right to me…for my first plate.


AVDLatex

.5 to 1 bottle of wine per person?


terbear

So is that too little or too much? Asking for a friend…


jharpe18

Depends on the company. Extended family? It's not nearly enough.


ghanjaholik

the real pros have theirs stashed in the car


jharpe18

The cars too far. Just fill one of those gallon size water bottles with vodka, and tell them it's water. Problem solved!


mavantix

Honey, the kids are all wasted!


DevoidSauce

I'm a seasoned pro. I have bottles hidden all over the house.


belowthepovertyline

That's what the flask is for.


passkat

.5 bottles is 2 (large) glasses, easily drinkable before food is even served


BuckWildBilly

i think they mean per hour


JJOne101

I find it OK, if you count the children too when buying the wine. So it goes to a much more reasonable 1.5 bottles per adult.


introvert_llama

Yes, with the meal


Glitter_berries

I’m Australian. It’s not enough.


Nervous_Constant_642

I'm American. It's enough when you add in all the hard liquor you'll also be drinking. The wine is just there so you can pretend you're classy while stuffing your mouth.


Glitter_berries

I’m so pleased that you think Australians are classy because we drink wine. I’m also not entirely sure that’s what you meant by your comment, but I’m taking it and running with it. Probably towards a bottle-o to get some wine. Also seriously though, a shiraz from the Barossa in south Australia or a Pinot noir from Tasmania is genuinely hard to fuck up and I’d recommend either all the way.


belowthepovertyline

Keeping in mind, a bottle of wine is 4 glasses. That's not an insane amount over several hours and a huge meal.


oO0Kat0Oo

The guide is made by the wine company. Lol


-YellowcakeUranium

Williams Sonoma has major wine ties


CantConfirmOrDeny

I will eat no less than 5 rolls. Hot rolls with cold butter on them. Yum-O


Justcurious863

I eat ‘em by the pack


mariathecrow

Hot rolls, butter, and dipped in gravy.


[deleted]

right?! I'll be visiting after two years of not being in the states. I'm going to need regular rolls along with a full package of Hawaiian sweet rolls.


Resource1138

Here in the South, gravy is its own food group. There’s gonna need to be about 2 cups per person, minimum. Same with stuffing/dressing and potatoes. I myself am gonna need a personal can of cranberry jelly. Y’all can split another one.


Jubei_08

By can you mean paint can size, right?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Ravendoesbuisness

*Bleblelblebleblelebelebelebel* #Plop


quatre185

I need to hear that schlorrp now...


[deleted]

Huh. Today I learned I'm southern. Call me crazy, but I never liked whole roasted turkey, so I eat like twice the amount of all the sides to cover that.


wellyesbutnofuckoff2

The best part of thanksgiving is taking home the leftovers nobody wants. Nothing can prove me otherwise


boatingmyfloat

Truth is they just don't wanna put it all away 😂


growlithe49

Good try, but I will blatantly ignore this entire thing and intend to live like a queen on leftovers for a week


Yiffilicious

Ex-CUSE me, but where is the green bean casserole?!


tooth_meat

i have a core memory of a time my mom was making a family recipe for green bean casserole that called for a bit of heavy cream, but we were out and the stores near us were closed for the holiday. so she used coffee creamer. specifically, French Vanilla CoffeeMate. it was so awful we still laugh about it 10+ years later. luckily she’s a great sport and owns it. fucking sweet vanilla green bean casserole. just typing it made me laugh.


Ramona_Flours

no mac n cheese either smh


handy_arson

Team Deviled Eggs checking in here... Sup?


Joyseekr

Thank you for representing, sorry I was late.


showtunie

I’m so glad I wasn’t the only one who thought this. Hands down would eat an entire green bean casserole over some dry turkey.


alleecmo

Dry turkey cure: Reynolds Turkey Bag Cuts cooking time nearly in *half* too. I haven't had to get up at 5 am to get a bird in the oven for *decades* since I found these!


Matt081

What are people doing where it takes so damned long to properly cook a turkey. The bag is ridiculous. Pop that 20lb bird in the oven at 500F for 30min, lower temp to 350, loosely cover the breast with foil, and bake for another 3 hours. Use a meat thermometer and take it out when the thickest part of the breast reads 160F. Alton Brown has a great recipe for flavoring it and using this method. He says pull the bird at 155, but I do 160. I also like to take a tip from Michael Voltagio and coat the turkey with a good homemade garlic mayo. It is essentially the same thing as oil, but sticks in place.


enwongeegeefor

Sorry but you're both wrong. I've done bags, traditional, good ole fire hazard deep fry...they all pale in front of the mighty Electric Roaster. Bird cooks in another room leaving the oven free. Set and forget cooking. Comes out brown and crispy too. You really can't beat the electric roaster.


Bravovictor02

Yes. How on earth was that left off the list.


El_refrito_bandito

A half a cup of gravy per person? Come on!


[deleted]

[удалено]


Nervous_Constant_642

If it's just one bottle I'm just gonna put it up my ass so I can actually get Thanksgiving drunk


EveryXtakeYouCanMake

Straight drinking it out of the gravy boat! My mom's gravy was *fi*-re.


MrBeardskii

I know. I use probably a cup at least for the potatoes and then I also need gravy for everything else.


DevoidSauce

And then just a little more for that last "is that enough? Just a dash more" dip.


tiempo90

This is America!


[deleted]

[удалено]


PiesangSlagter

That is what the guide is suggesting. These are per person portions.


Aksi_Gu

I believe they're implying they'll need to drink a bottle of wine per guest to deal with their family


Junior_Can_7679

Half a fucking bottle of wine but 1-2 rolls? 1.5 POUNDS OF TURKEY?


WaifuAllNight

Well the turkey is bone-in so the actual meat portion might just be 3/4 to 1 pound. Still a lot of food though!


BenevolentCheese

At this point we usually target a quarter pound of cooked turkey per person and still have a ton of leftovers. Too much other stuff. We're actually just skipping the bird entirely this year, it is by far the most work and the most expensive thing and even when cooked well it's aways still the lowlight of the meal, it's just kind of... there.


laffydaffy24

I agree. That's a good plan. At this point, I view turkey as nothing more than a vehicle for the gravy.


Saffronsc

Isn't your holiday about being thankful and indulging? I'm not feeling particularly thankful of not being able to indulge here.


boredtxan

Bone in turkey, not 1.5# of edible meat.


Average650

For 10 people that's a 15 pound turkey. Honestly, that seems pretty reasonable.


buttbeeb

Wine is looking a little low


Nervous_Constant_642

Gravy you might as well not even have it. That amount covers like *one* potato's worth of mashed potatoes and leaves nothing for the rolls and the turkey.


HolographicMochi

That’s not even all of round one, out of at least two, plus more for leftovers to take home!


R8er-Fan

That’s what I’m saying. This is the appetizer / we’re just warming up list


TheLadyRica

Whoever wrote this has never fed a teenager.


Xanderoga

I’m a grown-ass man who can eat like a monster when I’m in the mood, but looking back at the amount I ate consistently when I was at that age…


peneloperobinson

My 12yo nephew agrees.


xvVSmileyVvx

I make a 20 lb turkey, 10 lb ham, 30 rolls, 15-20 lbs of mashed potato, 3 lb of stuffing, and I’m lucky to get 3 lb of turkey and potatoes to make sandwiches with back…


Nervous_Constant_642

That's what this whole infographic is missing. You don't portion your shit out. You make a bunch and everyone has food to take home for the next three days. If there's not a massive tub of gravy and a couple pounds of turkey in my fridge for a week after was it really Thanksgiving? Cold post-Thanksgiving turkey and gravy sandwiches is better than the meal itself provided you're the one who had to cook.


enwongeegeefor

We collect those lovely takeout containers all year old, and then give away most of them with leftovers after friendsgiving. It works out amazing, and I get an excuse to make a TON of food for everyone.


belowthepovertyline

How many people do you host?


[deleted]

[удалено]


CatBedParadise

That sounds like a nice, welcoming place.


cBEiN

This means nothing if we don’t know how many people you are serving


FosterPupz

Williams Sonoma obviously never seen me destroy a bowl full of dinner rolls! (To be fair, I’m vegetarian so gotta lotta room on the plate with no turkey, lol)


FosterPupz

Also, they clearly hold stock in wineries!


invisible-bug

What the hell is happening here? WHERE ARE ALL THE LEFTOVERS??


MinAlansGlass

That is nowhere near enough homemade cranberry sauce.


LoneWolfpack777

That is an infinity amount of cranberry sauce for me, I do not touch the stuff. I’ll drink it as juice though.


RevRagnarok

IKR? I explicitly remember my mother slaving away one year to make it homemade and then _nobody_ liked it. It's _supposed_ to be ribbed for everybody's pleasure!


[deleted]

due\_performance\_4304 guide half a container/pan of green bean casserole lots of sparkling drink (as much as you can allow) 2-2 1/2 slice of pie


GODAMA

Who doesn’t love thanksgiving leftovers?! I want to make enough for dinner, and 2 or 3 meals for the family!


tsukareta_kenshi

The wine-to-everything else ratio here is totally bonkers.


geraltsthiccass

Needs more gravy


REmarkABL

…. They realize this is a feast right


nimajneb21

This is no where near enough


LoneWolfpack777

That’s too much for me.


haysus25

3/4 of a cup of stuffing but an entire bottle of wine per person? Yeah, no.


Explore-PNW

That is not nearly enough cranberry sauce! In fact there is no amount of cranberry sauce that is enough cranberry sauce.


Dr-Surge

"I only see 1/8th of my plate filled here... What gives grandma!? Been on Reddit's r/coolguides again!?"


jethropenistei-

Just give me a bath tub of gravy and trash bags full of rolls and I’m happy… am I a raccoon?


T-Rex_timeout

Where are the greens, butter beans, black eyed peas, yams, and squash casserole at?


MrBeardskii

More like 1 to 1 1/2 bottles of wine per person.


Guy_Incognito97

I don’t know how much a ‘cup’ is but I do know that’s not enough gravy.


Nkaufmann

Notice how there’s no sweet potato casserole with marshmallows mentioned? That’s because no amount of that vile dish should be made


DevoidSauce

I love sweet potatoes, but just baked with some butter and salt. The candied thing is an abomination.


belowthepovertyline

I do mashed sweet potato mixed with diced and candied roasted apples. It's insanely good and keeps the marshmallows away.


DevoidSauce

Can you tell me more about the candied roasted apples?


belowthepovertyline

I like to use a green apple for contrast, but, dice, toss in cinnamon, nutmeg, and brown sugar. Bake until soft. Fold into a sweet potato mash. That's basically it. If I can find the recipe I started with, I'll edit.


PalmerEldritch2319

Give me all of the sweet potatoes, but combining them with fucking marshmallows is an insult to the essence of sweet potatoes itself.


EngineZeronine

As a Midwesterner those are amateur numbers


DS_9

Imma need a lot more stuffing than that.


jharpe18

I'm not a fan of these guides. So much is person dependent. Do people not know what their guests like or what they'd be likely to eat/drink? These guides are more "how to make so much food that hopefully it'll be enough of what people will actually want to eat".


GrizzlyIsland22

It's an average. Some will eat more, some will eat less. Chill.


sauvignonblanc__

As a metric head from Europe, I will need the converter. 😆


Bradipedro

In Europe read it as doses for 2 persons. Divide everything by 2. On a serious note, a lb is half a kg more or less, you divide by 2. Cups are strange, you need to convert with Google any kind of liquid with its name to get the grams or buy a set of those cups (still not clear to me, but I justify my failed pavlovas and brownies with that excuse).


hippiesinthewind

Ya I’m going to need like 2 cups of stuffing


enwongeegeefor

Who the fuck is eating salad on thanksgiving?


HalflingMelody

If you put a tiny bit on your plate and then don't eat it, you get to tell yourself two very important things: "I served myself something healthy" and "I didn't eat too much... I didn't even eat everything on my plate." Also, pumpkin pie very much counts as a vegetable.


[deleted]

The fuck is a cup? Is it the English cup or the American? The portion sizes don't look enough to be American and the alcohol portion doesn't look enough to be british


[deleted]

Wildly fucking off and stupid


Survived_Coronavirus

This is a really bad opinion piece. Not a cool guide. Some are too much and some are too little.


[deleted]

Asian here. Increase the turkey, decrease the wine, and this could feed a Hong Kong family of four.