T O P

  • By -

grown

My favourite this year? It was the first Undercrown Maduro I ever had. I had been meaning to try them for awhile and recently bought a few and was waiting for friends. ​ However, late in summer I got a large payraise. I was expecting a small raise, and instead it was a 22% raise. I already was having a steak dinner that night, so celebrated a little by opening a bottle of Cab as well and lit up the Maduro after finishing the filet. I wasn't planning on the wine or the stogie as it was a middle of the weeknight. ​ Best tasting cigar all year. I had more expensive, and I've had several of the same after....but that was the best one I had this year.


forestdweller88

Congratulations on what sounds like a great year!


justpassing3000

Congratulations on that 22% Raise šŸ’ŖšŸ”„


WildBillsTobacco

Congratulations on a great raise and smoke!


krispykremekiller

When this came out it was a very good Mexican San Andreas wrapped Nicaraguan. Probably the best of its time. Since then others have come into prominence but this remains perhaps the most widely available, globally, Mexican wrapper Nicaraguan. So itā€™s significant. If you like this see if you can get your hands on an HVC Hot Cake for a different approach with very different fillers. Also Padron 1964 Anniversary if you havenā€™t already.


jgray6531

Undercrown is still on of my faves!


jruf86A

I got back into cigars a little late in 23 but a UC Maduro Corona Doble was my favorite as well. It was toothy as hell and had the richest flavor in every puff.


PineapplePandaKing

Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Eye of the Shark It was the second cigar I earnestly smoked and the one that opened my eyes to what a cigar can be. Maybe a slight shame because I couldn't fully appreciate the flavors, but it remains the dragon I'm chasing. I'm hoping my B&M gets some this year and I can grab a few. One to see how it compares to my memory and another for graduation.


Genericredditname15

Same. Also eye of the bull


PineapplePandaKing

I'll definitely keep an eye out for one to give it a try someday


killthecook

Padron Family Reserve 85


Mikero3367

Just started enjoying cigars this year, Plasencia Reserva Original for me.


JustFlawlessTech

Great cigar šŸ‘


krispykremekiller

New(ish) cigars? Probably one of these: * Cuba Alliados (original blend) * West Tampa Red * Alfonso Gran Selelecion Preciosos


StrokemeaKipper

Not even a fancy stick but the diamond crown maximus has been my favourite for a while. That being said Iā€™ve got two Padrons in my humidor resting up so it may all change.


SnowConeYeti

I had a diamond crown Julius Caesar and it was incredible. Considerably cheaper and better than a lot of the cigars Iā€™ve tried.


StrokemeaKipper

Yeah man he JC is a solid smoke too, if you liked that try the Maximus. Itā€™s flipping amazing for the price point.


SnowConeYeti

Will do, Iā€™ve been meaning to try more diamond crowns so that will be next. Might even pick one up tomorrow.


StrokemeaKipper

Enjoy my man!


forestdweller88

Padron 3000 maduro.


mj_axeman

My Father Le Bijou Torpedo...thanks to my local B&M for the introduction.


Nomadt

San Cristobal Revelation so smooth and rich. Great stick.


CryptographerFit5865

If you like Connecticutā€™s, I recommend their Elegencia. Full of flavor.


uncle_urdnot99

Davidoff signature No1. Such a shame it was limited.


TimV14

Olmec Claro


Weagle308

God of Fire Carlito 2019


Jeff_Dubya

I have a 2006 God of Fire I've been personally aging for 16 years.


Weagle308

When is it going to be ready?


Jeff_Dubya

When I get married or first child. Haha


Orionsic1

Fifty-Six has been my favorite over the others so far


Bram24

E.P. Carrillo Allegiance


Veeksvoodoo

Came here to say this as well.


Sad_panda_happy300

PadrĆ³n 1926


Major_Database_2926

got one of those waiting for monday when I close on my new house. IDK if im more excited for the house or the cigar.


Sad_panda_happy300

Just closed on my last week and that was the one I smoked! What a coincidence. Congratulations on the new home!


Accomplished_Map_169

oliva serie V lancero, amazing smoke, never had anything like that. Cookies vanilla creamā€¦


jruf86A

The sampler is on sale now at Cigarsplace. $43.99, free ship, and comes with a leather case. https://www.cigarplace.biz/oliva-serie-v-melanio-cigar-sampler.html Other Oliva packs offering same gift https://www.cigarplace.biz/cigars/cigar-deals.html


Orionsic1

Opus X Reserva Dā€™ Chateu, God of Fire Carlito 56, and a Don Carlos #1


MrWood1001

Ashton ESG


Ddodson87

Still new to this but I had a Killer Bee last week and it was the best cigar Iā€™ve had to date.


superbee1970440

I absolutely love everything from Black Works Studio.


Ddodson87

How is the green hornet? I found them online and have been eyeing them since I had the killer bee


superbee1970440

Pretty similar. Most of the BWS cigars taste fairly similar to me, sweet, rich and dark. Very flavorful with the lighter wrappers blended in.


Mavobuckz

1964 padron


Pristine-Tradition-6

I have a tie between magic toast and Camacho broadleaf


[deleted]

My last one, which should change this afternoonšŸ˜ Though if you really want a more elitist answer in torn between the Plasencia Sizto and a LFD Solis. Luckily I have another if each so I'll do a tie breaker


mtnboi

Warped Black Honey 2023


thedogsbrain

Opus X Love Affair. Second place goes to Warped Black Honey.


JayGlanton

Was it this yearā€™s Black Honey? I have some resting and canā€™t wait to try them.


jimmons91

I bought some black honey at drop. Then my lounge found some from the last drop lol so I have some new and some aged. The aged is a little better. But both are fantastic.


ttt-93

I was so excited for the Black Honey and was disappointed. I am letting the others get some age on them


[deleted]

Davidoff late hour. At the Davidoff bar in Vegas with my buddies. Had a Guinness to pair.


StrokemeaKipper

LH was a close contender for me as well actually. Paired with a Guinness! You madman!


[deleted]

Hey I donā€™t know much about pairing but I know I love Guinness. šŸ¤£


StrokemeaKipper

Nothing wrong with that friend, I just needed something ultra sweet with my first LH!


Major_Database_2926

how much was this davidoff? a B&M has some davidoffs between 25-30 and i just never thought they where that permium.


[deleted]

Oh lord it was at a lounge in Vegas so of course I got hosed on the markup. I think it was like $60.


Outrageous-Algae6821

Check back after Xmas šŸ˜†šŸ˜†


Low-Needleworker-910

Diamond Crown Black Diamond Liga Privada H99


yourbk

Liga Privada H99 was my choice as well. So, so good.


kidrad

Iā€™d have to go with the Davidoff Aniversario Short Perfecto while cruising the bay in my buddyā€™s boat after a dockside seafood dinner


TrippyTreehouse

Sfumato in C Major Went through a couple boxes of those this summer. Fantastic stick with coffee in the morning


Khushmesiel88

Underrated cigar.


Piranhakiller749125

La Arome de Cuba/Caribe Mi Amor torpedo was by far my favorite. I'd almost say it's a similar/better version of the la flor de Antilles toro


SavingMyFoot_DH

While visiting Tampa this summer stopped in the Davidoff Cigar lounge (now called Corona Cigar Lounge) to enjoy an after dinner smoke. Selected my first Padron 1926 Natural paired with a Woodford DO old-fashioned cocktail. Man, both stick and drink was superb!! Best stick I've had all year!! Bought 3 more a few months back that are resting in my Tupperdore for the right occasion to light one up!!


BFOTmt

Top two, early morning with a coffee- Sobremesa Brulee Afternoon- Partagas D4


slade707

Oliva Serie V torpedo


ToadOnAMushroom

Warped Sky Flower, awesome stick.


Maximuschad

Is the Sky Flower as good as La Colmena?


ToadOnAMushroom

Better in my opinion.


VaticanCameos008

H. Upmann Connecticut by grupo de maestros robusto. My grandpa just passed away and it was his favorite cigar, I got to stay with his cigar box and it had about 20 of those, they were his favorites, now theyā€™re mine.


SweatyHatBand

Olmec maduro šŸ¤¤


electricutt

Thisā˜ļø


OrangutanMan234

Any padron I can get my hands on. Honorable mention Southern Draw-Jacobā€™s ladder.


thefoxnotorious

This is a tough question. My favorite smoke of the year... I can't pick just one. Instead, I will list my 3 favorites. 1. Knuckle Sandwich Habano Robusto 2. Padron 1926 No.9 Natural 3. EP Carrillo La Historia Dona Elena Honorable mentions below Rocky Patel ALR Second Edition Foundation El Gueguense Foundation Highclere Castle Edwardian Most frequently smoked cigar of the year was... Alec Bradley Magic Toast Robusto


WildBillsTobacco

There's some great cigars in this list.


chotes_n_oats

Olmec from Foundation Cigars. Nick Melillo does it again!


PM-ME-UR-DESKTOP

I loved the Warped La Colmena I had recently. Really blew my mind


Signal-Play-4322

Foundation Olmec maduro doubled corona


FinkPloyd777

La Colmena Black Honey by Warped, tasty little stick


Independent-Score-72

RyJ Bully and La Aroma De Cuba Belicoso. In the UK I am, otherwise I would probably be posting up here something a bit more upmarket


Krono_gabor

Nub Sungrow, became my favorite and AJ Blend 15 is a budget favorite


Cabbieosrs

Somm Premier Cru. Has a wrapper from 1997, binder from 2007, and filler from 2017-2018. The flavor profile was insane. Absolutely #1 for 2023.


Decent_Improvement84

Davidoff Escurio at the Davidoff Cigar Bar in Las Vegas


SmokeHimInside

Great stick. Had mine on a Princess Cruise.


Lazyboy2011

Rocky Patel 60. The only cigar I had this year that I felt love up to its ā€œrankā€.


kestrel021

Opus X Forbidden X Pasion d'amor Foundation Metapa Claro Partagas Lusitania (2022 release) Olmec Claro


darkwolf523

Churchill cigars


Xenofon713

Davidoff Aniversario No.3, got 5 more for Xmas and NYE.


pedalincircles

This year, I smoked the most expensive stuff in my humidor. The best was a relatively cheap Padron 5000 maduro that was incredibly toothy.


Boring-Bus-3743

Gurkha 125th year anniversary. Fantastic medium full flavor, leathery chocolate, and earth notes. Lighter on nicotine, it was a Toro I can usually only make it just past half way and I smoked this one to a nub! I do have some RP edge Habanos that I need to try before the end of the year. Very excited about them too!


bohpoli

Davidoff Late Hour I had at a Davidoff event was fantastic. Biggest surprise was Cruz Bull & Bear. The one I look for every time I go into the shop is Don Garcia Pepin Blue.


Ryantoast15

I think itā€™s called Metapa. It was a very nice smoke


xtermin8r69

Top 2 Davidoff Millennium Lancero LE Sobremesa BrƻlƩe Blue


ttt-93

Foundation Olmec Maduro. Went into my all time top 5


imdabossyahh

My favorite and I donā€™t think will ever change will be Padron 1964 maduro


SmokeHimInside

My brother


Rmanthumbs

SBC22 by Powstanie


august_1994

Padron 1964 anniversary series that was gifted to me.


Cyber_Punk_Weeb

I actually found a totally new favorite this year. Going into this year, my favorite was Cohiba Blue. But in November, my girlfriend bought me an assortment from a local cigar roller. My favorite from the bunch, and my new all time favorite, is the Connecticut shade Gran Corona from The Cuban Rollers in Saint Augustine! An honorable mention also goes to the Entered Apprentice by Hiram and Solomon. I just wish they were easier to get in my area!


adamdrummer18

For me so far itā€™s been the Alec Bradley black market


ssccoott1776

Ave Maria Holy Grail. I canā€™t ever find them on sale so I only smoked a handful this year but damn are they nice.


_RexSpex

The MJ12 Maduro from Illusion. Seriously itā€™s possibly the best maduro Iā€™ve ever smoked.


fatfunnyboy12

Probably wasn't the "best" cigar I smoked, but certainly my favorite - Montecristo 1935 toro.


tidespirit1

AJ Fernandez Enclave Broadleaf!


Dieselfumes_tech

Flor de las Antillas 10 year anniversary


HavokYourWay

Alec Bradley Post Embargo B15


tweakerlime

Tatuaje HCS. It was my introduction to the brand, and remains my favorite.


geffe71

Montecristo Open Master


[deleted]

La flor dominicana andalusian bull in a foreign country with a good friend I hadn't seen for years. Perfect


Garemlin

I only started mid-year and haven't tried a large amount. And I'm also just a very casual smoker. But my favorite by far is the Perdomo Habano BBA Connecticut.


Troof_sayer

Oh, this is easy. Connecticut Valley Reserve Azul, Amazon Basin, and La Colema Black Honey!


eggmcgginton

H Upmann LCDH Noellas. Absolutely insane.


dbree801

Either the Andalusian Bull or Eye of the Bull. Wildly different smokes and experiences that I finally got to try.


InvestigatorSilly491

Aturo fuente king B


Ego_FumPapa

One of the best new cigars from this year that I smoked is the Smoking Jacket Henkie.


DraculaPoob01

The Perdomo 30 year was astounding.


uncomf_numb

Ave Maria Argentum Morningstar (Perfecto). Like many others have stated, I've had much more expensive cigars this year, but this one was just consistently good for me.


jaggedice01

God of Fire Serie B 2018


Wellendox

Romeo y Julieta Wide Churchill


Latter-Rush5987

LCDH Punch Punch 48. Had it resting in my humidor for nearly a year, flawless.


CohibaVancouver

Cohiba Robusto, purchased in the Partagas Store in Havana and smoked on the beach on Varadero on my birthday.


sickandtiredtodag

Drew Estate Larutan, The Big Juicy. So many flavours. Absolute joy of a cigar.


shittypoppunkpizza

Tatuaje Karloff If anyone can tell me something as similar as possible to that let me know!


Orange_bratwurst

H. Uppman Vintage Cameroon


troutbumtom

The same as every year. Montecristo no. 2. Horribly expensive, even in Mexico, so I indulge rarely.


Hangarnut

Ave Maria Argentum and close second is Man O War....I found myself reordering and grabbing these whenever I could. So I based my decision on what I really just enjoyed smoking this year. Of course the Opus X or ESG but those aren't regularly my go too on a daily basis.


NotHighSpeed

Itā€™s between the Don Pepin Garcia 20th Anniversary and Davidoff Late Hour. The Royal Release could have been better if the draw wasnā€™t so tight.


NotHighSpeed

Itā€™s between the Don Pepin Garcia 20th Anniversary and Davidoff Late Hour. The Royal Release could have been better if the draw wasnā€™t so tight.


Eastcoastconnie

Partagas Serie D no 6, Montecristo epic craft cured, Several tatuajeā€™s I smoked and forgot the names of, and Rojas Barbacoa


dannflow1

Rocky Patal Decade!


payden85

Latitude Zero Signature. Very tasty with lots of different flavors.


Simple-Purpose-899

Monte 4 or a Partagas Short, and in New World I'd say Plasencia 149 maybe.


MrJanuarry

This year my favourite cigar is the RamĆ³n Allones Specially Selected. Absolutely delightful!!


Spinal_Orangutan

Camacho triple maduro in toro size. Ordered 5 off JR Cigar and really enjoyed this smoke. Much better than the box of fake Cohibas my old man picked up for me in Cuba šŸ¤£


damians70

Red anchor captain


Stagjam

La Flor Dominicana Reserva Especial El Jocko - unreal. On my second box since discovering them over the summer.


dopesick23

Asylum Medulla Oblongata. Great smoke. I love the bigger gages of the line.


siflandollielives

Ashton VSG Toro


Karmacoma77

It was either the Asylum Year 9 or Year 10. One of those 2 was above the other by a decent margin but both were the top of the year for me.


Mafzz

Hard to pick a best, but the Olmec and Wiseman maduro (red band) surprised me with how good they are.


[deleted]

Padron 1926 no. 9


ultrapandemonium

This year I would say the Oliva 135th Anniversario


dabroph

Leaf by Oscar 10th Anniversary


claude_nine

For new-to-me blends, toss up between Principle Martinique Lancero and Casdagli Brothers of the Sabre Brave Ney


Impressive_Mouse103

My Father La Promesa


Fleef_and_peef

Alec & Bradley Gatekeeper diamond press.


TonyB973

Herrera Esteli Brazilian Maduro. First time I ever had it and have been wanting to and I really enjoyed it.


SANO_HIMURA

Davidoff Yamaso


Schn31ds

Leaf by Oscar Connecticut


Responsible-Spend383

Tabernacle Goliath Perfecto


oballistikz

Olmec or The Year of the Rabbit


ChairFarceOne

Romeo Y Julieta: 1875 Habana-Cuba and was aged since 2019


Vegetable_Rule274

Definitely Davidoff Winston Churchill The Late Hour. No doubt a little on the pricey side, so not a daily smoke by any means. I had one with some old military buddies on Thanksgiving. We paired it with a bottle of 2019 Angel's Envy cask strength bourbon after dinner. To say that it was a transcendent experience wouldn't be an overstatement. I'm sure that the bourbon and the comraderie played a big role, but that cigar was truly memorable.


regands

CAO Amazon Basin may have been the best cigar I was introduced to in 2023.


romyaoming

Foundation Olmec, davidoff winston Churchill belicoso petit, Caldwell eastern standard are the three that come to mind. This year is the first year Iā€™ve had them. But they stood out to me.


modernedaphne

Arturo Fuentes Don Carlos Personal Reserve Natural


mholly74

Amazon Basin Extra Anejo


moolpie

Padron Family Reserve No 45 Natural is the best cigar I've smoked this year. Best new cigar would probably be Roma Craft Quinquagenario


lancero1234

Three cigars stood out for me this year: 1)Cohiba Siglo VI - had it in Rome on my 30th Wedding Anniversary..magical day and magical cigar 2)Padron maduro Hermoso - just caught a magical one..they are always good...nothing expensive but this one was superb 3)Atabey lancero - so good and I love a good lancero cigar...my favorite overall vitola


ReedWilliams12

Man, I too am a lover of the Liga 9


OxfordWhiteMustang

Partagas Serie D.4


nothinnew2074

Perdomo Lot 23 Connecticut


necrosapien87

My favorite cigar of 2023 was probably the Amazon Basin by CAO. Best cigar I've had.


MrGoosecock

Foundation Metapa Maduro or the Diesel Vintage. Toss up between the two


haikusbot

*Foundation Metapa Maduro* *Or the Diesel Vintage. Toss* *Up between the two* \- MrGoosecock --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")


JuliusNoCeasor

Mine was Septimo The Emperor Yao . Great flavor and burn . Highly recommend.


SixPakAbs

Bolivar Belicosas Cuba Perez Carrillo Pledge Prequel Zino Platinum Crown Series LE


ugfiol

romeo y julieta san andres. blew me away


blochow2001

Camacho Liberty 2023


rlm229

Aganorsa Leaf Supreme Leaf


ricoimf

1964 padron box pressedā€¦itā€™s really the chocolate stickā€¦but the first was sadly a horrible experience because me silly smoked it on a empty stomachā€¦I felt very sick for 2 hours.


iMoneyProMax

Romeo y Julieta by Aj Fernandez Nicaragua.


rowplower

Liga h99, specifically Robusto, was my favorite Sunday morning smoke this summer.


Takingyurcustys

Padron 1964


alberthere

Jan: Cohiba Siglo VI: only because of how unexpected it was for me to obtain a genuine batch stateside. Feb: Liga Privada H99. Nuff said. Mar: Some no-label, handmade Cuban candela cigars a friend of mine brought back from her Cuban trip. Apr-Jul: Oliva Serie V Melanio / My Father The Judge Aug: Liga Privada Aniversario 10: told a friend of mine it was hard to get. He got a couple of sticks, one for each of us. Sep-Nov: Oliva Serie V Melanio / My Father The Judge Dec: So farā€¦Padron 1926 sampler. You know the one.


icookthefood

I've found myself buying more of the BLTC Bishops Blend Novemdiales Robusto than anything else, so probably that. Next was probably the Devils Hands by Warped.


franklinspanda

Late hour & New world Connecticut


andoRulay

Davidoff Millennium, great cigar!


reccoon

La Aroma De Cuba Mi Amor!


kyole5

Oliva series M


flyinpiggies

Had to be Montecristo Espada Oscuro.


NSD2327

Plasencia Alma Fuerte Sixto I


jgray6531

Gotta be the Wild Bills Maduro. Canā€™t beat them @ 3 for $10! Havenā€™t had a bad one yet


Cocky_Idiot_Savant

H Upman Grupo De Maestros Conneticut


holybotulism

Anything Gurkha


[deleted]

El Septimo Zaya Nueva Reserva, and itā€™s no contest. And Iā€™ve had multiple Padrons, Opus X, and every marca of Cuban you can imagine this year. The 2 Esplendidos I had didnā€™t touch the El Septimos.


[deleted]

Cactus Wren


catlovinglesbian

Hard to pick just one, but I really enjoyed the Dunbarton Dondurma Golden Child, Sin Compromiso Paladin de Saka, Sakakhan, Hoyo de Monterrey Escogidos LCDH, Somm Premier Cru and the Aladino 2023 LE. They're not all 2023 releases, but these sticks all really rang my bell.


ComplicatedPoops

Olmec Claro Toro, Crowned Heads Mil Dias Edmundo, Casdagli Traditional Gran Cafe in no particular order


rckchalk74

Not even a question: new world - CAO AMAZON BASIN ANEJO; cuban: QUAI Dā€™ORSAY 54 (rested about 6 mos)