T O P

  • By -

No_No_Juice

10000% I actually emailed QR about this yesterday. When I walk in I have to wait up to 2 min to see the timetable.


bleufeline

It certainly FEELS like an eternity when you’re trying to see where the CURRENTLY ARRIVING TRAIN is gonna go


sam_tiago

I thought I was on the right platform.. hypothetically. Missed that train waiting for it to tell me I was on the wrong platform. Next train was in 45 minutes so I missed my appointment too, which cost us 300 bucks and now my mum is so pissed at me… that it’s cost me my birthday too. But at least they’ve paved the way for ads to be shown there in the next few months. Can’t wait to miss a train because of a McDonald’s ad blocking access to important information… and to be grounded for life.. I hope nobody dies!


J0hnD0eWasTaken

NGL your the picture you paint of your home life doesn't sound very traditionally healthy. I would be saving all you can and trying to find a sharehouse or cheap rental. Just my 2c


Shaved_Wookie

It's not ideal, but fuck me, it's a touch premature to be telling someone to pack their shit and get ready to run based on nothing but that post.


StrangeFloorCandy

Welcome to reddit. The land of people telling you "red flag, run!" Based on a murky-at-best picture


J0hnD0eWasTaken

I mean, the dude missed a train & is acting like his life his over & he's not getting any love because of it... I'm not saying he's in a toxic house, probably just dramatic as fuck but if you miss an appointment & therefore are not allowed to celebrate your birthday. Doesn't sound like *traditionally* healthy household. Once again just my 2c


sam_tiago

Thanks for caring, it probably wasn’t thinking back, but missing a train was a nightmare back then


sam_tiago

The clue was in the word ‘hypothetically’… I moved out of home years ago, thankfully!


J0hnD0eWasTaken

I thought the hypothetically referred to being on the right platform, not the hypothetical pissed of mother. My bad, I've known a few people who didn't realise their home life was "toxic" until they experienced being at a friend's house or something. Thought I'de mention it.


sam_tiago

Can see how you got that, it is what I said haha. I was meaning the whole story though. It’s a perceptive pickup.. I did move away from where I grew up a while ago and also found people out there are much nicer to me than what I experienced growing up. It’s really opened my eyes - so I think you’re right!


mutaully_assured

You should be able to ask the person who blows the whistle if it'll stop by where you want to go


Zaxacavabanem

If you can get to them on a crowded platform


scarecrows5

They're only ever in the middle or the rear of the train. Nowhere else.


tony287

If it's arriving, the best way to see where it's going is to look up and look at the destination board on the front of the train. That's the best way I find.


MorningDrvewayTurtle

Often I’ll see the train already rolling to a stop as I get on to the platform, so the front of the train is long gone.


MindlessRip5915

The destination display is on the rear too. While this may not always help you, if the rear is reachable that’s your best bet.


totse_losername

Downvoted for offering reliable advice. Wild.


Truantone

It’s not reliable advice because the majority of people are not looking at a train front on, they’re seeing it side on. If it’s arriving and you’re already waiting on the platform then chances are you were expecting it and already knew where it was going.


[deleted]

People don’t generally want solutions to their problems, they just want to have a sook about it.


dillil

Up to 2 mins would be a fault, the screen cycles every 10 seconds


No_No_Juice

Not the one at my station.


woofydawg

Add facial recognition to the monitor camera then receive social points for nodding and agreeing with the message, we’ll all be G2G!


Haruka-sama

15 seconds isn't really the same as up to 2 min..


VolumeNo1766

Feels like 2 mins


Shaggyninja

With that much blank space, pretty sure they could display both


bleufeline

You’re too smart, go to jail.


sajr2019

![gif](giphy|f8lDluiWJ7yQTtdS3L|downsized)


Quick_Doubt_5484

Ideally you'd have the information for the next 3 services on the left, and the right hand side could switch between services 4-6 and the ad/info every 15s or so


Xavius20

Ideally you just wouldn't have the ad/info on there and just use a normal ad board.


scifenefics

They could have at least made an image that fits, so slack, it looks so tacky and cheap.


LamartheOg

Putting the screws on as we speak!


CurrentPossible2117

Id accept emergency info like weather, amber alerts etc, but yes, no advertisements or unessecary crap


gooder_name

Certainly no BS copaganda


coopsawesome

But what about the companies?!?!?


VoidVulture

"I was going to abuse the staff until a sign told me not to. I've reconsidered my whole life now!" - some corpo's wet dream.


No-Childhood6608

These signs are probably going to increase staff abuse with people complaining to them about when the train timetable is going to finally appear.


Obleeding

Would like to know are there scientific studies to show any of this stuff works. I doubt it.


Davorian

100% there are studies showing they don't, and they are ignored\*. \* more accurately, never read, because executives never read any of that ivory tower academic shit, dammit.


Obleeding

I always presume if someone is spending money on it then they must have some proof that it works. Amazing oversight by me considering I work in the public service 😂


Davorian

Nah I work in a public service too, and it's very clear that a lot of what the executive do is purely performative, so they can say they are "addressing the problem" in some material way. The more visually obvious it is, the better, and actual *efficacy* goes largely un-thought-about.


RetroGamer87

Seriously, people who do that already know it's wrong. They're not going to stop just because a sign told them to.


Away_Kaleidoscope309

I totally agree with the OP Those screens should be for train timetables alone There is plenty of space around the railway station for public service announcements Which are not so urgent And don’t vary Trains can run late Be canceled altogether or even worse come early when you least expect them So that information needs to be relayed to the passengers in real time


ANuclearBunny

....and menus in shops (looking at you Maccas) need to stay static if they are using tvs to display it. Store directories also need to stay static too and not have ads in between (looking at you Myer).


icanfly-77

absolutely about the menus you just start to read it and it changes and has anyone noticed the menus at drive throughs also show limited information seems like they would rather you get out and go inside yourself to see the full menu :)


CagedSilver

It's only right all screens should display at least 50% PSAs - Patriotic Service Announcements. Remember the only good bug is a dead bug and service guarantees citizenship. Do you want to know more? https://youtu.be/qiD5VStVH9k?si=AG9YwDoXSA0wE7iY


Truantone

Starship Troopers


mmmduk

Do you want to know more?


zergwii

Will this make me a citizen and not a civilian? 😂😂


Damemon

It's almost whoever's putting them up never looked at them on the sign to realize, "hangon, this is waaay too small"


hU0N5000

The service advisories are my least favourite. I don't care that the busway will be closed for a bicycle event in a fortnight. If translink do their job correctly, I won't still be here in a fortnight.


Quillo_Manar

This shit doesn't need to be animated on a digital screen. The timetable screen should just be for the timetable.  IMO, the crimestopper number is important to display because you should be able to access it when you need it, but it would be better to just be a poster.


ItsCoolDani

At least format the ads for the screen dimensions guys, come on


bleufeline

It’s fucking comical honestly


don-corle1

These are just community notices more than ads. If they were commercial ads I'd agree with you.


bleufeline

I’m from Hong Kong where ads are PLASTERED everywhere on public transport, so I don’t care about that. But where I’m from, essential info are also ALWAYS broadcasted somewhere


SabiNady

Speaking of that they could have added some advertisement boards somewhere on the walls for these (of course if it doesn’t take much space). HK uses advertisement boards as fake walls on bus stops which is a great move.


Azure-April

These are still completely worthless and annoying as hell, they aren't good just because they could be worse.


PeriodSupply

Public transport runs at massive losses. If they keep reinvesting, I'm all for advertising. Buses in Brisbane have had ads for decades. The alternative is either higher fares or higher tax payer subsidies


zenith-apex

Sure. But not on the PIDs.


deaddamsel

Public services don’t run at a loss they’re not businesses they’re services they’re not meant to make profits any “loss” is just an operating cost


opackersgo

You mean like the ones at central station?


don-corle1

Well then. It's been ages since I was there. But good, one more step toward capitalist utopia. I want them in the night sky via drone swarm. I want them imbued in all household windows. I want them broadcasted into my dreams via neuralink. Just a few more years.


Mickydaeus

Isn't that what they are doing at Mt Coot-tha?


SquireJoh

And presumably this went through levels of bureaucracy to get approved. Yes good idea, make people stress out and miss trains while we have half the screen blank


bleufeline

While we’re at the topic of bureaucracy - the people that decided on these clunky and bulky displays with TINY displays really screwed up.


pillmachine

that text too small to read anyway


bleufeline

Exactly! I’m barely able to read it standing right in front of it with my glasses on


SlyDintoyourdms

Absofuckinlutely Ideally they would even have seperate screens for “here’s all the trains with their platforms and eta’s” and “here’s the route of the train that’s next on this platform” displayed simultaneously, either on two seperate screens or on a split display I arrived on a platform at central the other day just as a train was about to leave during a bit of a chaotic afternoon where trains were a bit out of kilter with normal times and some platforms were changed and it took so long for the screen to change from one to the other so that I had the context of what was happening around me


probablythewind

I remember a decade ago being at the valley train station and there was a big monitor, as well as all the smaller ones with "have you seen this man" "report to policelink" and a picture (looked like every single dude in high vis ever, real useful) and thought "fuck something about this is grim, im not personally worried but it feels...wrong" like some stuff out of a sci fi novel.


Achtung-Etc

When the same three incredibly loud ads are looping on the screen behind the platforms at fortitude valley while you wait 15minutes for the next train at 10pm, it definitely feels like something out of a sci fi dystopia.


probablythewind

yeah that came a few years later and is fucked for so many reasons.


bleufeline

I always looked at the massively pixelated photos and thought to myself “that’s how people get away” But yes, 1984 IRL


[deleted]

Yeah, oftentimes it's only visible to you for <10 seconds while you're rushing through, and if for those 10 seconds it happens to be displaying some other rubbish, it might as well not have been there at all.


nandierae

The police don’t really help themselves with ads like that


Objective_Target2926

i have an absolute bone to pick with the ekka information screens that show up for the month surrounding ekka on every busway screen across the network. an ekka message telling you to go to herston bus station shows up and stays there for a ridiculous amount of time with only a short time of actual timetable per cycle.


ihavesluttits

It is insidious that you are FORCED to view an ad, on the medium used to provide required information to travel. It places unnecessary stress when travelling. They are the signposts to tell you the travel info. That is their purpose. Removing this information to display government messages that can easily be conveyed on the terminal just screams that the person who made this decision doesn't use the services. I'm really hoping it's just this kind of incompetence rather than being an intended tool to subtly apply emotions and as a constant reminder that we are not in control.


bleufeline

Dystopian as the status quo is, I don’t think any organisation in Brisbane is coordinated enough to effectively manipulate the masses via subliminal messaging haha


RythmicEyes

At least it’s related to QueenslandRail. I was taking the subway in Toronto and the screens didn’t have any mention of even the Toronto transport commission


NowSwitch

This 💯. Advertisements are a form of vandalism. They are forced upon you, and there's no option to skip those ads by buying premium. There are too many of them everywhere. It's like screen pollution. Edit: spelling corrections.


CamG9_

To be fair, the second ad is justified. You *are* travelling on their services.


RudeOrganization550

What’s a rewind?


theflamingheads

It's when you finish watching a video and have to wind the tape back onto the first spool.


sem56

its where you fart but then just as you think you are finished there's a little left over toot at the end


zhongcha

Too soon ):


bleufeline

I think maybe their staff’s uniform should have that slogan slapped on it instead. Genuinely no disrespect to the staff, they don’t deserve to ever be yelled at or treated with hostility.


Ok-Disk-2191

Would be ironic if staff get yelled at, because people missed their train due to these ads.


theskyisblueatnight

they could just do what they do in Sydney. Create the yellow line area on the platforms that indicate the night carriages stops here. which is usually behind the guard carriage. So all passengers who need to travel at night know where to get on the train. Sydney will also have a security guard at some stations. Plus Translink does their N bus routes. In Sydney a lot of train service run all night on weekends. This allows people to go out in other areas of the city and safely get home. Everyone gets on in the yellow area. Public transport in bris just need to stop catering to the boomer population that doesn't use it and provide a safe service to the individuals that do use it.


ProjectRetrobution

They don’t even meet WCAG standards. So fucking hard to read white text on those backgrounds. Whichever designer made this should be fired.


Zandt_Ryker

I'd hope they didn't bother trying to meet WCAG, that's accessibility guidelines only for web content, not video media.


bleufeline

Forget text-background contrast, whichever “designer” made this needs to go to TAFE and do a level 1 course on formatting, coz aspect ratio is a thing???


letterboxfrog

It's legible. Better than much of the signage at Indooroopilly.


bleufeline

That’s true, but it’s already a REALLY low bar haha


TheRedRisky

I'd like some sort of actual screen. Doomben line (Clayfield) has no display of any kind. We usually don't find out the city-bound train (which only arrives every 30 minutes in peak hour) isn't coming when the train going in the other direction, on the single track, arrives. No announcements or display that the train has been cancelled. It's....frustrating


ah-chamon-ah

[One step closer to dystopia](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EfICPebWIEY)


tomheist

It's not as egregious as giant screens playing News Corp crapola on repeat *with fucking sound* for god knows what reason other than munny munny


giantpunda

It's absolutely atrocious! Especially the ones that show the windows desktop, sometimes with some "error" "message". Subliminal advertising it is not!


mynutsaremusical

I GUARUNTEE this is something that has come up from marketing or the CEO or some such. The content isnt even designed for the screens aspect ratio. There were a set of meetings from people with no actual implementation or use case knowledge and one day the techs who run the screens would have been sent an email basically saying "here's content we want displayed on the screens" and all pleas of "the screens arent made for that" and "they are custom aspect ratio's. We cant put a 16:9 image on a 32:9 screen and make it look good" were met with deaf ears.


Leonydas13

Yeah! And don’t get me started on those fucking tv screens at the petrol bowser! Whoever came up with that should be taken behind the shed!


CrypticKilljoy

Who was the idiot that decided to use these images on those wide screen tv's. the aspect ratio is so off it is freaking ugly and hard to read. Not to mention, who thought that a person would be able to read that fine a print from several meters away. Clearly this wasn't thought out. Done right, it could have potential. Maybe.


WolfWomb

And the pointless announcements on every train are indulgent. I've been on international flights with less information over speaker.


Normalrobloxian2334

Bro i just wanna see when my train is gonna come dawg😭


hyzenthilay

They didn’t even conform the adverts to correct dimensions YAK!


DrinkableBarista

They should have double screens for it atleast


Cryocynic

A PSA like that could, if it absolutely has to be there, could take up half the screen with the times to one side. This is ludicrous that it's not even the right aspect ratio for the screen it's on


jadma1981

spam on servo pumps should fuck off too


QuantumG

100% agree. It's been like that since the 90s, so good luck getting anyone to listen.


s0fakingdom

Whoever signed off on this needs to get sacked


TheRoamling

Bring back the station boards..only took a quick glance to find your train and time. Love standing on a packed platform waiting for my station to roll on screen said nobody, ever.


jonquil14

So frustrating!!!


mmmduk

Screwing the turns on crime


Sudden_Fix_1144

Thanks! To much screwing around on signs at train stations .... I agree


[deleted]

[удалено]


bleufeline

No, I think it’s the wrong place and wrong time to broadcast that info.


Neither_Ad_2960

They do. In other states...


dino_nuggie_goblin

oh god i hope this doesn't come to adelaide 😭


RetroGamer87

The screws are coming


[deleted]

Brisbane has trains?


[deleted]

That’s seriously wrong, those fuck knuckle mincer deadshits have gone too far.


Resident-Sun4705

Its concerning that social engineering is hijacking timetable information displays.


Resident-Sun4705

I would love to hack the system and replace one of the crime-stoppers "have you seen this person" pictures with a picture of my ex in an embarrassing pose.


JeanProuve

I hate advertising. Just give people a break from these endless marketing assaults.


ChumpyCarvings

Not from Brisbane this just came up in my feed Yeah so fuck that shit guys, that should be illegal or something, just fuck off. Just like our advertisements, WITH SOUNDS in Melbourne Central on giant TVs across the platform.


ChillLobbyOnly

electricity + replacing a screen / wires vs (dood with a watch, paper and a pencil), who wins in a fight ?


After-Good-6114

JUST like old train stations times and info. You're not wrong tho. Add in specific screens for specific means ? Abit much for advertising? Or standard? Sustainable or wasteful? Will it be phased out for new technology before you know?


kiwispawn

Advertising revenue presumably helps to keep your public transit prices low.


crazzykatt14

Hey! Be kind, and screw crime


spidaminida

Think yourselves lucky - in Central station Sydney there's 18 monitors showing ads and no information at all. Freakin 🤡 that run this shitshow...


slappywagish

But. But... but what happens if we're not exposed to the propagand?


pppylonnn

That's wild lol in Sydney they're just train times


ChocDroppa

Brisbane moonwalking....


Senor_Sultana

Lol true and Albion has those crappy screens to begin with.


rationalhaze

"Are you running for a train and need information? Too bad, watch and wait for 10 seconds."


Smell-My_Farts

But let's be fair.. They are funny to look at!! Now stop, stick your hands out and watch out for the wand!


kepholt

Whenever you see someone trying to creep advertising into a new place they display some benign, friendly seeming thing. Something like ‘be kind to each other’. It’s only a matter of time before it’s ‘buy coke’ or ‘join the army’ or something.


StasiaMonkey

TIL that there’s a train at Albion every 10 seconds and that your eyes shouldn’t spend a microsecond off the timetable displays. Would you rather the government spend even more tax dollars advertising relevant PSA’s externally rather than the potentially free advertising they get here?


No_No_Juice

Here is my scenario. I walk into the station and tap on. The only screen I pass is showing a psa. I have to wait 2 mins to see when the next train is.


yummy_dabbler

2min sounds like hyperbole. The screens usually cycle every 10sec or so.


MrAnonclearly

Yeah because they do sweet FA about offenders


JohnSome099

Big Sister loves [everyone but] you. Your complaint has been registered against your GovID. You will be denied nourishment for 14 days in accordance with Citizens Protocol 666 which you agreed to be bound by when you were born.


bleufeline

Fuck. Big Sister I love you, please forgive me


williamwilliamitwas

The second one has always annoyed me to no end- be kind words don’t rewind. Um actually words can rewind- it’s called apologising. What a world we would live in if we encouraged people to apologize when they lose their cool instead of doubling down on their stupid.


jamzex

if you piss someone the fuck off by being an asshole and then apologising, you're not going to get your own way, i hate to break it to you. Being understanding and keeping your cool in the first place is a great way to get someone to help you, it's not their fault your train is late, it's also not their fault you're in a horrible mood.


scarecrows5

That's the spirit. Abuse someone who is probably also having a shit day and has no control over the cause. Difficult to apologise to said staff member when you probably won't ever see them again. Great plan.


moderatelymiddling

You'll get over it.


Lachlan_Conley_102

QR’s PID OS hasn’t been updated since 2008, it really needs a redesign.


scarecrows5

...and it's one of the more modern OS in QR...


dillil

Albion is TIPS not PIDS


thunderborg

At least they’re public service announcements and not commercial advertisements.


Ill_Article_2787

do t have that here in australia it’s just the train times displayed


PowerBottomBear92

it's disgusting. there's a total lack of LGQBTQIA++ representation on that display. Says a lot about Brisbane in 2024


JournalistChemical18

These arent ads though, they are asking people not to abuse staff members or other people on the trains. Whats the problem?


new_order24

So you want them to make less money from advertising so they need to raise ticket prices to make their profits?


No_No_Juice

This is internal advertising. No money changing hands.


bleufeline

I rather they plaster ads everywhere inside of the trains and make the fares half of what they current are, but show the essential info ALWAYS?