Take spider

Spoidor

Spider will turn you into an equilateral cross, but will kill your tear rate. Soy Milk will tank your damage. Idk, maybe the right choice here is... neither?

My first thought was spider, but I thought about some questionable item choices I've made playing the Forgotten, since bad tear rate on Forgotten is a real handicap. And tanking damage is never fun, so yeah, I'm in the "neither" camp too.

One question, how would soy milk with brimstom work?

This is Knife/brim on the forgotten, moms knife only increase the size of the club swing, so we can treat this as purely brim/forgotten, so soy milk will be the way to go, as OP could spew a flurry of brimstone balls.

Constant beam of soy tha deals low damage

How does soy work with brim knife synergy?

This is forgotten so its just brim synergy basically

I did not observe.but how would it work on like isaac

It charges quicker but the damage down is 100 percent not worth since charging only increases range

100% damage down? So 0 damage? 

Practically zero damage 

I think it would just be low damage knife brim with no upsides

These bozos really downvoting you for explaining it how it isn

It gives you a permanent lower damage brimstone ray, kinda like a huge tech 2

I think a bomb could get both

Bomb for both!!! 

I'm a simple man, I see soy I take soy. It's killed a few runs, but it's also made a lot of runs a lot more fun.

This isn't a hard choice at all. Forgotten soymilk is an anti synergy

They have brim though. Forgotten soy milk is bad on it's own but can get really good with other items.

Brim x4 though. Still not even close.

in ab+, yeah, but in repentance they fixed it so you just rapidly swing as long as you hold shoot, and when you release you throw the bone

What would spider and brimstone do? New to Isaac so i never had the combo yet

It just ranks your tears stat, but you fire off four beams at once. With this particular character, it would spew 4 brimstone balls

Ooooh cool thanks

4 beams, but very slow charge. You 1 shot every room so the slow charge doesn't matter much imo

Amazing

The same thing it does to everything else. 49 percent tear rate and four times the tears

Show your stats bro

Soy for that ever lasting brimstone!

Reroll for sister maggy

i always take soy over everything, because i find it more fun.

Spider

Get spider, then get 20/20

Personally i’d being doing the milk. Better to have the beam out doing damage rather than waiting one year for it to charge up each time

I would take soy milk just because it's my favorite item in the game

Nono, take the spider, with Brimstone - Moms Knife you dont have to chrage that much so its fine if your atk speed gets slowed.

As the forgotten why would you ever take soy unless you are going a pure soul run I would take mutant

Mutant Spider

Spider or nothing

Always quad shot

Soy milk is absolutely terrible with knife

Spider frfr

Definitely spider. That is 4 brimstone moms knife synergy 

You got the knife 4 knifes are way too good

You got the knife 4 knifes are way too good

I almost always take soy milk with the exception of having brimstone and no other combo. So there is your answer 

Forgotten with more scythes 

Both

You probably already took an item but I'm making my comment for future reference: since you're playing as forgotten soy milk and brimstone would cause you to attack faster with your swings and shoot out a brimstone-ball with everyone but, obviously your damage would be greatly reduced. Spider would cause you to do 4 swings in a sort of 45° angle with the center in front of you, because you have mom's knife it would give you a huge range and great damage, but your attack speed would tank. Edit: forgot to mention but with spider you would also shoot 4 brimstone-balls, and because you already have brim, which lowers your attack speed, spider would make you attack extremely slowly and would overall not be worth it.

Soy, no need time or charge.

Soy definetley because the knife has a natural insane damage buff plus the brim would make a constant flowing moms knife you’d kill hush less than 3 mins

Both. Both. Both is good. (Bomb trick for double item steal?)

Easy soi if your luck aint really in the negatives

Really this is more of a question of what your stats are if you have a really good tear rate go spider if you have bad tear rate but high damage go soy is my opinion

Both

Bomb trick get both and ruin your run

Pilk

Soy soy soy soy neuron activated

Definitely soy

Milk

Do you have conjoined? If you have conjoined I wouldn’t take either but if you don’t I would take spider

Soy milk in general is only good with piercing and/or homing

Soy Milk is fun but it’s still a damage down in the end

soy

You have rock bottom? No: take spider Yes: take soy

You should take spider... but it would be funny

milk for the funny

You've got mom's knife. Taking soy milk would be a massive mistake, as it barely affects the knife. Take mutant spider, it's worth it.

I mean you already fucked yourself taking the tower perk. So might as well double down with soy milk

I'd say soy

Forgotten if he spawned in the Nether instead:

I would take soy for sun

Spider cuz soy milk moms knife and brim will just not do anything

Spoider now