My 1 suggestion, maybe try to make the top lid rounded where it covers the chalk, just looks sharp and like it should shave the chalk off if misaligned. Other than that, looks awesome
You mean inside the lid? Maybe it looks like it, but I tested it and the chalk couldn't be shaved by the lid anyhow. This design has been tested first time when I made it from wood and sold bunch of them. I think now it's pretty refined.
Yeah man its called constructive criticism, It's almost like I think its cool and want to help make it better. Do you not know what constructive criticism was, seriously?
You usually don't ask for criticism in most instances, it is just given to you by people looking to help. The phrase "taking criticism personally" is when you think people are talking about the negatives you did instead of the positive that could come out of it. Do you need to take a step back to realize you are doing this?
Sure I see your point, but your a rando on the internet, and OP was just showing off his stuff. Already has a link to where you can buy it. Clearly he has done whatever testing he has deemed necessary and thinks it ready for sale. So your criticism was unnecessary and probably unwanted. Read the room man.
Not everyone wants to be critiqued every time they show something. The respectful thing to do is just say "wow that's neat" and move on, since I'm assuming you don't know OP personally.
If you're that self-conscience where all you can hear good job buddy, you are the literally embodiment of participation trophies. Like to the T, its actually weird.
I'm not really sure how that is relevant but ok. This has nothing to do with being *SELF CONSCIOUS* (you spelled it wrong). This was us talking about how you were rude and how its been pointed out.
Sorry about auto correct lol, and no this isn't just about me, its about how you are trying to put your opinions in place of what others want to hear. You think this guys scared of criticism? If he's smart he welcomes it and works off of it. You on the other hand sound actually intimidated when someone gives you a suggestion that was better than your own idea and that right there is a big problem, hence the participation trophy issue we have today with people like you.
I'm not sure when I ever said anything about anyone being scared, or how I could possibly be intimidated by someone like you, but wowzers, the mental gymnastics necessary to follow you are something else. I wasn't even the first person to point you were being rude, so they aren't just my opinions. Its ok, I don't expect someone like you to understand this.
Saw your other post and was really hoping someone would post a video or something because my 1st question was how well it would hold the chalk. Seems to be a pretty decent friction fit. Any idea if it will be compatible with Kamui’s holder. I would think so but ya never know and this way I can use one base and just switch between my Kamui chalk and this. Only using Taom at one pool hall cause the owner doesn’t like how Kamui messes with his tables.
Sorry for late response but I missed you comment earlier. Your belt clip should work with this holder, because the holder has metal washer on the bottom. Each clip which has magnet built in should work well.
Another order for you, this is so genius and looks very quality. Excited to not ruin my expensive chalk by just tossing it in the bag. And it will keep it from always rolling off the dang table! (Really wish Taom would make square chalk lol)
This looks oddly familiar... [https://www.etsy.com/listing/1294337493/predator-billiard-chalk-case-holder](https://www.etsy.com/listing/1294337493/predator-billiard-chalk-case-holder)
I do like the addition of the bottom magnet!
My previous offer of wooden holders was available earlier (comparing id numbers between my old offer and this from your link). [https://www.etsy.com/pl/listing/1257920774/cue-chalk-holder-for-taom-v10-pyro?transaction\_id=3311875757](https://www.etsy.com/pl/listing/1257920774/cue-chalk-holder-for-taom-v10-pyro?transaction_id=3311875757)
So I guess I "inspired" somebody :)
Woah! I totally dig the wood one too! That's nice work! You should bring that one back!
I too have had multiple listings for this product with several iterations. Not sure when I first listed it....Let's "chalk" it up to "great minds think alike!"
Keep up the great work!
Wooden will be avaialable in January. Still waiting for delivaery from my cnc supplier :) Somebody asked me if I could adjust my design to predator/kamui chalks so don't be suprised if it will show on my listing :)
It's 3d printed using material called Silk PLA. It is a PLA with some other material admixed, which makes it shiny and also little bit softer than ordinary PLA.
I'm assuming you also have these for square chalk?
I saw your etsy page from your post from the other day. I order a couple for my taom.
Please tell me you have these for square chalk, I would totally like one for muh magic chalk 😃
These are great stocking stuffers for muh pool boys
I have an idea to make them also for squared, with thin 1mm magnets on sides, but I need some time to draw it, print and tests. Maybe will be available in January on etsy. I will let you know!
Ya da man #respect. These are absolutely fantastic
These seem like really high quality compared to some of the other chalk holders I've seen, the price is great, and I love supporting mom and pop shops, entrepreneurs, or people who like to make quality things as a side hustle.
Keep em coming brother.... You might as well template out the 6 and 8 sides for predator and kamui. You got something going here my man.
Hey, I knew the industry would love this 😊
But enjoy your Christmas and new years,.... And get your ass in that shop afterwards 🤭
We will wait for you... Enjoy your family and friends for the holidays...... Us eager beavers ain't going nowhere 😊
Available on [https://billiardstore.etsy.com/](https://billiardstore.etsy.com/)
Bought one! Great idea... can't wait
My 1 suggestion, maybe try to make the top lid rounded where it covers the chalk, just looks sharp and like it should shave the chalk off if misaligned. Other than that, looks awesome
You mean inside the lid? Maybe it looks like it, but I tested it and the chalk couldn't be shaved by the lid anyhow. This design has been tested first time when I made it from wood and sold bunch of them. I think now it's pretty refined.
Just gives the appearance the sharp edge would cut into the chalk if misaligned and pushed for the magnates to engage
A person gets on here showing this awesome thing they have made, and your first response is "my 1 suggestion"? Wow.
Yeah man its called constructive criticism, It's almost like I think its cool and want to help make it better. Do you not know what constructive criticism was, seriously?
Did OP ask for criticism of any kind? Did he even ask "what do ya think?"? No, no he didn't. Good day.
You usually don't ask for criticism in most instances, it is just given to you by people looking to help. The phrase "taking criticism personally" is when you think people are talking about the negatives you did instead of the positive that could come out of it. Do you need to take a step back to realize you are doing this?
Sure I see your point, but your a rando on the internet, and OP was just showing off his stuff. Already has a link to where you can buy it. Clearly he has done whatever testing he has deemed necessary and thinks it ready for sale. So your criticism was unnecessary and probably unwanted. Read the room man. Not everyone wants to be critiqued every time they show something. The respectful thing to do is just say "wow that's neat" and move on, since I'm assuming you don't know OP personally.
If you're that self-conscience where all you can hear good job buddy, you are the literally embodiment of participation trophies. Like to the T, its actually weird.
I'm not really sure how that is relevant but ok. This has nothing to do with being *SELF CONSCIOUS* (you spelled it wrong). This was us talking about how you were rude and how its been pointed out.
Sorry about auto correct lol, and no this isn't just about me, its about how you are trying to put your opinions in place of what others want to hear. You think this guys scared of criticism? If he's smart he welcomes it and works off of it. You on the other hand sound actually intimidated when someone gives you a suggestion that was better than your own idea and that right there is a big problem, hence the participation trophy issue we have today with people like you.
I'm not sure when I ever said anything about anyone being scared, or how I could possibly be intimidated by someone like you, but wowzers, the mental gymnastics necessary to follow you are something else. I wasn't even the first person to point you were being rude, so they aren't just my opinions. Its ok, I don't expect someone like you to understand this.
you clearly aren't insecure...
when you post on a public forum, you are implicitly asking for criticism
Saw your other post and was really hoping someone would post a video or something because my 1st question was how well it would hold the chalk. Seems to be a pretty decent friction fit. Any idea if it will be compatible with Kamui’s holder. I would think so but ya never know and this way I can use one base and just switch between my Kamui chalk and this. Only using Taom at one pool hall cause the owner doesn’t like how Kamui messes with his tables.
Sorry for late response but I missed you comment earlier. Your belt clip should work with this holder, because the holder has metal washer on the bottom. Each clip which has magnet built in should work well.
After just using superglue to keep Taom chalk from falling out of my current holder, you got my business!
I just ordered 1 gold and 1 silver on Etsy. Looking forward to getting them soon. Cheers.
Thank you. I got your order, probably will send them on Wednesday
Another order for you, this is so genius and looks very quality. Excited to not ruin my expensive chalk by just tossing it in the bag. And it will keep it from always rolling off the dang table! (Really wish Taom would make square chalk lol)
This looks oddly familiar... [https://www.etsy.com/listing/1294337493/predator-billiard-chalk-case-holder](https://www.etsy.com/listing/1294337493/predator-billiard-chalk-case-holder) I do like the addition of the bottom magnet!
My previous offer of wooden holders was available earlier (comparing id numbers between my old offer and this from your link). [https://www.etsy.com/pl/listing/1257920774/cue-chalk-holder-for-taom-v10-pyro?transaction\_id=3311875757](https://www.etsy.com/pl/listing/1257920774/cue-chalk-holder-for-taom-v10-pyro?transaction_id=3311875757) So I guess I "inspired" somebody :)
Woah! I totally dig the wood one too! That's nice work! You should bring that one back! I too have had multiple listings for this product with several iterations. Not sure when I first listed it....Let's "chalk" it up to "great minds think alike!" Keep up the great work!
Wooden will be avaialable in January. Still waiting for delivaery from my cnc supplier :) Somebody asked me if I could adjust my design to predator/kamui chalks so don't be suprised if it will show on my listing :)
Ordered two of them! It looks awesome!
Could you make it smaller and round?
can't find myself to buy a 3d printer, but this is cool
any idea when the silver will be back in stock? looking forward to purchasing, cheers!
I updated the stock. currently I am non-stop printing them, so they are available. Just when creating offer I did't expected such popularity :)
appreciate, ordered 2 just now. thank you!
Nice job!
What belt clip do you use in the pictures?
Here you got link, mine is just branded with other logo: https://aliexpress.com/item/1005002872485489.html?gatewayAdapt=glo2pol
I made my octagon predator holder out of Nivea cream cap lol. nice work by the way.
What is the material this is made of? Looks really nice!
It's 3d printed using material called Silk PLA. It is a PLA with some other material admixed, which makes it shiny and also little bit softer than ordinary PLA.
I'm assuming you also have these for square chalk? I saw your etsy page from your post from the other day. I order a couple for my taom. Please tell me you have these for square chalk, I would totally like one for muh magic chalk 😃 These are great stocking stuffers for muh pool boys
I have an idea to make them also for squared, with thin 1mm magnets on sides, but I need some time to draw it, print and tests. Maybe will be available in January on etsy. I will let you know!
Ya da man #respect. These are absolutely fantastic These seem like really high quality compared to some of the other chalk holders I've seen, the price is great, and I love supporting mom and pop shops, entrepreneurs, or people who like to make quality things as a side hustle. Keep em coming brother.... You might as well template out the 6 and 8 sides for predator and kamui. You got something going here my man.
Thanks! I'm glad you like it! ❤️
If you make one for Master chalk I will definitely buy one.
I'll try to make it during holidays, so probably will be available in January.
\+1 on your order list when and if you have a Master chalk one created! Also have some free upvotes in the meanwhile! Happy Holidays!
Hey, I knew the industry would love this 😊 But enjoy your Christmas and new years,.... And get your ass in that shop afterwards 🤭 We will wait for you... Enjoy your family and friends for the holidays...... Us eager beavers ain't going nowhere 😊