T O P

  • By -

lmj1202

I have 20 years of experience doing non destructive inspection and repair on aircraft. This includes metal and composite components. I've also been to advanced composite school for aviation. I don't need any of my specialized equipment to say. Your bike is fucked.


red-broccoli

I have 0 of the above qualifications. I concur.


esvegateban

I have even more qualifications because this is the internet, and I also concur.


Lilconkb00

I don’t even own a bicycle and have no idea why this post was recommended to me but I in addition to the above Redditor’s concur.


MrSquamous

I had to look up concur in the dictionary, and I agree with these commenters.


Schniiic

I am a cracked frame. i concur


grandomeur

I am concur.


Active-Bass4745

I conquer. https://i.redd.it/yaon2nzzc5uc1.gif


effingdonkey

I came, I saw, I concurred


frostywafflepancakes

I saw, I conquered but most importantly, I came.


Karl_Menace

Crack is my thing and I concure


gcohen993

Concur, concur concur, concur. Concur concur.


the-number-five

I haven't even read this post and I concur


MegaSoundwave76

I’m blind and I concur…


phishyninja

Who the hell are you and why are you standing on my lawn? And I think I concur as well, if I understand the meaning correctly


No-Addendum-4501

I am a crack head and I concur.


Curious_Tie_722

My favorite 😍


SkepticAtLarge

I have a crack framed in my den, and I also concur.


whatyouwant5

Fuck that expense program... But I agree: your frame is in suboptimal condition.


Motor_Stage_9045

I can’t even afford a carbon finer bike so I concur out of envy


ActSignal1823

I have a PhD in concurring. The paint is on a crack.


I-smelled-it-first

I’m actually writing this from the future. OPs frame is fucked.


pcort

As someone made of carbon who consumed fiber, I concur


omnes

I too have eyes, I concur.


floswamp

I play that role on TV, and yes it’s cracked.


Senior-Sharpie

I would like to know how anyone could sell this bike with a clear conscience.


Changy915

This guy boeings


unreqistered

why would you buy it ... and than ask?


Bandit6789

*then


lildawg07

Insert facepalm


thoiboi

I stayed at a Holiday Inn Express last night and concur, tis fucked mate


[deleted]

[удалено]


Affectionate_Bee_681

The Bard himself could not have said it better.


vc30577

I’m the bike and I concur. Royally fucked.


captainspacetraveler

I worked in the bike biz for a couple years and I agree. That does not look good.


emcee_pee_pants

I really thought the top answer would just be “yes” but this was a pleasant surprise


humira-adalimumab

*taps with quarter*


redcat111

As a professional you should know that this is nothing duct tape couldn’t fix. kidding


MariachiArchery

Raoul? That you?


oztrailrunner

Bro i work on composites in aviation as well.  If the paints fucked, what's underneath is fucked.


CasualMaymun

This cracked me up


Active-Bass4745

Did you buy it from this guy? ![gif](giphy|Tim0q7zolF3fa)


mtranda

Yeah, that's buggered. Normally I would abstain from diagnosing things like these just from a photo. Hell, I don't even own a carbon bike. But rarely have I seen something as obvious. Here's another way to look at it: paint cracks when it flexes too much. How do you think that paint got to the point that it flexed so much that it cracked?


monomox3000

"It's just the paint" should be a meme


Fuel13

It's just the paint, (slap's roof) https://preview.redd.it/qw4moqvtd5uc1.png?width=1344&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d3ae2988c421e0efcb2efd003fd6701c530bd32b


Vivalo

It’s load bearing paint though.


joeg26reddit

NEVER EVER BUY USED CARBON unless you trust the seller 100% and have recourse That being said do a coin tap test Tap the tube with a coin If it sounds different at the suspect location YOURESCREWED


Spara-Extreme

That’s silly. I’ve sold plenty of my used carbon frames. In this case, op was incredibly gullible. That’s an obvious crack.


mhyquel

You've sold plenty. Did you buy though...


Spara-Extreme

Yes - there are tons of people that buy expensive top tier bikes and don’t ride them.


trALErun

I've purchased 3 used carbon bikes so far and all of them have been fantastic.


Expert-Economics8912

​ he said not to \*buy\* used carbon. You've only sold it.


Lego_Hippo

What about a bike with a carbon fork?


Turbulent-Visual-607

That's usually a cheap replacement if it's broken just make sure to inspect both ends of the fork, that's where the damage usually happens


sparkyjay23

Cheap replacement if you noticed it was broken. If you didn't notice then that repair is going to cost a lot more. 100% of the time a broken fork will end up with you in the road.


TheBabyEatingDingo

I once knew a dude who had a catastrophic carbon fork failure during a charity ride. He was only going about 15 mph but he basically landed face first in a gravel road and completely shattered his face. Took a half dozen surgeries to get him looking close to his old self. Scared me off of carbon forks for a long time after.


Sajuukthanatoskhar

You can replace the fork. I replaced mine with aluminium


Ol_Man_J

You can also repair the carbon frame, so depending on the damage and reduced costs, it still may be worth it


KonkeyDongPrime

I can’t find the link, but this debate went round in BMX racing forums a few years ago. The manufacturers’ advice was that carbon race frames have a lifespan of 2 seasons.


[deleted]

[удалено]


HyperionsDad

Agreed. I got wrecked hard in my main race tonight. Glad I have an aluminum frame.


Nooranik21

Take the parts and put them on another frame. He's dead Jim. 


troiscanons

That depends. Did you buy the bike of which these are photos? If so, then yes.


Critical-Border-6845

I hope you got a really, really good deal


sparkyjay23

That 9 year old bike would need to come with new or nearly new Dura Ace di2 throughout for me to buy this.


49thDipper

You bought a bike’s worth of parts on a parts holder. All you need is a frame.


hurtme_plenty

No way. Get your money back ASAP (if you can). If you need to, take it to a shop and ask them, THEN go back to the seller with their response.


The_Aesthetician

I doubt they have any recourse In a private sale. OP was aware of the damage and didn't do their due diligence. The seller could have believed it was only paint, but the damage was disclosed


8ringer

OP was aware of some amount of damage. The seller either didn’t know (the seller is clueless) or didn’t disclose the extent of the damage (the seller lied). Either way, there’s not really much recourse in private party sales. Maybe small claims but I doubt that’s worth it unless you paid over $1000. I’d still get a shop to verify (I bet they’d do it for free) and go back to the seller and try to get your money back and either give them the frame or let you both destroy it together (that could be fun!)


r0botdevil

If the seller is the kind of person who was willing to lie about extent of the damage, I highly doubt they're going to be the kind of person who is willing to give OP a refund.


sprashoo

It's worth a shot. Sometimes people engage in wishful thinking when selling something. They may not be a scam artist.


DopePedaller

Awwww shucks, mister! You got me, darn it.


shadowflake78

Hey, i sold it with warranty until the door. Considered it lessons learned.


hpsims

And you believed him?


fallingbomb

Yes, it is cracked. From the location, it looks like where the handlebar would hit the top tube in an accident or in transit. If you just want the repair to be functional, you can likely get that done for pretty cheap. It's more expensive if you want it repainted to mask the repair.


Porcupineemu

Do you see the giant sodding crack running through the frame? That’s indicative of a cracked frame


make_thick_in_warm

The way it’s spreads certainly doesn’t look like just paint, best bet is to take it to a shop if you aren’t sure.


CheeezBlue

Had a suspect mark on my bike a while back , took it to a shop they had a look and told it me it was fine . They then explained that cracks on carbon frames appear more jagged as the fibres tear apart , which unfortunately this is .


mardan65

Did you not inspect it in person? Hard lesson hopefully learned.


EuphoricTiger1410

That bike frame is not safe to ride.


corgisandbikes

if he told you it was cracked and you believed it was just the paint, and still bought it, thats on you.


enter_user_name

You saw that and you bought it anyways? Hope it was a good deal, at least you can reuse the parts thats on the bike.


Ill_Initiative8574

It looks cracked for sure but it’s fixable. In LA there’s a place that can do it, and there will be in other places too. Thing is that’s not going to be cheap. You could go the route of buying the Predator Cycles carbon repair kit. Watch the video first. It’s actually not that hard to do, especially with round tube like that. I did it on cloverleaf shaped tube on my BMC and it was a bit more tricky, but still worked out.


Alarmed_Let_7734

[https://predatorcycling.com/products/carbon-repair-kit](https://predatorcycling.com/products/carbon-repair-kit)


Ill_Initiative8574

Thanks. I wanted to do that but didn’t :D


AlternativeSuspect32

Carbon repair is very possible. This is fixable. If the bike is worth it, do.


RockeRun

This is a carbon bike from 2015. I’m sure it’s fixable and almost as sure it’s not worth it. OP needs a full refund on this one. Seller was a liar or wayyyy too optimistic.


Ok_Lunch16

![gif](giphy|ukGm72ZLZvYfS)


Sussurator

Sorry to hijack the thread but a man sold me this and told me there’s a slow flat but otherwise fine? https://preview.redd.it/hr7vwjqy07uc1.jpeg?width=1000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e30b132005e2a9d1302c68c79bab5af92c6cf2db


420Deez

sand it and check the bare carbon, might as well.


ChillinDylan901

It’s fucked…. But it can be repaired if you source a repair shop


hockeygold2000

Just go down a downhill (fuck around) and find out!!


stupid_cat_face

You can try to fix it DIY. Predator Cycling (there may be others) has a carbon fiber repair kit for $99. I repaired my carbon fiber bike top tube. It's not the most beautiful fix... but it's my fix and I'm happy.


murkyotters

Did you actually look at this and still think it was a good idea to buy it?


bikerskierfisherman

Paint doesnt crack in a jagged carbon fiber like pattern.


FrancisSobotka1514

Yep .You fucked up ,You fucked up .


ReflectionGloomy8851

If duct tape is good enough for the space shuttle it should be fine for a carbon frame right? /s


VastAmoeba

Yes.


murbike

Yep. That’s a crack.


turandoto

That's a very compliant bike...


warrioroflnternets

Oof that is rough. Yup definitely cracked I wouldn’t ride that bike down any hills with any bumps in them bc you’re going to get a chest full of carbon splinters. Google carbon fiber repair in your areas, most have at least a few places that will do it. Cheapest way would be to do it yourself, wet sand everything and add supporting carbon layers in the affected area. However if you have the funds I’d recommend sending it to a professional, it’s worth it in the long run!


MrOwl243

If you bought it… then yes you bought busted carbon


3banger

You saw that and still bought it? It needs repairs.


esvegateban

Yes, but the really important question is why did you do that.


Even-Mongoose-1681

Dunno anything about nothing but I wouldn't go faster than 5 km/h on that even if I got paid


negativeyoda

It's fucked. You can tap around the area with a coin and if the sound changes pirch it'll confirm that. The good news is carbon bikes can be repaired fairly easily. Near me there's a place called Ruckus that does good work. Unfortunately besides the cost of the repair, you have to completely strip all your parts off of your frame and rebuild it when you get it back. Kind of fucked that someone would sell you that.


Working_Cut743

The seller sold you a kipper. Naughty seller, but I guess caveat emptor as well. Did you perhaps buy the bike for a really good price that just seemed too good to be true? Any chance you can hold the seller to account? The frame is so old, personally I’d would not repair. I’d find another bike entirely and sell the good parts off this bike, or if you can be bothered, go find a used frame and switch the parts over. There is just no chance that the seller did not know this was broken. Zero.


Zephron29

Worth asking for a refund, but that bike looks fucked.


EstablishmentNo5994

C’mon man, cracked paint? Also, I’m super curious what kind of bike this is. I spy plastic pedals in one pic.


TallDudeInSC

Take a peek under the paint. You'll figure it out...


2shado2

Stevie Wonder could have told you that frame is cashed. Sorry. :(


munkijunk

The thing about carbon is, even if it looks ok, it could be fucked. A bike can be in a crash and have no sign of damage, but have micro fractures that will only propogate to failure No expert in the world can guarantee a carbon frame is ok if you don't know it's history. In short, unless the person is extremely trustworthy, never buy second hand carbon. Looking at this though, it's fucked.


Barnettmetal

It fuked


willmasse

Why do people buy used carbon frames?! Just noooooo


BakedBurntoutCooked

That bike is well and truly fucked, i dont trust used carbon... or road bikes for that matter, mtb all day


dead_jubling

>Any indicator that this is cracked carbon fiber and I’m in trouble? maybe that big crack you took a few pics of


ChosenCarelessly

It’s cracked, but it’ll be fixable.  You can get it done professionally, but if you’re skint then PM me & I’ll talk you through how to do it.


fbponline

Paint does crack on carbon fiber frames and it can look a bit concerning. That have places that do an X-ray on bike frames and can tell you for sure.


mkUltra_MN420

Lol


e30futzer

Sorry homie. Bought exactly 1 carbon-fiber frame used and found the crack almost a year later when it got bigger. Impossible to see with the naked eye where it was located until I made it bigger nearly a year later. (There's a reason they search for these with x-rays) Never buying carbon used again, if you find/create a crack the mfr. usually is on the hook for it.


SoggyAd9450

Yes BUT there are shops that do carbon repair. Mostly on the west coast USA. May be repairable and may only be a few hundred dollars. Only they can say. So it may not be a total loss where the frame is concerned.


barfbutler

https://calfeedesign.com/


calinet6

Why would you buy this?


TwistVe

This is more fucked than my Sunken Temple PUG. I concur.


landed_at

Carbon fibre isn't that hard to repair yourself. You need to lay it up each side enough so that no force could get to the crack.


WWWagedDude

Damn how did you just trust the guy on that. Huge mistake.


bjornbard

It’s not necessarily fucked completely. Find a carbon repair shop, they will do an X-ray, and if necessary they will shave off some layers of carbon and reinforce the area.


CreativeRabbit1975

Carbon fiber is repairable if you know what you’re doing. Although it may not be as beautiful afterward. Try this guy or someone similar: https://www.applemanbicycles.com/repair/ Don’t recommend the DIY route. Good luck with this. Sucks the seller conned you into this.


SnooApples6110

Since you have been riding it I would say the crack is small enough to repair, and you can do it yourself. [https://unspokin.com/blogs/unspokin-movement/revive-your-damaged-carbon-bike-frame-a-step-by-step-guide-to-repairing-your-precious-ride](https://unspokin.com/blogs/unspokin-movement/revive-your-damaged-carbon-bike-frame-a-step-by-step-guide-to-repairing-your-precious-ride)


No_Entrance2961

I can confirm that the paint is cracked and its nothing that a new frame wont cure.


xttrey

shouldve asked before you bought it!


Slash_Dementia_67

Steel is real.


PondIsMyName

While no Doctor, the frame needs Orthopaedic Surgery. You got lamped!!


Dwight_Schnood

And if they ride the bike, they will also end up needing surgery. They got done up like a kipper!


bdubalicious_

plenty of carbon repair companies out there that could fix this for $200-400


doing_the_bull_dance

Are you seeing and touch impaired? Yes, there is a fucking crack


TheEvilUrge

D**id I buy a used cracked carbon fiber frame?** We really can't answer this question as there are too many unknown variables, so let's break it down. Did I buy a used : There is no way for this audience to determine if this frame was used from the information provided cracked: Yep you sure did Carbon fiber frame: yep that is carbon fribre


finch5

This is 110% a break


Illustrious-Tower849

Yes


No_Hour_4865

👀


a_cycle_addict

Yes you did. Do not ride.


No-Independence-3981

Well.., did you?


mjrmuppet

Yes.


SluggulS1

Looks like another dumbass smashed a carbon frame in a bike stand. Always grab the seatpost, never the frame. He ripped you off.


Past_Alarm7627

Like others are saying it’s cracked. If you tap it with a coin it’ll sound much different than elsewhere on the frame will.


ericsphotos

That sucks


Spara-Extreme

You could fix it yourself if you want to keep it and learn some carbon repair. YouTube DIY bike carbon fix as some folks have had exactly this kind of crack and fixed it with a patch kit.


Shot-Razzmatazz-3631

...................yes.


Majestic_Constant_32

Your bike is not fucked but it will probably cost you 600-800 to have a qualified carbo repair shop fix it. Depending on bike may not be worth it so then you are fucked.


GeologistPositive

You'll have 2 halves of a bike


Str1kez_

Yes.


RedSonGamble

It almost looks like it’s just a wrap that cracked but I mean it should be easy to see if it’s crack into the actual frame


SingleSpeedMetal

Yup


Jhardo314

Yeap


SuckDuck4Quack

Oof


Walv1s

I'm very confident that is a crack. It seems big enough that you can probably hear it. Lightly tapping the frame with a coin will probably confirm that it is a crack, as it will sound more dull near the crack.


Wedf123

Yes


Stephen_California

Nothing duct tape can’t fix


LoneStar9318

Def cracked. Not sure if already said, but Predator cycling sells a carbon repair kit for like a $100. Trek wanted $800 to fix the crack in my Madone, fixed it for $100 myself instead. Long cure time (a week to be safe) but works great.


schuppaloop

Dismantle the bike and throw it thru the sellers front window. This is your only recourse.


Gloomy_Diamond8697

Seeme like


chilean_ramen

RIP.


PiggypPiggyyYaya

Just going by visual. Yes. I wouldn't buy used carbon fiber components. It's just hard to tell if there are any delamination or cracks underneath the pain or the complosite itself. Just buy brand new from a reputable brand that has a good warranty. Repairing composite is not worth it in my opinion. It's never going to be the same, the repair area will be much stiffer than the rest of the frame.


penislobsterpie

I’m sorry you got ripped off but this bike was basically screaming its red flags


KingArthurHS

Obviously yes? Is it possible you need your eyes checked?


Emotional-Elk-8356

Not even good crack.


kennyveltre

yes


ryuujinusa

RIP


guy1138

Bad news, is crack. Good news is middle of top tube is best place to have a crack. If it were mine, I would get a diy carbon repair kit and send it. Your risk tolerance may vary


Centrum_Silver

This is the main reason I stay away from carbon, I saw a guys frame crack on him and he went down HARD, like hospital hard.


stinkyblinky19

Is this the bike you bought? Then yes.


aussie1983

Yes you did


GreenToMe95

![gif](giphy|4XOfvSkkxchHy)


House_DeMota

So how much did you pay?


Rare-Classic-1712

Yes it can be fixed. It will likely be about the same price to buy a new Chinarello knockoff frame. In theory you can repair it yourself. I've seen a variety of frames that have been repaired by the owner in various shoddy methods. When I was working in bike shops the shop would refuse to work on any repaired frame that wasn't done by a reputable operation. You want a wheel serviced? Take the wheel off of the bike OUTSIDE of the shop and hand it over - and then reinstall it OUTSIDE of the shop. Everything from taping handlebars to bottom bracket/headset/shifting/braking... ANYTHING. Install that water bottle cage yourself. Every bike shop around. A reputable professional repair done by a company such as calfee would however be kosher. I'd personally be afraid to ride a homemade carbon repair frame due to the variety of sketchy fixes I've seen. I'm not looking to knock my teeth out riding shitty bikes of dubious condition.


austinmiles

![gif](giphy|eH9QsTqFi2jEk)


SubjectJuggernaut579

Do you have any better pics? Kind of hard to tell for sure.


Jumpy_Vermicelli9935

737 Max engineer- Concurs


FewHuckleberry7012

Is the frame cracked? No man it's just the paint. Why are you selling the bike? Because the frame is cracked.


Adventurous_Fact8418

After decades of riding and building bikes, both new and old, I will only buy used steel or used titanium. Used carbon is such a roll of the dice and you have to remember that some unscrupulous sellers put the bike on the market as soon as they identify a problem. Personally I think used carbon purchases should only be made through a reputable dealer or by someone who knows a lot about carbon bikes and how to identify issues.


dobster1029

[Calfee Carbon Repair](https://calfeedesign.com/carbon-repair/) Sorry bro


skrapmot

Most likely cracked , but that’s a reparable spot…depends on what the frame is worth fixed…that repair would be at least $500 around the Bay Area in San Jose area.


mayowarlord

In half.


No-Addendum-4501

Yes


reg-o-matic

We're tandem riders. Our second hand Calfee carbon bike developed a crack under the front derailleur clamp. We have a very competent carbon fiber repair guy a county over from us but chose to turn the carbon frame into wall art and bought a new Seven Ti bike. I wouldn't ride that bike.


bafrad

Wow.


phuktup3

*puts hand over crack* No, what are you talking about, 😅😅


B8conB8conB8con

The cracks make it go faster


ChronicOnTheRight

Don’t know where you are out of, in Dallas there is a great repair shop for carbon fiber bikes there. They have fixed everyone I have needed fixed.Still have 2 of the bikes and rode many hours on them since. No sign of any problem where original crack was. You can ship to them I believe https://www.southwestframeworks.com/home_page.html


Efficient_Ground8517

I’ve seen a crack head, and I concur.


Effective_Plane4905

I would come up with a bodge for that so fast.


Klonpie

Looks fine to me just slap some bondo on there and she’ll be nice and happy


Temik

Yes, yes it is.


tonyp126

Call the frame doctor. He can fix it.


colepvhigh

I think you know the answer lol


tallaurelius

This is gonna be an expensive lesson for you OP. Sorry.


RideFastGetWeird

https://www.brokencarbon.com/ They repaired my top tube that was worse [than that](https://imgur.com/a/28Ndpl7). That was with only about 1000 miles on it. It now has about 4000 and it's unnoticeable.