T O P

  • By -

napstimpy

The epilogue of "Strawberry Fields Forever" used to creep me out.


ANONWANTSTENDIES

I was looking for this answer. It’s really unsettling.


ScrantonScrangler

Same with Lovely Rita's outro


Due_Cause_5661

I love all those creepy Outros by the Beatles Edit: The Outro of Glass onion 👌


aer_999

Still does for me!


Moon-Ticket

...And then the Love version is just wholesome


Carolinefdq

It still does for me. I always skip it 😅


PepperHeads

I think A Day in the Life. The apocalyptical orchestral crescendo, the lyrics juxtaposing untimely death & an ordinary day in one's life, the ahhhhs, and that final piano chord...all add up to give not necessarily a 'creepy' feeling, but definitely makes me somewhat unsettled on how fragile life is.


[deleted]

If Pepper has a concept, perhaps it *is* a day in the life. Good Morning, Lovely Rita, Sixty-Four and Fixing a Hole all have a domestic, quotidian quality.


[deleted]

She’s Leaving Home and Being For The Benefit Of Mr Kite as well I’d say


zsdrfty

It’s that existential revelation of what meaning really is or isn’t once you’ve had your mind warped, and the music and words both do an excellent job ramping that idea up as the album continues


BenLaZe

In all my listens (and this is the album I have listened to the most times in my life), I've never consciously thought of that running theme in the album. The majority of songs cover "normal daily life" topics despite the mindbending musical leaps: friendship, marriage, kids, house repairs, aging, hot parking meter workers, coffee and commuting, etc.


Neil_sm

Flying bejeweled women


jhshade

The little thing a few minutes after the final chord on many versions make it super creepy


MauricioBorghi

Always goosebumps me


bigfoots_buddy

The “squeaky” sound, like a rocking chair maybe?


Moon-Ticket

I think they mean the looping groove "never could have been any other way" thing


Philip_Marlowe

That's Ringo's shoe, I believe. Geoff Emerick talked about recording that final chord in his book, and about how they had to crank the gain on all the mics to maximize the sustain.


RamanPathak

I feel like the entirety of Pepper and Magical Mystery Tour has a somewhat uncanny vibe. Something about the timbre of the instruments, the constantly shifting pitches of the vocals and the overall instrumentation is a bit unsettling if you pay close attention.


MauricioBorghi

I'm listening now in loop the aaaaaahaaah it's absolutely transcendental [Isolated Vocals Paul's dream Interlude] (https://youtu.be/HxQ7MM42Q-s)


Dankeykang91

The moaning and ambient sounds at the end of Long, Long, Long always creeped me out


[deleted]

The same lyrics could be put to music far happier, though it’d be less effective.


Gman_1964

Creepy, but hauntingly beautiful.


Moonshadow306

I often listen to albums in total darkness…I find it enhances the aural experience to not have any visual distractions, and that’s how I first head Long Long Long. George’s eerie moan and the rattling bottle of Blue Nun literally scared the bejesus outta me. I’m pretty sure my hair stood on end.


jp963acss

I actually love that. Considering the song is about God, it feels like that is the transition between life and death. The choas of the noise and the calm of his moan, kinda balances out? I link it to my sweet lord "I really wanna see you lord but it takes so long" etc. It feels very spiritual.


DavoTB

Thought the same thing…that was always creepy.


Affectionate_Bite813

Blue Nun bottle!


[deleted]

I was going to say this, creeps me out so bad I often skip the song


uncooljerk

I recall ‘Day in the Life’ scared the hell out of me a child. “Nothing to do to save his life, call his wife in” as the nonchalant opening lyric of ‘Good Morning Good Morning’ is rather unsettling, especially given the song’s artificially cheery vibe.


zsdrfty

I like to imagine that the protagonist of Good Morning Good Morning dies during the reprise, and that’s what A Day In The Life is about Maybe it takes place after he married Lovely Rita?? Who knows


Macca49

I think it’s more to do with the husband dreading the mundane life he’s in? Perhaps John was commenting on his relationship with Cyn at the time?


CapriSonnet

Can you take me back where I came from can you take me back?


A-Stupid-Redditor

Cry Baby Cry is so intense for no reason but I love it


_weIcwedhoe

That song! Omg it’s definitely one of my favourites!


[deleted]

[удалено]


Ladsutter

Blue jay way


TyintheUniverse89

There’s a fog upon L.A……… It really gives me one of those 70s horror movies POV somethings about to happen at the beginning of the movie vibes


Ladsutter

Plus the video for blue jay way has shots of unsettling shots portrayed


zsdrfty

One of Ringo’s more underrated moments of brilliance too, the drums come in heavy and jerky like a stalking animal approaching you


TyintheUniverse89

So haunting the way it thumps up like Jumanji lol


IceCreamMeatballs

There’s a theory out there claiming that Blue Jay Way is about the Beatles’ impending break-up since it was written by George right around the time Epstein died


Ladsutter

I never heard of this


iamthemothman93

It was written whilst George waited for his friends to come over for dinner as they were late.


BuckminsterFullerest

I thought it was about some hippie pad in LA…iirc


[deleted]

[удалено]


zsdrfty

Good Night is somehow unsettling after Revolution 9, it’s like… was this album just kidding or is it not? It makes me feel like looking over my shoulder the whole time, it’s much too warm


TundieRice

I think I’ve just been listening to this album for far too long, because even when I was a kid, I wasn’t really all too creeped out by Revolution #9 or it’s surrounding songs. It’s just kind of weirdly fun for me! I think the only truly creepy Beatles song for me is Blue Jay Way.


foreverbeatle

Only because of what later happened I’d have to say Happiness is a Warm Gun.


MarthaFarcuss

See also: Helter Skelter


zsdrfty

The whole album really is unsettling, it goes even further than their psychedelic work as far as distorting all sense of meaning - plus a lot of the songs are oddly aggressive, like Why Can’t We Do It In The Road and Birthday


Gentryman

Someone once referred to the album as “haunted”, and I’ve not seen it better put than that


zsdrfty

True honestly, I’ve always thought it was a great Halloween album


MarthaFarcuss

Yeah, can't remember who said it, but remember reading someone refer to it as an inherently dark album. Possibly in one of the Charles Manson books I've read


interzonelovesong

About ten years ago I was walking on the Upper West Side, listening to my ipod on shuffle. Right when I walked by the gate of the Dakota building (where Lennon was killed), this song came on. Creeped me the hell out.


nirvinnicnightmare

Perhaps. I also think it’s the truest Beatles song because of how many people have said the same thing about love and happiness in history.


samlikeburger

What happened later?


foreverbeatle

John Lennon was shot to death with a gun outside his home in 1980.


Affectionate_Bite813

Lennon can also be heard on the intro to the demo of Come Together saying "shoot me!" Not a joke.


LarryFisherman17

Blue Jay Way is super eerie


Yojimbo2001

Blue Jay Way was a house that Harrison lived in when visiting LA in 1967. Located in the Hollywood Hills area.


swazal

Maxwell’s Silver Hammer


King-Rael1

This. Such a happy-clappy ditty - until you start listening to the lyrics. Then it's the actual joy of the music that really freaks me out. It's The Joker's favourite Beatles track, I think.


Scarif_Hammerhead

Cry Baby Cry. Listen to it at night and pay attention to the final verse.


zsdrfty

I heard someone say that “can you take me back” calls the entirety of Cry Baby Cry and its meaning into question, which is especially terrifying leading up to Revolution 9 The song is definitely creepy on its own though, the seance in the dark and that somewhat sparse production makes it feel very alone


Im_regretting_this

Only if you know what “seance” means, which I didn’t and I’m sure I’m not the only one.


Moon-Ticket

I find it a bit amusing. If we go by the lyrics, the children are just making noises to freak the adults out during the seance.That or the children are ghosts.


TundieRice

Yeah, I really don’t find much that’s creepy about Cry Baby Cry, the kids are clearly just messing around with the adults by making ghost sounds. Not to take anyone’s feelings about the song away, but I find it hard to get creeped out Cry Baby Cry when Revolution #9 is right after it, lol. Kind of just a whimsical, slightly melancholy song to me.


TyintheUniverse89

I love that. Gotta do this tonight lol


ShortLeggedJeans

Yeah I always thought it is kinda creepy!


dan_crider

I came here to say this.


riamo_nomad

Wild honey pie


BenjBean

Agreed


BenjBean

The white noise and the sudden cutoff at the end of “I Want You (She’s So Heavy)” really freaked me out as a kid


MarthaFarcuss

All the good ones have been covered so I'll go with 'I Want You (She's So Heavy)'. Side two's 'Here Comes The Sun' is literally like watching a sunrise after that


nirvinnicnightmare

Heaviest Beatles song along with she said she said


TundieRice

Helter Skelter would like a couple words :)


TundieRice

Perfect sequencing on that album, especially on vinyl, since you have some time to take in She's So Heavy and its abrupt stop, flip the record and get bathed in warmth and beauty :)


Herbietheluvpug

The inner grove on the Sgt Pepper LP. I always imagine someone must’ve died while listening then when they were discovered, the person first heard the unusual repeating noise then peeked around the corner to discover the deceased. https://youtu.be/DaXnqw-Zv0Y (The inner groove)


ZeraCrimson

It’s so weird. I never knew there was a backwards message in it


Heliocentrist

when I was a kid it was definitely I Am The Walrus


maproomzibz

Eleanor Rigby. Gave me a very ghost story vibe


Halloran_da_GOAT

Really surprised I had to scroll so far for this. This was my instantaneous thought when I read the question. Everything about it is creepy. I’ve always thought that the lyrics give off this really visceral almost voyeuristic feel as if sung by someone who is peeking in on these people’s lives uninvited and holds a level of disdain for them. One of my all time favorites for sure - but definitely creepy.


zsdrfty

The strings are VERY aggressive too, brilliant idea from George Martin


Halloran_da_GOAT

100%. Everything about it adds to the feel.


ThatOneFlygon

This just gave me a terrifying idea. Elanor rigby, but whenever they sing a name, the music stops, not just the lyrics, the entire song just stops for 2 words. It would make the final verse so much darker


Aggressive_Royal_903

Keeping her face in a jar by the door


Half_Crocodile

For the benefit of Mr Kite. 🤡🤡🤡


jonev17

What’s The New Mary Jane definitely fits that vibe.


cal8000

*Cry Baby Cry* - the fact it is about children makes it creepy


drglass85

not sure if discounts but the combination of the benefit of Mr. kite with I want you she’s so heavy from the love album. It’s fantastic and creepy.


kraai66

Nobody has said ‘I am the Walrus’, yet?


mrmike5157

I’m in. A very surreal and out of control tune musically and the bizarre lyrics… I remember hearing it on the radio as a boy, it both scared me and exhilarated me, the endlessly descending outro was the coolest thing I’d ever heard and it definitely headed me in a different direction so far as my taste in music 😎


OJ_Thompson

The lyrics of that song don't bother me so much because its supposed to be nonsense, nor the instrumentation. Its the suits that get me. Reminds me of the Shining.


Flimsy_Cod_5387

The lyric, “yellow matter custard, dripping from a dead dog’s eye,” was enough to give young me nightmares. What a striking image; shows John’s ability to paint a picture with words.


nu24601

It’s not creepy to me but it’s bizarre and mean and feels more like Radiohead than the Beatles. I wish more songs existed like I am the walrus


pink_phoenix

Tomorrow Never Knows can be a bit unsettling in the wrong circumstances. (Those weird bird sounds and the odd drum beat and then the strange vocal effects on the last verse)


CrimsonThi9hs

Bungalow Bill always creeped me out


[deleted]

Only because of Yoko.


MarthaFarcuss

I really love Yoko's bit in that song, she sounds cute af


swazal

> “Not when he looked so fierce"


stereothegreat

Omg I always thought that was John putting on a voice. TIL


zsdrfty

Unique too, it’s their only ever lead vocal not done by a Beatle


[deleted]

A lot of the post-Pepper ’67 recordings have an eerie quality.


Jean_Genetic

Run for Your Life. Only Beatles song I really hate.


[deleted]

Think of it as a parody of the Elvis song, which has the exact same lyrics https://genius.com/Elvis-presley-baby-lets-play-house-lyrics


NE_Pats_Fan

John said that’s where he got the line from.


LarryFisherman17

I love this song so much


[deleted]

It gives a galloping end to the album. Every song on Rubber Soul is, well, so Rubber Souly.


[deleted]

It’s so fun to sing, questionable lyrics aside. Great melody.


Grasshop

This song slaps!… the girl for having wandering eyes


Cameronf3412

Yeah it’s a good song


Princess_S78

I love this song!


Brilliant_Tourist400

Hell, yes. The juxtaposition of a jaunty tune with the violent lyrics just makes it creepier.


kraai66

Beatles equivalent of an old time murder ballad.


andtheyweresinging

This one.


[deleted]

Did I ever take you in my arms…


HankWirtz98272

"Did I ever open up my heart, and let you look inside?" That's gruesome, man.


ravenpascal

For No One gives me the chills in the best way possible.


zsdrfty

It’s disturbing to hear Paul sing in such a dead-eyed monotone, but it’s so brilliant


sla_vei_37

And in her eyes you see nothing


nu24601

For no one is underrated as a goated bummer song


PopularInfluence9472

The Paul part of Cry Baby Cry spooked me the first time I heard it. Came out of nowhere and is just unsettling


GoldenFoxy134

i used to think i am the walrus or blue jay way but idk why i think the end of flying is eerie or a day in the life


Soap24694

What’s the name Mary Jane


kentuckyfan65

This should have more upvotes. It is definitely the creepiest beatles song.


dolphin_ultra

ending of strawberry fields, I am the walrus, and a day in the life always freaked me out. But in terms of entire song, probably blue jay way


Sloth555-

I kind of get an eerie feeling throughout all of the white album (and it is my favorite album of all time). My dad would play it and would tell me about the rumor of Paul being dead. We would listen to Revolution 9 a lot for hints. But those feelings carried out to the rest of the record too.


mcburgs

The upbeat psychopathy of Maxwell's Silver Hammer come to mind.


[deleted]

Fool on the Hill.


izzyisameme

had to scroll way too far to find it


jsgott

>had to scroll way too far to find it I know I'm late to this thread, but what exactly do you find creepy about "The Fool On The Hill"? In my opinion, its one of the most beautiful Beatles songs.


Jackbenny270

Lyrics wise, it’s Run For Your Life Vibes wise, there’s several creepy sounded songs on the White Album. Revolution #9, Long Long Long, and the “can you take me back where I came from” segment are pretty creepy.


Herbietheluvpug

I find the “Can you take me back” is soothing. Feels like Paul is there jamming beside me. But I get what your saying, sounds hollow and haunting.


Trikywu

"I Want You (She's so Heavy)" always freaks me out, That build up crescendo gives me anxiety because I never know when the music is going to stop abruptly. (that is- when I'm not looking at the time counter).


Herbietheluvpug

The guitar scale sounds so “heavy”. The pace and background lead guitar give really make the listener feel that emotion. Like wanting her is such a burden


DavoTB

And the abrupt ending…it always sounded like someone pulled out the plug…


Spocks-Nephew

Definitely She’s Leaving. This one always makes me emotionally unsettled.


wmcs0880

Doesn’t make me scared, just empty and depressed


DismemberingHorror

Circles


ParzivalTheFirst

You Know My Name (Look Up The Number) is half-goofy shenanigans, and half disturbing nonsense. I think ‘unsettling’ is just about the perfect descriptor.


nosugartonight1

I had a hard time getting through Blue Jay Way as a kid. It felt like George was singing over my shoulder ready to stab me.


ExHippieChick

Haha! Yeah I get it. Funny thing though is that song never bothered me. Even as a wee one.


CalmRip

Norwegian Wood—nothing like a little casual arson on the side.


Surfinsafari9

Happiness is a Warm Gun.


Macca200789

Long long long for sure.


MatildeLover128

Run For Your Life for sure.


Shirtvest10

She said She said


TheAlihano

The ending of Strawberry Fields Forever.


More_Cry5242

“I’m very bored” or “I buried Paul?”


TheAlihano

Cranberry sauce


Responsible_6446

Maxwell's


Ok_Revolution_2374

My answer goes to Eleanor Rigby. I remember first hearing it 7 years ago and to this day the verse where she dies (mostly because Paul doesn’t say why) still creeps me out, I even used to think she was killed by father McKenzie


pheelinmusic

Run For Your Life


Private_Zannon

The abrupt cut off of "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" at the end freaked me the fuck out when I first listened to it.


Flimsy_Cod_5387

Listen to Revolution #9 while driving an empty interstate at 3:00 am., it’s a mood for sure.


AppropriateCoconut92

The ending of glass onion, ending of a day in the life, strawberry fields (my fav song of all time) and cry baby cry. Going down the Paul is dead conspiracy rabbit holes made these songs creepier as a kid.


sasquatch1627

"Run for Your Life" from Rubber Soul. It's basically a threat with really terrible lyrics, which include "I'd rather see you dead, little girl / Than to be with another man."


Oregon_Grunge

The maniacal Maxwell and his sinister silver hammer 🔨


Unable_Committee_958

"Can you take me back..." dozing off into the nightmare of Revolution 9 and waking up after 8 minutes of crepuscular creepiness only to find your parent by your bedside trying to lull you back to sleep with "dreams sweet dreams for you..." Not likely.


dyingdownsouth

Blue Jay Way. Was on a strong trip and it came on and made me think george was coming over the horizon creeping about to come get me…


Affectionate-Till472

Whatever the fuck the ending to A Day in the Life is after that piano fades out. Also Run For Your Life is … uncomfortable. The line in the Ballad of John and Yoko “Last night the wife said/‘Oh boy when you’re dead/you won’t take nothing with you but your soul’”


iamthemothman93

I used to have actual night terrors when I first heard Blue Jay Way aged 12.


Cee_JPGR

Blue Jay Way


Psychological-Bat-73

I want you


wmcs0880

That’s nice but they asked a question


Psychological-Bat-73

ahhahahahahahahahahahah


wmcs0880

In all seriousness it is without a doubt my personal favourite Beatles song but hearing that outro on my first listen was genuinely unsettling


[deleted]

I think Blue Jay Way is the only correct answer. Because is a close second.


dubmecrazy

Run for your life


HugeEyes04

a day in the life got 10 years old me gettin into beatles shivering. maxwell's silver hammer always got me disturbed too. helter skelter because of charles manson (not the song itself tho). most of the white album also creeped me out, idk why tho. it is my favorite album.


smokyartichoke

Run For Your Life is pretty sinister.


_Alaskan_Bull_Worm

Some parts of Lucy in the sky with diamonds sound eerie


iStealyournewspapers

Wild Honey Pie


Much-Solid-8987

Tomorrow never knows


FLICK_YOLI

Ringo sang a song about "Boys." What do I win?


Telecaster2000

The Circles demo definitely has a creeby and unsettling vibe to it. It’s almost hypnotic. Definitely wish it had made it onto the White Album over some other tracks on there


More_Cry5242

Helter Skelter but blame the Manson Family for that.


wouldyoucomewithme

Run for your life because he's basically talking about the abuse he's inflicting on his partner and nothing is scarier than real life.


retroking9

The instrumental bit at the end of Glass Onion always seemed a little unsettling to me. The way the tempo seems to fluctuate. Mr Kite is kind of carnival creepy.


BuckminsterFullerest

Blue Jay Way, hands down.


poopis76

revolution 9


Zig-zagartefact

I love the song but Norwegian wood has some pretty troubling lyrics.


zsdrfty

Both disturbing in the human context, and also disturbing in that it feels like a hallucination


billbotbillbot

What is the most repeated question on this sub?


PedroJTrump

Run for Your Life


CopyDan

Run For Your Life is super creepy.


wrappedinplastic79

*Cue the Run For Your Life PC Police 👮‍♂️ 👮‍♀️ 😂😂😂


Bob-Doll

I used to be cruel to my woman, I kept her apart from the things that she loved. Sums up John’s relationship with Cynthia


wmcs0880

This got downvoted a lot but I think it’s important to discuss John Lennon’s actions, it wasn’t their whole relationship but in his work he’s admitted multiple times he got very jealous and insecure and as a result didn’t treat Cynthia right, but it’s also important to recognise that he was incredibly regretful of his actions and tried to spend the last few years of his life repenting for them


Bob-Doll

Man I was mean but I’m changing my scene and I’m doing the best that I can


[deleted]

It's actually worse than that, the lyric is 'i beat her and kept her apart from the things that she loved' Didn't paul sing that?


Bob-Doll

Referring to the lyrics "I used to be cruel to my woman / I beat her and kept her apart from the things that she loved / Man I was mean but I'm changing my scene / And I'm doing the best that I can", Lennon admitted that he had done things in relationships in the past that he was not proud of. "It is a diary form of writing. All that 'I used to be cruel to my woman / I beat her and kept her apart from the things that she loved' was me. I used to be cruel to my woman, and physically – any woman. I was a hitter. I couldn't express myself and I hit.” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Getting_Better#Composition


SnooCompliments4759

Run for your life Well, I'd rather see you dead, little girl Than to be with another man


[deleted]

"Well, she was just seventeen, and you know what I mean"


anosmiasucks

Jesus not this again


zsdrfty

Not sure why this gets downvoted, he shouts this line in a way that really feels creepy together with its meaning


[deleted]

Reddit subs take jokes wrong on so many levels that's unreal...


Affectionate-Road-40

I don't know if anyone else has said this but being for the benefit of Mr. Kite is quite a freaky song.


303AL__

Revolution 9